Back to California Unemployment

Amy Fleming

Denied unemployment because of injury, can I apply for disability instead? California EDD question

So I got denied my unemployment claim and the Notice of Determination says the reason is basically that I wasn't able and available for work because of my injury. I hurt my back pretty badly about six weeks ago and when I had my phone interview EDD asked me if I could work and I told them honestly that my doctor had restricted me from lifting and I was in physical therapy twice a week. I figured being upfront was the right call but now I'm sitting here with a denial and no income. My job ended because the company did a round of layoffs, not because of my injury. The injury happened separately like two weeks after I got laid off. So technically the reason I lost work was the layoff, but EDD is saying I can't collect because I'm not fully available right now. Does that make sense to anyone? I never even connected the two things until this denial showed up. What I'm trying to figure out now is whether I can pivot and apply for State Disability Insurance instead. I've seen SDI mentioned in a few places but I have no idea if I still qualify given the timeline or how long I'd have to wait for it to kick in. Has anyone dealt with being denied unemployment because of injury and then switched over to disability? Or am I stuck trying to appeal the EDD decision while also dealing with the injury? Really not sure which direction to go here and my savings won't hold out forever.

DE 2501F - that's the form I ended up staring at for a while when my own situation came up. Got laid off in March and then developed a pretty serious shoulder issue about three weeks after, almost the same sequence as yours. EDD denied my UI for the same reason, couldn't meet the available-for-work requirement. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is what I ended up using to get a live EDD agent on the phone because I couldn't get through on my own. The video they put together on reaching a live person at EDD is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if you want to see what that looks like. What I actually asked the agent about was whether I could have my UI claim stopped and filed for SDI at the same time, or whether one blocked the other. The agent looked at my claim and said I had to stop certifying for UI before SDI could pay me for the same days, since EDD's rule is you can't get both programs paying you for overlapping days. She also confirmed my existing UI claim would just sit there and I could reopen it once my doctor cleared me to work, as long as the benefit year hadn't ended yet.

0 coins

The stopping certifying part is what I would have gotten wrong. I assumed you just filed SDI and EDD sorted it out automatically.

0 coins

Thank you, this is exactly the scenario I'm in. So I can file SDI now and then come back to the UI claim once I'm cleared? That's actually a big relief to hear.

0 coins

DE 2501F is for the claimant's SDI filing portion, there's also a part the doctor fills out. Worth knowing both parts need to go in before EDD processes anything.

0 coins

Unemployment requires being able to work, available for work, and looking for work every single week you certify. A lot of people think EDD focuses only on why you lost the job, but that's only part of it. If a physical restriction makes you unavailable during a week, that week isn't payable under UI even if the reason you lost work in the first place was totally legitimate. The denial in your situation is unfortunately technically correct, which is frustrating because the layoff was real.

0 coins

Makes sense now, I guess I conflated losing the job with being eligible week to week. Those are two separate questions.

0 coins

Yeah EDD checks both. Got caught by this myself when I had a minor surgery after a layoff. Week I had the procedure I had to stop certifying.

0 coins

The notice she got (DE 1080CZ) should spell out exactly which weeks were denied and why, so she can see whether it was all weeks or just specific ones when she was restricted.

0 coins

SDI timeline matters here. EDD's rule is that you have to file no earlier than nine days after your disability starts and no later than 49 days after. If your injury was six weeks ago that's 42 days, so you're still inside the window but just barely. File SDI Online as soon as you can so you don't blow the deadline. You'll also need your doctor to complete their section.

0 coins

49 days - okay that's the number I needed. Six weeks is 42 so I need to move on this immediately.

0 coins

Had no idea there was a filing deadline for SDI at all. I always thought you just filed whenever and they'd back-date it. Good to know that's not how it works.

0 coins

The 49-day rule is real and they don't bend it easily. File today if you can.

0 coins

SDI Online is at myEDD - same login as UI Online which is handy, you don't need a whole separate account setup.

0 coins

Appealing the UI denial is still an option and you have 30 days from the mailing date on the DE 1080CZ to file a written appeal using the DE 1000M or just a letter. But honestly in your situation the appeal might not change much since EDD's position is about availability, not about the reason for the layoff. You'd have to show you were able and available during the weeks they denied. If your doctor's restrictions were real during those weeks, that's a hard case to win on appeal. SDI seems like the more direct path for now.

0 coins

DE 1000M, got it. I'll look at the mailing date on the notice tonight. Thinking SDI is probably the right move but I want to keep the appeal option open just in case.

0 coins

Filing SDI doesn't stop you from appealing the UI denial, those are separate processes. You could do both.

0 coins

30 days goes faster than you think. Count from the mailing date on the notice, not from when you got it.

0 coins

Had a co-worker convince me once that SDI pays less than UI so it wasn't worth switching. That's not necessarily true at all. The two programs use different formulas so your SDI benefit could actually be higher, lower, or about the same as your UI amount depending on your earnings. You can estimate the SDI benefit on EDD's site using the DI benefit calculator, and separately estimate UI on the unemployment benefit calculator. Worth running both numbers before deciding how hard to push the UI appeal.

0 coins

Didn't even know EDD had an SDI calculator. Running both now.

0 coins

My SDI came out higher than my UI would've been. The base period calculations are a little different between the two programs.

0 coins

Also SDI doesn't have a job search requirement, obviously, since you're supposed to be unable to work. That's a practical difference too.

0 coins

What your doctor puts on the SDI certification actually shapes how EDD handles the claim. The start date and end date of disability on that form, the specific restrictions described, all of it feeds into which weeks SDI will pay. Make sure your doctor's dates line up with when you actually couldn't work, not just the date you first saw them.

0 coins

Good point, my first appointment was three days after the injury so there could be a small gap in the dates if the doctor uses the visit date instead of the injury date.

0 coins

Mention that to your doctor explicitly when they fill out their section. They should use the actual onset date of the disability, not necessarily the first visit date.

0 coins

The two programs really are completely separate in EDD's eyes. People sometimes think applying for SDI will mess up their UI claim or restart some waiting period, but those are independent processes. The only thing that overlaps is you can't get paid by both for the same days. Your UI benefit year clock keeps running whether you're on SDI or not, which matters for when you can go back to certifying for UI once you're cleared.

0 coins

Benefit year clock keeps running - noted. So I shouldn't assume I'll just have the full remaining balance waiting for me, the year might expire.

0 coins

Exactly that. I had an SDI period that ate into my UI benefit year and ended up with fewer weeks of UI left when I went back to work. Asked EDD about it - used Claimyr to get through to someone because getting anyone on the phone that week was not happening - and the agent pulled up my claim and confirmed how many weeks I had left on the UI side and what date the benefit year closed. Filed SDI and got back to UI once I was cleared with a clear picture of what was left.

0 coins

This is an important point that most people miss. The 52-week benefit year doesn't pause just because you switched to SDI.

0 coins

Made the mistake once of continuing to certify for UI while I was on doctor's restrictions because I figured I'd sort it out later. That just creates overpayment issues. EDD asked me on the certification whether I was able and available for work and I said yes when really I was under restrictions. Had to deal with an overpayment notice later that was not fun. If you have restrictions from a doctor, stop certifying UI and file SDI instead. Don't try to collect both.

0 coins

Really glad you said this. I've certified two weeks since the denial came and I should probably look at whether those were even legit given my restrictions.

0 coins

Those two weeks since the denial - what did you answer to the able and available question? That's the key thing to sort out.

0 coins

The overpayment process is genuinely stressful, the warning here is worth taking seriously.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration is required for most UI claimants, usually within 21 days of the notice telling you to register. If you're switching to SDI full time right now that requirement becomes moot for the moment, but when you eventually come back to UI certifying, make sure your CalJOBS profile is current and your resume is posted or EDD could flag your account.

0 coins

Hadn't even thought about CalJOBS during all this. I did register but I don't think my resume is actually posted.

0 coins

Log into caljobs.ca.gov and check that the resume is set to active/searchable. Sometimes people create a resume draft and never publish it.

0 coins

My understanding was that the waiting week for SDI was different from the UI waiting week, so you can't just assume one satisfies the other. Each program has its own unpaid first period. Someone with actual knowledge of both should weigh in.

0 coins

SDI has its own seven-day waiting period before benefits start, and UI has its own one-week waiting period. Completely separate. Serving the UI waiting week doesn't count toward SDI and vice versa.

0 coins

So she could have served her UI waiting week already and still have to serve another wait for SDI. That's a rough overlap.

0 coins

Yep, the SDI seven days run from when the disability starts. If you file within that first week they just apply it to the waiting period automatically.

0 coins

Something I didn't know when I went through a vaguely similar situation: Disability Insurance covers non-work-related injuries. If your back injury happened off the job, that's exactly what SDI is built for. Workers' comp is the program for injuries that happened at work. Sounds like yours was not work-related based on what you wrote, so SDI is the right door.

0 coins

Correct, the injury had nothing to do with work, happened during a move. SDI is the right fit then.

0 coins

Workers' comp and SDI are genuinely different programs and the application process is totally different. Good clarification.

0 coins

Paid Family Leave comes up in these conversations sometimes and I want to flag that PFL is for caring for a family member or bonding with a new baby. It's under the SDI umbrella but it's not what you file when you personally can't work due to injury. That's the DI part of SDI. Mentioning it because I mixed up PFL and DI when I first started reading about it and filed the wrong thing.

0 coins

DI vs PFL - I was vaguely confused about that acronym. DI is for my own disability, PFL would be for caring for someone else. Got it.

0 coins

Both are filed in SDI Online but the claim type is different. When you start the form it asks you to choose, so just pick the right one.

0 coins

The 49-day deadline is different for PFL too so if you're filing DI for yourself make sure you're on the right path before you check timelines.

0 coins

EDD's phone lines are genuinely brutal when you have a complicated claim situation. The UI and SDI sides of EDD have separate phone lines too which a lot of people don't realize. The SDI line is 1-800-480-3287. The UI line is the main 1-800-300-5616. If your questions span both like yours do, you might end up having to call both.

0 coins

Two separate phone lines for two programs. That's going to be a fun afternoon.

0 coins

SDI line hours and UI line hours are both weekdays 8 to 5. Neither one is easy to get through on the first try.

0 coins

The appeal clock on the UI denial is still ticking even if you decide SDI is the right move. Appeals have to be in writing within 30 calendar days of the mailing date. You can appeal and still file SDI simultaneously - they don't cancel each other out. If you're close to the 30 days on the notice, send a short letter or use the DE 1000M just to preserve the right to appeal, even if you don't have a full argument ready yet.

0 coins

Sending the DE 1000M as a protective measure while I build the actual argument - that makes sense. Can I still submit more information after I file the appeal form?

0 coins

Yes, once your appeal is in you can send additional documentation before the hearing. The administrative law judge at the CUIAB hearing will give both sides a chance to present. File first to protect the deadline.

0 coins

The notice from CUIAB will come by mail at least 10 days before any hearing, so you'll have time to prepare once the appeal is in the system.

0 coins

Social Security Disability is a completely different federal program and takes much longer, usually many months or even years to process a first decision. What EDD offers through SDI is a California state program that's separate from Social Security. If the injury is temporary and your doctor expects you to recover, SDI is the relevant program. Social Security is typically for long-term or permanent disabilities.

0 coins

Doctor expects full recovery in about two to three months, so SDI is definitely the right track here.

0 coins

The speed difference between SDI and Social Security Disability is massive. SDI is actually relatively quick by comparison once your paperwork is in.

0 coins

Important distinction. A lot of people hear disability benefits and immediately think Social Security, but California's SDI program is a totally different animal with different rules and timelines.

0 coins

Workers' comp situation is worth flagging even if the injury wasn't from the job. EDD's certifications ask you to report workers' comp if you're receiving it, and EDD decides how that affects your payment. Since yours wasn't work-related, workers' comp probably doesn't apply, but I wanted to mention it so you don't get caught later if anything about that changes.

0 coins

Definitely no workers' comp situation here. The injury happened at home during a move, totally unrelated to any employer.

0 coins

Just flagging it is the right call. Those questions on the SDI form about other income can trip people up if they have any overlapping payments.

0 coins

Pension or retirement income is another thing EDD looks at differently than you'd expect. If you happen to be receiving any pension from a past employer, EDD could potentially reduce your UI benefit based on it. SDI handles that differently. Since you mentioned the layoff and the injury both being recent events, this probably doesn't apply to you, but posting it in case others reading this thread are in a different situation.

0 coins

Pensions reducing UI was something I didn't know about until it happened to me. Good thing to flag here even if it's not the main person's situation.

0 coins

Social Security payments don't get deducted from UI, which is a thing people also often mix up with pension deductions.

0 coins

Layoffs followed by injuries before the first check even arrives is a rough sequence to deal with. When I had a UI claim that got tangled up with a medical situation, the UI Online message system was too slow for the specific questions I had, and the live chat in UI Online only runs Monday to Friday 9 to 2 which I kept missing. Claimyr got me to an EDD agent when I couldn't get through on my own - the agent looked up my file and confirmed which weeks had already been processed and which were still pending so I knew exactly where I stood before deciding whether to pivot to SDI.

0 coins

Live chat only until 2 PM - I didn't realize it had a cutoff. That explains why I kept seeing it unavailable when I tried after work.

0 coins

The live chat window being 9 to 2 is a detail EDD doesn't advertise loudly. Easy to miss.

0 coins

If the agent could pull up exactly which weeks were pending versus processed, that's the kind of specific info that's hard to get any other way when you're trying to figure out whether to appeal or just move on.

0 coins

Once you file SDI and it's approved, the benefit payments come to your EDD prepaid card or direct deposit, same delivery method as UI. You don't need to set up a whole new payment method. If you already had direct deposit set up for UI, the SDI payments should go to the same account once your SDI claim is approved.

0 coins

Good to know, I had direct deposit set up from when I was certifying for UI.

0 coins

The Money Network card is what EDD uses now. If you had that set up it carries over to SDI as well.

0 coins

Worth double-checking your payment preferences in myEDD once your SDI claim is active, just to confirm everything transferred correctly between the two programs.

0 coins

Once your doctor clears you to return to work and your SDI period ends, reopening your UI claim through UI Online is the fastest way to get back to certifying. The existing claim just needs to be reopened, not filed fresh, as long as the original benefit year is still open. If the year has expired you'd need to file a whole new claim and go through the process again from scratch.

0 coins

Okay so I need to track when my benefit year closes. The DE 429Z should have that date on it right?

0 coins

The DE 429Z shows the weekly benefit amount and the maximum benefit amount. The benefit year runs 52 weeks from when the claim started. EDD mails the DE 429Z after they process the initial application and it shows the claim dates.

0 coins

If the injury recovery runs long you could realistically end up at the edge of that benefit year, so worth keeping an eye on the calendar.

0 coins

Tax treatment is also different between the two programs. UI benefits are taxable at the federal level but exempt from California state income tax. SDI disability benefits are generally not taxable at the federal level unless they're treated as a substitute for Social Security Disability. It's worth knowing going into the year for planning purposes.

0 coins

Hadn't even gotten to taxes in my head yet but that's a genuinely useful thing to know.

0 coins

The 1099G from EDD covers UI. SDI issues its own form for the payments. Two separate tax documents to watch for if you end up collecting both in the same year.

0 coins

10 percent federal withholding can be elected on UI certifications. SDI has its own withholding options. Neither one is automatic so you have to actively choose it if you want taxes taken out.

0 coins

Had a friend try to file SDI late because nobody told them about the 49-day deadline, and EDD denied it. Appeal processes do exist for late SDI filings if you have a good reason for missing the window, but it's a whole extra headache. File as soon as possible, don't wait for the UI situation to fully resolve first.

0 coins

Filing SDI today. Genuinely not waiting another 24 hours on this after everything in this thread.

0 coins

The SDI filing taking priority over figuring out the UI appeal makes total sense given the deadline situation described.

0 coins

If your doctor needs a few days to get their portion of the form done, file your part now anyway so your submission date is documented. The doctor can submit their section after.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure