Does choosing no federal tax withholding unemployment certification mean full benefit payment on California EDD?
Okay so I finally got my weekly benefit amount from the DE 429Z — $387 a week — and I'm trying to figure out if the federal withholding question on the certification actually reduces what lands in my account. When I certify through UI Online I see the option to have 10% taken out for federal taxes, and I've just been clicking 'no' every time because I want as much money as possible right now to cover rent. But now I'm second-guessing myself. If I skip the withholding, does that mean I actually get the full $387 deposited? Or is there some other deduction happening that I'm not seeing? And then when tax season comes around, is the whole amount going to be treated as taxable income? I've never collected unemployment before and I honestly don't know how the tax piece works with EDD. I always assumed unemployment wasn't taxed because, like, you're already struggling — but someone at work told me that's not how it works federally. Would love to hear from anyone who's dealt with this.
68 comments

Paolo Conti
The 10% withholding thing tripped me up at first too. When I first read that question during certification I thought EDD was going to take money on top of whatever other deductions there were. Skipping federal withholding on the certification means nothing is taken out toward federal taxes before the payment hits your card or bank account — so yes, for a $387 weekly benefit, you'd see $387 (minus any other adjustments like partial earnings you reported). The catch is that unemployment benefits count as federal taxable income, so come tax time you may owe depending on your total income for the year. EDD mails a 1099G every January, and it's also viewable in UI Online under Payments then Form 1099G. California doesn't tax unemployment benefits, which is at least something.
0 coins
Keisha Robinson
AuthorSo the 1099G shows the full amount paid out, not an amount after withholding? That's what I need to know so I can estimate what I might owe.
0 coins
Paolo Conti
The 1099G shows total benefits paid in the year. If you chose no withholding the whole time, the box that shows federal taxes withheld will be zero. So whatever you received is what you'd report as income.
0 coins
Amina Sow
California not taxing it was something I had no idea about until I filed last year. Saved me from some panic when I saw the 1099G amount.
0 coins
GalaxyGazer
Thought the same thing my first time — assumed EDD was quietly taking a chunk out regardless. The withholding question during certification is the only place that affects what you receive before it's paid out. No withholding chosen means nothing is held back for federal taxes, so the deposit reflects the full weekly benefit amount (adjusted for any wages you reported that week). The tradeoff is you're responsible for whatever you owe when you file your federal return. For a lot of people, if unemployment was their only income for part of the year, the tax hit ends up being manageable. But if you had other income too, it can add up. Worth setting aside a little on your own if you're not doing withholding.
0 coins
Oliver Wagner
Setting aside your own percentage is honestly the smarter move for a lot of people. You earn a little interest on it sitting in savings and you're not letting EDD hold it.
0 coins
Keisha Robinson
AuthorThis is helpful. My situation is I was laid off in September so I had about 8 months of W-2 wages before this. Sounds like I should probably be saving something toward taxes on my own then.
0 coins
Natasha Kuznetsova
Yeah if you had a full salary earlier in the year the unemployment benefits stack on top of that for your federal return. The 10% withholding option exists specifically for people in that situation.
0 coins
Javier Mendoza
The withholding question was the least of my problems — my claim had been sitting at Pending for weeks and I couldn't figure out if EDD even received my certifications. Tried the UI Online chat, was out of luck every time I checked. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to EDD on the phone; there's a video they put out about reaching a live person at EDD if you want to see what that's about: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent I spoke with looked up my account and told me two weeks were held because my identity verification through ID.me hadn't fully processed on EDD's end, even though my ID.me account showed complete. She said to wait a few days after the flag cleared and those weeks would release. That was what I actually needed to know, not anything a forum could tell me.
0 coins
Keisha Robinson
AuthorPending weeks on top of the withholding confusion sounds like a nightmare. Glad the agent was able to give you specifics. I haven't had any holds on my payments yet but I'll keep that in mind if something changes.
0 coins
Emma Thompson
ID.me not talking to EDD's system properly is apparently really common. Good to know there's a way to get a real person on the phone to look at the actual account.
0 coins
Malik Davis
The identity verification disconnect between ID.me and EDD's side is a known issue that just doesn't get surfaced until someone digs into it. Phone is really the only way to confirm what's actually happening with a specific claim.
0 coins
Isabella Santos
Quick flag on something I used to believe: unemployment benefits are exempt from California income tax but they are absolutely federal taxable income. Learned that the hard way in an old claim — I hadn't done any withholding and owed more than I expected at filing. The federal rate on unemployment is whatever your marginal bracket ends up being, not a flat 10%. That 10% withholding EDD offers is just a convenience option to prepay toward what you might owe — it's not a special tax rate that applies only to unemployment. If your bracket is higher than 10%, withholding 10% still leaves you short. If your bracket is lower, you might get some of it back as a refund.
0 coins
Keisha Robinson
AuthorOkay this is the clarification I actually needed. I had thought the 10% option was some kind of fixed unemployment tax rate, not just prepayment toward regular income tax. That changes how I should think about it.
0 coins
StarStrider
The bracket thing matters a lot. Someone who was making decent money before getting laid off could easily be in a higher bracket after combining everything. The 10% withholding wouldn't cover it.
0 coins
Paolo Conti
Worth running a rough calculation in a tax estimator with your projected full-year income including the unemployment. That way you're not guessing.
0 coins
Ravi Gupta
My first instinct when I saw the withholding question was that choosing yes was somehow required or that EDD would flag my account if I said no. Completely wrong — it's entirely optional and EDD doesn't treat the two answers differently in any way on the claim side. Payments are processed the same either way. The 1099G at the end of the year is what ties everything together for your federal return.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
Same instinct here. Something about the way the question is worded made it feel like it had a 'right' answer tied to eligibility.
0 coins
Keisha Robinson
AuthorThat was my fear exactly — that saying no would somehow flag my certification as incomplete. Good to know it's purely a tax preference.
0 coins
Omar Hassan
Had a situation last year where I changed my withholding election partway through my claim. Switched from no withholding to yes about three months in when I realized my tax bill was going to be bigger than I thought. EDD applied the withholding starting from the next certification after I changed it. The weeks before the change had no withholding taken and those showed up on the 1099G with zero in the federal taxes withheld box for that period. Everything still worked out at filing, I just had to track it carefully. Point being — you can change your election during the claim, it doesn't have to be all one way.
0 coins
Keisha Robinson
AuthorCan you change it on the same certification or does it have to be a separate step?
0 coins
Omar Hassan
The withholding election is part of each biweekly certification, so you just answer it differently on the next one. No separate form or account change needed.
0 coins
Oliver Wagner
That's useful to know. I'd assumed once you picked one option you were locked in for the whole claim.
0 coins
StarStrider
My aunt told me EDD takes taxes automatically and I spent two certifications confused about why my payment matched the full benefit amount on the DE 429Z. Eventually figured out she was mixing up SDI deductions from a paycheck with unemployment — those are completely different things. Unemployment benefits aren't funded by anything deducted from your wages; employers pay the UI tax. The withholding question during certification is the only thing that touches the payment amount on the tax side.
0 coins
Chloe Anderson
The SDI versus UI confusion is everywhere. The CASDI deduction on a paystub is for State Disability Insurance and Paid Family Leave, not for unemployment. A lot of people think they 'paid in' to unemployment through that deduction.
0 coins
Isabella Santos
Exactly right. Workers don't pay into unemployment insurance in California — that's fully on the employer side. The CASDI deduction is a separate thing entirely.
0 coins
Keisha Robinson
AuthorI had that exact misconception. Assumed the unemployment payments were somehow tied to what I 'contributed' from my own paychecks over the years.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
Saw someone get this wrong in another thread so worth repeating here: the choice about withholding doesn't affect your eligibility for the week or the amount EDD calculates as your benefit. If you reported earnings for a week, those get factored into what EDD pays out for that week regardless of the withholding setting. The withholding only affects whether a slice of whatever EDD calculates is held back before it hits your account. Two completely separate calculations.
0 coins
Keisha Robinson
AuthorSo if I earned $80 from a few hours of part-time work in a week, EDD does the earnings offset calculation first, then separately either withholds 10% or doesn't based on my preference?
0 coins
Diego Vargas
Exactly. EDD figures out your payment for that week after applying the earnings offset. Then if you've chosen withholding, 10% of that result gets held for federal taxes. The 1099G reflects the gross amount before withholding.
0 coins
Amina Sow
EDD's earnings offset is actually more generous than people expect. The first $25 or 25% of gross earnings, whichever is more, gets excluded before the subtraction. So on $80 earned, you'd exclude $25, and $55 would reduce your benefit.
0 coins
CosmicCruiser
The first time I saw my payment come through for the full $387 I genuinely thought EDD had made a mistake because I'd never seen a 'benefit' come without any deductions at all. Had to reread the certification to remind myself I'd selected no withholding. Coming from a job where things like health insurance and retirement were taken out before you ever saw the money, getting the full dollar amount was disorienting.
0 coins
Keisha Robinson
AuthorThat's exactly where my head was at. I kept looking for a deductions summary or something.
0 coins
CosmicCruiser
There isn't one — the payment amount is what it is after any earnings offset, and that's what shows up. The 1099G at the end of the year is the only official record for tax purposes.
0 coins
Natasha Kuznetsova
EDD's withholding election question during certification is easy to overlook when you're anxious to just get through the certification and submit. But it's worth reading carefully because — and this is the part that burned me once — if you're in a situation where you have a spouse with a job, your combined income might push you into a bracket where the taxes on your unemployment become significant. What seemed like a small monthly benefit amount started looking bigger when it got added to joint income.
0 coins
Keisha Robinson
AuthorJoint filing hadn't even crossed my mind. My spouse is working so this is relevant. We'll probably end up withholding something going forward.
0 coins
Natasha Kuznetsova
For joint filers it's worth at least estimating the bracket your combined income falls into. The 10% withholding may be enough or may not cover it.
0 coins
Chloe Anderson
A tax person can run this calculation quickly. Some free tax prep services will do an estimate even outside of filing season.
0 coins
Anastasia Fedorov
Overpayment notice from last year threw me into a full spiral — EDD said I owed $920 from weeks that were supposedly ineligible due to some adjudication issue they never explained clearly on UI Online. Spent almost two weeks not being able to get anyone on the phone about it. Eventually got through to an EDD agent using Claimyr and the agent pulled up my claim and told me the flag was connected to wages that hadn't been verified in my base period. She confirmed I'd need to gather pay stubs from that quarter and respond through the Ask EDD messaging in UI Online. That was actually actionable information rather than just more waiting. Meanwhile the withholding question was moot since I hadn't even been getting paid during the disputed weeks.
0 coins
Malik Davis
An overpayment notice without any explanation of which weeks or which issue is incredibly frustrating. Good that the agent was at least able to point to what was actually flagged.
0 coins
Keisha Robinson
AuthorOkay the overpayment scenario is a whole other level of stress. I didn't know an adjudication issue from the past could come back and generate a notice like that.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
Unverified wages in the base period causing an adjudication flag isn't uncommon — EDD cross-references employer-reported wages and if something doesn't match what you reported, it can sit open for a while.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
My worry reading this thread was that choosing no withholding would somehow trigger an audit flag or cause EDD to scrutinize my certifications more closely. Genuinely thought it looked suspicious to decline. Had to remind myself that EDD's withholding option is just a convenience, not a screening tool. The two options are equally valid and EDD has no preference about which one people choose.
0 coins
Oliver Wagner
The idea of declining withholding looking suspicious is a surprisingly common anxiety. EDD genuinely doesn't care — it's entirely your call based on your tax situation.
0 coins
Keisha Robinson
AuthorRelieved I'm not the only one who thought that. I even hovered over the 'no' option for a few seconds like I was doing something wrong.
0 coins
Amina Sow
Had a coworker insist that you have to pay back some of the unemployment if you don't do withholding — like EDD would claw back money at the end of the claim. That's not how any of this works. If you owe federal taxes because you chose no withholding, that's between you and the IRS on your federal return. EDD doesn't do any kind of reconciliation or repayment demand based on withholding elections.
0 coins
Chloe Anderson
That clawback idea is a myth that keeps circulating. EDD's role ends with paying the benefit and issuing the 1099G. What you owe the IRS is a separate matter entirely.
0 coins
Keisha Robinson
AuthorThe idea of a clawback made me nervous reading it. Glad that's been cleared up.
0 coins
Oliver Wagner
For anyone in a situation where they had earnings earlier in the year and then went on unemployment — running the numbers before the end of the year can help you decide whether to switch to withholding for your remaining certifications. If you can estimate your total federal income and figure out roughly what bracket you're in, you can make an informed call. EDD's withholding is 10% of each payment. If you think your effective rate on the unemployment income is going to be higher than that, you might want to withhold or save the difference separately.
0 coins
Keisha Robinson
AuthorThis is exactly my situation — W-2 income from January through September, then unemployment. I'll try to do a rough estimate before my next certification.
0 coins
Natasha Kuznetsova
Even a ballpark is better than finding out at filing that you owe more than you have on hand. The IRS's own withholding estimator works for this kind of calculation too.
0 coins
Chloe Anderson
There's one more angle on this that I didn't see mentioned: if you end up getting a refund on your federal return anyway because of other deductions or credits, then not withholding from EDD was fine — you just reduced your refund rather than owing money. The withholding conversation is really only high-stakes if you expect to owe rather than be refunded.
0 coins
Keisha Robinson
AuthorThat reframe helps. If I was already going to get a refund because of mortgage interest and other deductions, the EDD withholding question matters less.
0 coins
Paolo Conti
Exactly. The withholding question is basically asking you to guess your year-end tax situation early. For some people it's a no-brainer to skip it, for others the 10% option saves them from a painful bill.
0 coins
GalaxyGazer
And changing it mid-claim is always an option if your estimate changes, as someone said earlier. Flexibility is the main thing to know.
0 coins
Malik Davis
Something I want to flag about the 1099G: it goes into UI Online by January 31 of the following year and EDD also mails a paper copy unless you switched to paperless statements. If you chose no withholding the whole year, the federal taxes withheld box on the form will show $0. That's accurate — it's not an error. The income amount in the main box is what you report on your federal return as unemployment compensation.
0 coins
Keisha Robinson
AuthorGood to know the $0 in the withholding box is intentional and not a document error. I'd probably have called EDD about it if I didn't know to expect it.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
Finding the 1099G in UI Online is easy once you know where to look — Payments section, then Form 1099G. Having it available digitally before the paper one arrives is handy.
0 coins
Sean Doyle
Partial week thing tripped me up — when I worked two days part-time one week, I wasn't sure if the withholding percentage applied to the full weekly benefit amount or just what EDD actually paid after the earnings offset. After my own claim had a week stuck in Pending and I finally got on the phone with an EDD agent through Claimyr, I asked about exactly that. The agent explained my specific week — she told me one of my partial-week certifications had a wage amount that hadn't cleared their system yet and confirmed the payment would release once it was processed. While on that call I also confirmed the withholding runs on the net payment amount after the offset, not the full weekly benefit. Knowing the actual number made it easier to track in my own records.
0 coins
Keisha Robinson
AuthorThat's the specific detail I wanted to know — 10% of the net payment, not 10% of the stated weekly benefit amount. Makes sense that it works that way.
0 coins
Oliver Wagner
So if your weekly benefit is $387 and you earned $100 that week, EDD pays $312 (after the $25 exclusion on the earnings), and 10% withholding would be $31.20 on that $312, not $38.70 on the $387.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
The numbers above look right. The withholding applies to what actually gets paid, not the ceiling.
0 coins
CosmicCruiser
There was a point in this thread where I thought someone was about to say EDD sends a bill if you underwithheld during the year. Just want to close that loop — EDD doesn't track your year-end tax liability and doesn't send you a bill or notice about underwithholding. The 1099G is an informational form. Any taxes owed go to the IRS through your federal return, and any underpayment penalties are between you and the IRS, not EDD.
0 coins
Keisha Robinson
AuthorThat's a clean ending to the question for me. EDD's job ends at issuing the 1099G. The rest is my problem to handle with the IRS if I underwithheld.
0 coins
Malik Davis
If someone does end up owing a lot and can't pay at once, the IRS has installment plans. It's not a reason to panic — just something to plan for.
0 coins
Emma Thompson
The original question about 'full benefit payment' — yes, no withholding means you get the payment as calculated by EDD without any amount held back for federal taxes. But 'full' is a relative term because if you reported any earnings for the week, those reduce the payment before withholding even comes into play. So the full payment after the earnings calculation, with zero held for taxes, is what shows up. The DE 429Z weekly benefit amount is the ceiling, not a guaranteed deposit.
0 coins
Keisha Robinson
AuthorThe 'ceiling not a guarantee' framing is exactly the right way to put it. I think I had conflated the stated weekly amount with what I'd always receive, but earnings in a given week change that.
0 coins
Emma Thompson
Right — a week with zero earnings and no other holds is when you'd see the number from the DE 429Z show up exactly in your account. Any other week involves at least one calculation layered on top.
0 coins