Back to California Paid Family Leave

Miguel Silva

PFL surgeon won't sign certification for spouse caregiver — can another doctor sign?

My husband had a serious operation about three weeks ago and I've been home caring for him full time since then. I filed my PFL care claim through SDI Online and got my receipt number, sent Part C, and gave the doctor's office the receipt number for Part D. The problem is his surgeon's office keeps telling me they're 'too busy' to fill out the certification and they've been saying that for two weeks now. Someone at his follow-up appointment suggested his primary care doctor might be able to do it instead since she's been managing his recovery, but I'm not sure if EDD will accept it from a different doctor. I really can't lose much more time on this — I know the 41-day deadline is a thing and I'm already past week three. Can Part D actually come from a doctor other than the one who did the surgery?

Two payments posted and then went quiet, so I had to figure out which weeks EDD had actually paid and when the next one was coming. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me to a live agent after I'd spent four mornings getting the recorded message. The agent pulled up my care claim and told me weeks one and two were issued, week three was pending, and the next payment would go out once it cleared. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

Reads like marketing to me, honestly. I've submitted three Request Claim Updates through SDI Online about my own claim and gotten no movement, so I'm not convinced any path actually reaches a live person at EDD.

0 coins

Felt the same way in September. Tried it anyway on a Thursday after my care claim payment was three days overdue. The agent confirmed week four had been issued on the 11th and that six weeks were still available in my 12-month window. It was a real EDD employee, not an automated thing.

0 coins

Six weeks still showing as available is actually useful to know an agent can confirm. I'll give it a shot.

0 coins

Part D just needs a licensed physician or practitioner who can certify the serious medical condition. It doesn't have to be the surgeon. The primary care doctor managing his recovery is fine, as long as she can attest to the nature of the illness and that you're needed as the caregiver.

0 coins

That's a relief. His PCP has seen him every week since he came home so she definitely knows his condition. I'll ask her office first thing tomorrow.

0 coins

My mom's specialist was completely useless about the form too, honestly. Her regular doctor ended up being the one who sent in Part D and EDD accepted it no problem. So yes, the PCP route works.

0 coins

Not sure if this matters, but does the doctor who signs Part D need to have treated the patient for a certain amount of time? Or can it literally be any doctor who's seen him at least once?

0 coins

EDD's requirement is that the physician can certify the serious health condition. No minimum number of visits is stated. A doctor who has examined and is familiar with the patient's condition can sign it.

0 coins

Worth flagging on the 41-day deadline: that clock starts on the first day you took leave, not the day you filed or the day the surgeon first stalled. If you started caring for your husband right after the surgery three weeks ago, you have roughly 20 days left to get Part D to EDD.

0 coins

Three weeks ago Tuesday was my first day home with him. So I'm counting about 18 or 19 days left. That's tighter than I thought.

0 coins

Don't wait on that surgeon's office. Call the PCP today, explain the deadline, and ask them to submit it in SDI Online with your receipt number. Faster than mailing.

0 coins

The SDI Online submission route for Part D is genuinely faster. The doctor's office just needs your receipt number and they can put it in directly. Mailing adds days you don't have right now.

0 coins

Part D mailed late on my husband's care claim and EDD said I could have lost benefits for those days. The form has to arrive within 41 days of when leave started, not just be postmarked. Tell the PCP office to submit it online with your receipt number if at all possible.

0 coins

Didn't realize it had to actually arrive, not just be sent. That changes things. I'm calling the PCP first thing.

0 coins

Same thing happened to us, Part D arrived one day late and we had to deal with a whole mess, anyway the online submission really does save time.

0 coins

On my own care claim for my mother, the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification came through and I wasn't sure what it confirmed exactly. I used Claimyr to reach an agent who told me the DE 2500E just meant my first payment had been issued and gave me the date it went out. I had been treating it like an approval letter, which it isn't.

0 coins

What exactly did you say to the agent when they picked up? I want to know if they could also confirm whether a pending payment on a care claim is stuck or just processing.

0 coins

I told the agent my claim ID and asked what the DE 2500E indicated and whether payment had actually gone out. She confirmed the date it was issued. For a pending payment you'd just ask the agent what the current status is on that specific week.

0 coins

been trying that line since monday. four mornings, same recording every time. good to know someone actually got through.

0 coins

The 41-day rule in EDD's own materials says benefits can be lost for days that fall outside it. That's not days lost on the claim overall, it's specifically the days before EDD receives the completed forms. So if Part D arrives on day 42, you lose the first day or more depending on the gap.

0 coins

So every day the surgeon's office stalls is potentially a day I won't be paid for. I really needed to hear this spelled out.

0 coins

Exactly right. The form has to reach EDD, not just leave the doctor's fax. Online submission through SDI Online is the safest move at this point in your timeline.

0 coins

Tell the PCP office it is urgent. Doctors' offices respond differently when you say you have a legal deadline, not just 'as soon as possible.

0 coins

EDD's phone line has been a brick wall for me for weeks. I'm dealing with a care claim for my dad and I cannot get anyone to pick up. At what point does SDI Online's Request Claim Update actually do anything, because I've sent two and heard nothing.

0 coins

Request Claim Update eventually gets answered, just not fast. Mine took 11 days.

0 coins

If the question is straightforward, Ask EDD on EDD's site sometimes comes back sooner than a Request Claim Update. Neither is instant, but Ask EDD at least gives you a ticket number.

0 coins

11 days is a long time when you're watching a 41-day deadline tick down.

0 coins

Can I just say the surgeon's office situation is infuriating. My aunt's specialist did the exact same thing. We ended up sending a written request to the office manager explaining that federal and state benefits depended on the form, and they had it done in 48 hours after three weeks of silence.

0 coins

That's a really good idea. I've only been talking to whoever answers the phone. Going to the office manager in writing sounds like it might actually move things.

0 coins

The phrase 'government benefit deadline' in writing tends to get a different level of attention than a verbal request to a front desk person.

0 coins

Going to the office manager is smart. Some practices also have a nurse or PA who can handle the certification paperwork if the surgeon is too busy, so it's worth asking who handles their disability and leave forms.

0 coins

Something to keep in mind: if the surgeon's office does eventually send it, make sure they use your receipt number so EDD can match Part D to your claim. Without it the form just floats.

0 coins

I gave the receipt number to the surgeon's front desk when I dropped off the form but I honestly don't trust that it's written anywhere useful. I'll put it in writing to both offices.

0 coins

Printed receipt number on a sticky note with the form itself. Low-tech but it works.

0 coins

What if neither doctor ends up submitting Part D in time? Is there any way to appeal or get the lost days back if the deadline passes through no fault of yours?

0 coins

EDD can deny benefits for days outside the 41-day window. If that happens you'd get a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination, and you'd have 30 days to appeal with the DE 1000A. Whether a late submission due to a doctor's delay affects the outcome is a question for EDD on your specific case, not something anyone here can promise.

0 coins

The appeal process exists and it's worth using if you get a denial, but preventing the miss is a lot cleaner than fighting it afterward.

0 coins

That makes sense. I'd rather not test the appeals process if I can help it.

0 coins

Went back part time about six weeks into my wife's recovery and the intermittent payments got confusing fast. I tried Claimyr and the agent walked me through what the DE 2580GF showed on my claim and confirmed which days EDD had me down as working versus on leave that week.

0 coins

My wife went back part time last month and I need to know if the days I reported actually registered. Sounds like Claimyr might be worth trying for that.

0 coins

Have your claim ID and the specific week dates handy. The agent can pull up the DE 2580GF right then and tell you what's recorded.

0 coins

ive been trying the edd line since last tuesday same dead end every time

0 coins

Part D can be submitted in SDI Online by the physician's office using your receipt number, or mailed to the address on the form. EDD doesn't accept it uploaded by the claimant. Those are the two paths: doctor submits online with the receipt number, or doctor mails it.

0 coins

My PCP's office asked me if they could just fax it. I'll check if mailing is what the form says and confirm with them.

0 coins

The form says mail it to the address printed on it, or the office can go into SDI Online with your receipt number. No other method is listed by EDD, so confirm with the office what they're able to do.

0 coins

Most medical offices these days can do the SDI Online submission. It's worth asking them directly because it cuts out mail time entirely.

0 coins

my coworker had this exact situation except it was her mom's cardiologist who wouldn't sign, she just had the regular doctor do it and edd accepted part d no questions lol. so yeah another doctor is totally fine

0 coins

Good to hear it worked for her too. I feel a lot better about going straight to the PCP now.

0 coins

wait does pfl even cover spouses or just kids and parents i thought it was only for bonding

0 coins

PFL care claims cover seriously ill spouses, yes. Bonding is for a new child. Care is for a family member with a serious health condition, and a spouse is on that list.

0 coins

oh okay i had it backwards. thought bonding was everything

0 coins

A lot of people mix those up. Bonding is specifically for a new child after birth, adoption or foster placement. Care is the separate type for ill family members, which includes spouses, parents, children, siblings, parents-in-law, grandparents and grandchildren.

0 coins

double check that Part C actually got there too, it's easy to assume it arrived because you mailed it but EDD has no way to tell you it got lost in the mail, anyway just worth checking via SDI Online or a Request Claim Update

0 coins

I sent it about two weeks ago and haven't confirmed receipt. Sending a Request Claim Update right now to ask.

0 coins

if you filed in SDI Online you can sometimes see document status in the claim, though for Part C it may just show the claim as pending until both pieces are in

0 coins

Filed my care claim on October 3rd, started leave September 23rd. That meant my 41-day window closed November 3rd. I had to tell the doctor's office the actual date, not just 'as soon as possible,' and that's what got it moving.

0 coins

Telling them the exact date is exactly what I'm going to do. 'You have until this specific date' is a lot clearer than 'it's urgent.

0 coins

Doctors' offices deal with these forms constantly. An actual deadline date gets filed differently than a vague urgency request.

0 coins

The PCP being familiar with his recovery is actually a good thing for Part D! She can speak to his current condition and his care needs, which is exactly what EDD wants the certification to address.

0 coins

She's literally been to the house twice to check on him, so she knows his situation better than the surgeon at this point.

0 coins

That is honestly ideal. The surgeon only knows the procedure, the PCP knows the whole recovery picture. Part D is really about the ongoing care need, not the surgery itself.

0 coins

Worth knowing: if the surgeon's office does send Part D eventually, make sure the PCP hasn't already sent one. EDD needs one Part D, not two for the same claim period.

0 coins

I hadn't thought about that. So I should pick one and tell the other not to submit.

0 coins

Correct. Decide which office you trust to get it in on time, give them the receipt number, and let the other office know not to send it.

0 coins

Two forms for the same claim could create a paperwork headache you don't need. One doctor, one Part D, receipt number attached.

0 coins

How did it go? Did the PCP agree to submit it?

0 coins

Reached the PCP's office this morning and they said yes, they'll do it in SDI Online with my receipt number by end of week. Such a relief after two weeks of the surgeon's office giving me nothing.

0 coins

That's the best outcome. Online submission means no mail delay, and you've still got enough time before day 41.

0 coins

The PCP route coming through is so good to hear! And submitting it online is the fastest way to get it matched to your claim.

0 coins

Follow-up question for anyone who knows: once Part D is submitted by the doctor in SDI Online, how long before EDD actually processes it and moves the claim forward?

0 coins

EDD says most claims are processed within two weeks of receiving a properly completed claim. Once Part D is in and matched, that's when the clock on a decision really starts.

0 coins

Mine was processed in about 10 days after the doctor submitted online. That's just my experience, not a promise.

0 coins

EDD also says deciding eligibility can take up to 14 days. The online submission just removes the mail step, it doesn't skip that review window.

0 coins

You're in a better spot now than you were when you posted. PCP is on board, you've got time left on the deadline, and you know to give them the receipt number. Get that submitted and you're done waiting on the surgeon.

0 coins

Truly. This thread answered so much more than just the original question. Thank you all.

0 coins

Hope the payment lands fast once Part D is in. The care claim process is stressful enough without doctor's office runaround on top of it.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure