Back to California Paid Family Leave

Geoff Richards

Why did employer pay payroll while receiving PFL baby bonding benefits?

So my wife went back to work part time around week five of her PFL bonding claim, still had three weeks left, and her employer just kept running her normal payroll the whole time like nothing changed. She didn't report any of it to EDD because honestly we didn't know we had to and figured PFL was separate from her job pay. Now we're getting nervous looking back at it. Can you get in trouble for that? Does EDD find out somehow? We don't want an overpayment notice showing up out of nowhere.

DE 2500E on my bonding claim showed up and I didn't even know what it was at first, panicked a little. EDD sent it because my first payment had processed, but then I got nervous about whether I'd reported everything right so I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone on the phone. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the start date and that the 41-day window had been met, so that part was fine at least. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

Reads like a marketing comment to me. Nobody just casually ends up on the phone with EDD that easily.

0 coins

Thought the same thing until I tried it myself in October. Didn't want to, spent three mornings hitting redial and getting nowhere first. After I got through, the agent looked at my claim and confirmed my actual start date and that my 41-day filing fell inside the window. It was an EDD employee, not some third party.

0 coins

Alright. Might give it a shot then since I've been at this for two weeks myself.

0 coins

Not trying to hijack this but does it work for the bonding questions too or just disability side stuff? Asking because my situation is exactly what this thread is about.

0 coins

Wages need to be reported to EDD regardless of where they come from. The rule isn't complicated: any wages earned, even if the check hasn't landed yet, go to EDD. When your wife went part time and her employer kept running full payroll, those wages should have been reported for each day she worked. EDD sends a Continued Claim Certification after a return to part-time work, and benefits stop if it isn't returned. If none of that happened, an overpayment is a real possibility.

0 coins

So EDD was waiting on a Continued Claim Certification and we just never got one because she never reported going back? That makes sense now. What actually happens next, do we just wait for a notice or should we contact them first?

0 coins

Reaching out first is usually better than waiting. SDI Online has a Request Claim Update option where you can write directly to EDD. Getting ahead of it is safer than an overpayment notice catching you off guard.

0 coins

Does that apply even if the employer has no idea about PFL? Like her company probably just ran payroll like normal because HR didn't flag anything. Does that matter to EDD at all?

0 coins

EDD's concern is the claimant's report, not what HR did or didn't flag. The company running normal payroll doesn't change what was owed to EDD.

0 coins

She kept getting paid by work AND getting PFL at the same time. That's the problem. EDD doesn't pay on top of your regular wages. You can't pull double.

0 coins

Yeah that's what we're realizing. She thought PFL was just its own thing and her job pay was separate. Didn't understand they look at both together.

0 coins

They do. And combined wages plus PFL can't go over what she normally makes. Anything over that is an overpayment.

0 coins

This happened to a coworker of mine too, honestly. She just didn't know. It's one of those things nobody tells you until it's too late.

0 coins

The PFL and wages question trips a lot of people up. PFL can run alongside employer-paid leave, but wages plus the PFL payment can't exceed normal wages. If her employer was paying full salary and EDD was also sending full PFL, the overlap is an overpayment on whatever exceeded her normal pay. She should check her Notice of Computation and her payment history in SDI Online and figure out the weeks where both were running.

0 coins

Where exactly in SDI Online does payment history show up? I want to help my sister check hers because she's in a similar boat.

0 coins

In myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ you open SDI Online and select the claim ID. Payment history is listed under that claim.

0 coins

This is the clearest breakdown I've seen. The 'both running at once' part is what confuses people because it feels like two separate systems, but EDD sees wages as wages regardless of who issued the check.

0 coins

Going back two days a week in January after my bonding leave, I reported my hours to EDD and still got confused about how the DE 2580GF worked. Tried calling the PFL line for a few days straight and never got through, so I ended up trying Claimyr. The agent told me which of my intermittent days EDD had on file and confirmed the certification had been received, which was the piece I couldn't see on my end.

0 coins

When you got through to the agent, did they tell you anything about how to report the days going forward, or just what was already on file?

0 coins

They confirmed what was already received and said the Continued Claim Certification would come back in the mail once EDD processed the days. Told me to just return it when it arrived.

0 coins

been trying that line for two and a half weeks now. every morning. either busy or it cuts off.

0 coins

Two and a half weeks is brutal. We haven't even tried calling yet, been putting it off because I figured it'd be a wall.

0 coins

EDD cross-checks wages through the state's tax records eventually. It's not immediate but it catches up. If she was pulling full salary from her employer and full PFL at the same time, they will figure it out. Better to contact EDD now through SDI Online than to get a formal overpayment notice and have to deal with that whole process.

0 coins

Is an overpayment notice something you can appeal if you disagree with the amount?

0 coins

Yes. Appeal within 30 days of the notice, same DE 1000A form they use for denials.

0 coins

Don't sit on it. Clock starts the day the notice is dated.

0 coins

you cant get pfl AND full pay from your job at the same time, thats not how it works. if she was getting both she owes back whatever was over her normal wages

0 coins

Not what we wanted to hear but yeah makes sense. Do you know if she has to pay it all back at once or can it be a payment plan or something?

0 coins

no idea about payment plans, edd would know that, not me

0 coins

The piece worth flagging here is the sick leave and vacation part. If her employer was applying sick time or PTO alongside PFL, there is a specific limit there too: wages plus PFL can't go over her normal weekly wages. How an employer applies paid time off is their own policy, but the EDD calculation doesn't change based on what label the employer puts on the payment.

0 coins

So the category of employer pay doesn't matter to EDD, it's just total wages against total PFL?

0 coins

Exactly. EDD looks at combined wages, however the employer categorizes them, against normal wages. The benefit gets reduced to keep the total from exceeding that.

0 coins

This cleared up something I'd been confused about for weeks. My employer said the PTO would 'top off' my PFL and I didn't understand what that meant until now.

0 coins

my manager told me pfl replaces your whole paycheck so you dont get anything from work at the same time. is that actually right? sounds like from this thread thats wrong

0 coins

It's not quite right. PFL replaces a portion of your wages, around 70 to 90 percent depending on your income. Paid time off from work can run alongside it, but the two together can't go over what you'd normally earn. Some employers do top-off policies that make up the gap, as long as the total stays at normal wages.

0 coins

oh ok so there IS a limit. my manager made it sound like you get pfl AND full pay no problem but thats not right then

0 coins

Your manager was wrong. Tell HR, not your manager.

0 coins

The Continued Claim Certification is the piece she missed. When someone goes back to work during a PFL claim, EDD expects wages to be reported and sends that form. Without it, payments keep going out even when they shouldn't.

0 coins

So EDD kept paying because they didn't know she went back? Not because anything was wrong on their end?

0 coins

Right. EDD pays based on what it knows. If the return to work wasn't reported, it kept paying on the original schedule.

0 coins

that makes the overpayment make a lot more sense to me now

0 coins

she should check if EDD even issued a Continued Claim Certification after week five. If it did, and she ignored it, that's one situation. If it never came because she never reported going back, that's different. worth knowing which one before contacting them

0 coins

That's a good point. We honestly don't know if something came in the mail and got missed or if EDD just never sent it because we never triggered it.

0 coins

SDI Online would show payment history by date. That at least tells you what EDD sent out and when.

0 coins

Check the mail from around week five too, just in case something did come and got set aside. Happens more than people think.

0 coins

A Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination (DE 2514) arrived for my care claim last spring and I genuinely didn't understand why, the status had been showing approved. I tried the PFL line for three days without reaching anyone, then used Claimyr to get through. The agent looked it up and explained the determination had flagged an issue with the dates on file, nothing that couldn't be corrected, but I would have missed the 30-day appeal window if I'd kept waiting.

0 coins

I've got a question about my own determination notice and I've been unable to get anyone on the phone for over a week. Going to try Claimyr for it. What do I need to have ready when I call?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, the claim ID from SDI Online, and the determination notice itself in front of you. The agent will want the notice date and the reason code on it.

0 coins

30 days goes fast, especially if you're not checking mail every day. Glad you caught it.

0 coins

PFL is specifically designed so that it CAN run with partial wages, that's the whole point of the intermittent option! But there's definitely a ceiling on the combined total. The calculator on EDD's site gives you a benefits estimate so you can see roughly how the math works with wages in the mix.

0 coins

Is the calculator on EDD's site easy to find? We want to run the numbers on her weeks before we contact them.

0 coins

Search 'EDD PFL calculator' and it should come right up on edd.ca.gov. Put in wages and it shows an estimate, though the real number is always on the Notice of Computation.

0 coins

Worth noting the calculator gives an estimate, not a guarantee. The Notice of Computation is the actual official figure.

0 coins

Wait, is there a waiting period on PFL before the payments start? Someone at work told me there are seven unpaid days first, same as disability.

0 coins

PFL has no waiting period. The seven unpaid days is a disability insurance thing, not PFL. EDD is clear on this: PFL payments start from the first eligible day with no waiting days.

0 coins

Oh good, I had that completely mixed up. So the disability waiting period doesn't carry over to bonding at all?

0 coins

Not at all. If a birth mother moves from a pregnancy disability claim to a bonding claim, the PFL side has no waiting period of its own. The two programs run separately.

0 coins

I was confused about this too when I filed. The disability side and PFL really are two completely different things even though they're both under SDI.

0 coins

If she kept working and EDD kept paying, the safest move is to contact EDD through SDI Online now. Send a Request Claim Update and explain what happened. Don't wait for them to find it.

0 coins

We're going to do that this week. Would it help to have her pay stubs from those weeks ready to attach to the message?

0 coins

Yes. Document everything. Dates, amounts, all of it.

0 coins

Should the Request Claim Update describe the whole situation or just ask a question? I'd be afraid to say too much.

0 coins

Describe it plainly. EDD needs the facts, not a legal argument.

0 coins

There's a separate question buried here worth raising: does the employer have any obligation to tell employees they need to report wages to EDD while on PFL? Because most HR departments just keep running payroll without flagging that the employee has to do anything on the EDD side.

0 coins

Employer and EDD are separate. The employer's payroll and the claimant's EDD reporting are two independent tracks. Employers aren't required to coordinate with EDD on the claimant's behalf, and EDD's requirement to report wages is on the claimant regardless of what HR does or doesn't say.

0 coins

That's the gap, then. People assume one side communicates with the other and it doesn't work that way.

0 coins

my hr never said a word about it when I went on leave. I had to figure everything out from EDD's site myself

0 coins

does the 8 week total reset every year or is it tied to the 12 months from when bonding started

0 coins

It's 12 months from the child's birth or placement date, not a calendar year. Any bonding weeks used come out of that 12-month window, and care or military assist weeks in the same stretch count toward the same eight-week total.

0 coins

wait so if i use 5 weeks bonding i only have 3 left for a care claim in the same 12 months?

0 coins

Exactly. It's one eight-week pool for all three claim types within any 12-month period.

0 coins

I did not know that. I thought bonding and care were separate eight weeks each. That's a big deal if you end up needing both.

0 coins

My bonding claim ran six weeks before I went back part time and I was so confused about whether I had to file a whole new claim for the remaining two weeks or just report the days. Ended up calling and spending about two hours trying to get through before I gave up and sent a Request Claim Update in SDI Online instead. The message came back a couple days later and confirmed I just needed to return the Continued Claim Certification.

0 coins

Two hours on hold and you still didn't get through? That's the part that scares me about calling.

0 coins

Never actually got through to a person that day, the line just ended the call. The SDI Online message worked though, it just took a couple days.

0 coins

the online message route seems more reliable than the phone honestly

0 coins

So if she contacts EDD now and admits the overlap, does she automatically owe everything back or does EDD recalculate what PFL should have been with the wages factored in?

0 coins

EDD recalculates. It compares what PFL paid against what PFL should have paid given her wages during those weeks. The overpayment is the difference, not necessarily the full amount she received.

0 coins

That's actually more manageable than I was picturing. I thought it meant paying back everything she got.

0 coins

Not everything. Only the portion that exceeded what the benefit should have been with wages counted in.

0 coins

if she got a notice of computation already she should check the weekly amount on there, and then compare it to what she actually got paid by her job those weeks. the math will tell her pretty quickly if there was an overlap

0 coins

We still have the Notice of Computation somewhere. That's actually a good starting point before we write to EDD, so we know what we're talking about when we contact them.

0 coins

yeah pull that out first. youll see the weekly benefit amount edd set for her and you can line it up against her pay stubs

0 coins

Great approach honestly. Going in with the numbers already worked out makes the conversation with EDD a lot smoother.

0 coins

Appeal rights exist even on overpayment notices. If the amount EDD comes back with doesn't match what your math shows, there's a form, the DE 1000A, and a 30-day window from the date on the notice.

0 coins

Good to know going in. We're hoping it doesn't get to that but at least there's a path if the numbers are off.

0 coins

30 days from the notice date, not from when you receive it. Open the mail the day it arrives.

0 coins

That's the part people miss. The clock doesn't wait for you to read it.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure