Back to California Unemployment

Giovanni Conti

Does a request for proof of wages w2 pay stubs affect weekly benefit amount on California EDD?

So I got a letter from EDD last week asking me to submit proof of my wages - specifically W2s and pay stubs from my last two employers. I'd already submitted my application online and everything looked fine at first, then this letter shows up out of nowhere. My UI Online Claim History shows some weeks as Pending and I'm now freaking out wondering if this request for proof of wages w2 pay stubs affect weekly benefit amount that EDD originally showed on my award notice. Like, will they recalculate everything based on what I send in? The DE 429Z I got showed $390 a week but now I'm scared that number could change once they look at my actual documents. I worked at two different places over the past year and a half - one full time and one part time - so the wage calculation feels complicated to me. Has anyone had EDD ask for wage verification documents after the fact and did it mess with your weekly amount?

Layoff paperwork cleared out in March and my DE 429Z showed $375 when it arrived, but then EDD sent a similar letter asking for W2s and pay stubs about ten days later. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me on the phone with an EDD agent after I'd given up trying to reach anyone myself - the agent pulled up my file and said the wage verification letter was flagged because one of my employer's quarterly wage reports hadn't been matched yet, so they needed my documents to confirm the numbers before finalizing. She walked me through which quarters they were looking at and confirmed the $375 on my DE 429Z was calculated from my highest quarter wages, so once I uploaded the stubs it would either stay the same or potentially go up if the documents showed higher wages than what the employer reported. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD by phone is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if the phone lines are killing you. I sent in my W2 and three months of pay stubs through the mail since the letter said to, and my amount stayed at $375.

0 coins

$375 staying the same after you sent docs is reassuring. My DE 429Z shows $390 so I'm hoping the same thing happens for me. Did they ever explain why one employer's quarterly report wasn't matched? That's exactly the situation I might be in since I had two different jobs.

0 coins

The wage verification letter after the fact is way more common than people realize. EDD cross-references what employers report to what you said on your application, and if anything is off even a little they flag it. Usually it doesn't hurt the weekly amount, it just delays things.

0 coins

sending docs through the mail always makes me nervous, did you get any kind of confirmation they received them?

0 coins

Proof of wages requests from EDD typically come up when employer records don't match what you reported, or when there's a gap in what the state's wage database shows. Your $390 on the DE 429Z came from your highest-paid quarter during the standard base period, which covers roughly the first four of your last five completed calendar quarters before you filed. If the W2s and pay stubs you send in confirm higher wages than EDD currently has on file for that quarter, your weekly benefit amount could actually go up, since the formula pulls from the highest quarter. If the docs match what's already in the system, nothing changes. The only scenario where the amount might drop is if your documents show lower wages than what your employer reported to EDD, which would be unusual. So gather your complete W2s and all pay stubs from both employers for the period they're asking about and send exactly what they requested.

0 coins

This breakdown actually makes so much sense. My part-time job paid way less than my full time one so the highest quarter is definitely from the full-time job. If EDD already has the right wage info from that employer there shouldn't be a problem.

0 coins

The base period stuff always confused me too. So to be clear, they look at your HIGHEST single quarter, not your total earnings across all quarters right? That matters a lot if someone had one really good quarter and a few slower ones.

0 coins

Exactly right - it's based on the highest single quarter wages, not total earnings across the whole base period. The maximum weekly benefit amount is $450 in California, and the minimum is $40, so wherever your highest quarter falls within that range is what sets your rate.

0 coins

Had the same thing happen to me about two months ago with a wage verification request and my two jobs situation. Sent everything in, nothing changed on my award amount. The pending weeks cleared about two weeks after they received the docs.

0 coins

My claim from earlier this year had a pending hold for almost three weeks because of a wage discrepancy between what I reported and what showed in EDD's system. I want to flag something that tripped me up - when they ask for pay stubs, they usually want the actual pay period stubs showing gross wages, not just totals. My first submission I sent a year-end summary document and they came back asking for the individual stubs by pay period. Sending the right format the first time saves a lot of back and forth.

0 coins

This is a really good heads up. The letter I got just says proof of wages but doesn't specify the format. I have both individual pay stubs and a year-end summary. Sounds like I should send the individual ones to be safe.

0 coins

Agree with sending the individual pay stubs. The granular data gives EDD what they need to match up each quarter separately. Year-end summaries sometimes don't break things down by quarter which is what EDD actually needs for the base period calculation.

0 coins

DE 1101I had me sweating when I first filed because I wasn't sure if the wages I listed from my second job matched what that employer had actually reported. Eventually got through to an agent using Claimyr after the phones were impossible for days - turns out that employer had reported slightly different quarterly amounts than my records showed, and the agent said to send in my pay stubs so EDD could use the correct figures. The weekly benefit amount ended up staying exactly the same because the discrepancy was in a quarter that wasn't my highest one anyway.

0 coins

EDD asking for wage documentation doesn't automatically mean bad news for your weekly rate. What they're really doing is building a verified wage record so the amount on your DE 429Z holds up. The pending weeks in Claim History are just sitting there waiting for that verification step to complete - once it does and you're current on certifications, those weeks typically process.

0 coins

Are the pending weeks usually released all at once or one at a time once the wage verification clears? I have about three weeks showing pending right now.

0 coins

Usually all at once once the hold clears, at least that's how it went for me and from what I've seen others say. EDD doesn't pay them out individually in most cases once a documentation issue is resolved.

0 coins

Three weeks pending is stressful but not unusual when there's a wage question open. The good news is those weeks don't disappear if you've been certifying - they just wait until EDD has what it needs.

0 coins

The letter asking for W2 and pay stubs sounds like what EDD calls a wage audit or wage verification, and it's actually a step that can protect you. If your employer underreported your wages to EDD, your verified documents could get your weekly benefit amount bumped up to what it should rightfully be based on your actual earnings. I've seen people on here surprised when their amount went up after sending in their documents.

0 coins

I had not even considered the possibility it could go up. That would obviously be great but I'm not expecting it. Just hoping it stays at the $390 on my DE 429Z.

0 coins

Same thing happened to a coworker - their employer had underreported a quarter and when they sent in pay stubs the weekly benefit amount actually increased. So it goes both ways but it's not always bad news.

0 coins

it really depends on whether the employer had your wages right in EDD's system to begin with. most of the time it's already correct and nothing changes.

0 coins

Something to keep in mind while this is processing - keep certifying every two weeks even while your weeks show pending. A lot of people get stressed by the pending status and stop certifying thinking they have to wait for it to clear first. If you stop, there are no certified weeks for EDD to pay even once the verification issue is resolved.

0 coins

I've been certifying the whole time, so good on that front. Just getting anxious about how long this drags out.

0 coins

Certifying through the pending period is so important and people don't emphasize it enough. If you stop certifying and then the hold clears, you'd have to try to certify retroactively which is a whole extra headache.

0 coins

Pay stub verification held up my file for almost a month last spring - I called and confirmed EDD had everything they needed after sending my documents. Tried Claimyr to get through since the hold music on the main line is relentless - the agent confirmed my docs were in the system and that my pending weeks were queued up to process once the wage match completed. Kept certifying the whole time and everything paid out together when it finally cleared.

0 coins

Can I ask a dumb question - does the proof of wages request mean EDD is questioning whether you actually worked at those jobs, or is it more of a math check to verify the dollar amounts they calculated? I always assumed those letters meant they suspected something was wrong with the claim itself.

0 coins

Usually it's the math check, not a suspicion of fraud. EDD gets wage data from employer quarterly reports, and sometimes there are timing gaps or mismatches in what an employer filed vs. what you reported. The letter is EDD asking you to fill in the gaps with your own records. It's routine more often than it is an accusation of anything.

0 coins

That actually makes me feel better for OP and for a situation I might be dealing with soon. I was really worried the letter itself meant EDD thought you lied.

0 coins

The letter scared me too when I got one but it was completely routine. My employer just filed their quarterly report late so EDD's system hadn't matched it yet when they calculated my award.

0 coins

Just to follow up on the base period calculation since someone asked about it upthread - EDD also has what's called an alternate base period if the standard one doesn't give you enough wages for a valid claim. The alternate looks at the most recent four completed quarters instead. EDD runs the alternate automatically if the standard base period doesn't get you to a valid claim; you don't have to ask for it. But if the standard base period already works for you - which it sounds like it does since you got a DE 429Z with $390 on it - the alternate doesn't come into play to change anything.

0 coins

So the alternate base period can't be used to increase the weekly amount if you already have a valid claim? I always thought you could pick whichever one gave you a higher amount.

0 coins

Correct - the alternate only gets used when the standard base period doesn't produce a valid claim at all. It's not a way to pick the higher of two calculations when both would work. Worth knowing since there's a lot of confusion about this.

0 coins

This clears up something I genuinely got wrong before. I told someone the alternate base period could boost their amount and that's apparently not right.

0 coins

About forty days into my claim and UI Online still had two weeks stuck on pending - called EDD using Claimyr and the agent said a wage verification flag was open because my second employer's Q3 report had come in lower than what my pay stubs showed. The agent told me to upload my pay stubs to the documentation request and noted in my file that I had called. My weekly benefit amount didn't change because the discrepancy was in Q3 and my highest quarter was Q2 by a solid margin. Those two pending weeks released about nine days after I got the docs in.

0 coins

Nine days after submitting docs is actually a reasonable turnaround. That's helpful to know what kind of timeline to expect.

0 coins

Q3 vs Q2 situation makes so much sense - if your highest quarter is locked in then a discrepancy in another quarter is way less scary.

0 coins

For anyone who's not sure what documents to gather - your W2 covers the full calendar year and your pay stubs fill in the quarterly detail. EDD is really looking at wages broken down by quarter so having stubs that show which quarter each paycheck fell into is key. For the most recent employer in your last year of work, pay stubs are especially important since the W2 may not exist yet or the employer's quarterly reports might still be catching up.

0 coins

My most recent job ended in November so I do have a W2 for it, but you're right that the quarterly breakdown from individual stubs is probably what EDD really wants.

0 coins

November W2 is good since it covers the whole year. I'd still include the last few months of pay stubs just to show the per-quarter breakdown explicitly, especially if there were any variation month to month.

0 coins

yeah stubs are always better than just W2 when you need to show quarterly breakdowns because W2 only shows annual totals

0 coins

The thing about the weekly benefit amount once it's on the DE 429Z - it can be corrected if the wage verification shows it was calculated on wrong numbers, but EDD has to actually process the corrected wages first. If you believe the $390 on your DE 429Z is too low based on your actual highest quarter wages, your documents are your best chance to get it right. If you think it's about right, the documents are just confirming what's already there.

0 coins

I actually think $390 is pretty close to right for my highest quarter so I'm mostly just hoping to confirm it, not expecting a change.

0 coins

That's the right mindset going in. Send the documents to confirm and let EDD do the math check. If it comes back different you deal with it then, but expecting confirmation is realistic in most cases.

0 coins

Heads up on one thing - if the letter has a deadline for submitting your proof of wages, pay close attention to it. Missing that deadline can extend the pending status significantly because EDD has to send a follow-up request or issue a determination based on incomplete information. If you're close to the deadline and don't have all the documents ready, respond with what you have and note in a cover letter that additional documents are coming.

0 coins

The letter I got didn't have an explicit deadline which is part of why I'm confused about how urgent this is. Should I assume it's time-sensitive anyway?

0 coins

Treat it as urgent regardless. The sooner you send the documents the sooner the pending weeks can clear. There may not be a hard cutoff date but a pending flag just sits there until EDD has what it needs.

0 coins

Always better to be fast than slow with EDD document requests. Waiting to gather everything perfectly can cost you two or three extra weeks of processing time.

0 coins

Had a two-employer situation similar to yours and the wage verification request was specifically about the quarterly reporting from my second, part-time employer. EDD's system had their wages in a different quarter than my records showed - the employer had filed an amended quarterly report at some point that shifted some wages from Q4 to Q1. My pay stubs were the source of truth that clarified everything. The weekly amount stayed at $310 exactly and the pending weeks cleared about two weeks after I submitted.

0 coins

An amended quarterly report from an employer is something I never would have thought to consider. That's a good reminder that the discrepancy might not even be anything I did - could be the employer's end entirely.

0 coins

Employer amended reports causing mismatches are actually pretty common and EDD needs your documents to sort out which set of numbers is accurate. The claimant's pay stubs are considered reliable evidence.

0 coins

DE 1326C is the identity verification request and DE 4800 is the interview notice - just flagging this because sometimes people on these threads confuse the different kinds of EDD letters. The wage documentation letter you got is separate from both of those. Each letter is asking for something different and it matters to respond to the right request with the right documents.

0 coins

I definitely have only the one letter asking for wage proof. No identity verification letter and no interview scheduled that I know of. So I should just focus on the wage documents for now.

0 coins

Good distinction to make. I confused myself early on thinking an identity verification request and a wage letter were the same thing and panicked thinking I had two separate problems when I only had one.

0 coins

EDD sends a lot of different letters and the forms numbers help tell them apart but most people don't know that. DE 429Z, DE 1080CZ, DE 4800 - each one means something completely specific.

0 coins

what happens if you cant find all the pay stubs because the employer didnt give them out? i had a job that only did digital stubs on some portal i can no longer access

0 coins

Former employer portals cutting off access after you leave is a real headache. Options include contacting your former employer's HR or payroll department directly and asking them to provide wage records - they're required to maintain those. Your W2 alone might be enough if the stubs aren't available, and you can note in a cover letter to EDD why the stubs aren't included.

0 coins

ok so reaching out to the old employer HR is probably the move. i was hoping to avoid that but sounds like it might be necessary

0 coins

If HR drags their feet, your bank statements showing payroll deposits can sometimes help fill in the picture, though EDD prefers the actual wage documents. Lead with the W2 and whatever stubs you have and explain the gap.

0 coins

EDD's system matching wages to what employers file quarterly - this whole process made more sense to me once I realized employers file separate quarterly wage reports and EDD basically gets wage data piecemeal throughout the year. By the time you file a claim, some of your most recent wages might not have made it into EDD's system yet if the employer filed late or hasn't filed that quarter yet. The verification letter is EDD bridging that gap with your personal records.

0 coins

That timing thing explains so much. I always wondered why EDD didn't just have all my wages already if my employer was paying into the system the whole time. Quarterly lag is the answer.

0 coins

Exactly - the lag between when you earned wages and when EDD's system has them verified is a normal part of the process, not a sign something went wrong with your claim.

0 coins

After you submit your wage documents, checking in through the UI Online message center or the live chat from the Help button in myEDD (available weekdays 9 to 2) can help you confirm EDD received and is processing them. The live chat agents can often tell you if the documentation flag is still open or if it's been resolved on their end, even if UI Online still shows pending on your side.

0 coins

I did not know about the live chat option in UI Online. That seems way easier than trying to call. I'll try that first to check on the status after I send my documents.

0 coins

The live chat fills up fast so getting in around 9 am Pacific when it opens gives you the best shot. After about 11 am the queue tends to close for the day.

0 coins

Live chat is underrated for status checks. Phone is better for more complicated issues but for a simple document confirmation the chat usually does the job.

0 coins

One more thing that actually came up when I was dealing with my wage verification - the agent mentioned that the weekly benefit amount on the DE 429Z can be appealed within 30 days of the mailing date if you believe it's wrong once EDD finalizes it after the verification. So if documents come back and your rate ends up lower than expected or different from what your highest quarter should produce, you have that appeal window to push back in writing using the Appeal Form on the notice.

0 coins

Good to know there's a formal way to push back if the final number is wrong. I'll keep that 30-day window in mind and hold onto the mailing date on whatever notice comes next.

0 coins

The 30 days from the mailing date on the notice is the hard deadline for a written appeal, so documenting that date is important. Appeals go through the CUIAB if EDD doesn't revise on review.

0 coins

That's correct - DE 1000M is the Appeal Form, included with a Notice of Determination, and you mail it to the address on the notice. 30 calendar days from the mailing date, not from when you receive it.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure