Back to California Paid Family Leave

Sergio Neal

Why is paying full pay on PFL while working part time — is that an overpayment waiting to happen?

So I went back to work three days a week about two weeks into my bonding leave and I reported it when I filed, answered yes to the question about working during leave and listed my days. But EDD has been sending me the same payment amount as when I was on full leave. I'm not complaining exactly but I'm scared this is going to come back as an overpayment later. My weekly check from work is definitely not zero and I don't want a bill from EDD six months from now. Did anyone else have this happen? Do I need to contact them and say something, or does the Continued Claim Certification sort this out when it comes?

Around day 11 of my bonding claim the payment that posted didn't match what I expected at all, so I spent a few days refreshing SDI Online and getting nowhere. Eventually I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through on the phone, and an agent pulled up my account while I was on the line. She told me the payment dated the 14th covered days 1 through 14 and that the next one would issue after EDD processed my reported wages for the overlap period. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. That call cleared up exactly what date to expect and what the hold was about.

0 coins

Did you have to do anything before the call, like get your receipt number ready?

0 coins

Yep, I had my receipt number and the specific pay period dates I was asking about. Having those meant the agent could pull up the right weeks immediately.

0 coins

been trying that line since tuesday morning, three attempts, it just cuts off. might look into what you used here.

0 coins

To sort out what's happening in your situation, I'd first look at whether EDD has actually received and processed your wage reports yet. When you go back to part-time work during a bonding claim, PFL doesn't simply stop paying: EDD calculates each day based on your reported wages, and the payments adjust accordingly. If wages haven't been factored in yet, you may see the full amount first and an adjustment later, which is exactly why reporting every dollar earned is so important even before the Continued Claim Certification arrives.

0 coins

Thank you, so the adjustment can come after the fact? That's what I'm worried about, that there's a gap between what they paid and what they owe me.

0 coins

Yes, there can be a lag. The key is that you've reported accurately. Keep records of your pay stubs and the wages you reported to EDD so that if any adjustment comes, you can show exactly what you earned each week.

0 coins

This is reassuring to read. I went back two days a week and had the same thing where the first payment looked full. It did get adjusted on the second payment.

0 coins

You reported it, that's the main thing. EDD will catch up. The Continued Claim Certification they send you is where they square the numbers.

0 coins

Ok that makes me feel better. I just didn't expect the first payment to look exactly like when I wasn't working at all.

0 coins

Same thing happened to mine. First payment was full, second one was lower because wages got factored in. Just keep your stubs.

0 coins

Wait, I'm confused about something. Does PFL pay full rate even if you're working? I thought it was supposed to only pay for the days you're not working. Not sure if I'm reading that right.

0 coins

You're reading it right. PFL pays for the days you're not working, at about a day's worth of your weekly benefit for each eligible day. If you work three days a week and take two days of leave, PFL covers those two days. The issue in this thread is timing: the first payment sometimes goes out before wages are factored in.

0 coins

Oh ok so the payment isn't supposed to match a full week if you're working part time. That makes more sense now, I was afraid I was going to get the same thing.

0 coins

yeah it pays per day basically, one seventh of your weekly amount for each day off, so part time leave should be less than a full week payment lol

0 coins

Honestly just file the DE 2580GF as soon as it shows up and report every day you worked and what you made. That's the form that keeps everything clean. Anyway don't sit on it.

0 coins

I've been watching for that form in SDI Online. It hasn't shown up yet, is that normal at two weeks in?

0 coins

It showed up for me around week three, give or take. EDD sends it once they see the claim moving. Anyway keep checking.

0 coins

I didn't even know that form existed until after I filed, nobody told me about it. Would've been nice to have a heads up!

0 coins

edd paid me full for like a week and a half before the wages got processed, then the next payment was lower. its not an overpayment if you reported, theyre just slow to run the numbers

0 coins

Good to know, so it really is just a processing lag.

0 coins

yeah exactly, as long as you reported it youre fine. they catch it on the certification

0 coins

Reported wages plus a lag equals a confusing first payment. EDD's not trying to trick you, they're just slow.

0 coins

Five weeks into my bonding leave and I wanted to confirm how many of the eight weeks I still had available before filing anything else, so I tried Claimyr to reach someone at EDD. The agent checked my claim and confirmed I had three weeks remaining in my 12-month period after using five for bonding. Worth knowing because all eight weeks are shared across bonding, care and military assist in the same 12 months, not eight weeks per reason.

0 coins

I didn't know bonding and care shared the same pool. I used six weeks bonding and was planning to use more for my dad. I'm going to try Claimyr to ask how many weeks I have left before he has his procedure.

0 coins

Have your receipt number and the start date of your bonding claim ready when you call. The agent pulled those up right away on mine and confirmed the count in under a minute.

0 coins

shared pool, that catches a lot of people off guard. good correction.

0 coins

For the record, the eight-week shared limit is spelled out in EDD's PFL guide, the DE 2530. It's one limit per 12-month period, not one per reason. Important to check before you file a second claim.

0 coins

My situation was a little different but same kind of confusion. I went back to work two days a week and my first payment was for the full five days. I panicked and called my employer thinking they'd messed up my hours, turns out EDD just hadn't processed the wages I reported yet. Second payment came out right.

0 coins

This is exactly what I'm experiencing, thank you. So it really does sort itself out.

0 coins

It did for me! Just keep all your pay stubs from those part-time weeks so you can reference them if anything looks off later.

0 coins

glad someone said this. same thing happened but i thought i had to call edd immediately. would have saved me stress to know it adjusts.

0 coins

The rule worth knowing here: your PFL payment plus your wages from the same days can't exceed your normal full weekly wages. That's the ceiling EDD works from. If the first payment pushed you over that ceiling, the adjustment will come through the certification process, which is why returning that DE 2580GF promptly matters.

0 coins

That ceiling rule is really clear, thank you. So if I earned $400 at work and my full PFL week is worth $600, EDD should only pay me $200 of PFL for those days?

0 coins

The math works roughly like that, though it goes by days rather than a flat weekly split. EDD applies it per day based on what you earned. Your Notice of Computation shows your weekly benefit amount and you can work from there.

0 coins

The DE 2530 guide explains this too, available on EDD's site. Matching your Notice of Computation weekly amount against your part-time wages for the week gives you a good estimate.

0 coins

Two things that helped me when I went back part time: screenshot your SDI Online status every time a payment posts, and keep a simple note of which days you worked each week and what you were paid. If EDD ever sends an overpayment notice you have everything ready to compare.

0 coins

Screenshotting status is a great idea, I hadn't thought of that.

0 coins

I do this too. Having the records made the certification so much easier to fill out accurately.

0 coins

You're not the first person to panic over this. EDD runs behind on wage processing. As long as you told them you were working, you did your part.

0 coins

I did tell them. I just want to make sure the system actually catches it on the back end.

0 coins

The DE 2580GF is how they catch it. Fill it out exactly, return it on time, done.

0 coins

wait does pfl even have a waiting period? my coworker told me the first week is unpaid and i should plan for that. now im second-guessing everything

0 coins

PFL doesn't have a waiting period. Your coworker might be thinking of Disability Insurance, which does have unpaid days at the start. PFL benefits can begin from the first day of leave.

0 coins

oh wow, good to know before i filed wrong! so for bonding i should get paid from day one?

0 coins

That's right, no unpaid waiting period for PFL. DI is a separate program with different rules. Easy to mix up since they're both under SDI.

0 coins

i thought the same thing as your coworker, glad someone corrected it here. i would have planned my budget wrong

0 coins

Start date on my bonding claim got flagged somehow and I needed to know if the 41-day filing window was going to be a problem. Three mornings on that phone line and nothing but a recording. I ended up using Claimyr to reach an agent and she confirmed my claim start date was recorded correctly and that my filing date was within the 41 days, so there was no issue with the window at all.

0 coins

my situation was similar actually, I had a gap between when I thought my leave started and what SDI Online showed, used Claimyr too and the agent confirmed which weeks had been paid and told me the next payment was scheduled for the following Friday. After that I went into SDI Online and filed the DE 2580GF for the part-time weeks I'd been putting off.

0 coins

Three mornings of trying that line with no luck, I completely feel that! I've had the same thing happen and it's so frustrating when you just need a straight answer.

0 coins

yeah every morning that week the line just played the recording and ended the call. the agent answering was such a relief compared to that.

0 coins

October 3rd through October 16th on my claim showed two separate payment amounts, which confused me until I matched each one to the days I actually worked versus the days I took leave. Each day of PFL pays one seventh of your weekly benefit, so a week where you worked three days and took two days of leave should show roughly two-sevenths of your weekly amount, not the full week.

0 coins

Breaking it down per day makes it much clearer. I was thinking of it as a weekly block but it's really daily.

0 coins

Exactly. Your Notice of Computation shows the weekly benefit amount and you divide from there. Keeps the math straightforward once you know the formula.

0 coins

This per-day breakdown is the thing most people don't get until they're staring at a confusing payment. Good explanation.

0 coins

My bonding claim went so smoothly once I understood the reporting piece! I was so scared of overpayments that I over-reported at first, listing every single hour. Turns out you just report wages earned each week and EDD handles the rest through the certification.

0 coins

Over-reporting is exactly what I've been tempted to do. I'd rather give too much info than too little.

0 coins

Totally understandable! The certification form is actually pretty clear about what it's asking for. You list the days worked and wages earned, and EDD runs the adjustment.

0 coins

EDD can be slow about updating what they owe vs what they paid. That's not unique to part-time situations. It just means your first payment might look off, then settle.

0 coins

Yep. Mine took about 10 days to reflect the wages I reported before the second payment came out at the adjusted amount.

0 coins

Slow and right beats fast and wrong, usually. Annoying, but it corrects.

0 coins

Keep a weekly log of your wages and days worked. If an overpayment notice ever shows up, you appeal it with the DE 1000A and you'll need those records. Better to have them and not need them.

0 coins

I didn't know there was an appeal form for overpayments. Good to know if it ever comes to that.

0 coins

30 days to appeal from the date on the notice. Don't wait on it if one arrives.

0 coins

not sure if this is dumb but can you appeal even if you think EDD might be right that it's an overpayment? like if you're not 100% sure?

0 coins

Appeal anyway. The process lets you present your records and EDD explains the calculation. Better than paying a bill you don't understand.

0 coins

Honestly, filing correctly and reporting honestly is half the battle with PFL. The other half is just patience waiting for EDD to process things in order. You reported your work, you're doing it right.

0 coins

Patience is not my strong suit when money is involved but I'll try!

0 coins

Ha, same! But knowing you've done everything correctly is at least one less thing to worry about.

0 coins

if the continued claim cert comes and you dont return it benefits stop, so dont forget about it. edd doesnt chase you, they just stop paying

0 coins

learned this one the hard way, missed the return window and had to contact EDD to sort it out. anyway, return it the same day you get it.

0 coins

yeah same, lost a week of benefits because i sat on it thinking i had more time. dont do that

0 coins

The SDI Online portal lets you check your payment history and status without having to call, which is useful for tracking whether the wage adjustment has posted yet. Under your claim ID you can see each payment's date and amount. No need to guess if the numbers shifted.

0 coins

I've been checking there but it still shows the same full amount. Maybe the adjustment just hasn't posted yet.

0 coins

Give it another week. If there's still no change and you've received the DE 2580GF by then, fill it out and return it, that usually prompts the recalculation.

0 coins

sdionline is the only way i know whats happening on my claim tbh, never get answers any other way

0 coins

Came across this thread while dealing with the same part-time question. Filed my DE 2501F with the yes on A13 and the schedule attached, and I was so confused when payment one hit at the full amount. Everything in this thread confirmed it's just the lag. Payment two was lower and matched the days I actually took leave.

0 coins

This is exactly what I needed to hear. So the system does work, it's just not instant.

0 coins

It really does work, it's just slower than you'd expect. Hang in there and keep your records clean.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure