Paid family leave overpayment when employer pays full salary — did I do something wrong?
So I'm kind of panicking right now. I took PFL bonding leave starting in October for my daughter and filed my claim on SDI Online. EDD approved it and I've been getting weekly payments. The thing I didn't fully think through is that my employer actually kept paying me my full salary the whole time, their policy is just to do that for new parents. I didn't report any of this to EDD when I filed or after. Someone at work mentioned this week that I might have created an overpayment situation and now I'm spiraling a little. Is paid family leave overpayment when employer pays full salary actually a thing? Like did I do something wrong by not reporting wages? What happens now and what do I even do to fix it?
82 comments

Isabella Tucker
Your coworker is right to flag this. If your employer kept paying your full regular wages while EDD was also sending PFL payments, there is a potential overpayment because your combined wages plus PFL can't exceed your normal weekly pay. The key detail is whether your employer intended those payments to supplement PFL or run alongside it. That's something to sort out with your employer's HR first, then report to EDD.
0 coins
Emma Swift
AuthorSo it depends on how my employer set it up? I had no idea this was even a rule. I just assumed EDD and my employer paying me were two separate things.
0 coins
Isabella Tucker
They're separate systems but EDD's rules say wages and PFL together can't top your usual pay. HR can tell you whether the company meant those checks as a supplement or just their own policy on top of PFL.
0 coins
Emma Swift
AuthorHR literally never mentioned any of this to me. Going in tomorrow to ask.
0 coins
Jayden Hill
The rule as EDD writes it is that sick leave, vacation or paid time off can be combined with PFL, but wages plus PFL can't go above your normal weekly wages, not counting overtime. The way your employer frames those salary payments matters a lot here.
0 coins
LordCommander
Does that apply even if the employer doesn't have a formal supplemental plan, just a generous policy?
0 coins
Jayden Hill
Yes, the cap is on the combined amount regardless of what the employer calls the policy. If you end up over the weekly limit for even one week, that week could become an overpayment.
0 coins
LordCommander
That's honestly a really easy mistake to make if nobody tells you going in.
0 coins
Lucy Lam
My direct deposit never showed up after the second payment and I needed to know if EDD had my bank info right, so I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone on the line without spending my whole morning redialing. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the payment method EDD had on file was still the debit card from when I filed, even though I updated it in SDI Online. She told me to verify the update went through completely by checking payment info in myEDD. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM
0 coins
Aidan Hudson
Got a DE 2514 denial notice a few weeks back on my own bonding claim and tried Claimyr too. Actually ended up talking to an EDD agent who told me EDD had issued the denial because the proof of relationship document hadn't been matched to my claim yet even though I'd uploaded it. Glad I called when I did.
0 coins
Zoe Wang
Wait they found it unmatched even after you uploaded it? Did the agent say what to do next?
0 coins
Aidan Hudson
Yeah she said they could see the document on their end, it just hadn't been linked. She told me to watch for a new notice in the mail within a few days and to appeal within 30 days if I still disagreed with anything. It resolved on its own after that anyway.
0 coins
Emma Swift
AuthorKnowing there's a way to actually reach someone is kind of reassuring given how stressed I am about this overpayment question.
0 coins
Connor Richards
Talk to HR today, not tomorrow. If your company was paying you full salary as a supplement to PFL, that's one thing. If they were just paying you on top of it without coordinating, you've got an overpayment. EDD will figure it out eventually.
0 coins
Emma Swift
AuthorYeah I moved the HR meeting up to this afternoon after reading the first few replies here. I want to know exactly how they categorized those payments.
0 coins
Connor Richards
Good. Get it in writing if you can.
0 coins
Grace Durand
I tried getting EDD on the phone six mornings in a row about my own unrelated care claim issue. Six times I either got the busy signal loop or the system cut me off after ten minutes of hold music. The PFL line is brutal.
0 coins
Steven Adams
Five mornings here, same exact thing. The line just disconnects and there's no explanation. It's not like you did anything wrong, the line just can't handle the volume.
0 coins
Grace Durand
EDD's whole contact situation for PFL is basically designed to make you give up. I eventually sent a Request Claim Update through SDI Online and got an answer that way, took a few days but at least it went through.
0 coins
Alice Fleming
Request Claim Update got me nowhere. Waited a week and nothing.
0 coins
Hassan Khoury
From an admin perspective, the cleanest path here is to get a written confirmation from HR on how those salary payments were classified, then contact EDD proactively through SDI Online with a Request Claim Update explaining the situation. Waiting for EDD to find the overpayment themselves usually means a demand letter later.
0 coins
Emma Swift
AuthorSo it's better to self-report than to wait and see?
0 coins
Hassan Khoury
Yes. Proactive contact gives you more standing. EDD notes when a claimant came forward versus when they had to pursue it.
0 coins
Victoria Stark
October 1st through the end of my own leave I kept a week by week log of exactly what my employer paid and what EDD paid. Made reporting straightforward when my situation got complicated. Strongly recommend doing the same going back to whenever your leave started.
0 coins
Benjamin Kim
my job paid me full during leave and i just reported all my wages to edd each week. never had a problem. but i also wasnt getting full salary AND pfl at the same time so maybe different situation
0 coins
LordCommander
Reporting wages as you go is exactly right. The issue here is wages weren't reported, which is the part that creates the overpayment exposure.
0 coins
Benjamin Kim
oh yeah if nobody reported anything that makes more sense why theyre worried
0 coins
Samantha Howard
There's an appeal process if EDD does issue an overpayment notice. The Appeal Form is the DE 1000A and you have 30 days from the date on the notice to file it, online or by mail. Don't let that window slip by while you're sorting out the HR side.
0 coins
Emma Swift
AuthorI didn't know there was a 30-day window on that. I'll keep the appeal option in mind even though I'm hoping to resolve this before it gets to that point.
0 coins
Isabella Tucker
The 30 days runs from the date printed on the overpayment notice, not from when you receive it. Mail can cost you a few days so if you get one, file the appeal right away.
0 coins
Zoe Wang
Is the appeal online or does it have to be mailed in?
0 coins
Samantha Howard
Either way works. The DE 1000A can be filed online or sent by mail to the address on the notice itself.
0 coins
Megan D'Acosta
Couldn't find the receipt number from my original PFL filing anywhere in my email and needed it to give to my wife's doctor for Part D. Tried Claimyr and had a live EDD agent pull it up for me in about one conversation. Way less painful than I expected from that phone line.
0 coins
Sarah Ali
Reads to me like a sponsored comment dressed up as experience. I've heard this before about various services and it usually turns out to be noise.
0 coins
Ryan Vasquez
I actually thought the same thing the first time I saw someone mention it! But then Part D for my mom's care claim had been with the doctor for two weeks and I couldn't get confirmation EDD received it, so I tried it and spoke with an actual EDD agent. She confirmed EDD had no Part D on file yet and told me my doctor needed to resubmit using the receipt number. That was real and it helped.
0 coins
Sarah Ali
Alright. If it gets an actual EDD employee on the line I might give it a go. My care claim has been sitting in a weird state for nine days.
0 coins
Emma Swift
AuthorNine days with no update sounds rough. Hope you get a clear answer soon.
0 coins
Avery Saint
You reported zero wages this whole time?
0 coins
Emma Swift
AuthorZero. I didn't know I was supposed to. My employer just kept depositing my salary and EDD kept depositing payments and I didn't connect the dots that there was anything to report.
0 coins
Avery Saint
That's the whole problem right there. Any wages during PFL have to go to EDD. All of them.
0 coins
Connor Richards
Yeah EDD makes it clear in the forms but it's easy to miss if nobody explains it at the start.
0 coins
Zoe Wang
So wait, does the same rule apply if my employer is using my accrued vacation to pay me during leave? I'm about to file a PFL bonding claim and my company is planning to run my vacation balance down while I'm out. Is that also an overpayment issue?
0 coins
Jayden Hill
Vacation pay used while you're on leave counts as wages for this purpose. Combined, your PFL payment plus whatever your employer pays can't top your normal weekly wages. If they're only paying you a portion of your regular pay from vacation, you may be fine. If it pushes you above your normal weekly amount, that's where overpayment risk comes in.
0 coins
Zoe Wang
Okay so I need to report the vacation payouts to EDD each week I receive them? Even if it's just a partial week of vacation?
0 coins
Jayden Hill
Yes, any wages need to be reported. The Continued Claim Certification EDD sends you is where you report what you earned during each period.
0 coins
Zoe Wang
Thank you, this is exactly the scenario I was about to walk into without knowing.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
been dealing with edd overpayment notices before and they dont just go away on their own. they add up fast if youre talking multiple weeks of full salary plus pfl payments running together.
0 coins
Emma Swift
AuthorHow did you deal with yours when it happened?
0 coins
Taylor Chen
I appealed within the 30 days. Filed the DE 1000A and explained the situation. EDD mailed a notice after that with their decision.
0 coins
Emma Swift
AuthorThat's good to know there's a path through it even after the fact.
0 coins
Steven Adams
My employer has the same generous policy as yours. When I asked HR, they said the company considers it supplemental, meaning they top up whatever PFL doesn't pay. So if PFL covered 70 percent, they'd pay the other 30. That way the total doesn't go over regular wages. Might be worth seeing if your company set it up that way.
0 coins
Emma Swift
AuthorThat's exactly the type of thing I'm hoping HR tells me today. If it was always structured as a supplement and the total never went above my regular pay, maybe this isn't as bad as I feared.
0 coins
Steven Adams
Could be you're totally fine. Some employers coordinate this really carefully. Others just pay full salary without thinking about PFL interactions and that's where problems come in. HR should know which kind yours is.
0 coins
Lucy Lam
If the total never exceeded your normal weekly wages, there wouldn't be an overpayment to report at all. The rule is about the ceiling, not about receiving money from two sources.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
Not reporting wages during PFL can lead to an overpayment, but the size of it depends on how many weeks this covered and what your weekly benefit amount was. Find out from HR, then lay it out week by week.
0 coins
Victoria Stark
December 3rd I did exactly that for my own claim. Went back week by week and documented the overlap. It made the Request Claim Update I sent much clearer and EDD responded faster than I expected.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
That's the right approach. Clear and organized beats vague every time with EDD.
0 coins
Samantha Howard
My Notice of Computation came in the mail during the first week of leave and I had no idea what the weekly benefit amount it showed actually meant in terms of my paycheck, so I used Claimyr to get through to someone on the PFL line. The agent confirmed the amount on the DE 429DF was my potential weekly benefit based on my base period wages and told me it wasn't a guarantee of approval, just what I'd receive if I qualified. Helped me plan the month out.
0 coins
Jayden Hill
Did the agent break down how that figure was calculated from the base period, or just confirm the number?
0 coins
Samantha Howard
Just confirmed the figure and said the actual calculation is based on the highest quarter of wages in the 12-month base period. She didn't go further than that, pointed me to the calculator on EDD's site for an estimate before filing.
0 coins
Alice Fleming
Two weeks now trying that line. Calling right at eight in the morning and still nothing.
0 coins
LordCommander
For anyone wondering about the appeal: the DE 1000A is the form and the 30-day clock starts from the date on the overpayment notice. If you get a notice and disagree with it, don't wait to see if something resolves on its own. That window moves fast.
0 coins
Zoe Wang
Is the 30 days calendar days or business days?
0 coins
LordCommander
Calendar days based on the date printed on the notice. That's why filing as soon as you get it is the safer move.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
Learned that the hard way. Counted from when I got the notice in the mail and was almost two days short by the time I filed.
0 coins
Sarah Ali
If EDD already sent payments and you weren't reporting wages, they can recoup the overpayment. No amount of hoping resolves it. Contact them through SDI Online or on the phone before they issue a formal notice.
0 coins
Emma Swift
AuthorI sent a Request Claim Update in SDI Online about an hour ago explaining the situation and what I found out from HR, that the company intended the payments as supplements and the total never went above my regular weekly wages. So at least EDD knows I'm aware of it now.
0 coins
Sarah Ali
That was the right move.
0 coins
Connor Richards
Good. Keep a copy of what you wrote in that update.
0 coins
Ryan Vasquez
Had a scare like this with my own bonding claim last spring when my job threw in a bonus the first week I was out. Called EDD and the agent said to report the bonus amount that week only and that one over-limit week would be adjusted, not the whole claim. Turned out fine after that one correction.
0 coins
Emma Swift
AuthorThat's actually encouraging. So it doesn't necessarily blow up the whole claim if only a week or two were affected?
0 coins
Ryan Vasquez
In my case it was just that one week and they adjusted it cleanly. But I reported it right away, that probably helped.
0 coins
Isabella Tucker
Reporting promptly before EDD catches it on their end makes a real difference in how the adjustment gets handled.
0 coins
Aidan Hudson
my employer has the same thing and nobody told me either when i first went on leave. the HR packet was about fifty pages and the sentence about edd coordination was buried on page forty-something. so youre definitely not alone in missing it
0 coins
Emma Swift
AuthorHonestly that makes me feel a little less foolish about all of this. It really wasn't front and center anywhere.
0 coins
Aidan Hudson
nah it wasnt obvious at all. the fact that pfl and employer pay interact like this should be like the first page of the HR packet not page forty. anyway i hope the HR conversation goes well for you today.
0 coins
Steven Adams
The coordination stuff really should be explained before leave starts. So many people find out about it like this.
0 coins
Victoria Stark
November 7th, two weeks into my own leave: I went back and built a spreadsheet showing each week's EDD payment amount, what my employer deposited, and what my normal weekly pay was. Seeing the numbers side by side made it clear which weeks, if any, went over the cap. Worth doing that before you even contact EDD so you know what you're dealing with.
0 coins
Emma Swift
AuthorHR confirmed today that the payments were structured as a true supplement, meaning they topped up whatever PFL didn't cover. A few weeks they may have added more than they should have. Building the spreadsheet you're describing is exactly what I need to do next.
0 coins
Victoria Stark
If it turns out the total was over in two or three weeks, you're not looking at a catastrophic overpayment. The week-by-week breakdown will tell you the actual exposure.
0 coins
Hassan Khoury
Having that documentation ready before EDD responds to your claim update is smart. If they come back with an overpayment amount, you can verify it matches your own records.
0 coins
Emma Swift
AuthorI really appreciate everyone here. Going to get the spreadsheet built tonight and have it ready when EDD responds.
0 coins