SDI multiple jobs one without SDI private disability pregnancy — how does California EDD handle this?
So I'm about 28 weeks pregnant and trying to figure out how my leave is going to work because my situation is a little complicated. I have two jobs. My main job withholds CASDI from my check every pay period, no problem. But my second job is through a staffing agency and I noticed they don't take out any SDI at all — they have some kind of private plan through the agency. I asked HR and they said it's a "voluntary plan" or something? I don't even know if that counts for PFL purposes. What I'm trying to figure out is whether EDD will only look at my wages from job one when they calculate my benefit, or if they can somehow include job two even with the private plan. I'm worried I'll end up with a really low weekly amount because job two is actually where I make more money. My due date is in February and I want to get this sorted out before I even file so I don't get a surprise on my Notice of Computation. Has anyone dealt with something like this — two jobs, only one pays into SDI, the other has some private disability thing?
84 comments

Adrian Hughes
The base period wages EDD uses for your PFL benefit are the ones where CASDI was actually withheld. If your staffing agency job runs under a state-approved voluntary plan, those wages might still count, but you'd need to confirm that with EDD directly — it's not something you can assume either way.
0 coins
Lara Woods
AuthorSo there's no automatic way SDI Online would pull in both jobs' wages? I have to actually ask EDD?
0 coins
Adrian Hughes
Exactly. File your claim in SDI Online and then contact EDD to ask how wages under your agency's plan get treated on your specific claim.
0 coins
Molly Chambers
The benefits calculator on EDD's site can give an estimate once you know which wages are included, so that's worth checking before you file just to get a rough idea of your range.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
The DE 2530 guide says the weekly benefit amount comes from the highest-earning quarter of your base period, which covers about 5 to 18 months before your claim starts. If only one employer's wages count, that's the pool EDD draws from, so a lower base period could mean a noticeably lower weekly amount.
0 coins
Lara Woods
AuthorThat's what worries me. Job two is where most of my income is. If those wages are out, the weekly amount on my Notice of Computation could be much less than I need.
0 coins
Eli Butler
Worth pointing out that the Notice of Computation isn't an approval, it just tells you the potential weekly benefit amount. The eligibility decision comes separately, so there could be two different pieces of mail.
0 coins
Lara Woods
AuthorWait, so I could get the Notice of Computation and still not know if I'm actually approved? That's a little stressful.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
Yes, they're separate. The Notice shows the calculated weekly amount, and eligibility gets decided in a separate step. Both can arrive pretty close together though.
0 coins
Marcus Patterson
Two jobs during leave is kind of my situation right now, different reasons, and I ended up needing to understand how the reporting works. After the baby arrived I went back to my second job part-time after a few weeks, and my Continued Claim Certification, the DE 2580GF, came and I wasn't sure what wages to report on it. I tried the EDD phone line maybe six times over three mornings and either got a busy signal or the system ended the call before I reached anyone. Eventually I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to someone at EDD. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent looked at my claim and confirmed which pay periods fell in the certification window and walked me through which wages to put on the DE 2580GF. I hadn't been reporting anything for one of the jobs because I thought bonding benefits were separate from wages, but the agent was clear that any wages, even ones not yet paid out, go on that form or it can cause an overpayment.
0 coins
Lydia Bailey
EDD's PFL line picks up for you now? I've been at it every day this week and it just cuts the call off after the hold music. Hard to believe that just works.
0 coins
Marcus Patterson
Three mornings I tried on my own and nothing. The Claimyr route was different — I ended up actually talking to an agent. I was surprised too, it wasn't what I expected after those three mornings.
0 coins
Mateo Warren
Agent confirmed my payment method was still set to debit card when I'd actually set up direct deposit in SDI Online. Turned out the update hadn't taken on their end. Had to confirm it with EDD directly to get it corrected before my next payment issued.
0 coins
Lydia Bailey
So the debit card and direct deposit can get out of sync between SDI Online and what EDD actually has on file? I didn't know you could even verify that by phone.
0 coins
Mateo Warren
You can. The agent could see what payment method was recorded on the claim and confirmed it didn't match what was showing in SDI Online. She said to watch for the next payment to confirm it went to the right place.
0 coins
Sofia Price
Okay so the private plan thing tripped me up too when I had my second kid. My part-time retail job had some employer plan and I genuinely had no idea if those wages were going to show up anywhere. I never got a straight answer until I just looked at my Notice of Computation and compared it to what I expected. The number was lower than I wanted, which kind of told me something.
0 coins
Lara Woods
AuthorDid you ever get an explanation of which wages made it in and which didn't?
0 coins
Sofia Price
Honestly no, I just accepted it and moved on. The estimate on EDD's calculator was lower too so it kind of lined up. If your situation is more complicated I'd actually contact EDD before you file so you're not guessing.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
Same thing happened to a coworker, she had one job with CASDI and one without, looked at her Notice of Computation and it was just the one job's wages in there. Never got the other one included, lol.
0 coins
Owen Jenkins
You mentioned the agency calls it a voluntary plan. If it's a state-approved voluntary plan it might still feed into SDI coverage. If it's not state-approved it probably doesn't. That's a question for HR or EDD, not something to guess at.
0 coins
Lara Woods
AuthorHR at the staffing agency was pretty vague about it. I think I need to actually ask EDD. I just wasn't sure if this was even worth raising before I filed.
0 coins
Owen Jenkins
Worth raising before. If those wages matter to your weekly amount you want to know now, not when the Notice of Computation shows up with a lower number.
0 coins
Lilah Brooks
Agreed. Get that answer before the baby comes, not after when you're buried in paperwork and sleepless nights.
0 coins
Jackson Carter
The whole private plan question aside, filing in SDI Online through myEDD is straightforward once you're in. The part that bites people is the 41-day window — you file no earlier than the first day of your leave and no later than 41 days after it starts. Miss that and you lose some of those days.
0 coins
Lara Woods
AuthorAnd for a pregnancy disability claim that comes before bonding, the 41 days starts from when disability leave starts, right? Not the due date?
0 coins
Jackson Carter
The disability claim starts from your first day off work. Then bonding is a separate PFL claim after that. The 41-day clock on the bonding piece starts from the day your bonding leave begins, which is usually when disability ends.
0 coins
Kolton Murphy
New mothers get a special form for the bonding piece, the DE 2501FP, so that transition is a little different from filing a brand new bonding claim. No extra proof of relationship needed with that one, anyway.
0 coins
Evelyn Rivera
The determination I got after my care claim was denied caught me off guard — the Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination, the DE 2514, came with an Appeal Form, the DE 1000A. I had 30 days from the date on that notice to appeal, online or by mail. I hadn't touched the EDD phone line in weeks because every attempt just ended without reaching anyone. So I went through Claimyr and spoke with an EDD agent about whether the DE 2514 was truly final or if there was anything still pending on the claim. The agent pulled up the claim and confirmed the determination had been issued and that the appeal window was 30 days from that date — that was what I needed to know before deciding whether to appeal.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
What exactly is Claimyr? I keep seeing it mentioned here.
0 coins
Evelyn Rivera
It handles the hold time with EDD's line so your phone rings when an actual EDD employee picks up. That's the whole thing. No magic, just someone else handling the wait.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
That's useful to know. My PFL care claim has been pending for going on 11 days and I want to ask EDD whether Part D from my mom's doctor ever got matched to my claim. That might be worth trying.
0 coins
Eli Butler
Part D can be submitted in SDI Online by the doctor's office using your receipt number, or mailed. If you gave the office your receipt number and they submitted it online, it should be linked. But confirming with EDD directly is the safest move.
0 coins
Julia Hall
my second job doesnt take out casdi either and i just filed my claim on the wages from job one only. the number on my notice of computation was what it was, wasnt going to fight it. if your second job wages dont count then they just dont count
0 coins
Lara Woods
AuthorWas the amount still enough to cover things? That's really what I'm stressed about.
0 coins
Julia Hall
it was okay, not great. i made it work. if yours is tight you might want to ask EDD before you file so you know what youre working with
0 coins
Arjun Patel
PFL does not have a waiting period — that's a point people mix up with disability, which has seven unpaid days at the start. With PFL, benefits start from the first day of your bonding or care leave.
0 coins
Lara Woods
AuthorWait, so after my pregnancy disability claim ends I won't have another week of nothing before PFL kicks in?
0 coins
Arjun Patel
No waiting period for PFL. The seven-day wait is for the disability side only.
0 coins
Jade Lopez
yeah i thought there was a wait for pfl too and there isnt. found that out when my notice came.
0 coins
Molly Chambers
It's a common mix-up. The disability claim has the waiting period, PFL does not. Worth knowing before you plan your budget for those first few weeks.
0 coins
Tony Brooks
Has anyone here actually gotten EDD to explain in writing how they treat wages from an employer voluntary plan? I've never seen that spelled out clearly anywhere.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
The DE 2530 guide mentions that PFL is part of SDI and that wages where CASDI is withheld form the base period. What happens with an approved voluntary plan is a gray area the guide doesn't map out for you.
0 coins
Adrian Hughes
For anything that specific, Ask EDD through the online contact form is usually the better move — you get a written answer tied to your account.
0 coins
Tony Brooks
Ask EDD being actually reliable would be news to me. I've submitted questions on there and gotten form responses. But it's worth a shot I guess.
0 coins
Ella rollingthunder87
For the pregnancy disability part, your OB or midwife fills out the medical certification, and EDD decides your start date from that! So your claim dates are really driven by what your doctor certifies, which is worth talking through with them before you go out.
0 coins
Lara Woods
AuthorSo I should loop in my doctor now-ish about the certification so there's no surprise on timing?
0 coins
Ella rollingthunder87
Yes, definitely! Let them know you'll need that certification completed promptly. The 41-day window doesn't wait for a slow office to send paperwork.
0 coins
Molly Chambers
Proof of relationship came up as a question for me on my bonding claim — I uploaded what I thought was correct and then heard nothing for over a week. After several mornings of unanswered calls, I tried Claimyr and reached an EDD agent who pulled up my claim and confirmed the birth certificate had been received and matched. The agent said the claim was still in the eligibility review period, which can take up to 14 days, and that I should allow that full window before expecting a determination.
0 coins
Jackson Carter
Reached a live EDD agent through Claimyr for my own claim too — my receipt number wasn't showing the claim properly in SDI Online and I needed to confirm EDD had it on their end. Agent found it right away and confirmed the receipt number matched the claim in their system.
0 coins
Yara Campbell
Did they say anything about how to fix the SDI Online display?
0 coins
Jackson Carter
Just that the claim was there in their system and to let the review period finish. The SDI Online display sorted itself out a couple days later.
0 coins
Kolton Murphy
14 days is the outer edge but mine moved faster. Filed the bonding claim on a Monday, had a Notice of Computation by Wednesday, anyway.
0 coins
Eli Butler
The eight weeks of PFL for bonding and the possibility of a care claim later in the same 12 months isn't eight plus eight — it's eight total across both. Worth knowing if there's any chance you'd need to care for someone in the same year you use bonding weeks.
0 coins
Lara Woods
AuthorOh I did not know that. So if I use all eight weeks bonding with the baby I'd have nothing left if I needed to care for a sick family member that same year?
0 coins
Eli Butler
Exactly. It's a shared pool for the 12 months. Five weeks bonding, for example, leaves three weeks for a care claim in that same period.
0 coins
Marcus Patterson
I made the mistake of thinking they were separate pots. They are not. One total limit for the 12 months covering bonding and care both.
0 coins
Arjun Patel
And a key point: PFL pays benefits during leave but your job protection, if you have it, comes from CFRA or FMLA, not from EDD. Those are employer-side rules, so check with HR about your specific coverage.
0 coins
Lilah Brooks
If your due date is February, file your disability claim no earlier than your first day off work. Don't file before that. And hang onto your receipt number — you'll need it.
0 coins
Lara Woods
AuthorIs there a way to retrieve the receipt number later if I lose it? Or do I need to screenshot it right away?
0 coins
Lilah Brooks
Screenshot it the second it shows up. I wouldn't rely on being able to find it again later when you're exhausted and dealing with a newborn.
0 coins
Sofia Price
You can also check your claim in SDI Online through myEDD — the claim should show up there once it's filed, so the receipt number isn't completely gone if you miss it in the moment.
0 coins
Lydia Bailey
PFL and unemployment don't pay at the same time for the same days either. If you're getting PFL you can't also collect UI for that same period. Some people learn that one the hard way with an overpayment notice.
0 coins
Lara Woods
AuthorI wasn't planning on filing for unemployment, I'll still have my jobs. But good to know.
0 coins
Lydia Bailey
Just putting it out there for anyone reading who might wonder. Overpayments come with their own headache.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
your two-job situation is actually more common than people think lol. the short answer most people land on: file on the wages where CASDI was taken out, see what your Notice of Computation says, and if the amount looks wrong call EDD to ask how the other wages were handled
0 coins
Lara Woods
AuthorThat feels like the most practical approach honestly. File, see the notice, and then follow up if the numbers look off.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
Exactly. And if you want to avoid a surprise, use the calculator on EDD's site with just your job-one wages first so you know the floor before you even file.
0 coins
Kolton Murphy
New mother bonding transition was smoother than I expected for my spouse — the DE 2501FP came in the mail toward the end of her disability claim. File it within 41 days of when bonding starts and that's really all you need to do, no extra proof of relationship documents required, anyway.
0 coins
Lara Woods
AuthorSo the bonding form for the new mom is different from the regular bonding claim form? I thought it was all the same.
0 coins
Kolton Murphy
Different form. DE 2501FP for the new mom after disability ends. DE 2501F or SDI Online for everyone else, and that one needs proof of relationship like a birth certificate.
0 coins
Molly Chambers
The DE 2501FP transition form is specifically for birth mothers whose pregnancy disability claim has ended. It streamlines the step because EDD already has the medical connection established.
0 coins
Jade Lopez
been trying to get clear on whether my second employer's private plan wages count for anything for weeks now. still dont have a solid answer. maybe i should just call EDD
0 coins
Adrian Hughes
Calling EDD directly is the right move for this one. It's genuinely too fact-specific to get a reliable answer from a forum.
0 coins
Jade Lopez
yeah i know. ive been putting it off because the line never goes anywhere but i guess i have to.
0 coins
Yara Campbell
Payments come by debit card, direct deposit, or check. Direct deposit is only available if you filed in SDI Online.
0 coins
Lara Woods
AuthorGood to know. I was planning to file in SDI Online so direct deposit should be an option for me.
0 coins
Yara Campbell
Yes, just set it up when you file and double-check it took correctly before your first payment is due.
0 coins
Evelyn Rivera
The employer who runs a voluntary plan should have documentation about whether it's state-approved. If it's state-approved, it's part of the SDI system and the wages may factor in. If it's not, those wages are outside the SDI framework entirely.
0 coins
Lara Woods
AuthorSo I should ask the staffing agency specifically whether their plan is state-approved, not just whether it's a "voluntary plan"?
0 coins
Evelyn Rivera
Exactly. "Voluntary plan" is the name but state-approved is what determines whether it connects to SDI at all.
0 coins
Owen Jenkins
Ask for it in writing from HR if you can. Vague verbal answers from a staffing agency about benefits tend to shift around when it matters.
0 coins
Ella rollingthunder87
The benefits calculator on EDD's site is worth running with just your CASDI-covered wages before you file so you go in knowing the realistic floor. Then if the actual Notice of Computation comes back higher, great!
0 coins
Lara Woods
AuthorI'll do that this weekend. At least I'll know what to expect at minimum and can plan from there.
0 coins
Ella rollingthunder87
And if the notice comes back lower than even that estimate, that's your signal to contact EDD and ask what went into the calculation!
0 coins