Back to California Unemployment

Ravi Gupta

Can I get unemployment if laid off after performance improvement plan - California EDD question

So my employer put me on a PIP about two months ago and last week they let me go. The whole thing felt pretty orchestrated honestly - like they handed me this improvement plan with targets that kept shifting, then terminated me before the 90 days were even up. HR called it a 'separation due to performance' but I was never formally written up for anything before the PIP landed on my desk. I filed my California EDD claim the same day I got the news, went through myEDD and got it submitted. The thing that's eating at me is whether being on a performance improvement plan before the layoff changes how EDD looks at this. Did they fire me? Did they lay me off? I honestly don't know what box I checked on the application. My base period wages are solid - I was making decent money for about 18 months at this company before the PIP showed up. I'm worried EDD is going to look at the PIP as some kind of proof I deserved to be let go and deny the whole claim. Has anyone gone through something like this where EDD had to decide whether a PIP termination counted as misconduct?

PIP situation ended my job back in spring - targets kept moving on me too, and when they finally cut me loose the separation paperwork just said 'performance.' Filed with California EDD and kept hitting a wall trying to reach anyone to find out where my claim stood. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to the phone queue and ended up actually talking to an EDD agent. They pulled up my claim and told me the interview was already scheduled, the date and time were on the DE 4800 notice EDD had mailed me, and that I should check the UI Online homepage where it would show up too. The agent said the interview is where both sides tell their story - the employer and me - and EDD decides from there whether the ending was misconduct or not. They couldn't tell me the outcome, but they confirmed my claim was moving and not stuck. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD by phone is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if you want to see what that process looks like.

0 coins

The DE 4800 thing - does that show up in UI Online too or only in the mail? I haven't received anything physical yet and I applied five days ago.

0 coins

The UI Online homepage showed mine before the paper notice showed up at the house, so check there first. The date and the time of the interview were both on that screen.

0 coins

Worth knowing the interview is set up so you can actually tell your side. EDD doesn't just take the employer's word on a PIP situation.

0 coins

Whether EDD treats it as a firing or a layoff matters a lot here. My company did something similar - called it a 'performance exit' on the paperwork, and when EDD got involved the question became: did the employer prove there was actual misconduct? EDD's standard is that if you're fired, the employer has to show real misconduct happened - not just that your numbers slipped or they decided they wanted you gone. A PIP with shifting targets sounds like it's really far from that bar. The interview is where the employer makes their case, and if the best they can say is 'he didn't meet PIP goals' that's usually not misconduct in EDD's view.

0 coins

So even if the paperwork says 'performance termination' EDD can still look at it differently at the interview stage?

0 coins

Exactly - the label HR puts on it doesn't lock EDD in. The phone interview is specifically for EDD to hear both sides and decide what actually happened. What you tell them about the shifting targets matters.

0 coins

Had a friend who went through almost this exact thing and EDD approved him. The employer just said 'didn't meet PIP requirements' and that wasn't enough to show misconduct.

0 coins

That tracks with how EDD reads it. 'Didn't meet targets' and 'committed misconduct' are different things.

0 coins

Wait I'm confused about something - is the phone interview the same thing as an appeal? Like if you do the interview does that mean you've already been denied?

0 coins

Not the same thing at all. The interview happens before any decision, when EDD still needs to hear both sides about why you left. An appeal is what you file after a denial, within 30 days of the Notice of Determination. Completely different stage.

0 coins

Oh okay that makes way more sense, I was getting really stressed thinking the interview meant bad news already.

0 coins

Super common mix-up. Interview is part of the normal process for anyone who was fired or quit, not a sign anything's going wrong.

0 coins

The 'misconduct' question kept me up at night when I was in a similar spot. Here's the thing I learned going through it: California EDD's bar for misconduct is specifically about intentional wrongdoing, not poor performance. My supervisor kept telling me I was going to get denied because I had a PIP, but that's just not how EDD reads the law. Performance issues by themselves - missing targets, low ratings, things like that - aren't misconduct. Misconduct in EDD's world is more about deliberately breaking rules or doing something dishonest. A PIP is almost always a performance story, not a misconduct story.

0 coins

This is exactly what I needed to hear. My situation was 100% performance framing, never anything about breaking rules or dishonesty.

0 coins

Then go into that phone interview and tell them exactly what you told here - shifting targets, no formal writeups before the PIP, the whole picture. That's your record for EDD to evaluate.

0 coins

My company tried the same thing, HR told me EDD would deny me because of the PIP and I believed them for like two weeks before I actually talked to someone. The HR people were just wrong.

0 coins

Does CalJOBS have anything to do with this? I know you're supposed to register there but I don't know if it affects how EDD looks at a PIP termination.

0 coins

CalJOBS is about your job search going forward, not about why you were terminated. EDD sends a notice called the DE 8405 that tells you if you need to register there, and you generally have 21 days from that notice to get it done and post a resume. It's separate from the question of why you were let go.

0 coins

Got it, thanks. I was mixing up two different parts of the process.

0 coins

EDD asked me in my own interview whether I had tried to fix the performance issues they were pointing to, and whether I'd been given any support or resources. For a PIP situation that question matters a lot - if you show up to that call with documentation that the goalposts kept moving, that's the kind of detail that shapes what EDD decides. I'd write out a timeline before the interview so you're not scrambling.

0 coins

Timeline is a good call. I actually have emails showing the targets changed twice during the PIP period.

0 coins

Those emails are gold. The interviewer can't see them directly but you can reference what they show, and that becomes part of the record EDD works from.

0 coins

I did the same thing for my own interview and I genuinely think having dates and specifics made the difference. EDD can't tell from the paperwork what the day-to-day reality was.

0 coins

Severance question here because it's been nagging at me - my PIP termination came with two weeks of severance. Does reporting that severance mess with my EDD benefits or delay when I can start collecting? Mine just came as a lump sum on my last paycheck basically.

0 coins

Severance paid under a company plan or policy isn't counted as wages for unemployment purposes, so it doesn't hold up your claim the way some people expect. You still report it when EDD asks because it's on the list of things to report, and EDD handles how it gets treated. I was worried about the same thing and used Claimyr to get an EDD agent on the phone before my first certification - the agent looked at my account and confirmed my pending weeks were there and that I should just report the severance as the certification asked. Filed and moved forward from that call.

0 coins

That's really helpful, I didn't know severance was treated differently from regular wages in this context.

0 coins

Vacation pay is different though, right? I thought that one could affect the timing?

0 coins

Vacation pay, holiday pay, in-lieu-of-notice pay - EDD handles those differently from severance. Report them all and EDD decides how they affect each week. Don't try to calculate it yourself.

0 coins

Something about the CalJOBS resume requirement that's worth flagging from my own experience - I didn't realize I needed to actually post a resume there, not just register an account. Thought signing up was enough and then got a notice that my payment was held up. Make sure you post the actual resume within that 21-day window on the DE 8405.

0 coins

Both steps required, got it. Register AND post the resume before that deadline on the notice.

0 coins

Exactly. And if you're not sure whether you even need to do it, EDD will tell you in the notice - some people are exempt but you won't know until it comes.

0 coins

I almost made this same mistake. I thought creating the account was the whole thing.

0 coins

The HR people at my old company told me flat out that because I was on a PIP I 'wouldn't qualify for unemployment.' I actually believed that for almost two weeks. Then I actually read what EDD says. The employer gets to respond to the claim and can argue misconduct, but just saying someone failed a PIP is not the same as proving misconduct. I ended up getting approved.

0 coins

How long did your whole process take from filing to seeing a payment?

0 coins

About five weeks total. The interview happened around week two, then I kept certifying while EDD processed everything, and the payments for the pending weeks all came through at once after the decision.

0 coins

Five weeks feels like forever when you're waiting but that's pretty standard from what I've seen on here.

0 coins

My claim after a PIP termination had a waiting week that confused me at first. Expected money for the first week I certified and nothing came - turns out every California EDD claim has a one-week unpaid waiting period on the first eligible week. First certification usually covers that waiting week plus one paid week, so payment shows up after the second week of your claim, not the first.

0 coins

So the waiting week is just always there no matter what, it's not a sign something's wrong?

0 coins

Always there, every claim. It doesn't reduce the total your claim can pay, it just means week one is unpaid. Doesn't mean EDD is punishing you or that there's an issue.

0 coins

I literally thought the waiting week meant my claim was under review for some extra reason. Nobody explained it to me when I filed.

0 coins

Can I ask a dumb question - does the fact that the company set you up with a PIP in the first place count as evidence of ANYTHING for EDD, or is it just background noise that doesn't matter to the decision?

0 coins

Not a dumb question. The PIP itself is context EDD hears about, but the question EDD is actually answering is whether what happened at the end was misconduct. A PIP shows there were performance concerns, but performance concerns aren't misconduct. EDD cares about what you did or didn't do and whether it rises to that level.

0 coins

So basically the PIP is like, the employer's internal process, and EDD has its own standard that doesn't map directly onto the PIP outcome?

0 coins

Exactly right. What HR called it doesn't bind EDD. EDD decides under its own rules.

0 coins

Spent three weeks after my own PIP firing trying to understand why my UI Online kept showing pending weeks with no explanation. Couldn't get through on the phone no matter what I tried. Ended up getting to an EDD agent through Claimyr - walked through my claim with them and they told me identity verification was still open on my account, that I needed to finish the ID.me process. Once I completed that the pending weeks resolved pretty fast.

0 coins

ID.me caught me too - didn't realize I had to upload a photo and actually let them share it with EDD. I thought creating the account was verification enough.

0 coins

Same assumption I made. The agent was clear that until ID.me confirms and shares the information with EDD, the claim just sits there pending.

0 coins

I did verify through ID.me when I first filed, got a confirmation. Should I be worried that mine might still be pending on EDD's end?

0 coins

Another thing about the certification side once you're approved - you report work and earnings for the week they were actually earned, not when the check hits your account. If you pick up any part-time work while this claim is pending, the week you worked it is the week you report it, even if you get paid two weeks later.

0 coins

Good to know going forward. I've been thinking about some freelance work while I look for a new job full-time.

0 coins

Freelance income gets reported too - same rule, week it was earned. EDD has a formula where the first $25 or 25% of weekly gross, whichever is more, doesn't count against you, and the rest gets subtracted from your weekly amount. Full-time work stops benefits for that week regardless.

0 coins

I didn't know there was an earnings formula like that. I assumed any work would just kill the benefits for the week.

0 coins

The base period thing is worth looking at. EDD uses your highest-paid quarter of the standard base period - the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before your claim starts - to figure the weekly benefit amount. With 18 months of solid wages there's a decent chance your weekly amount lands somewhere reasonable in EDD's range.

0 coins

How do I even figure out what my highest quarter was without waiting for EDD to tell me?

0 coins

EDD's site has a benefit calculator you can use to estimate - just plug in your quarterly wages. The real number comes on the DE 429Z notice EDD mails you, but the calculator gives you a ballpark before that arrives.

0 coins

I had no idea about the highest quarter thing. I assumed EDD just averaged everything out.

0 coins

The employer response window matters too. EDD mails the previous employer a notice about the claim and they have 10 days from the date on it to respond. If the employer just says 'PIP failure' and nothing more specific about misconduct, that's a weak response. If they don't respond at all, they lose the ability to appeal EDD's decision later.

0 coins

So an employer who doesn't respond to EDD's notice is basically giving up their right to fight the claim?

0 coins

They can't appeal EDD's decision if they didn't respond to the notice. EDD's rules specifically say that.

0 coins

My old employer did respond but their response was just restating the PIP criteria. EDD still approved me. The response has to actually show misconduct, not just describe a performance process.

0 coins

Not sure if this came up already but keep certifying every two weeks even while EDD is still deciding the interview outcome. You're not approved yet but EDD can only pay the pending weeks if you certified for them. If you stop certifying and they later approve you, those uncertified weeks are gone.

0 coins

This is so important, thank you. I wasn't sure if I should wait until there was an actual decision to start certifying.

0 coins

Certify on schedule no matter what. The pending status in Claim History just means EDD is still deciding. Keep going.

0 coins

And if you have an appeal later, same rule - certify during the appeal or you can't get paid for those weeks even if you win.

0 coins

Two months into my PIP and they let me go too - mine was 'not meeting expectations' on the termination form. Had a question about how the alternate base period works because I'd had a pay raise fairly recently and was hoping EDD might use a more recent quarter to get me a higher weekly amount. Got through to an EDD agent through Claimyr and asked directly. The agent explained that the alternate base period only kicks in automatically when my wages weren't enough under the standard base period to have a valid claim at all - since my claim was already valid under the standard period, the alternate base period wasn't going to come into play to bump my weekly amount. Helped me stop expecting a higher number than what the DE 429Z would show.

0 coins

Wait so you can't just choose the alternate base period if it would give you more money?

0 coins

That's what the agent told me - it's not an option you pick for a higher payout. It only applies automatically if the standard period doesn't have enough wages to qualify at all. If your claim already qualifies, the alternate period doesn't get used.

0 coins

This is a really common misconception. Had the same question when I filed.

0 coins

EDD's payments once things are moving - do they go straight to a bank account or is it that card?

0 coins

Default is a Money Network prepaid debit card EDD sends you. You can switch to direct deposit through myEDD if you prefer your own bank account. Payment info updates daily in UI Online and you can also check through EDD's automated phone line at 1-866-333-4606 anytime, it runs 24 hours.

0 coins

Money Network, not Bank of America? I keep seeing people say Bank of America online.

0 coins

EDD switched to Money Network. Anything saying Bank of America is outdated.

0 coins

For anyone reading who took a freelance gig or some contract work during the PIP period before the actual termination - wages from that work count toward the base period too if they hit the right quarters. Worth factoring in when you're trying to estimate where you land on the benefit amount.

0 coins

Is self-employment income treated the same as W-2 income for base period wage purposes? I always assumed EDD only counted traditional employment.

0 coins

EDD's base period pulls from wages reported to EDD, which typically means W-2 work. Self-employment where you're paying your own taxes separately usually doesn't count for the base period wage total. Worth asking EDD directly about your specific situation if it's a mix.

0 coins

One more thing for after the decision - if EDD mails a Notice of Determination and you disagree with what it says, the appeal window is 30 days from the mailing date on that notice. The form DE 1000M is the appeal form, it comes with the notice. If you miss that 30-day window you can still appeal but you need to explain why you missed it. The appeal goes eventually to an administrative law judge.

0 coins

I really hope I don't get to that stage but good to know the 30-day clock starts from the mailing date, not from when I actually receive it.

0 coins

Exactly - mailing date, so if it takes a few days to arrive you're already a few days into that window. Open it and look at the date the moment it shows up.

0 coins

And you keep certifying during the appeal. Someone already said it above but it's worth saying twice.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure