Back to California Unemployment

Maria Gonzalez

Do I have to pay taxes on unemployment benefits in California EDD?

Got laid off from my warehouse job back in September and finally got my claim sorted after a few weeks of back and forth with EDD. Weekly benefit amount came out to $387 on the DE 429Z they mailed me, which is at least something. But my coworker who went through this two years ago mentioned something about owing money at tax time and now I'm kind of freaking out. Do I have to pay taxes on unemployment benefits? Like is this income the IRS cares about or does California treat it differently? I've been certifying every two weeks and didn't choose any withholding option because I didn't even know that was a thing. Trying to figure out if I'm going to get hit with a bill in April.

Lost my job at the logistics company in July and had the same tax question when I finally got my DE 429Z showing $362 a week. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an EDD agent and asked specifically about the withholding situation — the agent pulled up my account and confirmed the payments were going out, then told me the federal tax piece applied to my claim but California wasn't going to touch it at the state level. She said I could turn on 10 percent federal withholding at any certification, that it comes right off the weekly amount. I went back into UI Online after the call and switched it on. Here's the video if you're trying to figure out how to reach a live person at EDD: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10

0 coins

Thanks for that. So the agent confirmed California doesn't tax it but the IRS does? That's exactly what I needed to know. Did you turn on the withholding starting the next certification or did it apply to ones already paid out?

0 coins

The withholding started on the very next certification after I changed it. The ones already paid were already gone, so those weeks will just show up as untaxed federal income on the 1099G. I'm setting money aside separately for those earlier weeks.

0 coins

Good to know you can flip that withholding setting mid-claim. I had no idea that was an option until someone mentioned it on a thread like this.

0 coins

Your coworker was half right and half wrong, actually. The federal government counts unemployment as taxable income, so you will owe federal taxes on your $387 a week if you don't withhold or set money aside. California is different though — the state doesn't tax unemployment benefits at all. So your state return should come out clean. The 10 percent federal withholding they offer at each certification is the easiest way to stay ahead of it. You can turn it on starting with your next certification, it doesn't have to cover every week from the beginning.

0 coins

Wait so when I certify next week I can just turn on the 10 percent? I didn't see that option when I certified the first couple of times, is it in a specific screen on UI Online?

0 coins

It shows up during the certification flow itself, not on a separate settings screen. EDD asks about withholding as part of the questions when you go through the certification on myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ — answer yes to withholding and they take 10 percent off each week going forward.

0 coins

Can confirm it's part of the certification questions, not buried in account settings. Easy to miss if you're just clicking through fast.

0 coins

Every January EDD mails out Form 1099G showing your total unemployment payments for the year. You use that to file your federal return. If you didn't withhold anything, those payments all show up as income you owe federal tax on. The good news for state purposes is California exempts unemployment from income tax, so you won't owe anything there. If you got $387 a week for several months that federal amount adds up fast, so the withholding thing is worth doing now for the rest of your claim.

0 coins

How does the 1099G get to me if I changed addresses since I filed the claim? Do I need to update something with EDD?

0 coins

Address changes should be updated through your myEDD account as soon as possible. The 1099G is also available in UI Online under the Payments section by January 31, so even if the mail doesn't reach you, you can grab it electronically.

0 coins

Address updates are worth doing ASAP. The 1099G mailing is easy to miss if EDD has an old address on file, and you need that number to file your federal return correctly.

0 coins

Also worth knowing the 1099G stays in UI Online for five years, so if you lose the paper copy you can always go back and find it in there under Payments, then Form 1099G.

0 coins

Okay wait I thought unemployment wasn't taxed at all because like you "paid into it" through your job? My buddy told me that and now I'm reading this thread going uh oh

0 coins

Actually that's a pretty common mix-up. Workers don't pay into unemployment at all — your paycheck never had a UI deduction. Employers pay the unemployment insurance tax, not employees. So the "you already paid taxes on it" logic doesn't hold up here. That's why the IRS treats it as income you haven't paid taxes on yet.

0 coins

Oh wow. So what's that CASDI thing on my paystub then because I always assumed it was part of unemployment?

0 coins

CASDI goes toward State Disability Insurance and Paid Family Leave, not unemployment. Two different programs. Easy to mix up since they're both administered by EDD.

0 coins

That actually clears up so much confusion I've had for years. Thanks for explaining.

0 coins

Does anyone know if the 10 percent withholding is enough to actually cover what you'd owe or should you set aside more? I'm on $420 a week and trying to figure out if I'm going to come up short in April.

0 coins

Whether 10 percent is enough really depends on your whole tax picture — other income during the year, filing status, deductions. The 10 percent option is what EDD offers because it's a standard federal withholding rate, but if you had a full year of wages before getting laid off you might owe more depending on your bracket. A tax person or even a free filing tool can help you estimate. I'd set aside a little extra separately just in case.

0 coins

Ugh okay so there's no clean answer. I'm going to have to actually do some math here. Thanks.

0 coins

Free tax software will let you run a rough estimate if you plug in your income. Worth doing before April so there are no surprises.

0 coins

Something I didn't realize until my second claim — if you forgot to turn on withholding for a bunch of weeks, you can still deal with it by making estimated federal tax payments directly to the IRS during the year. That way you're not scrambling at filing time. Not a California EDD thing but it's a real option if you've got a bunch of unwithheld weeks piling up.

0 coins

Estimated payments, didn't even know that was a thing. How do you actually do that, is it through the IRS website?

0 coins

You'd do it on the IRS site directly, they have a payment portal. It's outside EDD entirely, but it lets you chip away at what you might owe before the year ends so there's no big bill in April. Quarterly deadlines apply.

0 coins

Good to flag that estimated payments exist. A lot of people don't think about it until they're already behind.

0 coins

My sister went through a layoff last year and was completely blindsided by the federal tax on her benefits. She hadn't turned on withholding and owed about $600 at filing. Not the end of the world but very annoying when you're already tight on money during a job search. The 10 percent option really is worth using if you can afford the smaller weekly amount.

0 coins

$600 out of nowhere during an already tight stretch sounds awful. Glad she got through it. I'm turning on withholding at my next certification for sure.

0 coins

She said she wished someone had just told her at the start. The EDD notices don't exactly make it obvious. Hopefully this thread helps people catch it earlier.

0 coins

My layoff came with a pretty big severance lump sum on top of the weekly benefits, and I wasn't sure how any of it was going to shake out tax-wise or whether the severance would affect my payments. The whole situation was complicated enough that I ended up using Claimyr to get a live EDD agent on the phone. I asked the agent whether my severance had been applied to my account and she confirmed it was noted on my claim and that EDD had decided how to handle it. She also confirmed the 10 percent federal withholding was sitting at 'off' on my account, which I didn't realize, so I turned it on that same day.

0 coins

Interesting — so the agent could actually see whether withholding was on or off on your account? That's useful. Did she say anything about how the severance affected the actual weekly amount?

0 coins

She didn't say it would change the weekly amount one way or another, just that EDD had processed the information. For specifics on what it did to any particular week I would have needed to ask more directly, but mostly I wanted to confirm everything was recorded correctly and it was.

0 coins

Good to know agents can check the withholding status on your account. That's actually a useful thing to verify if you're unsure whether a change you made went through.

0 coins

Does the California exemption from state income tax mean I literally don't report it anywhere on my state return or is there a spot where I enter it and then it gets subtracted out?

0 coins

California has you enter unemployment on the state return and then it gets subtracted as a modification, so the net taxable income at the state level comes out to zero for those benefits. How that looks on the actual form depends on what software or preparer you use, but you'd still enter the 1099G amount somewhere on the state return.

0 coins

Got it, so it doesn't just disappear — it goes in and comes back out. That makes sense, thanks for explaining the actual mechanics.

0 coins

Tax software handles that subtraction automatically once you enter the 1099G. You'd see a California adjustment line that offsets the amount.

0 coins

Honestly nobody warned me about ANY of this when I first filed. I went the whole first claim not knowing about the 1099G or withholding and ended up having to scramble at tax time. Wish EDD made this stuff more visible at the start of a claim instead of buried in documents most people don't read carefully.

0 coins

EDD does mention withholding at each certification but honestly the certification flow just feels like a checkbox exercise after the first time and people skip through it. The tax part really should be surfaced more prominently.

0 coins

Exactly, it's very easy to click past. After the tenth certification you're not reading anything anymore.

0 coins

The DE 429Z that comes in the mail actually does mention that benefits are taxable income, but yeah, by the time you're certifying regularly you've probably forgotten what was in that initial mailing.

0 coins

Benefit year started for me in March and I had been certifying without touching the withholding option because I figured California taxes would cancel everything out anyway. Got that completely backwards — federal is what matters. When I called EDD using Claimyr I asked an agent to walk me through what my current withholding election showed, and she confirmed it was off and that nothing had been withheld from any of the weeks so far. That meant my next certification was the right time to turn it on and I did it that day.

0 coins

Really glad you posted this. Same mistake I was making, thinking California being exempt meant I was totally in the clear. It's the federal piece that catches you.

0 coins

Right, the two levels are totally separate. California being exempt is good news but it doesn't cover what the IRS wants.

0 coins

This is a genuinely common misconception. The California exemption sounds like a full pass but it only applies to state taxes, not federal.

0 coins

So let me make sure I have this right — unemployment is taxable at the federal level, not at the state level in California, EDD offers 10 percent withholding that you can turn on or off at any certification, and you get a 1099G in January for whatever the total was. Did I miss anything important?

0 coins

That's a solid summary. The one thing to add is that the 10 percent is optional — you can choose not to withhold and just deal with it at filing or through estimated payments during the year. Neither choice is wrong, it just depends on your situation.

0 coins

Okay got it. So it's a choice, not a requirement. Good to know.

0 coins

Also the 1099G is available electronically in UI Online by January 31 even if you opted out of paper mail, so you won't be stuck waiting for the postal version.

0 coins

My claim includes some weeks where I did part-time work and reported wages. Does the withholding apply to only the reduced benefit amount those weeks, or does it still take 10 percent of the full weekly benefit amount?

0 coins

The withholding comes off whatever EDD actually pays you that week. So in a week where you earned part-time wages and your benefit was reduced, it's 10 percent of that lower payment, not the full weekly amount.

0 coins

That makes sense. So the withholding scales with what actually hits the account. Good to know.

0 coins

Pensions also play into this if anyone here is older and started drawing retirement pay around the same time. EDD adjusts the benefit for a pension depending on the situation, and then whatever EDD actually pays is still the federal taxable amount. Something to keep in mind if that applies to you.

0 coins

Good point. People in that situation should definitely check their DE 429Z carefully and ask EDD how the pension was handled before assuming their weekly amount is set.

0 coins

Exactly. The 1099G at year end will show what was actually paid, which is the right number for the federal return. That's the number that matters for taxes, not what the DE 429Z estimated at the start.

0 coins

What about Social Security? If someone is collecting Social Security and also gets some unemployment weeks, does the SS income change how the unemployment is taxed?

0 coins

Social Security doesn't get reported when certifying for unemployment and EDD doesn't deduct it from the benefit. For federal tax purposes though, your overall income picture including Social Security can affect how much of your SS itself gets taxed, which is a separate IRS calculation. Worth running through a tax estimator if that's your situation because having multiple income sources can push you into a range where more of the SS is taxable.

0 coins

Okay that's more complicated than I expected. Good to know it doesn't affect the weekly benefit amount though.

0 coins

Had to call EDD about a totally unrelated issue — my Claim History in UI Online was showing a bunch of weeks as Pending even after I had certified, and I couldn't figure out if it was a withholding problem or something bigger. Tried the phone line a few times and kept hitting the busy signal dead end. Eventually tried Claimyr and got through to an agent who checked my account and confirmed the pending status was an identity step that hadn't been completed, nothing to do with withholding at all. That cleared up once I finished the ID.me process.

0 coins

Okay that's a whole different kind of stressful — pending weeks pile up fast. Glad the agent could actually pinpoint what was holding it up.

0 coins

Yeah the agent was very specific about which step was flagged. Without that call I would have kept guessing.

0 coins

Pending in Claim History with no explanation is one of the most anxiety-inducing things in UI Online. Good that you got a real answer instead of waiting around for something to change on its own.

0 coins

Does the tax situation change at all if you go back to work partway through the year and only collected unemployment for a few months? Like does partial-year unemployment income get treated differently?

0 coins

Nope, same rules apply regardless of how many weeks you collected. EDD adds up everything it paid you for the year on the 1099G, and that full amount is federal taxable income no matter when in the year the payments happened. If you also had wages from going back to work, those get added in and your overall income picture determines your bracket.

0 coins

Okay so there's no partial-year exception. Good to know, makes the math straightforward at least.

0 coins

The only thing that might change is whether the withholding you chose was enough, since going back to work adds more income. Worth running an estimate once you're employed again.

0 coins

Just want to flag something I saw get confused earlier in this thread — a few people were mixing up the idea of the certification and the application. The application is what you filed once to open the claim, and that's where you give your work history. Certifying is the every-two-weeks check-in where you answer the availability and work search questions and that's where the withholding election comes up. They're two separate things in UI Online and doing one has nothing to do with the other.

0 coins

Oh I definitely confused those two. I kept calling certifying 'applying' and my friend had no idea what I was talking about.

0 coins

Super common. The language EDD uses isn't always intuitive. Once you know the difference it makes all the online guides make a lot more sense.

0 coins

Worth clarifying for anyone new to this — the application starts the claim, certifying keeps it going every two weeks. Two completely different actions in myEDD.

0 coins

For anyone who's already deep into their claim without withholding, one practical thing to do right now is look at your total payments in UI Online under the Payments section. Add up what you've received so far, estimate what percentage of that you'd owe in federal tax based on your bracket, and figure out if you have that set aside. Then turn on withholding for whatever weeks are left. At least you go into filing season knowing the number.

0 coins

This is a really useful approach. I'm going to do this tonight — look at total paid so far, do the rough math, then turn on withholding for the rest.

0 coins

The Payments tab breaks it down week by week so you can see exactly what landed. Makes the total easy to calculate.

0 coins

Practical advice. It's one of those things that's obvious in hindsight but helpful to actually spell out.

0 coins

Doing the math before April is so much better than getting a number you weren't expecting from your tax software. At least then you can make a plan.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure