Back to California Paid Family Leave

Jacob Lewis

What are chances of winning PFL appeal after denial — anyone actually come out on the other side?

So my PFL care claim got denied last month and I'm kind of spiraling honestly. I've been home caring for my dad who had a pretty serious health episode and can't manage on his own right now, and EDD sent me a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination saying I wasn't eligible. The DE 1000A appeal form came with it. I filed the appeal but I genuinely have no idea what to expect. Like what are the chances of winning a PFL appeal after denial? Did I need more documentation from his doctor? Is there a specific window I'm missing? I submitted Part D within what I thought was 41 days but now I'm second-guessing everything. Has anyone actually appealed a PFL denial and won?

Part D not" received was the status on my care claim for two weeks after my'mom s doctor submitted it online with the receipt number, so I knew something'wasn t matching up on'EDD s end. I tried the phone line every morning for four days and never reached anyone. Eventually I tried (Claimyr) claimyr.com and ended up speaking with an actual EDD agent.'Claimyr s video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed Part D had arrived but was sitting unmatched because the receipt number on the form had one digit wrong. She had it corrected on her end and told me to watch for a status update in SDI Online within a few days.'That s exactly whathappened.

0 coins

May I ask, did the agent say whether you needed to have the doctor resubmit anything, or was the correction on EDD's side enough to move things forward?

0 coins

The agent fixed the matching issue herself without needing the doctor to do anything over again. She just confirmed both the form and the correction were noted on the claim.

0 coins

Four days of trying that line and you got through, meanwhile I've been at it for going on two weeks trying to ask about my own claim status. Mornings, afternoons, doesn't seem to matter what time I try.

0 coins

I'm kind of in the same boat as you, not sure but I think there are a few reasons a care claim gets denied. Like if Part D didn't reach EDD within 41 days of when your leave started, that might be it? Or maybe the doctor's certification wasn't complete enough? I'm not sure, just guessing from what I've read.

0 coins

Those are actually two of the common ones. Part D arriving past 41 days from the leave start date is a frequent denial reason. An incomplete or unsigned certification is another. The denial notice itself should say which applies here.

0 coins

That part about 41 days is what I'm hung up on. I started leave on October 3rd and I thought I filed everything in time, but now I'm not 100% sure when the doctor's office actually sent Part D.

0 coins

Does the SDI Online claim status ever show when Part D was received, or just whether it was received? That might help narrow down whether the 41-day deadline is what triggered the denial.

0 coins

SDI Online shows whether documents were received, not always the exact date in a way claimants can read. The denial notice from EDD should spell out the specific reason, which matters a lot for how to frame the appeal.

0 coins

My cousin went through a PFL appeal last year and she won, so it does happen. Her situation was that Part D got there in time but the doctor's office had left a section blank and EDD denied it. She appealed, sent a corrected certification, and it got overturned. She said the key was being really specific in the appeal about what the error was and that it was the doctor's clerical thing, not her fault.

0 coins

That actually gives me a little hope. My situation might be similar in that the denial could be a documentation gap rather than me actually not being eligible.

0 coins

Appeals do get overturned. It's not guaranteed but incomplete doctor forms are one of the cleaner ones to fix because there's a clear paper trail.

0 coins

Good to know it's possible. I've been afraid to even try.

0 coins

Appeal within 30 days of the denial notice. That part is not flexible.

0 coins

I sent the DE 1000A in already, about ten days after I got the denial, so at least that part's covered.

0 coins

Yeah the 30-day window is the one thing you don't want to miss because there's no getting around it after, anyway.

0 coins

What does your denial notice actually say? The DE 2514 should list the specific reason. That determines everything about what your appeal needs to show.

0 coins

Mine says Part D wasn't received within the required period. So that's the 41-day thing. What I don't know is whether Part D actually arrived late or whether EDD just didn't have it matched to my claim in time.

0 coins

That distinction matters a lot. If the doctor's office sent it on time and EDD's end had a matching problem, like a wrong receipt number on the form, that's worth raising in the appeal because it may not have been a true deadline miss.

0 coins

Ask the doctor's office exactly when they submitted it and how. If they did it in SDI Online, they might have a confirmation or a timestamp from that submission.

0 coins

wait so you can win a pfl appeal even if the reason is the 41 day deadline? i thought once you miss that youre just done

0 coins

Whether a late Part D is truly a missed deadline or a documentation matching issue is the question. If the doctor submitted on time but it wasn't linked to the right claim, that's different from it arriving past 41 days. EDD would need to see evidence of when it was actually submitted.

0 coins

oh ok so the appeal is basically your chance to show it wasnt actually late lol, got it

0 coins

And even a genuinely late submission can sometimes be explained in an appeal if there were circumstances outside the claimant's control. No promises on outcome but the appeal is the place to make that argument.

0 coins

For anyone wondering about the appeal form, the DE 1000A is pretty short but the written explanation section is where you want to put detail. Saying what happened, what documents you have showing timeliness, and asking for a hearing if you want one are all things that belong in that section.

0 coins

Is there any advantage to requesting an in-person or phone hearing versus just submitting written documentation? I don't even know what the process looks like after you file the form.

0 coins

A hearing gives you a chance to explain directly and answer questions in real time, which some people find helps. With just written materials, the decision rests entirely on what you submit. Neither is automatically better, it really depends on how strong your documentation is.

0 coins

The idea of a hearing honestly terrifies me but I can see why it might be better if the situation is complicated.

0 coins

October 14th my payment still hadn't posted, eleven days after my PFL bonding claim showed approved, so I used Claimyr and talked to a PFL agent directly. She checked the payment date on my claim and confirmed it had been issued October 12th to the debit card on file, and that it typically takes a few business days to show up. I hadn't updated my payment preference to direct deposit yet so it was going out by card, and that explained the delay.

0 coins

I need to know when my own payment is going to post from my bonding claim, it's been sitting there for a bit. I'm thinking I'll try Claimyr for that. What should I have ready when I call?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, your claim ID from SDI Online, and the specific date range you're asking about. The agent pulled up my account fast once I had those.

0 coins

ive been trying that line since like last tuesday and i give up after 20 minutes every single morning cant get through

0 coins

Missing payment timing is one of those things that really doesn't need to be a mystery if you can get a live person. It's a quick question for them.

0 coins

This is making me realize I should also just try to ask EDD directly about why the Part D was flagged as late, not just rely on what the denial notice says.

0 coins

Agreed. Sometimes the written notice is vague and an agent can tell you more specifically what the record shows.

0 coins

For your appeal, definitely track down anything from the doctor's office that shows when Part D was sent. Even an email confirmation or a note from the front desk about the submission date could be helpful!

0 coins

I called the doctor's office this morning and they said they submitted it in SDI Online on October 28th. My leave started October 3rd, so that would be 25 days in, well within 41. If EDD is saying it wasn't received, that's a matching issue not a late submission.

0 coins

That is actually a solid position for your appeal. The submission was on time, so the denial may be based on something clerical that you can document and show.

0 coins

I'd ask the doctor's office to give you something in writing showing that date, even if it's just a printed note with the date and confirmation that they submitted via SDI Online. Attach it to your appeal or bring it to the hearing.

0 coins

Something worth checking too, make sure the receipt number on Part D was correct. If the doctor's office had a typo in that number, the form may have arrived but EDD couldn't link it to your claim, which would look like a missing Part D on their end even though it wasn't.

0 coins

How would I find out if that's what happened? Can I see that in SDI Online or do I have to call?

0 coins

SDI Online won't show that level of detail. You'd need to call EDD or use the Request Claim Update in SDI Online and ask specifically whether Part D was received but unmatched. That way you have a written record of asking too.

0 coins

I didn't know you could request a claim update in writing through SDI Online. That feels less terrifying than trying to get through on the phone.

0 coins

just want to say that the 41 days runs from when your leave actually started, not from when you filed the claim form. people mix those up.

0 coins

Oh that's actually worth double-checking for my situation. My leave started October 3rd and I filed the claim form before that date, thinking I was getting ahead of things.

0 coins

You can file no earlier than your first day of leave. If you filed before your leave started, EDD may have a different start date recorded than you think.

0 coins

Wait, so the system might have adjusted my start date to the date I filed? That could change the whole 41-day calculation. I need to find out what date EDD has as my leave start date.

0 coins

i keep reading that you can just send a Request Claim Update in SDI Online but every time i do it feels like it goes nowhere, no response for weeks

0 coins

The Request Claim Update does have a response time that can be slow. For something time-sensitive like an appeal, it may be worth combining that with a phone attempt during the week, mornings tend to have slightly shorter waits in my experience, though it's never guaranteed.

0 coins

yeah ive sent two of those with no response in like three weeks, its not exactly fast

0 coins

EDD denies a lot of care claims on Part D issues. The appeal process is there for exactly this kind of situation. Win rates aren't something EDD publishes but anecdotally the ones I've seen overturned were the ones where the person had documentation.

0 coins

Documentation is what I need to build then. Doctor's office submission record, the confirmation from SDI Online if there is one, and anything that shows the timeline.

0 coins

You've got a clearer picture now than when you posted. That's actually progress.

0 coins

my wife's care claim got denied too, different reason, hers was an incomplete Part C, we appealed and it's still pending so i can't tell you how it ends but we're in it

0 coins

What was incomplete on Part C? I'm wondering if mine had issues too and I just didn't realize it.

0 coins

Part C is the care recipient's statement, your dad would fill it out about his own condition. If that was blank or missing sections EDD flags it. Worth checking your submission to see if it got sent back or just denied.

0 coins

I did not know Part C was something the person being cared for fills out themselves. I thought the claimant filled out everything.

0 coins

Eight weeks of PFL sounded like plenty when I started my care claim, then I realized that eight weeks is shared across bonding, care and military assist all in the same 12-month stretch. I'd already taken a few bonding weeks with my baby earlier this year before my mom got sick. Used Claimyr to reach EDD and ask how many of those eight weeks I had left before I planned more time off for her appointments.

0 coins

The eight weeks being shared across all claim types caught me off guard on my own situation. I used Claimyr too after getting my Notice of Computation and wanting to understand how the remaining weeks would apply. The agent walked me through what the notice showed as my benefit amount and confirmed how many weeks of that benefit period I'd already used. I didn't want to plan time around a number and have it be wrong.

0 coins

ive been hitting that phone line hard this week trying to get the same kind of answer, nothing so far

0 coins

The agent told me exactly how many weeks remained based on what was in my claim history. That was the one clear answer I needed to plan the next few months.

0 coins

wait so bonding and care are the same pool of weeks? i thought you got 8 for bonding and then another 8 if you had a family member who was sick after

0 coins

Not quite. It's eight total weeks across all PFL claim types in any 12-month period. So if you used six weeks bonding with a baby, you'd have two weeks left for a care claim in that same window.

0 coins

oh wow that is not what i thought at all, glad i know now before i try to plan anything

0 coins

This trips up so many people! The 12 months starts from your first PFL leave date, so the window moves with you, not with a calendar year.

0 coins

is there a waiting period before pfl starts paying? i thought i heard there was a week you don't get paid

0 coins

PFL doesn't have a waiting period. That seven-day unpaid period is part of Disability Insurance, which is a separate program for someone's own illness or pregnancy. PFL for bonding or care starts paying from the first eligible day once EDD approves the claim.

0 coins

oh good, i was confused because someone told me i'd lose a week. that's a relief.

0 coins

I made the same mistake at first, mixing up the disability waiting period with PFL. They're really different programs.

0 coins

October 7th the claim status still said pending even though I'd uploaded the birth certificate two days after my son was born. I ended up using Claimyr to reach EDD about whether the 41-day clock had been started from the right date, since I'd filed a couple of days after I came home from the hospital. The agent confirmed EDD had my leave start date right and that the proof of relationship had come through fine. That cleared up the one thing I'd been anxious about all week.

0 coins

i dont know, i tried calling that number like six times this week and got a recording every time saying to try again later. if its that hard to get through for everyone im not sure how you actually managed to reach a live person

0 coins

I hear you, I had the same thing happen multiple days in a row before I tried Claimyr. When I finally got the agent she was clearly an EDD employee, answered questions about my claim directly. I can see why it sounds hard to believe based on what that phone line normally does.

0 coins

The agent I reached told me which weeks on my claim had posted as paid and which were still processing. That was the specific answer I needed and it came from someone looking at the actual claim, not a recording.

0 coins

Okay now I'm realizing I should figure out what start date EDD has on file for my care claim before I go further with the appeal, because if the date is different from what I think it is, that changes my whole argument.

0 coins

If you end up at a hearing, bring every piece of paper. Denial notice, Part D, anything from the doctor's office showing when they submitted, your own filing confirmation, all of it.

0 coins

Is it better to submit copies in advance or bring originals the day of?

0 coins

Submit copies when you file the appeal, bring copies again on the day. Keep your originals.

0 coins

You can also ask the doctor's office to submit a letter for the hearing record explaining when and how they sent Part D, since they'd be a witness to that timeline.

0 coins

Just want to circle back to the original question about chances. Nobody can promise a number but denial appeals on care claims do succeed, especially when the denial is paperwork-based rather than actual ineligibility. The more clearly you can show the timeline, the better your position.

0 coins

That's really the frame I needed. My dad does qualify as a family member for a care claim, the leave timing works, everything about eligibility seems fine. The only issue is EDD not receiving Part D or not matching it, and that feels fixable on appeal.

0 coins

That is a stronger position than you had when you first posted. Keep the appeal tight, documents in front, timeline clear.

0 coins

Get the doctor's office submission date in writing. That's your foundation.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure