Back to California Paid Family Leave

Avery Saint

SDI overpayment notice employer paid full salary during leave — now what?

Okay so I got a letter from EDD last week that honestly made my stomach drop. Got an overpayment notice on my PFL bonding claim, and after staring at it for way too long I think I understand why — my salon was actually really generous and kept paying my full salary the whole time I was out with the baby. I didn't realize that was going to be a problem. I filed my bonding claim through SDI Online like normal, got my payments, and my employer just... also kept my check coming. Now EDD is saying I was overpaid. I don't even know where to start. Can I fight this? Do I have to pay it all back? Has anyone dealt with an overpayment notice when their employer just paid them without asking?

The 41-day window that tripped me up is actually the smaller problem here — the bigger one is wages. PFL and your regular salary together can't go over your normal take-home, so if your employer paid 100% and EDD also paid, the PFL amount is what becomes the overpayment. It's not a penalty, it's just EDD taking back what you technically weren't entitled to under those circumstances.

0 coins

So there's no way to argue it was a mistake and get it forgiven? I genuinely didn't know the two couldn't stack like that.

0 coins

You can appeal the amount if you think the numbers are wrong, but the underlying rule is pretty firm. Appeal form is the DE 1000A, 30 days from the notice date.

0 coins

30 days goes fast, I need to look at that notice again tonight.

0 coins

Part D on my care claim for my mom showed "not received" for almost two weeks after her doctor said she mailed it in. I was panicking that the 41-day deadline would run out before EDD matched it. I ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an EDD agent because I could not get a human on that line no matter how many mornings I tried. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed Part D was there, it just hadn't been linked to my receipt number yet, and they updated it while I was on the phone. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

My Notice of Computation took forever to show up in SDI Online too — I had Claimyr on my end for a different reason. Agent found the DE 429DF had been issued and told me the weekly amount on it, which was more than I expected. Filed the DE 2501F the next day with that number in hand.

0 coins

how many times did you try the line before you gave up and did the claimyr thing

0 coins

Gave it about nine mornings across two weeks. After that it was easier to just have someone else sit on hold.

0 coins

Same stretch for me, maybe eleven tries. The recording would just end the call, never even a queue.

0 coins

The appeal deadline surprised me when I first read my own notice — 30 days from the date on the letter, not from when you receive it, so mail time eats into that. The DE 1000A is a single-page form, you can file it online through myEDD (https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/) or mail it to wherever the notice says. In an overpayment appeal you're typically disputing either the amount or whether it was actually an overpayment under EDD's rules.

0 coins

Wait, the date on the letter or the date I got it in my mailbox? Because mine sat in the mailbox over a weekend.

0 coins

The date printed on the notice itself. That's the clock EDD uses, so yes, weekends and mail delays count against you. File as soon as you have it.

0 coins

Okay that's actually kind of alarming, I had no idea. Filing tonight.

0 coins

Had the same thing happen to a guy at my warehouse. His employer kept his pay and EDD paid too. He owed it back, end of story. Appealing didn't erase the overpayment, just confirmed the math was right.

0 coins

That's not exactly encouraging but I appreciate the honesty.

0 coins

Better to know up front. At least the payments come out of the balance over time, they don't demand it all at once usually.

0 coins

Curious whether you told your employer not to pay you or if they just did it on their own. Some employers have a policy where they top off PFL to full salary, and in those cases the expectation is that the employee remits the PFL benefits back to the employer, not to EDD. If your employer just paid without any agreement like that, the overpayment situation lands differently.

0 coins

No agreement, they just kept paying me. Nobody said anything about me owing them the PFL money either, they were just being generous I guess.

0 coins

In that case the overpayment is between you and EDD, not you and your employer. Might be worth a quick conversation with HR just to make sure they don't come back later with their own expectations.

0 coins

Oh I hadn't even thought about the HR angle, good point.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is an absolute circus. I tried for two weeks on a care claim question and got hung up on every single time before even reaching a menu. The overpayment notices go out and then you're supposed to somehow reach a human to sort it out — good luck.

0 coins

Two weeks feels short, I'm going on five and counting.

0 coins

Five weeks and nothing, that's brutal. At some point you just have to find another way in.

0 coins

There isn't one that I've found yet.

0 coins

You can also send a Request Claim Update through SDI Online if calling isn't working! It's not as fast as talking to someone but at least it's documented and EDD has to respond to it.

0 coins

Does that actually work for overpayment questions though or just for pending claims?

0 coins

Worked for me for a payment timing question, I got a response in a few days! For something as specific as an overpayment calculation you might still want a person eventually but it's a start.

0 coins

The Request Claim Update is in SDI Online under your claim ID. For an overpayment dispute you'll want the written record anyway, so it's not a bad first step even before the appeal.

0 coins

Sick leave, vacation, any paid time off from your employer on top of PFL — the two together can't go over your usual wages. That's always been the rule. Most people just don't find out until the notice shows up.

0 coins

I really wish someone had explained that before I filed. Would have asked my salon to hold off on the salary.

0 coins

Tell your HR next time. Some places know to pause the salary during PFL, some don't. Not EDD's job to tell them.

0 coins

About three weeks into the payments on my own bonding claim one deposit just didn't land when I expected it. I tried the EDD line five mornings in a row and got nowhere. Ended up reaching an agent through Claimyr and asked about the payment's date. The agent pulled up the claim and said the payment had been issued two days earlier but was still in transit to my account, should land within a business day. It did.

0 coins

Five mornings and still nothing on the line — I've put in more than that and I'm still empty-handed. I'm not sure anything actually gets through to a live person on that line anymore.

0 coins

I had the same doubt. Eleven tries before that, nothing. The agent I talked to knew my claim number, the weekly amount, every detail. That was enough for me.

0 coins

Agent confirmed the payment was issued and in transit — that's the kind of concrete answer that tells you whether to wait or escalate. Good outcome.

0 coins

Fine, I'll give it a shot. If I do reach someone I want to ask about my current benefit period and which weeks have already been paid.

0 coins

The overpayment notice has the total amount right on it. Before anything else, check whether that number matches what EDD paid you during the weeks your employer also paid. Sometimes the math is just wrong.

0 coins

I actually haven't done that yet, sitting down with a calculator tonight.

0 coins

Do that first. If the number is off that's your strongest appeal argument.

0 coins

My coworker got an overpayment notice and panicked thinking EDD was going to garnish wages or something. That's not how it works, lol. You respond, you appeal if you disagree, and there's a process. It's annoying but it doesn't come out of nowhere.

0 coins

Can they actually garnish wages though? I'm now worried about that.

0 coins

EDD has collection options if someone ignores the notice entirely, but responding and appealing or making arrangements is what stops that from going anywhere. Don't ignore the notice.

0 coins

Yeah basically as long as you're engaging with it and not just ghosting EDD you're fine.

0 coins

i thought your employer paying you during leave was fine as long as it was sick time or something, not full salary? am i wrong about that

0 coins

Any paid wages plus PFL together over normal wages equals an overpayment issue, sick time included. Doesn't matter what the employer calls it.

0 coins

oh okay yeah that makes more sense then, i thought sick time was different for some reason

0 coins

The DE 1000A appeal form asks you to explain your basis for the appeal, so being specific helps. If you believe the overpayment amount is wrong, write that and show your math. If you think there's a factual error in EDD's determination, say what it is. Vague appeals take longer.

0 coins

This is super helpful, I'll make sure not to just say 'I disagree' and leave it at that.

0 coins

Exactly. The more precise you are, the clearer it is for the reviewer.

0 coins

does the appeal pause the repayment or do you still owe while you're waiting for a decision

0 coins

EDD's overpayment process and the appeal run separately. The notice stands until there's a decision changing it. Ask EDD directly about any arrangement during the appeal period.

0 coins

okay that's what i was afraid of, thanks

0 coins

my roommate had this exact situation, employer kept paying him and he got the overpayment notice like two months later. he said he had to pay back the pfl amount not the whole salary which makes sense i guess

0 coins

That tracks — it's the PFL benefits that become the overpayment, not the employer's payments. EDD takes back what they paid out, not what your job paid.

0 coins

yeah thats what he said too, he was stressed but it wasnt like a crazy amount in the end

0 coins

Weeks remaining in my 12-month window was something I had totally lost track of after going back to part-time. I used Claimyr to reach someone at EDD and asked how many of the eight weeks I still had available. The agent looked at my claim and said I had used five weeks already in the 12 months, leaving me with three weeks I could still use before the period closed. I adjusted my schedule based on that.

0 coins

What even is Claimyr? I keep seeing it mentioned but I don't know what it actually does.

0 coins

It waits on EDD's hold line in your place, and once a live EDD agent picks up, your phone rings so you take the call from there.

0 coins

Hm. I've been trying to get through about a care claim issue and my line situation is basically ten attempts, ten dead ends. Might be worth trying if that's really what it does.

0 coins

if you honestly didnt know the rule about salary plus pfl, that might matter in your appeal. not saying EDD will waive it but explaining the circumstances doesnt hurt.

0 coins

Someone else mentioned potentially a waiver — does that actually exist for PFL overpayments?

0 coins

The DE 1000A is the appeal form for disputing the determination. What EDD does from there is their call, but laying out the facts is the right move regardless.

0 coins

Got it. I'll write out exactly what happened and let them decide.

0 coins

One thing worth noting — PFL has no waiting period before benefits start. If the overpayment notice suggests otherwise, check whether they may have confused your claim with a disability claim, which does have an unpaid period at the start.

0 coins

Wait, PFL really has no waiting period? I read somewhere that there were seven unpaid days at the beginning.

0 coins

That's the disability claim, not PFL. For bonding or a care claim under PFL, benefits start from day one with no unpaid waiting days.

0 coins

Okay that actually clears up a lot of confusion I've had, I kept mixing those two up.

0 coins

Start date on my care claim had me spinning for a while — I wasn't sure if the 41 days ran from the first day I actually missed work or from when I filed in SDI Online. Used Claimyr to get an agent and asked specifically. She said the 41 days runs from the first day of leave, not from when you file, and that my start date on file was correct.

0 coins

I've used Claimyr on a bonding claim and got a straight answer about the DE 2500E — agent told me the electronic payment notification had been issued and what it said. Filed my bank info in SDI Online same day based on that.

0 coins

She also confirmed which account the payment would go to, which I'd been unsure about since I'd updated my bank info partway through the claim.

0 coins

Good to know it works for care claims too, I was a little unsure about that going in.

0 coins

For what it's worth the SDI Online upload feature is good for some documents but NOT for Part C or Part D on care claims — uploading those can actually slow things down. Mail or the doctor submits Part D online with the receipt number. Just flagging since it comes up a lot in these threads.

0 coins

Does that apply to proof of relationship on a bonding claim too or just the care claim forms?

0 coins

Proof of relationship for bonding you can upload in SDI Online. The no-upload rule is specific to Part C and Part D on care claims.

0 coins

That's a really useful distinction, I've seen people say to upload everything and that's clearly not right.

0 coins

Depending on when in the 12-month window the overpayment weeks fall, it could affect how many weeks you still have available. Might be worth confirming with EDD how the credited weeks shake out after they process the overpayment.

0 coins

I hadn't even thought about the remaining weeks piece. So the overpaid weeks might not count toward my eight weeks total?

0 coins

That's something to ask EDD directly. The resolution of the overpayment affects the week count, so get that clarified before you assume you've used those weeks.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure