Back to California Paid Family Leave

Mei Chen

Paid family leave overpayment notice after being declared father of child — what do I do now?

So this is a stressful one. I filed a PFL bonding claim back in the spring when my son was born, uploaded the birth certificate as proof of relationship, everything seemed fine, payments came in. Then a few months later there was a paternity dispute that went through the courts and I was legally declared the father — which I always was, but now there's an official declaration. EDD sent an overpayment notice and I genuinely don't understand why. I was the dad the whole time, I bonded with my kid, I uploaded the documents. Has anyone dealt with PFL and an overpayment notice when the paternity situation got complicated like this? I want to appeal but I don't even know where to start anyway.

Thirty days is what you have to appeal from the date on that notice, so that clock matters more than anything right now. The form you want is the DE 1000A, and you can file it online or mail it. Make sure you hold onto every document you have showing when your leave actually started and what proof of relationship you submitted. Interestingly, my own bonding claim ran into some scheduling questions around going back part-time. The return to part-time, two mornings a week at my old school, never got properly reported and EDD sent the DE 2580GF to certify those days. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to someone on the PFL line about it rather than keep guessing. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed which weeks were still showing as pending because of those unreported days, and walked me through what the DE 2580GF needed. So your situation is different but calling in and getting a real person to look at your specific overpayment notice seems like the right move before the 30 days run out.

0 coins

Direct deposit was the detail I had to sort out on my bonding claim too, and I went to Claimyr the same way. The agent confirmed my payment method was still set to debit card even though I'd chosen direct deposit in SDI Online, which explained why my first payment was delayed. After that I updated it and the next payment came through. Honestly the 30-day window is what I'd focus on first if I were facing an overpayment notice.

0 coins

been trying that phone line for three mornings straight, all i get is the recording then it hangs up. how do you even get someone to actually pick up

0 coins

that was exactly my situation before i used what's mentioned above, three days of that same recording. once i actually got through the call itself was pretty short, agent had everything right there

0 coins

The overpayment notice should say the reason for it. What did yours actually say? Because 'overpayment' can mean EDD thinks you weren't eligible, or it can mean there was a wage reporting issue, or sometimes it's a system thing that gets corrected on appeal. The reason matters a lot for how you write your appeal.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Mine says something about eligibility determination, which is what's confusing me. I was clearly bonding with my son, I have everything showing that. The court declaration came after I'd already been paid, so I think EDD got confused about the timeline.

0 coins

If the notice says eligibility, the DE 1000A is still what you file. EDD's site says you have 30 days from the date on the notice. Write out the timeline clearly in your appeal, include the dates your leave started, when you filed, what proof of relationship you submitted, and when the court proceeding happened. The sequence of events is going to matter.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

The timeline is actually really clear on my end so that helps. Filed in April, bonding started the day my son came home, uploaded the birth certificate. The court stuff didn't start until two months into the leave.

0 coins

Don't miss that 30-day deadline. Send the appeal in certified mail if you're doing it on paper so you have proof it went out.

0 coins

The certified mail point is a good one. I've heard of appeals getting lost and having no way to prove they were mailed on time. Even the online version gives you a confirmation you can screenshot.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Filing online makes more sense at this point, easier to have a record of it.

0 coins

Wait, I'm confused about something. Does EDD require the father's name to already be on the birth certificate when you file? Or is a Declaration of Paternity enough? Because my husband is on the birth certificate but I keep reading about the CS-909 form and I don't know if we needed that too.

0 coins

For a bonding claim the proof of relationship options are the birth certificate, a Declaration of Paternity which is the CS-909, a foster care agency letter, or an Adoptive Placement Agreement. Any one of those works, you don't need more than one.

0 coins

Oh that's a relief. We just submitted the birth certificate and I was worried we were supposed to also do the CS-909 on top of it. Thank you.

0 coins

The birth certificate alone is sufficient if the father is listed. The CS-909 is for cases where the father isn't on the birth certificate yet. EDD doesn't ask for both.

0 coins

EDD sending an overpayment notice when you clearly had a valid claim is so typical. They'll claw back money first and sort it out later. Appeal it, give them every document you have, and don't assume the notice is accurate just because they sent it.

0 coins

Overpayment notices can be appealed and sometimes overturned. Worth doing.

0 coins

Yep. File the appeal. Don't pay anything until you get a decision.

0 coins

My bonding claim got a denial notice last month, a DE 2514, and I honestly didn't know what to do. The letter said something about proof of relationship but I had uploaded the birth certificate when I filed. I tried calling the PFL line probably six or seven times over two weeks and either got a busy signal or the system cut me off. Eventually I tried Claimyr to get an agent on the line about the DE 2514. The agent looked at my claim and told me the birth certificate file had been received but wasn't matched to my claim ID yet, it was sitting unattached. Knowing that actually let me write a specific appeal explaining what happened rather than just saying 'I sent it.

0 coins

Not sure I buy that a file just floats there unattached to your claim. That sounds like something went wrong on EDD's end. How do you even know the agent was seeing your actual record and not giving you a generic answer?

0 coins

I had the same doubt, honestly. But the agent read back my receipt number, the date the file was uploaded, and the file name, so they were definitely looking at my claim. And my appeal did go through after I explained exactly what happened.

0 coins

ive had the same thing happen, the document was there but nothing connected it. the agent told me my receipt number and what was showing on my claim and that was it, and yeah that helped me write the appeal too

0 coins

Can I ask something that might be obvious — when you get an overpayment notice does EDD automatically stop any remaining payments, or can you keep getting paid while the appeal is going?

0 coins

That's genuinely worth checking directly with EDD because the answer can depend on what the notice says. Some overpayment situations pause future payments, others don't. The notice itself usually explains what's on hold.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Mine didn't say anything about stopping future payments but I only had a couple of weeks left in my claim so I'm not sure it matters at this point.

0 coins

The appeal process and any ongoing payments are kind of separate tracks. You can be appealing and still have weeks that haven't been paid yet, but it really does depend on what EDD flagged. Reading the notice carefully is so important!

0 coins

That 30-day clock on the appeal is real. I've seen people wait thinking they had more time and then they're stuck. File first, sort out the details in the actual appeal.

0 coins

Agreed. The appeal doesn't have to be perfect on day one. File it to stop the clock, then supplement with documentation if needed.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Filing it today actually. Pulling everything together now.

0 coins

I've been on the PFL line since my fostering placement went through and I need to know if EDD got my placement letter. Three calls, nothing. What is Claimyr that someone mentioned up there?

0 coins

You stay in your day while it handles holding with EDD, and your phone rings when a live agent picks up. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

Oh that's actually useful. I'd want to ask whether EDD has the foster care agency letter on my claim, that's what's been holding me up.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Proof of relationship on a bonding claim is exactly the kind of thing worth confirming directly. Hope your placement goes smoothly.

0 coins

Proof of relationship on my bonding claim took almost two weeks to show as matched. The file was there but EDD's side of it was slow. I used Claimyr to ask an agent to confirm the document was received and attached to my claim. The agent found the placement letter had been received four days earlier but not yet matched to the claim, and told me it was in process. That was enough to stop me from filing a duplicate.

0 coins

Wait so they can see exactly when it came in? That's actually really helpful to know.

0 coins

The agent gave me the date it was received and the status. That was all I needed.

0 coins

Filing a duplicate is a bad idea anyway, EDD's site says don't submit the same claim twice. Calling to confirm the status is the right move.

0 coins

41 days after the leave start date is the outer limit for filing a bonding claim without losing benefits. That's worth knowing for anyone still in the process. After that EDD won't back-pay the days you missed.

0 coins

I filed on day 38 and I was sweating the whole time. Made it though and everything processed.

0 coins

I didn't know there was a hard cutoff. I thought you just filed whenever and they'd figure it out. Good to know that's wrong.

0 coins

The 41-day rule is EDD's own language. After that you can still file but you lose the days before you filed.

0 coins

wait does pfl have a waiting week before payments start? i thought bonding had like a 7 day gap before you see anything

0 coins

PFL doesn't have a waiting period. That's disability insurance, which is a separate program. Bonding benefits start from day one of leave, no unpaid waiting week.

0 coins

oh wow i had that completely backwards, i was telling my coworker he'd have to wait a week. glad someone said something

0 coins

Easy thing to mix up since disability and PFL are both under SDI. But yeah, PFL is the one without the wait.

0 coins

For the appeal itself, attach everything chronologically. Date you started leave, date you filed, what proof of relationship you submitted and when, the date the court proceeding started, the date of the overpayment notice. Make the sequence impossible to misread.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

This is exactly how I'm laying it out. The dates tell the whole story — the paternity question came up two months after I was already into my claim.

0 coins

A clear timeline in an appeal is genuinely the most useful thing. EDD reviewers aren't reading deeply, they're scanning for whether your facts match their records.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation came for my claim before I even had a decision on eligibility and I completely panicked thinking it meant something was wrong! It just shows the weekly benefit amount, it's not an approval or a denial. Took me a few days to figure that out!

0 coins

Mine came on day four and I also thought it meant something was decided. It really doesn't, it's just the amount calculation.

0 coins

The DE 429DF is the Notice of Computation and it's just the potential weekly amount based on your base period wages. The actual eligibility decision comes separately.

0 coins

Overpayment notices go out automatically when EDD's system flags something. It doesn't mean a human reviewed your claim and decided you owe money. The appeal process is where a human actually looks at it.

0 coins

This is the thing people don't realize. The notice is generated by the system, not by someone reading your file. That's why appeals exist.

0 coins

File the appeal and make them look at it properly. Nine times out of ten there's more to the story than what triggered the flag.

0 coins

Is PFL the same as CFRA? My coworker told me bonding leave protects my job and I'm not sure if she means PFL or something else.

0 coins

PFL pays benefits but doesn't protect the job. The job protection piece, if it applies, comes from CFRA or FMLA. Those are separate laws with their own rules. EDD's own language on this is that PFL provides benefit payments but not job protection.

0 coins

Oh that's a really important distinction. So I could be getting PFL payments and still not be guaranteed my job back?

0 coins

Whether CFRA covers your situation is between you and your employer. For the job protection question, HR is the right person to ask.

0 coins

The Electronic Benefit Payment Notification, the DE 2500E, is the one that comes out when the first payment is actually issued. If you got that one, you were paid. If the dispute is about payments you already received showing up as an overpayment, that's worth spelling out in your appeal.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

I did get the DE 2500E at the start, yes. All the payments came through before the court stuff started, so the timeline is clear.

0 coins

Include that in the appeal. If the DE 2500E predates the court proceeding, that sequence is your argument.

0 coins

EDD overpayment notices have been wrong before. Appeal it. You were the dad before the court said so, the court just confirmed it. That's what the appeal is for.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Exactly my read on it. The declaration didn't create paternity, it confirmed what was already the case.

0 coins

Put that in writing in the appeal. Exactly that logic.

0 coins

does appealing stop them from sending you to collections or whatever while its pending

0 coins

The overpayment notice itself has the information about what happens during an appeal. Reading the notice carefully is the first step, and the appeal form DE 1000A is where you officially contest it. What happens to collection activity during that period is in the notice.

0 coins

ok gonna read mine more carefully then

0 coins

How did the appeal go? Did you file it yet?

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Filed it online this afternoon. Uploaded the birth certificate, the original filing confirmation from SDI Online, and a written timeline of everything. Now waiting to see what they say.

0 coins

That's a solid submission. The written timeline especially, it makes it easy for whoever reviews it to follow the sequence without having to piece it together themselves.

0 coins

The 30 days feels tight but you made it. Hope the review goes the right way.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure