Can I get unemployment if fired after refusing a schedule change? California EDD question
So basically my manager came to me two weeks before my shift was supposed to change and said they were moving me from days to nights permanently starting the following Monday. I have two kids in school and there's no way I can do overnight shifts - my spouse works evenings so there would literally be nobody to get the kids up and to school. I told my supervisor I couldn't do it and asked if there was any flexibility. They said no. I showed up the next week still on days because I hadn't agreed to anything, and they handed me a termination letter saying I refused to comply with operational requirements. Now I'm trying to figure out if I even qualify for California EDD unemployment. I didn't quit - they fired me. But I also didn't just accept the schedule change. Has anyone dealt with this exact situation? I'm really scared I'm going to get denied and I don't know how to explain my side of it.
81 comments

Omar Hassan
Termination paperwork from my last job said the same thing - 'failure to comply with operational directives' - and I ended up needing to actually talk to someone at EDD about how that was going to look on my claim. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to a live EDD agent because every time I called on my own I hit a wall of automated messages. The agent walked me through what the phone interview process looks like for a termination situation and told me to gather documentation showing the schedule change notice, any communications where I tried to work something out, and my termination letter. There's a video they put out about reaching a live person at EDD by phone: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. What the agent told me was that EDD looks at whether the employer can show there was actual misconduct, not just that you didn't go along with a change, and that the interview is where I'd get to explain my side. I ended up getting paid after the interview.
0 coins
Freya Christensen
AuthorOkay this is really helpful. I've been trying to call EDD for two days straight and can't get past the recording. What kind of documentation did you end up sending in? I have the text messages where I asked my supervisor about alternatives and the termination letter itself.
0 coins
Chloe Robinson
The part about misconduct is key. A lot of people assume getting fired automatically means they're disqualified but EDD's standard is whether the employer can prove there was actual misconduct, not just a disagreement about work conditions.
0 coins
Omar Hassan
The texts showing you tried to find a compromise are exactly the kind of thing to hold onto. I kept screenshots of my emails and mentioned them during the interview - the interviewer asked if I had anything to submit and I said yes and they told me how to send it in.
0 coins
Diego Chavez
My whole claim got tangled up last year because I mixed up what a 'phone interview' was versus filing an appeal. I kept waiting for an appeal hearing letter and doing nothing, thinking the interview was something different. For anyone in the same boat: if EDD has a question about why you were separated from your job - fired, quit, whatever - they schedule a phone interview first. The notice they mail is called the DE 4800 and it has the date and time on it. That's when you explain your situation. You don't do anything until that notice comes, and then you make sure your phone is on and available at the exact time listed. That interview is separate from an appeal, which only happens if EDD decides against you afterward.
0 coins
Freya Christensen
AuthorWait, so there's going to be a phone interview before EDD makes any decision on my case? I thought I would just get approved or denied first. This actually makes me feel a little better because I want a chance to explain the childcare situation.
0 coins
NeonNebula
The DE 4800 also shows up on your UI Online homepage so you have two places to check the time. Don't miss it - if you're not available when the interviewer calls at that time, EDD will decide with whatever information they already have and that can mean a denial.
0 coins
Diego Chavez
Exactly right on the UI Online homepage thing. And if for some reason you can't do the scheduled time you have to contact EDD at least a day before to try to change it - they can only give you an open slot but it's worth asking if something comes up.
0 coins
Anastasia Kozlov
Spent three months convinced I was going to lose my benefits because HR labeled my termination as 'insubordination' on their forms. What I learned the hard way is that EDD draws a distinction between an employee who refuses a reasonable work direction versus an employee who pushes back on a significant change to the terms of employment. The way my claims rep explained it during the phone interview: the employer has to come to EDD and show there was misconduct on my part - willful disregard of their reasonable expectations or something along those lines. HR calling it insubordination on a form doesn't settle the question. EDD talks to both sides.
0 coins
Freya Christensen
AuthorSo the fact that my termination letter says 'refused operational requirements' isn't automatically a denial? That's what I was most afraid of - that those words on the paper would just end it right there.
0 coins
Sean Kelly
The letter is what the employer says, not what EDD decides. EDD makes their own determination after they hear from both you and the employer. The employer gets mailed a notice too and has a chance to respond but their version isn't the final word.
0 coins
Anastasia Kozlov
Right. And in my situation the employer actually didn't respond to EDD's notice in time, which meant EDD only had my side when they made the decision. I found that out during the interview itself.
0 coins
Zara Mirza
Can I ask something that might be dumb - does it matter that you technically showed up to work and then got fired rather than just refusing to come in at all? Like does the fact that you were physically there affect anything?
0 coins
Chloe Robinson
Showing up under your old schedule after they announced the change actually works in your favor because it shows you didn't abandon the job. You kept coming in - they chose to end the employment relationship. That's going to be part of the picture EDD looks at.
0 coins
Zara Mirza
That makes sense. I was thinking maybe continuing to show up might look like you were refusing to follow instructions but it sounds like it's more complicated than that.
0 coins
Luca Russo
The key factor is who ended the employment. The original poster was fired - EDD treats that differently than a quit. With a quit, the burden shifts to you to show you had a good reason. Getting fired puts it on the employer to show misconduct. Those are pretty different starting points.
0 coins
Chloe Robinson
Small correction to what was said above - actually both are evaluated by EDD after the phone interview, it's not exactly a 'burden shift' in a legal sense. EDD's own language is that if you quit you need to show a good reason, and if fired the employer has to prove misconduct. But either way EDD is the one deciding, and the interview is where both sides get to give their information.
0 coins
Nia Harris
Applied for unemployment last spring after my employer changed my territory and tripled my drive time, I didn't agree to it, and they let me go. EDD sent me the DE 4800 about ten days after I filed. The interview took maybe 15 minutes - they asked about the original terms of my employment, what changed, whether I had asked about alternatives, and what happened at the end. I had written down a timeline before the call and that helped a lot because I could answer everything in order without getting flustered.
0 coins
Freya Christensen
AuthorWriting down a timeline before the call is a really good idea. Did they ask you to prove the change was significant or did they just take your word for it?
0 coins
Nia Harris
They asked me if I had anything in writing about the territory change. I did - my original offer letter described the territory and I had an email from my manager announcing the expansion. The interviewer said I could submit them and told me where to send copies. Having the paper trail helped.
0 coins
GalaxyGazer
The original offer letter comparison is smart. If the original employment terms are documented and what the employer tried to change them to is documented, that's a lot clearer than just saying 'they tried to change my schedule' with nothing to back it up.
0 coins
Mateo Sanchez
My cousin went through something similar and she got denied. I think its because she quit before they could fire her though? Like she walked out first. that might be the difference here
0 coins
Chloe Robinson
Whether someone quit or was fired matters a lot to EDD. A quit means you have to show you had a good reason to leave - like the change made the job impossible to keep. Being fired means the employer has to prove misconduct. If your cousin quit she was in a tougher spot from the start, though a schedule change that made childcare impossible could potentially be a good reason to quit too - EDD would have to decide that.
0 coins
Mateo Sanchez
ahh okay that makes sense. she was really frustrated and walked out so I guess EDD saw it as a voluntary quit. I told her she should have waited them out but she was done
0 coins
Aisha Mahmood
Just to add - the advice to 'wait to be fired' is something people pass around but it's really case by case. Sometimes waiting does help, like in this thread. But someone who stays on with impossible terms for months might face different questions about whether the change was really that unworkable. It's not a magic move.
0 coins
Ethan Moore
Went two full weeks without any updates in UI Online after my interview and started spiraling thinking I'd been denied without getting a letter. What actually happened was EDD was still in the adjudication period - that's the window when they're reviewing everything and haven't made a decision yet. If your claim shows weeks as Pending in Claim History it doesn't mean you're denied, it means they haven't decided yet. The Notice of Determination is what comes when they've actually made a call, and it comes by mail.
0 coins
Freya Christensen
AuthorHow long did your adjudication period end up being? I'm trying to figure out when to start worrying versus when it's just normal processing time.
0 coins
Ethan Moore
Mine was about three weeks from the date of the interview to when payments posted. I didn't get a Notice of Determination mailed to me - I just checked UI Online one morning and the pending weeks had flipped to paid. I think a Notice of Determination comes when they deny you, not when they approve you.
0 coins
NeonNebula
That's correct - if EDD decides in your favor the payments just process for the weeks you've certified. If they decide against you, you get the Notice of Determination with the denial reason and an Appeal Form (DE 1000M) attached. The 30-day clock to appeal starts from the mailing date on that notice.
0 coins
Yuki Kobayashi
What happens if EDD decides the schedule change was actually reasonable and they say the firing was justified? Does that mean misconduct?
0 coins
Anastasia Kozlov
EDD's standard for misconduct is about willful disregard of an employer's reasonable expectations - it's not just about whether the employer had a valid business reason for the change. Someone who tried to work something out and genuinely couldn't comply for serious personal reasons is in a different position than someone who just refused out of preference. Childcare for school-age kids when there's no other coverage is a pretty substantial reason.
0 coins
Yuki Kobayashi
Okay so it's not like EDD automatically sides with the employer just because they had a business reason. The circumstances of why you couldn't comply matter too.
0 coins
Anastasia Kozlov
Exactly. EDD isn't a rubber stamp for whatever the employer calls misconduct. The interview exists specifically so the claimant can put their own circumstances on the record.
0 coins
Carmen Vega
Overnight schedule change two months ago knocked out my childcare completely too. When EDD kept showing my weeks as pending with no update for almost four weeks I tried the EDD phone line every single morning but kept getting cut off before reaching anyone. Claimyr got me through to an EDD agent that same afternoon - I asked specifically whether my pending weeks were waiting on the phone interview or something else. The agent pulled up my claim and said there was actually an identity verification step that hadn't been completed, nothing to do with the interview at all. Would have sat there waiting forever if I hadn't gotten through to find that out.
0 coins
Freya Christensen
AuthorIdentity verification holding up the claim is something I hadn't even thought about. I did do ID.me when I applied but I don't know if that fully went through. How long did it take to clear once you knew what the issue was?
0 coins
Carmen Vega
About a week after I handled the verification step online through ID.me. Once that was confirmed the pending weeks moved through pretty quickly.
0 coins
QuantumQuester
The identity verification thing catches a lot of people off guard. EDD sends a Request for Identity Verification (DE 1326C) if they can't confirm who you are through ID.me automatically. If you applied online and completed ID.me it usually resolves on its own but if something didn't match it triggers that hold.
0 coins
Andre Moreau
NOBODY tells you that the first week you're eligible doesn't even pay anything. I went through all of this last year, got approved, certified, and then was confused why my first payment was for one week instead of two. Turns out there's a waiting week built into every California unemployment claim - first eligible week is unpaid. It doesn't change how much your claim can pay total but it means your first actual payment covers week two.
0 coins
Freya Christensen
AuthorI had no idea about the waiting week. So when I certify the first time it'll cover two weeks but only one of them pays?
0 coins
Andre Moreau
Yep, the first certification usually covers the waiting week plus one paid week. You get paid for that second week and the waiting week just counts as served. It's annoying but it doesn't reduce what your claim can pay overall.
0 coins
Zoe Stavros
Worth knowing that the weekly benefit amount is based on your highest-paid quarter during the base period, not your most recent paycheck. EDD mails a Notice of Unemployment Insurance Award (DE 429Z) showing what your weekly amount will be. If anything looks off on that notice you have 30 days from the mailing date to appeal it in writing.
0 coins
Sean Kelly
EDD's CalJOBS registration requirement tripped me up after I got approved. I didn't know I had to register on the CalJOBS site and post a resume within 21 days of the date on the notice EDD sends about it. Missed that window, payments stopped, had to call and sort it out. The notice is called the DE 8405 - if you get one, do not let it sit.
0 coins
Freya Christensen
AuthorIs the CalJOBS requirement for everyone? I want to make sure I don't get cut off for something like that after going through all of this.
0 coins
Sean Kelly
EDD's notice will tell you if you need to do it. Most active claimants do have to register and post a resume within that 21-day window. EDD will tell you on the DE 8405 if you're exempt for some reason.
0 coins
Luca Russo
The site is caljobs.ca.gov. Registering takes maybe 20 minutes if you have your work history handy. Posting the resume is a separate step from registering so make sure you do both before the deadline on the notice.
0 coins
GalaxyGazer
Something that helped me going into my own phone interview for a termination case: I wrote out a short version of events in plain sentences before the call. Not a legal brief, just: what my job was, what changed, when it changed, what I did when I found out, and what happened at the end. The interviewer's questions basically follow that same order anyway so having it laid out meant I wasn't fumbling around trying to remember dates under pressure.
0 coins
Freya Christensen
AuthorDid the interviewer ask about whether you had any alternatives you could have done instead, like whether you asked HR or tried to find another solution within the company?
0 coins
GalaxyGazer
Yes, they asked whether I raised the issue with anyone else before the end date and whether I requested any accommodation. I had emailed HR in addition to talking to my direct manager so I mentioned both. Having that paper trail mattered.
0 coins
Nia Harris
The interviewer asked me the same thing - what steps did you take, did you ask anyone else. I think they're trying to figure out if someone genuinely tried to work it out versus just refusing cold.
0 coins
QuantumQuester
Certifying bi-weekly is something a lot of people understand wrong when they first start. You're not certifying every week - it's every two weeks, covering two weeks at a time. First certification comes about two weeks after EDD processes your application. You can do it in UI Online (fastest), by EDD Tele-Cert at 1-866-333-4606 using option 2, or by mail on a DE 4581. Don't skip a certification period - uncertified weeks can't be paid later.
0 coins
Freya Christensen
AuthorEvery two weeks not every week - I definitely assumed it was weekly. So the first time I certify I'm answering questions about two weeks at once?
0 coins
QuantumQuester
Right, two weeks of questions in one session. They ask about each week separately - were you able to work, were you available, did you look for work, did you earn anything. Answer for each week.
0 coins
Zara Mirza
The work search questions are the ones I always stress about. You just have to actually be doing it - applying to jobs, contacting employers. EDD doesn't give a specific number of contacts you have to make per week but keeping notes on where you apply is a good habit.
0 coins
Zoe Stavros
My benefits got shorted early on because I didn't understand the earnings reporting. If you pick up any part-time work while you're on unemployment you have to report what you earned in the week you earned it, not when the paycheck actually arrives. Got that backwards the first time and had to call EDD to sort it out. The first $25 or 25 percent of what you made that week - whichever is higher - doesn't count against you, and the rest comes off your weekly amount.
0 coins
Freya Christensen
AuthorGood to know in case I find part-time work during all this. Report earnings for the week worked not the week paid - that's the part that trips people up.
0 coins
Zoe Stavros
Exactly. And you report it on the certification for that week. There's also a Report Wages option in UI Online if you need to sort out what to enter before certifying - it doesn't fix a week already submitted but helps you figure out the right numbers going in.
0 coins
Ethan Moore
Vacation pay and severance are on that list too. EDD's official position is severance paid under a company plan doesn't disqualify you, but it's still something you report on the certification and EDD decides what to do with it. Same with vacation payout - report it and let EDD sort the calculation.
0 coins
NeonNebula
Appeals after a denial are something most people don't realize they still have available. If EDD denies you after the phone interview, the Notice of Determination (DE 1080CZ) comes in the mail with an Appeal Form (DE 1000M). You have 30 calendar days from the mailing date to submit that form or a letter in writing. After EDD reviews it, the case goes to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board and an administrative law judge holds a hearing. You can represent yourself, bring a union rep, or have an attorney.
0 coins
Freya Christensen
AuthorThe 30 days starts from when EDD mailed the notice, not when I receive it? So I should act on it as fast as possible once I get it.
0 coins
NeonNebula
Yes, the mailing date on the notice is what starts the clock, not when it arrives in your mailbox. Open any EDD mail the day it comes and check the date at the top. And keep certifying while you wait for the appeal hearing - EDD can only pay back weeks you certified for.
0 coins
Aisha Mahmood
The appeal hearing is different from the initial phone interview - a lot of people mix those up. The interview is EDD figuring out the facts on your case. The hearing before the administrative law judge is for appealing a denial. Two different things at different points in the process.
0 coins
Luca Russo
Something that burned me: assumed EDD would just figure out the right base period automatically and that my highest recent quarter would count. My pay had gone up a lot in the last six months but those months fell outside the standard base period window. The standard base period is the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before you file. So your most recent complete quarter and anything after it isn't in that calculation. EDD runs the alternate base period if the standard one doesn't give you a valid claim but that's only to see if you qualify at all - it doesn't bump your weekly amount up if you already qualify under the standard period.
0 coins
Yuki Kobayashi
So if someone got a raise recently that's in the most recent quarter, that quarter probably isn't in the standard base period and doesn't affect the weekly benefit amount?
0 coins
Luca Russo
Usually correct. The most recent completed quarter is part of the alternate but typically not the standard. If you already have a valid claim under standard, the higher quarter from the alternate doesn't get added in to raise your amount.
0 coins
GalaxyGazer
The DE 429Z that EDD mails shows the weekly benefit amount. If the number looks wrong - like it's based on older wages when you know you had higher recent earnings - you can appeal that specific determination within 30 days of the mailing date.
0 coins
Chloe Robinson
Misconduct is a word that gets thrown around a lot in these conversations but EDD's actual bar for it is pretty specific. Losing my job after arguing with a coworker in front of customers, my manager initially called it 'misconduct' on the separation paperwork. EDD still approved me after the interview because willful disregard of reasonable expectations is what they're actually looking for - a one-time bad judgment call in a stressful situation was treated differently than a pattern of intentional rule-breaking. The bar is higher than just 'you did something the employer didn't like.
0 coins
Freya Christensen
AuthorThis is what I keep coming back to. I didn't defy a reasonable rule - I just couldn't physically do overnight shifts with no warning and no childcare. That feels very different from someone who just refused to follow instructions out of spite.
0 coins
Chloe Robinson
The circumstances you're describing - documented childcare need, tried to find alternatives, they gave you no flexibility - is a pretty different picture from someone who just walked off the job. The interview is where all of that context gets put on record.
0 coins
Anastasia Kozlov
Exactly. And the employer still has to come to EDD and make their case that it was misconduct. HR writing the word on a form isn't the determination - EDD makes the determination after hearing both sides.
0 coins
Jamal Harris
DE 429Z came in the mail showing my weekly benefit amount of $390 and I had no idea whether that was right or not, plus my Claim History in UI Online showed three weeks pending with no explanation. After a week of getting nowhere calling EDD myself, Claimyr put me on the line with an EDD agent. I asked about those pending weeks and the agent said two of them were waiting on the interview outcome and one was pending for a certification question EDD needed to follow up on. The agent also confirmed the $390 amount was calculated from my highest base period quarter. Ended up keeping notes on everything the agent said to refer back to later.
0 coins
Freya Christensen
AuthorHaving someone actually read your specific claim details back to you sounds so much more useful than the generic answers you can find online. Did the agent tell you anything about how long the pending weeks would take to resolve?
0 coins
Jamal Harris
The agent couldn't give me a specific timeline but confirmed the interview was the main step holding things up. Once the interview happened and I certified for those weeks the pending status cleared within a few days.
0 coins
Zara Mirza
Three pending weeks with no explanation is exactly the kind of thing that would send me into a panic. Knowing which one is for what reason at least lets you focus on the right thing.
0 coins
Aisha Mahmood
Certifying while an appeal is in process is something EDD actually asks people to do and not everyone knows it. If you get denied and appeal, you have to keep certifying every two weeks during the whole appeal period. EDD can only pay you for weeks that were certified - if you stop certifying because you assumed you'd have to wait until after the appeal, those weeks can't be recovered.
0 coins
Freya Christensen
AuthorSo even if EDD says no initially, I should keep certifying as if I might win the appeal?
0 coins
Aisha Mahmood
Exactly. You certify, you appeal, you wait for the hearing. If the judge rules in your favor those certified weeks can be paid. Uncertified weeks are gone even if you win.
0 coins
Sean Kelly
This is one of the biggest practical mistakes people make. The appeal is about whether you deserved benefits - the certification is you telling EDD you were still available and looking for work during that time. Both have to happen.
0 coins
Mateo Sanchez
does anyone know if the schedule change has to be in writing for EDD to care about it? my manager told me verbally they were changing me and nothing was ever put in an email
0 coins
GalaxyGazer
EDD doesn't require written documentation to decide - you give your account of what happened during the phone interview and the employer gives theirs. That said, any written record helps. Texts, emails, even a note you wrote to yourself the day it happened with the date. It corroborates your version if the employer tells EDD something different.
0 coins
Mateo Sanchez
okay so like even a text to a friend the day it happened saying 'my manager just told me' would be something to have
0 coins
GalaxyGazer
Something contemporaneous like that could matter. The best case is documentation from the employer directly - even a text from your supervisor counts - but anything that shows you're giving an accurate account of when things happened is worth keeping.
0 coins