Back to California Paid Family Leave

Anna Xian

SDI denied because paid family leave was paid first — how to fix this?

So I'm kind of panicking here and hoping someone has dealt with this before. My wife had the baby in August and I filed my PFL bonding claim right after. Got paid out the eight weeks no problem. Then my wife filed her own disability claim for the pregnancy and postpartum recovery, which apparently should have come before any PFL, and EDD denied it because PFL benefits had already gone out on our household first — or at least that's how the denial letter reads to me. I'm honestly confused because I thought we were filing two totally separate claims as two separate people. Did I do something wrong when I filed? Is there any way to appeal this or fix it so she gets her disability payments? We really needed that money and now I don't know what we're doing.

DE 2500E on my bonding claim showed up and the payment date looked wrong to me, two weeks off from when I actually started leave. Tried the PFL line every morning that week, never got past the recording. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) instead and got a live EDD agent on the phone. She pulled up my claim and confirmed the payment date was tied to the start date EDD had on file, not the date I thought I gave them. That cleared it up for me. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

Start date being off is exactly what I ran into too. Had the same thing where the payment came out to fewer days than I expected. Used Claimyr as well and the agent told me my claim's start date was logged a week later than I filed, which explained the gap. If you're still trying to reach them the regular way, I gave up on that after day four of busy signals.

0 coins

Four days of busy signals and then you just gave up? That's terrifying. I've been trying for two days on my own claim and already feel like screaming.

0 coins

Two days feels like nothing by the time you've been at it a week, honestly. The line just does not cooperate most mornings.

0 coins

Your wife's situation and yours are completely separate claims filed by two separate people, so your PFL bonding payments should not have caused her disability claim to be denied. Those are different programs entirely. The disability claim covers her own recovery from childbirth, while your PFL was for bonding. EDD should not be linking them that way. It sounds like there may be an error on EDD's end, and she should appeal that denial.

0 coins

Anna Xian

Author

That's what I thought too, that they were separate. The denial letter mentions something about benefits already paid for the same period, which is what confused me. I'll look at the appeal form.

0 coins

The overlap in time period is probably what triggered it. EDD may have flagged the same weeks as already paid, even though the two people filing are different. Worth looking closely at which weeks the denial covers before writing the appeal.

0 coins

The Appeal Form is the DE 1000A, and she has 30 days from the date on the denial notice to submit it, either online or by mail. I would note in the appeal exactly what the person above said — that the two claims are filed by two different individuals for two different programs covering the same calendar period.

0 coins

Wait I'm not sure I understand — so PFL and disability are really two totally different things? I always thought they were the same, like SDI was just the umbrella name for all of it. Does filing one actually block the other for someone else in the family? Because now I'm scared I'm going to mess something up with my own situation.

0 coins

PFL and Disability Insurance are both under SDI but they are separate claims. PFL is for bonding or caring for a sick family member. Disability is for your own illness or injury, including pregnancy recovery. One person's PFL doesn't block another person's separate disability claim. They should not interfere.

0 coins

Okay that actually makes sense, thank you. So the denial in the original post sounds like it might just be a mistake on EDD's side then.

0 coins

Exactly right. The two programs share the SDI payroll deduction on a paystub but each claim stands alone. If EDD denied the disability claim citing PFL paid to a different claimant, the appeal should make that distinction clearly.

0 coins

Seen this before. EDD sometimes flags a household address when two claims overlap in dates. Doesn't mean either claim is wrong. Appeal is the move.

0 coins

Address flag makes a lot of sense actually. Same house, same weeks, different people, EDD's system gets jumpy.

0 coins

Anna Xian

Author

Nobody told us that could happen. We just both filed like normal and now we're stuck dealing with it.

0 coins

Appeal really is the only path at this point. The denial doesn't mean it's over.

0 coins

Just to lay it out clearly since it helped me when I was confused: a birth mother's pregnancy disability claim and a partner's PFL bonding claim can cover the same weeks because they are filed by two different people. EDD's own rules say PFL provides payments to someone who can't work because they're bonding with a new child. Disability pays the mother for her own recovery. Those are not the same benefit for the same person. The denial sounds like a system error.

0 coins

This is so confusing to navigate when you're already sleep deprived from a new baby, honestly. The fact that EDD's system could just flag this automatically with no explanation in plain language is so frustrating.

0 coins

My sister went through something similar and had to appeal too. The key on her appeal was being super specific that the two claimants are different people with different SDI accounts.

0 coins

Anna Xian

Author

Being specific about the separate accounts is a good tip, I'll make sure to put that in the appeal letter.

0 coins

Went back part time about six weeks into my bonding leave and had to report the intermittent days. The DE 2580GF came back and I wasn't sure I'd filled it out right. Called the PFL line for a week straight, nothing. Tried Claimyr and got an EDD agent on the phone who told me which of my reported days were showing as pending on her end and which had already processed.

0 coins

Tried that line every morning for a week myself and got the same result every time — recording, then nothing. Hard to believe anything actually gets through to a live person there.

0 coins

I had the same doubt, trust me. But the agent I spoke with could actually see my specific claim and the days I had reported. That's not something a recording does.

0 coins

another person here who actually got through? mine showed two weeks as pending with no update. found out from an agent that the DE 2580GF submission hadnt posted yet. relieved it wasnt something worse. the payment came on a Money Network debit card and I wanted to make sure the right one was on file.

0 coins

ive been redialing that number for three days straight, still nothing. glad to know getting through is at least possible

0 coins

The appeal window is 30 days from the date on that denial notice, not from when you got it in the mail, so she should check the date printed on the form itself. Miss that and it gets a lot harder to fix, lol.

0 coins

That is exactly right and worth repeating. The 30 days runs from the date printed on the Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination, which is the DE 2514. She should not wait on that.

0 coins

Anna Xian

Author

Pulling the notice out right now to find that date. Thank you for flagging this.

0 coins

I didn't even know they mailed a physical denial notice. I've been only checking SDI Online. Should I be watching the mail too on my own claim?

0 coins

Watch both. EDD mails notices and they also appear in SDI Online on the claim. If you're waiting on something important, check mail and the portal.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is genuinely one of the worst experiences I've had dealing with any government office. You call, you wait, the recording tells you to try again, and by afternoon it just hangs up. No path forward on that line.

0 coins

Mornings used to be slightly better but even that stopped working for me after a while.

0 coins

The line does what the line does. Not much to say about it.

0 coins

Used to try first thing every morning too. After about eight tries across two weeks I stopped expecting anything from it.

0 coins

Can I ask a dumb question — when she appeals, does she need to send anything with the appeal form or just submit the DE 1000A by itself? I want to make sure I understand in case I ever have to do this.

0 coins

Not a dumb question at all. The DE 1000A itself is the appeal, and she should include a written statement explaining why the denial is wrong. In this case, she'd want to clearly state that she is a separate claimant from her husband, that her disability claim covers her own postpartum recovery, and that his PFL bonding claim should not affect hers.

0 coins

Attaching copies of anything that shows the two claims are separate people — like her own SDI Online confirmation or the receipt number from her filing — would probably strengthen it.

0 coins

Anna Xian

Author

This is really helpful. I'm going to sit down tonight and help her write the statement before we mail anything.

0 coins

My cousin had an appeal situation with EDD a while back and what her rep told her was to be super literal in the written statement. Don't assume EDD knows the context. Spell out every detail like they've never seen the claim before.

0 coins

That tracks with what I've heard. Appeals that give specific dates, claim numbers, and the exact reason for disagreement tend to hold together better than ones that just say 'this is wrong.

0 coins

Pretend you're writing it for someone who knows nothing about your case. Because whoever reviews it might not.

0 coins

wait so she can still get the disability payments even though pfl was already paid to you? like it doesnt cancel out her weeks?

0 coins

Right. Her disability claim and your PFL bonding claim are separate. Each of you has your own claim, your own eligibility, your own benefit weeks. One doesn't consume the other.

0 coins

ok that makes way more sense than what i was imagining. thought it was like a family pool of weeks or something

0 coins

The 'pool of weeks' thing trips a lot of people up. The eight-week limit is per individual claim within a 12-month period, not per household. Each person filing has their own limit.

0 coins

A Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination came on my care claim after I'd already submitted everything, and I couldn't tell from reading it whether it was a denial or just an update. Tried reaching EDD directly but couldn't get a person. Used Claimyr to get through and talked to an agent who confirmed the DE 2514 on my claim was a denial and walked me through what specifically was missing.

0 coins

What's Claimyr? I keep seeing it mentioned and I don't know what it is.

0 coins

It waits on EDD's line for you so your phone rings when an agent picks up. That's really all it is. I'd been getting nowhere for days before I tried it.

0 coins

Huh, that's simpler than I expected. I have a question about my own claim's weekly benefit amount that I've been trying to get answered for two weeks now. Might be worth trying for that.

0 coins

For anyone confused about the timeline here: in a situation where a birth mother should file disability first for her postpartum recovery, and then separately file for PFL bonding later, the sequencing matters. If the PFL bonding claim goes in first and pays out before the disability claim is even filed, EDD's system can get confused about overlapping periods. That's likely what happened here.

0 coins

Anna Xian

Author

That's exactly the sequence that happened. I filed my PFL bonding right after the birth and she filed disability weeks later. Didn't know there was a right order to any of this.

0 coins

The mother's disability claim for pregnancy and recovery typically comes first, then she transitions to PFL bonding after recovery. Your bonding claim as the father runs parallel and shouldn't be affected. But if her disability claim came in after yours had already paid, EDD's system may need the appeal to sort it out.

0 coins

Nobody explains this order anywhere obvious. I had no idea either until reading this thread.

0 coins

EDD's site has some of this but it's buried. The SDI Online filing process doesn't exactly walk you through how two parents should coordinate their separate claims, lol.

0 coins

Part D on my care claim was submitted by my father's doctor online using the receipt number I gave the office. Two weeks later SDI Online still showed no certification received. Tried the EDD line most of that week with no luck. Went through Claimyr and spoke to an agent who confirmed Part D had come in but wasn't yet matched to my claim because the receipt number on the submission had a digit off.

0 coins

Receipt number digit off — that exact thing happened on my claim too! Used Claimyr and the agent confirmed the receipt number on file was correct after I read it to her. Huge relief because I had been convinced the whole filing was lost somewhere.

0 coins

How did you get the right number to give the agent? Did you go back to the original confirmation page in SDI Online?

0 coins

Yes, I went back into SDI Online and found the original confirmation. The receipt number is on that page. Had it in front of me when I called so the agent could verify it against what was in the system.

0 coins

Appeal is the move here but I'd also say don't expect it to be fast. These things can sit for a while before anyone looks at them.

0 coins

Accurate. File it, note the date you filed, then wait.

0 coins

Anna Xian

Author

Is there any way to check status on an appeal or does it just sit invisible until they contact you?

0 coins

EDD mails a notice once a decision is made on the appeal. Keep an eye on your wife's mail. She can also check SDI Online for any updates on the claim.

0 coins

Reading this whole situation is making me nervous about my own bonding claim. I'm a dad and I haven't filed yet, my wife is about five weeks out from her due date. Should I be worried about the same kind of overlap problem if she also files for disability?

0 coins

File yours after the baby arrives, no earlier than the first day you're actually home on leave. Her disability claim for the pregnancy goes in separately, also after the birth. Keep the two filings separate and document both. The issue in this thread came from the sequencing getting mixed up after the fact.

0 coins

So there's nothing inherently wrong with filing both at the same time, as long as they're separate claims filed separately by each of us?

0 coins

Separate claims by separate people is the key. EDD handles each one individually. The problem described here looks like a system mix-up after the fact, not a rule that says one blocks the other.

0 coins

Also worth saving your receipt number the moment you submit in SDI Online. That number is what ties any follow-up documents to your claim and you'll want it on hand.

0 coins

been dealing with a care claim for my mom for three weeks now and this thread is giving me anxiety about whether my Part D got matched right. i dont even know who to ask

0 coins

In SDI Online, open your claim and look at the status. If Part D shows as not received after your doctor submitted it, call EDD or send a Request Claim Update from inside SDI Online. Give the doctor's office your receipt number and confirm they used it when submitting.

0 coins

the receipt number tip is good, i honestly didnt think to ask if they used it. i gave the number to the office but never confirmed it made it onto the submission

0 coins

My wife had her appeal go through. Took about six weeks from when she mailed it. Just sharing so the person in this thread knows it can work out.

0 coins

Anna Xian

Author

That's genuinely good to hear. Six weeks is a long time but at least there's a resolution at the end of it.

0 coins

She kept notes on every date — when she filed, when she mailed the appeal, when the decision came. Made it easier to track.

0 coins

PFL not having a waiting period is something I had completely wrong in my head before I filed. I kept telling myself there were seven days at the start where nothing would pay out, like I'd read somewhere about disability. Had to unlearn that before I filed.

0 coins

That seven-day wait is Disability Insurance, not PFL. PFL doesn't have a benefit waiting period at all. Easy to mix up if you've been reading about both programs at the same time.

0 coins

Yes that was exactly it, I'd been reading about both and blurred them together. Good to know I had it straight by the time I actually filed.

0 coins

I made the same mistake! I thought I had to budget for the first week with nothing coming in. Finding out there's no wait on PFL was actually a relief.

0 coins

Curious whether the partner's PFL bonding claim and the mother's disability claim being filed in the right order actually matters to EDD's system, or if it's more about the dates overlapping regardless of who filed first.

0 coins

From what I understand it's the overlapping dates that trigger the flag, not the order of filing per se. But a birth mother filing disability first, then transitioning to PFL bonding after recovery, is the natural sequence EDD expects. When that order gets reversed or the disability claim comes in late, the system doesn't always handle it cleanly.

0 coins

That's also why the appeal statement should be specific about the dates and programs involved, not just general. EDD's reviewer needs to see exactly why the overlap isn't a double-payment situation.

0 coins

Anna Xian

Author

Writing all of this down to use in the appeal statement. Dates, program names, two separate claimants. Got it.

0 coins

One thing I'd double check before mailing the appeal — make sure she's signing the DE 1000A herself, not you signing on her behalf unless you're her authorized representative on the claim. EDD is picky about that.

0 coins

Correct. The appeal should come from her as the claimant on her disability claim. Her signature, her statement, mailed or submitted the way the form directs.

0 coins

Anna Xian

Author

Good catch. I was about to help her write it and just sign it myself without thinking twice about that.

0 coins

Has anyone tried sending a Request Claim Update through SDI Online instead of calling? I did that once when my claim sat pending and EDD responded through the portal within a few days with an actual explanation.

0 coins

Yes, that's the Request Claim Update option inside SDI Online. You pick your claim, choose the request type, write out your question. It's slower than a call but you get something in writing back.

0 coins

I used it twice. First time got a response in four days. Second time nothing for eleven days. Inconsistent but at least it's something when the phone line isn't cooperating.

0 coins

didnt know that existed. going to try it on my part d situation before i do anything else.

0 coins

ok so to summarize for people like me who got lost: dad files pfl bonding, mom files disability separately, they dont cancel each other out, and if edd messes it up you appeal within 30 days. did i get that right

0 coins

That's correct. Two separate claims, two separate people, neither one cancels the other. And 30 days from the date on the denial notice to appeal.

0 coins

Anna Xian

Author

Pretty much exactly the situation I'm in. Now going to get the appeal in before that 30-day clock runs out.

0 coins

Get the date off the notice first, then count. Don't guess from memory.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure