Back to California Paid Family Leave

Micah Franklin

Paid family leave denied not bonding during this period — how to appeal, father here

So I got hit with a denial last week and I'm honestly still kind of stunned. I'm the dad, took time off when our daughter was born in August, filed my PFL bonding claim through SDI Online and uploaded her birth certificate as my proof of relationship. Everything seemed fine and then the Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination came in the mail saying I wasn't bonding during this period. I was absolutely home with her the whole time, didn't go back to work until October. I have no idea what that means or how they made that determination. The appeal form was in the envelope, DE 1000A, but I'm not sure what I'm supposed to write or how strong my case is. Has anyone appealed a denial like this? Do I just explain that I was home with her and attach anything showing that? I have 30 days from the notice date and I'm already 8 days in so I need to move on this.

DE 2514 came to me with almost the same language on my bonding claim last spring. Spent three days trying to reach EDD before I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and ended up talking to an agent the same morning. She pulled up my DE 2514 and read me exactly which eligibility condition triggered it. Turned out the base period wages EDD had on file were from an employer who had filed their payroll late, so the system read me as ineligible. I hadn't touched anything wrong. That call told me exactly what to put in my appeal. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? I've been staring at that denial notice for days and can't get through the phone line at all.

0 coins

You dial in and it handles the hold for you, then your phone rings when an EDD agent picks up. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

Got it. I'd want to ask why mine says the proof of relationship wasn't received when I uploaded the birth certificate the day I filed.

0 coins

This is basically my situation too. What did you say to the agent once you had her? Like did you just read the denial code back or something?

0 coins

Gave her my claim ID and asked her to read the reason on the DE 2514. She did. That was enough to know what the appeal needed to say.

0 coins

Filing a bonding appeal as a father is completely doable. The DE 1000A just needs you to state clearly that you were on leave bonding with your child during the dates on the denial, and that the birth certificate was submitted as your proof of relationship. Keep it factual. Attach a copy of the birth certificate if you have one handy, and anything from your employer showing your leave dates if you can get it quickly. EDD's appeals office does look at this.

0 coins

Is there a specific section on the DE 1000A for attaching documents or do you just include them loose?

0 coins

You include them with the form when you mail it. Write your name and claim ID on each page so nothing gets separated.

0 coins

Does the employer letter need to be on official letterhead or will an email from HR work? I'm trying to get mine together fast too.

0 coins

EDD denying bonding claims on dads is infuriating. I got a denial once because they said my leave dates overlapped with my wife's pregnancy disability claim, which made zero sense because those are totally separate claims. I appealed and it got reversed. The system just flags things and sends denials without anyone checking the actual facts.

0 coins

How long did your appeal take to get a decision?

0 coins

About six weeks from when they received my appeal to when I got the reversal letter. Longer than I wanted but it worked.

0 coins

Six weeks sounds about right from what I've seen. Not fast but it moves.

0 coins

The 30-day clock to appeal runs from the date on the DE 2514, not the day you received it, so if you're already 8 days in you need to move fast. The appeal form is the DE 1000A. EDD's site says you can file it online or by mail. For a bonding denial specifically, the most important things to address are the leave dates and the proof of relationship you submitted.

0 coins

Wait, from the date on the notice, not the day I got it? Mine took about four days to arrive in the mail, so I actually have less time than I thought.

0 coins

Yes, the date printed on the notice is what matters. Get that DE 1000A in as soon as you can.

0 coins

I didn't realize it was the date on the notice either. I thought it was when you received it. Good to know, that changes my timeline too.

0 coins

My brother went through almost this exact thing after his son was born. He called EDD and the agent told him the denial came because the birth certificate upload didn't attach to his claim properly even though SDI Online showed it as uploaded. He had to resubmit through SDI Online AND appeal at the same time. Both.

0 coins

So you can appeal and still fix the underlying document issue at the same time? I wasn't sure if appealing meant I had to wait for that outcome first.

0 coins

That's what his agent told him. Do both, don't wait. The appeal protects your timeline and the document fix addresses the actual problem.

0 coins

That tracks. The appeal is just preserving your right to dispute the decision. It doesn't prevent you from also correcting a document issue on the claim side.

0 coins

Fill out the DE 1000A and get it postmarked before that 30 days is up. Keep your copy. Send it certified so you have proof it went. That's all you can do from your end right now.

0 coins

Certified mail, got it. Should I write anything special in the appeal statement or keep it short?

0 coins

Short and factual. What dates you were home, that you were bonding with your daughter, that the birth certificate was submitted. No extras.

0 coins

This is the right call. Don't overthink the statement. Facts only.

0 coins

Birth certificate upload confirmation was sitting in my SDI Online claim and EDD still marked the proof of relationship as not received. I called through Claimyr and the agent could see that the document had been uploaded but wasn't yet matched to my claim, which apparently can happen in the first couple weeks. She noted it on the claim while I was on the phone. Everything moved after that. Claimyr's how I finally got an actual person on that line after trying for four mornings straight.

0 coins

Used Claimyr myself for a different question on my husband's care claim. When I got through, the agent confirmed the receipt number had been logged and that Part D was linked to it. Getting that confirmation from someone who could actually see the claim was the only way I stopped worrying about it. Did your agent say anything about how long the matching usually takes once it's in the system?

0 coins

She just said it was noted on the claim and to watch SDI Online over the next few days. Didn't give a timeframe but things updated within the week.

0 coins

So the document can show as uploaded on your end but EDD's side hasn't connected it yet? That would explain a lot of denials that seem to come out of nowhere.

0 coins

Exactly what the agent said. The upload confirmation in SDI Online just means it arrived, not that it's been linked to your specific claim yet.

0 coins

Can I ask something that might be dumb. If EDD denied it saying you weren't bonding during this period, does that mean they think you were working? Or that they just didn't have proof you were home? I'm trying to understand what the denial code actually means because I'm worried something similar might happen with my claim.

0 coins

Those denials can mean a few different things. Sometimes it's a wage or base period issue, sometimes a document that didn't link to the claim. The only way to know which one is to either call EDD or read the DE 2514 carefully. It usually has a code that tells you the specific reason.

0 coins

Mine says something about the period of leave not being established. Does that mean the dates I listed weren't accepted?

0 coins

That phrasing usually points to a leave start date question. When you filed, did you enter the first day you were off work as the start of your leave? That date matters a lot.

0 coins

i thought dads had to wait for their partner's disability claim to close before filing bonding lol. is that not right?

0 coins

Bonding and a birth mother's pregnancy disability are separate programs. The birth mother files her disability claim and then moves to bonding after. A father files his own bonding claim on his own timeline. There's no waiting required.

0 coins

oh ok that makes way more sense. i was totally confused about that.

0 coins

I actually had the same confusion when I first filed. They really are completely different claims and EDD processes them separately.

0 coins

The appeal statement doesn't need to be long. State your name, claim ID, the denial date, and two to three sentences: you were on approved leave from date X to date Y bonding with your daughter, her birth certificate was submitted on date Z as proof of relationship. That's your whole argument. Attach the birth certificate copy.

0 coins

This is exactly what I needed. I kept trying to figure out how to structure it and was overthinking every sentence.

0 coins

Keep it clean. The appeals office has your file. They just need your statement to know what you're disputing and why.

0 coins

edd denied my bonding claim too and i appealed it and won. just be real specific about your dates in the appeal form dont leave anything vague

0 coins

How long from your denial date to when you filed the appeal?

0 coins

like 10 days. filed it online. pretty fast once i sat down and did it

0 coins

I'm in a similar spot but my denial came even faster than yours, like two weeks after I filed. I've been scared to appeal because I'm not sure if I'm missing something in my claim that I should fix first before the appeal makes things worse. Can you even do both at the same time?

0 coins

Filing the appeal doesn't lock anything on the claim itself. You can appeal and still work on correcting any document or information issue at the same time. The appeal just preserves your right to dispute the denial.

0 coins

That actually makes me feel a lot better. I thought appealing meant admitting the claim was final.

0 coins

Definitely do both. Missing that 30-day window and not appealing is the bigger risk. You can sort the rest out while the appeal is in process.

0 coins

Submit the appeal before anything else. Missing the deadline is the one thing that can't be undone.

0 coins

Heard. Filing it this afternoon.

0 coins

Agree. Everything else can be sorted after, but not the deadline.

0 coins

Second payment on my bonding claim never posted when it was supposed to and SDI Online just showed pending with no update for over a week. Used Claimyr to reach EDD and the agent pulled up my claim and told me the exact date the payment had been issued and that it was on its way to my debit card. Turned out there was a one-day overlap in the reporting period that the system had flagged, nothing I had done wrong. Agent said it would clear and it did.

0 coins

Sounds like marketing for that service if you ask me. Hard to believe you just get a live person that easy when the rest of us can't get through at all.

0 coins

thought the same thing honestly until i had to try it for a question about my notice of computation. agent looked at my claim and read me the weekly amount and the base period quarters they used to get there. that was the number on my DE 429DF. wasnt what i expected but it was real.

0 coins

alright. might give it a shot then. been trying that line every morning for two weeks.

0 coins

The agent I spoke with was EDD, same as any other call. What she told me about the payment date matched what posted two days later.

0 coins

Can I ask what happens if the 30 days passes and you didn't know? Is it completely over or is there any way to still appeal late?

0 coins

EDD's rules say 30 days from the date on the notice. Missing it generally closes the appeal. That's why everyone here is saying to file it now, even imperfectly, because you can add information later but you can't re-open a missed window.

0 coins

That's scary. I had no idea the window was that strict.

0 coins

Same, I didn't realize how firm that deadline was until I read the form closely. 30 days felt long until I started doing the math.

0 coins

The thing that makes bonding denials for dads extra frustrating is that the proof of relationship requirements are clear, you upload the birth certificate, and then EDD still manages to lose it or not connect it. And then you're the one scrambling to appeal within 30 days over a document you already submitted.

0 coins

Exactly. Document was there. System didn't link it. Dad gets a denial. Makes no sense.

0 coins

This is basically what I think happened. The upload showed as complete on my end but maybe EDD's side didn't process it right.

0 coins

Filing the DE 1000A online took me maybe 15 minutes once I had my claim ID and the denial date in front of me. Easier than I expected. If you go through myEDD it walks you through it.

0 coins

Is the online version the same form or is it different from the paper one?

0 coins

Same appeal, just submitted digitally. You enter your statement in a text box. I found it faster than printing and mailing.

0 coins

Did you get any confirmation that EDD received it when you submitted online?

0 coins

Worth knowing that PFL doesn't protect your job on its own. The benefit payments and any job protection come from two different places. For the job side, that falls under CFRA or FMLA depending on your employer. PFL is just the wage replacement piece. I see this come up a lot with dads who think the PFL claim also locks in their job return rights.

0 coins

I'm already back at work so the job piece isn't the issue for me, but good to know that for anyone reading this who isn't yet.

0 coins

I didn't realize those were separate. I thought filing PFL automatically covered both. I need to look at my CFRA situation with my employer separately then?

0 coins

Yes, CFRA is your employer's territory, not EDD's. EDD handles the PFL payment side, your employer handles the leave protection side under CFRA. HR is the right place to ask about that.

0 coins

been sitting on a denial for 11 days and keep putting off the appeal because it's overwhelming. this thread finally got me to just fill it out tonight.

0 coins

Good. Get it in. That's the only move right now.

0 coins

submitted it online about an hour ago. have my confirmation number. now i wait i guess.

0 coins

Good. I'm doing mine this afternoon so we're in the same boat now.

0 coins

If your appeal does go through and gets reversed, the benefits for the original approved period should still pay out from the original claim start date. The reversal doesn't restart the clock or the 12-month window. Just keep that in mind for the bonding timeline.

0 coins

So if I win the appeal the payments would cover the period I was actually home in August and September, not from whenever the appeal is decided?

0 coins

That's how it works. The appeal outcome applies back to the original claim dates, not forward from the appeal decision date.

0 coins

Correct. The 12-month window for bonding runs from the birth, not from the appeal date, so you'd still be using the same window.

0 coins

EDD gets these wrong. Appeal it. You have the birth certificate, you have leave dates from your employer, that's your case. Don't second-guess it.

0 coins

Appreciate the directness. I've been going back and forth wondering if I'm missing something obvious but I think I'm just overthinking it.

0 coins

You're not missing anything. File it and let the appeals office look at the actual documents.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure