Back to California Paid Family Leave

Mei-Ling Chen

PFL payment amount includes second job wages what to do if EDD used both

Okay so I filed a PFL bonding claim after my daughter was born in September and I've been trying to figure out if EDD pulled in wages from my second job when they calculated my benefit. I work at the university three days a week and I also do weekend shifts at a coffee shop, both deduct CASDI. When the Notice of Computation came I didn't recognize the wage figure they used, it was higher than just my university pay but lower than what I'd make adding both jobs together, and now I'm second-guessing what base period they looked at. My question is basically whether EDD is supposed to include wages from all employers in the weekly benefit amount, and if they did that correctly here, what does the final PFL payment amount include in terms of second job wages and what should I do to verify it's right?

October 3rd the status still said pending, eleven days after I uploaded my daughter's birth certificate for my own bonding claim, and I finally stopped refreshing SDI Online and tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) instead. Got through to an actual EDD agent and she pulled up the claim right there. She confirmed the start date I'd entered and said the 41-day window was fine, nothing was missing, it was just still in review. That was the whole hold-up, just waiting. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

Eleven days of pending and you just found some random service online to call EDD for you, reads like an ad somebody placed in a forum to me, honestly.

0 coins

Felt that way to me at first too, I'll be straight. Then I'd been shut out of the line four mornings in a row and figured fine, let it do the waiting. Agent picked up and I asked about my intermittent days, whether my DE 2580GF had been received, she confirmed it was matched to the claim. So that part worked as advertised, I'll say that much.

0 coins

Huh. Okay, that's more convincing than I expected. Gonna sit on it for a day and see if SDI Online updates first, then maybe give it a go.

0 coins

Both employers deduct CASDI from your check, so yes, EDD combines wages from all covered employers in the base period when they set the weekly benefit amount. The Notice of Computation reflects the highest-earning quarter across the full 12-month base period, all jobs included. If the wage figure on yours doesn't match what you expect, the calculator on EDD's site lets you run the numbers before you call.

0 coins

That confirms what I suspected. The figure on the Notice was between my two jobs' totals, so maybe they caught one quarter where the coffee shop hours were lower. I'll try the calculator tonight.

0 coins

Wait, so it looks at the highest single quarter from all employers combined? Not an average? I've been adding up my annual wages and dividing and I think I've been doing this completely wrong.

0 coins

Highest quarter, not an average. The base period covers four calendar quarters ending about five to eighteen months before your claim date, and EDD takes the quarter where your combined earnings from all covered employers were highest. That's what lands on the Notice of Computation.

0 coins

Okay that actually explains why my estimate was off. I had the wrong quarters entirely.

0 coins

When I filed my care claim for my husband a few years back I had a part-time tutoring job on top of my school district work. Both had SDI deducted. EDD included wages from both on my Notice of Computation and my weekly benefit came out higher than I'd expected from just the district pay alone. So in my experience they do pull all covered wages in. Worth double-checking by comparing each quarter on your pay stubs against what the Notice says.

0 coins

Pay stubs by quarter is a good idea. I hadn't thought to organize them that way, I was just looking at annual totals.

0 coins

Same situation here, two jobs both with CASDI. EDD combined them without me doing anything extra.

0 coins

EDD's supposed to include every employer where CASDI comes out of your check. That's the deal. If the number on your Notice of Computation looks off, you can appeal it within 30 days of that notice using the Appeal Form DE 1000A. Don't sit on it.

0 coins

30 days on the appeal window, noted. I'm still within that so I need to sort this out fast.

0 coins

The appeal form is DE 1000A, right. File it online or mail it, your choice. But check the math yourself first so you know what you're actually disputing before you file.

0 coins

Yeah exactly. Know your numbers before you appeal. EDD isn't going to explain the math to you, you have to come in already knowing what quarter you think they got wrong.

0 coins

I'm kind of in the same situation, not sure if I understand this. My second job doesn't take out CASDI, it's a contract thing, so I think that means those wages don't count? But I'm not 100 percent sure and I'm nervous I'm leaving money on the table.

0 coins

If CASDI isn't withheld from those contract earnings, EDD generally won't include them in the PFL base period wages. Only wages with SDI withheld count. So you probably aren't leaving anything out, those wages just aren't in the pool.

0 coins

Okay that's a relief to hear. I kept second-guessing myself every time I looked at the Notice.

0 coins

yeah if theres no casdi on the stub it doesnt go in, my roommate had the same thing with his gig work

0 coins

Payment method question tripped me right up after my son was born, I'd filed in SDI Online and assumed direct deposit was automatic. It wasnt. Ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr and she checked my claim and said the payment method was still showing as debit card, nothing had been updated. She walked me through where to change it in SDI Online. Saved me from wondering where my first check went.

0 coins

Did EDD tell you if there'd be a delay because of the payment method switch, like do they hold the payment while it updates?

0 coins

Agent said the first payment would go to whichever method was on file when it processed. So I updated it right away and it went to direct deposit, no issue anyway.

0 coins

been trying that line since tuesday. three mornings, same result, it just cuts off. still no payment method set up on mine.

0 coins

The base period is four calendar quarters, the second through fifth quarters before the quarter your claim starts in. So depending on when in September your bonding started, the quarters EDD looked at may not include very recent pay. That could explain why the coffee shop wages look partial, if you picked up those shifts recently.

0 coins

That timing thing is what I think happened. I only started the coffee shop shifts about seven months ago, so some of those quarters predate that job entirely.

0 coins

That tracks. The base period can exclude the most recent quarter or two, so a job you started partway through the year might show up in only one or two of the four quarters they use.

0 coins

Exactly. So the Notice might be right even if it looks low compared to what you're earning now.

0 coins

if u think edds math is wrong just call them and ask. they can tell u what wages they used for each quarter. better than guessing

0 coins

Calling is the right move but that line is brutal. I spent most of a morning on hold last time and it dropped.

0 coins

yeah thats the problem lol. sdionline message might be faster honestly

0 coins

Request Claim Update in SDI Online, pick the right request type, write your question. That's what I'd do first.

0 coins

Before disputing anything, I'd compare each quarter on your Notice of Computation against your actual pay stubs. Sometimes the number looks off but the quarters just don't line up with what you expect. Turned out that way for me when I had two jobs during my care claim, the Notice was right, I'd just been looking at the wrong time window.

0 coins

I'm going to do exactly that tonight. Pull the stubs, map each quarter, then see if the coffee shop wages in the base period match the Notice number.

0 coins

If the stubs match, you're good. If they don't, that's when you send a Request Claim Update in SDI Online or use the Appeal Form.

0 coins

Is the base period always the same four quarters or does it change based on when you file? I filed at the very end of a quarter and I'm worried they looked at weird dates.

0 coins

Receipt number on a bonding claim matters more than people think. I forgot mine and couldn't get EDD to match my uploaded birth certificate to anything for two days. Tried Claimyr and had a live EDD agent in a few minutes. She found the receipt number on the claim, confirmed the proof of relationship had been received and matched, and told me the claim was just pending review. That was it.

0 coins

Proof of relationship on my claim still shows nothing in SDI Online and it's been nine days. I want to ask EDD if they actually got the birth certificate. I'll try Claimyr for that.

0 coins

Have the receipt number from your original confirmation page ready when you get through. If you don't have it, they can find the claim by your Social Security number, but the receipt number makes it faster.

0 coins

Got it, I saved the confirmation email so the receipt number is there.

0 coins

My cousin had two jobs when she filed PFL and her benefit was definitely higher than just her main job alone. EDD figured it out without her doing anything, it just showed up on the Notice of Computation. So I think as long as both employers take out CASDI it should be automatic.

0 coins

That's been my experience too. EDD sees all employers reporting wages with SDI withheld under your Social Security number, so they come in automatically.

0 coins

Reassuring to hear it's not something I had to actively do. I just want to make sure the coffee shop reported their wages to EDD correctly, which is the part I can't control.

0 coins

If you believe the employer didn't report correctly, that's worth raising with EDD directly, through a Request Claim Update or by phoning them.

0 coins

Notice of Computation on my claim had a wage amount I didn't recognize at first because I'd changed jobs mid-base-period. Used Claimyr to get an EDD agent on the line and she went quarter by quarter with me, confirmed which wages from each employer had been reported, and told me the weekly benefit amount on the notice was calculated correctly from what was on file. I had been mentally adding up the wrong months entirely.

0 coins

The quarter-by-quarter breakdown the agent gave you is exactly what I'd want for my claim. I've used Claimyr too, and once the agent confirmed my Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination had been issued and walked me through what it meant, I filed my DE 1000A appeal the same day. The 30-day window on those is real and I almost missed it.

0 coins

30 days on the determination appeal is the one that catches people. Glad you caught it in time.

0 coins

Had to try the EDD line six days straight before I went another route. The notice language on the DE 2514 is easy to misread so having the agent explain what triggered it helped a lot.

0 coins

If you think the number's wrong, file the appeal. DE 1000A, 30 days from the Notice. Don't overthink it. If the math checks out after you pull your stubs, never mind. But don't let the deadline pass while you're deciding.

0 coins

That's the part stressing me out most, the clock. I'm going to run the stubs tonight and decide by tomorrow whether to file.

0 coins

Good. Know what you're disputing before you file, don't just appeal because the number surprised you. Have the specific quarter and amount ready.

0 coins

Can I ask a maybe dumb question here, does PFL have a waiting period like disability does? Someone at work told me I'd lose the first week of benefits and I'm panicking that I didn't budget for that.

0 coins

No waiting period on PFL. The seven unpaid days are for Disability Insurance claims, not Paid Family Leave. PFL starts paying from the first eligible day.

0 coins

Oh thank goodness. I've been dreading that.

0 coins

Yeah your coworker was thinking of DI, not PFL. Easy mix-up but they're separate programs.

0 coins

I really need to stop getting financial advice from my coworkers lol.

0 coins

the payment amount question is making me think. i have a weekend retail job, both employers take out casdi. filed last month and my notice came and it looked right but i never actually verified it against my stubs. maybe i should.

0 coins

Worth a check. Take your pay stubs, find the highest calendar quarter where both employers paid you, and see if that lines up with the wage figure on your Notice of Computation.

0 coins

yeah ill do that. never would have thought to look at it that way.

0 coins

EDD getting all your wages right depends on every employer actually reporting them. If the coffee shop hasn't reported wages to EDD yet for a recent quarter, those won't show on the Notice. That's the gap to check.

0 coins

That's my biggest concern. The coffee shop is a small place, I genuinely don't know if they're reporting on time.

0 coins

Ask EDD what wages they show on file from that employer. That tells you fast whether the reporting gap is the problem.

0 coins

If wages are missing because an employer didn't report, EDD has a process for that but you'd need to contact them to start it. Not something that fixes itself.

0 coins

Both jobs deduct CASDI, both sets of wages go into the base period calculation. The Notice of Computation has the quarterly breakdown. Check it against your stubs and if something's off, appeal within 30 days of that notice.

0 coins

Does the Notice actually break it down by quarter or just show one total figure?

0 coins

It shows the base period quarters and the wages used. You can see which quarter was highest and what figure EDD has on file.

0 coins

I clearly didn't read it closely enough. Going back to it now.

0 coins

EDD's benefit calculator on their site, edd.ca.gov, lets you plug in a wage figure and get an estimated weekly benefit. If you run your expected combined wages for the highest quarter and get a different number than your Notice, that's your sign to contact EDD before the appeal window closes.

0 coins

I actually didn't know the calculator was public. That'll help me check the math before I do anything else.

0 coins

It's under the PFL section on EDD's site. Just an estimate, the official number is always what's on the Notice, but it's close enough to tell if something's clearly off.

0 coins

While we're talking about wages and payments, worth knowing PFL can be taken intermittently if you go back part time. You'd need to report any work and wages, and EDD sends you a Continued Claim Certification to return. I dropped the ball on that my first time back and payments stopped.

0 coins

Not my situation right now, full leave, but good to know for later in the 12 months if I want to take some days.

0 coins

yeah the certification form trips everyone up. if u dont send it back payments just stop, no warning

0 coins

Pretty much. EDD sends the DE 2580GF, you fill it out and return it, or it's done.

0 coins

The EDD line for PFL is 1-877-238-4373. That's the number. Good luck actually getting through, but that's the number. If you want to ask in writing first, there's a Request Claim Update in SDI Online under your claim.

0 coins

Every time I've tried that number it disconnects at a certain point in the menu. Never fails.

0 coins

Had three mornings in a row like that last spring. It's not you, it's the volume. SDI Online message ended up being faster for me.

0 coins

One more thing on the base period timing, I asked an EDD agent about this on my own claim and she confirmed the specific start date I'd entered and which calendar quarters that pulled in. That's something they can tell you when you get through, exactly which four quarters they used and what wages were in each one. Useful to know if you're trying to figure out whether your coffee shop wages made it in at all.

0 coins

That's the exact question I want answered. Which quarters they actually used and what wage amount came from each employer in those quarters.

0 coins

That detail is what makes a phone call worth it, honestly. SDI Online can show you the Notice but it won't break it down the way an agent can.

0 coins

Decided I'm going to send a Request Claim Update first since I'm still within the 30-day window, and if the answer isn't clear I'll escalate from there.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure