Back to California Unemployment

Alice Coleman

California EDD will investigate if employer says i was terminated for refusing work

So I got laid off — or at least that's what I thought happened — from my warehouse job about two weeks ago. My supervisor told me verbally that my position was being eliminated due to slow season. Cool, makes sense, applied for unemployment right away through myEDD. Then I get the paperwork and notice that EDD sent my employer a notice about my claim. Next thing I know my manager is blowing up my phone saying that if I don't withdraw my UI claim they're going to tell EDD I was terminated for refusing a work assignment. Which... is not what happened. I did push back once on a last-minute schedule change but I never refused to work and I was never warned or written up for anything. So now I'm spiraling. My claim is processing, I haven't had any interview scheduled yet, and I'm terrified that the moment my employer responds to EDD with their version of events, the whole thing gets shut down and I'm disqualified. Can they just say whatever they want and EDD takes their word for it? Does EDD actually investigate these conflicting stories or do they just go with whoever responds first? I have texts from my supervisor from the night of the schedule dispute that show I didn't outright refuse anything. Would those help? I filed two weeks ago and have been certifying normally. No phone interview notice has shown up yet on my UI Online homepage or in the mail. I don't know if I should wait it out or try to get ahead of this somehow.

Week two of waiting after a disputed termination is honestly the hardest part because nothing visible is happening but EDD is working through it. The question you should be putting to yourself right now is: what exactly does my employer have in writing versus what do I have? Because when EDD schedules that phone interview, they're going to hear both sides. Your texts showing the schedule conversation are exactly the kind of thing you bring up. Keep them saved somewhere easy to access.

0 coins

How specific do I need to be with the texts — like do I read them out loud or do I send copies to EDD beforehand?

0 coins

The interview is by phone so you'd reference what the texts say during it. You don't typically mail them in ahead of time unless EDD specifically asks. Have them in front of you when the interviewer phones at the time on your DE 4800 notice.

0 coins

The notice also lists the questions likely to come up so you can prep your answers around your actual timeline of what happened.

0 coins

Employer threatening to change their story unless you drop the claim is shady and worth documenting. Screenshot those texts or save the voicemails where they said that. That pressure campaign is a separate thing from the underlying question of why you stopped working, but it paints a picture of their credibility if it ever comes up.

0 coins

I did screenshot everything already. My worry is that EDD just takes the employer's word since they're the one paying into the system.

0 coins

EDD doesn't just rubber-stamp what an employer says. The whole point of the phone interview is so the claimant gets to give their account directly. Employers have to actually prove misconduct — that burden is on them, not you.

0 coins

That's slightly off — the burden framing is EDD's own language around firings specifically, not about who goes first or who they believe more. The interview is genuinely two-sided though.

0 coins

Disputed termination reason kept my claim stuck for almost six weeks before anything moved. The DE 4800 notice finally showed up and I had the interview, but then heard nothing for two more weeks after that. Eventually got on the phone with an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) — it basically holds your place in the phone queue so you end up talking to a live person instead of hitting the busy signal loop. There's a video that walks through reaching a live person at EDD if you want to see it first: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up my claim and told me identity verification had stalled out, completely separate from the employer dispute. Got that cleared and the pending weeks started moving.

0 coins

Identity verification — was that the ID.me step? I did that when I first applied but maybe it didn't go through fully?

0 coins

For me it was flagged internally and I had no way to know without calling. The UI Online claim history just showed pending with no explanation of which piece was stuck.

0 coins

Pending with zero explanation is the most maddening thing about UI Online. At least the phone call gave you something concrete to act on.

0 coins

The thing people don't realize going into these disputed claims is that EDD isn't trying to find someone to punish — the question they're actually working through is whether what happened fits the definition of misconduct. If you pushed back on a last-minute schedule change and there was no prior written warning, no formal write-up, that's a very different situation than outright refusing an assigned shift with no context. EDD's own standard is that your employer has to prove misconduct on their end for a firing.

0 coins

So even if they tell EDD I 'refused work,' EDD still evaluates whether that actually counts as misconduct?

0 coins

Exactly. One disagreement over a schedule with no paper trail of warnings or discipline is a thin case for misconduct. Your account of the same events matters just as much in the interview.

0 coins

To add to that — keep certifying every two weeks through all of this. If the decision eventually goes in your favor, EDD can only pay the weeks you actually certified. Missing a certification period means those weeks are just gone.

0 coins

My employer also changed their stated reason after I filed, went from 'position eliminated' to something vague about 'performance issues.' EDD still scheduled the interview, I gave my side, they had their side, and I got paid. The key was I had my original termination letter saying position eliminated and that contradicted what they told EDD later.

0 coins

Did you bring up the original termination communication during the interview or did EDD already have it on file?

0 coins

I brought it up myself during the call. The interviewer asked me to describe how the job ended in my own words and I explained the contradiction right there. They noted it.

0 coins

Having that original communication is huge. If it says one thing and the employer suddenly tells EDD something different, that inconsistency does the work for you.

0 coins

I'm so stressed reading this because I'm kind of in the opposite situation — I'm the one who actually did refuse an extra shift but it was because of a medical thing and my doctor told me not to do overtime. Filed anyway because I need the money. Does that count the same way as what you're describing? Like does EDD look at WHY someone refused work?

0 coins

The question you'd want to ask EDD directly is whether a medically documented limitation on extra hours is treated the same as a flat refusal of assigned work. EDD looks at the full picture of what you were asked to do and whether there was a legitimate reason you couldn't. Those are genuinely different facts. For your situation I'd document the medical instruction and bring it up in the interview.

0 coins

Okay that actually makes me feel a little better. I was afraid refusing any work in any context was an automatic disqualification.

0 coins

Refusing assigned regular work and declining extra voluntary overtime because of medical limitations are pretty different things. But yes, context is everything and the interview is where you explain that context.

0 coins

Six weeks of pending status after the employer dispute notice went in, and my UI Online just showed Claim History with every week still pending — no detail on what was actually holding things up. Used Claimyr to get through to EDD and finally talked to an agent about my own claim. She confirmed the employer had responded but that an adjudication issue was open and they were still within their processing window. She told me to watch for a Notice of Determination in the mail once the decision was made.

0 coins

Adjudication issue — is that different from the phone interview stage? I keep seeing that term and I'm not sure if they're two separate things or the same process.

0 coins

They're related but separate. The phone interview is how EDD gathers the information. Adjudication is the broader process of EDD deciding eligibility when there's a question — the interview feeds into it but adjudication can also involve document review and other steps.

0 coins

Worth knowing that if adjudication results in a denial, the Notice of Determination (DE 1080CZ) has an Appeal Form (DE 1000M) right on it. You have 30 calendar days from the mailing date to submit that if you disagree with the decision.

0 coins

Registered for CalJOBS yet? A lot of people with disputed claims forget this piece because they're so focused on the employer dispute. If EDD sent you a Notice of Requirement to Register for Work (DE 8405), you've got 21 days from that date to register at caljobs.ca.gov and post a resume or payments can be held up for a completely separate reason.

0 coins

I did register on CalJOBS, did that in the first week. Wasn't sure if the resume actually had to be fully filled out or just uploaded.

0 coins

EDD says the resume needs to be posted, so make sure it's visible in the system and not just saved as a draft. A complete one is safer than a placeholder.

0 coins

My claim got flagged for the CalJOBS requirement even though I had registered — it was because my resume was set to private instead of searchable. Switched it to public and the flag cleared.

0 coins

Something that tripped me up early on: the employer responding to EDD's claim notice doesn't mean the employer controls what happens. EDD mails the former employer a DE 1101CZ notice and gives them 10 days to respond. What they put in that response is their account. What you put in your interview is your account. Neither one automatically wins.

0 coins

Does EDD tell me what the employer actually said in their response or is that confidential?

0 coins

You'll hear the substance of their account during the phone interview when the interviewer goes through the questions with you. The interviewer phrases things around what EDD has in the file.

0 coins

This is accurate. You won't get a copy of the employer's written response but the interview questions will reflect what they raised.

0 coins

The hardest part for me was the waiting after the interview ended. Finished the call, thought I explained everything clearly, and then... nothing for 11 days. No status change in UI Online, no letter, nothing. Then the payments just showed up for the pending weeks. No separate approval letter came — just the money deposited to my Money Network card.

0 coins

No letter at all after they decided in your favor? Just the deposit?

0 coins

Just the deposit. The DE 429Z came earlier to show my weekly benefit amount, but after the dispute was resolved there was no separate correspondence — the pending weeks just processed.

0 coins

Exactly how it worked for me too. The absence of a Notice of Determination usually means EDD decided you were eligible, since the denial is what comes in writing.

0 coins

If they do send a denial — the Notice of Determination — read the mailing date carefully, not the date you receive it, because the 30-day appeal window runs from when it was mailed. People miss appeals because they count from when they opened the envelope.

0 coins

Does the appeal have to be in a specific format? Can you just write a letter?

0 coins

The DE 1000M appeal form is on the notice itself but EDD also accepts a written letter mailed to the address on the notice. The letter needs to say you're appealing and which determination you're contesting. It goes to EDD first and then to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board if EDD doesn't reverse it.

0 coins

Good to know I can write a letter — I wasn't sure if the form was mandatory.

0 coins

The specific phrase 'refusing work' that your employer is apparently using — that matters. EDD looks at what actually happened and whether it rises to the level of misconduct. A one-time disagreement about a schedule change, with no written warnings, no disciplinary history, is a very different profile than someone who repeatedly refused assignments after being told the consequences.

0 coins

They never gave me any written warning or even a verbal one on the record. Everything was informal. Would that work in my favor?

0 coins

Absence of documentation on the employer's side generally doesn't help their misconduct argument. Bring up the lack of warnings when the interviewer asks you to describe the events leading up to your last day.

0 coins

That's the kind of detail that makes a difference. 'Was there any prior discipline or written warning?' is exactly the type of question the interview tends to cover.

0 coins

Certifying every two weeks regardless of what's happening with the dispute is not optional — people skip it thinking 'what's the point while it's pending' and then if EDD decides in their favor there's nothing to pay because the weeks weren't certified. Keep doing it even if Claim History shows everything pending.

0 coins

Do you certify the same way even when there's a pending dispute? Like the same questions and everything?

0 coins

Yes, same certification process. Answer the questions accurately for each week — were you able to work, were you available, did you look for work. The pending status doesn't change how you certify.

0 coins

And answer the work search question honestly each week. EDD doesn't publish a specific number of contacts required but you need to be genuinely available and looking.

0 coins

Two-week stall right after the employer filed their response with EDD, and my pending weeks weren't budging. Got through to an agent via Claimyr to ask about my own claim — the wage information from my base period needed a secondary verification step that the agent flagged for me. That was completely separate from the employer dispute that I thought was the only thing holding things up. The agent said to watch for a letter within two weeks.

0 coins

How did you even know to ask about the base period wages specifically? Did you go in with that question or did the agent bring it up?

0 coins

The agent pulled up the claim and walked through what was open. I went in asking about the employer dispute but the wage verification issue was what she actually found.

0 coins

That's exactly the problem with just watching UI Online — it shows pending but doesn't tell you which of the three possible things is actually causing it.

0 coins

Ask yourself before the interview: what is the most specific, honest account of that schedule dispute conversation I can give? The interviewer is going to ask you to describe what was said, by whom, and what you understood the outcome to be. Vague answers like 'we disagreed' are less useful than 'my supervisor sent a text at 9pm asking me to come in at 5am the next day and I said I couldn't on that notice, and that was the only time the subject came up.' Specific is better.

0 coins

Should I write out a timeline before the call so I don't blank during it?

0 coins

Absolutely. Write the timeline, have the texts in front of you sorted by date, and have the DE 4800 notice nearby so you're clear on what questions are coming. Speaking from notes during a phone call is completely fine.

0 coins

I did exactly this — wrote a one-page timeline two days before my interview and practiced saying it out loud. Helped a lot when the interviewer asked me to 'describe the events in your own words.

0 coins

The employer threatening to change their story is worth noting but it's not something you raise in the EDD phone interview. The interview is about the facts of the separation. The pressure campaign is a separate thing. What you do bring up is the original conversation where you were told your position was being eliminated — that's the central fact in your favor.

0 coins

Should I mention that my employer called and pressured me to withdraw the claim? Or does that come across as complaining?

0 coins

The interview is focused on what happened before and during the separation, not what happened after you filed. Stick to the facts of the job end itself. The intimidation call is worth having documented separately but it's not the core of what EDD needs to hear in the interview.

0 coins

Agreed — keep the interview focused on the events at work. The other stuff may matter later if it escalates but the interview isn't the place for it.

0 coins

Halfway through the adjudication wait on my own claim right now — employer says one thing, I say another, and UI Online just says pending. Tried Claimyr on my claim to see where things stood, and the agent told me my identity verification had actually been cleared and the only open item was the employer response review. At least now I know what I'm actually waiting on.

0 coins

Did the agent give any timeframe for when the employer response review wraps up?

0 coins

She said to expect a Notice of Determination in the mail once the review was complete but didn't give a specific number of days. Just said to keep certifying.

0 coins

That's about as much as they can usually say — the determination is the signal. Keep certifying in the meantime no matter what.

0 coins

DE 429Z is what most people confuse with an 'approval letter' — it shows your weekly benefit amount and your maximum benefit amount, but it's not EDD saying you're eligible. It comes pretty early in the process. Don't mistake it arriving for the dispute being resolved.

0 coins

I got that letter and thought I was approved. So that's not what it means?

0 coins

Nope — it shows what your claim could pay based on your wages, nothing about whether EDD has decided you're eligible. If there's a dispute open, the eligibility question is still being worked through separately.

0 coins

The actual eligibility decision on a disputed claim comes either as payments processing for your certified weeks, or as a Notice of Determination if EDD decides against you. Those are the two outcomes to watch for.

0 coins

For anyone reading this later: the work search requirement doesn't pause because there's a dispute. You still need to be actively looking for work during every week you certify. EDD doesn't post a required number of contacts anywhere but you should be genuinely in the market, not just technically certified.

0 coins

Should I be keeping a record of where I'm applying in case EDD asks?

0 coins

Keeping your own record is a smart habit. EDD doesn't have you submit it weekly but if questions come up you'll have something concrete to point to.

0 coins

Agreed — a simple spreadsheet with the company, date, and how you applied is enough. Something you actually created and can describe, not a list you reconstructed after the fact.

0 coins

The one thing I'd tell my past self: don't withdraw the claim just because an employer pressures you to. EDD exists specifically for situations where there's a disagreement about why the job ended. That's what the interview process is built for.

0 coins

I was actually tempted to withdraw because I was worried the dispute would make it worse somehow. Good to hear that's not how it works.

0 coins

Withdrawing would just mean losing access to the benefits entirely with no hearing of your side. The interview is your due process — use it.

0 coins

Exactly right. And if EDD eventually denies, the appeal process exists for that too. No reason to withdraw preemptively when you have a legitimate account to give.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure