Back to California Paid Family Leave

Mei-Ling Chen

PFL denied wrong sick leave answer — appeal reapply or both?

So I got a denial letter last week and I'm still kind of in shock. I filed a PFL bonding claim after my daughter was born in October and EDD sent back a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination saying I was denied. I think the problem is that I answered yes to a question about receiving sick leave during the claim period when I actually hadn't taken any, I just misread it completely and panicked and hit yes. Now I'm sitting here with a DE 1000A appeal form and also wondering if I should just refile entirely instead of appealing. Does anyone know which is the better move, or do I need to do both? I have 30 days from the determination letter to appeal and I'm already at day 8. The whole situation is making me so anxious because I really needed those eight weeks for bonding and I don't know if I messed it up permanently.

Part D not received was what my status kept showing, two weeks after my mom's doctor submitted it online with my receipt number. I ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) because the phone line just ended the call every time I got past the menu. The agent pulled up the claim and confirmed Part D was there but hadn't been matched yet, and also told me the 41-day clock from my leave start date, so I knew exactly how much time I had. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

Wait, I have a bonding claim and I'm not sure if my birth certificate got linked to my receipt number or if EDD is still waiting on it. Would Claimyr work for that kind of question? I'm kind of scared to call and get nowhere again.

0 coins

Yeah that's exactly the kind of thing the agent can look up. Have your receipt number and Social Security number ready when it rings through, that's really all you need.

0 coins

Glad you got through. That line cutting off mid-menu is infuriating, happened to me four mornings in a row.

0 coins

Appealing is almost certainly the right first step here. The Appeal Form DE 1000A has a section where you explain the basis for your appeal, and a one-sentence correction, something like 'I answered yes to the sick leave question in error; I did not receive sick leave during the claim period,' is entirely appropriate there. EDD will review the determination in light of what you submit.

0 coins

Is there any supporting document I should send with the appeal, or just the written explanation on the DE 1000A?

0 coins

A short written statement from your employer confirming you took no paid sick leave during the bonding period would strengthen the appeal considerably. It doesn't have to be formal, just signed and on company letterhead if possible.

0 coins

Worth noting the 30-day window runs from the date on the determination letter, not the date you received it. So count from that letter date to be safe.

0 coins

Don't file a new claim while the appeal is open. You'll end up with two records on the same period and that creates a mess. Get the appeal in first and see what comes back.

0 coins

That makes sense, I was worried doing both at once would confuse things even more.

0 coins

Agreed. One thing at a time with EDD or you're just adding to your own headache.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is basically decorative at this point. I called six days straight trying to get someone and either the line dropped or I hit a recording that said to try again. For something like this, where you need to know exactly what triggered the denial, actually talking to someone is the only way.

0 coins

six days is brutal, what did you end up doing

0 coins

Eventually got through. It took more tries than I should have had to make, but I did reach someone.

0 coins

Honestly the phone situation with EDD is just a whole thing. Some days you get through, most days you don't, lol.

0 coins

The appeal and a potential refile are not mutually exclusive, but the sequencing matters. If the appeal is granted, the original claim stands and there is no gap. If EDD denies the appeal too, you can consider refiling, but the bonding window for a child born in October runs 12 months from birth, so you have time to see how the appeal resolves before that door closes.

0 coins

So the 12 months from her birth date in October gives me until next October to still use the bonding weeks if the appeal works out?

0 coins

Exactly, as long as the bonding claim's weeks are used within those 12 months from the birth date.

0 coins

That 12-month window stressed me out when I filed too. Good to know it doesn't start over if you appeal.

0 coins

Submit the appeal before anything else. A wrong answer on the form is a correctable error, not a permanent bar. You have more time than it feels like right now.

0 coins

Thank you, that's actually reassuring. I keep assuming the worst.

0 coins

It really is fixable. The appeal process is there for exactly this.

0 coins

Did your denial letter say anything specific about the sick leave answer being the actual reason, or just that you were denied? Because sometimes EDD lists multiple reasons and you want to address all of them in the appeal, not just the one you spotted.

0 coins

The DE 2514 listed the sick leave thing as the reason but I'll read it again more carefully to make sure I'm not missing something.

0 coins

Read every line of it. The determination notice will state the specific basis, and you'll want to respond to each point in your appeal statement.

0 coins

Good catch. Missing a second reason in an appeal is how people lose on a technicality.

0 coins

I went through a denial situation last year for a care claim and appealing was 100% the move. The online appeal form in SDI Online is actually pretty straightforward, you just upload your statement and submit it tied to the claim. The letter you get back gives a hearing date if EDD wants more info.

0 coins

Wait, there's an online option in SDI Online? I was going to mail the paper DE 1000A but online sounds faster.

0 coins

Yes, in SDI Online you can submit the appeal tied to the claim ID. Just keep a copy of whatever you submit.

0 coins

I didn't know you could do it online. That would have saved me a lot of guessing when I was confused about forms.

0 coins

Payment date question was what I needed answered on a bonding claim that had been sitting quiet for eleven days. Used Claimyr for it after the phone line gave me a system message four times in one morning. The agent looked up the claim and told me the payment had been issued two days earlier and to watch for the debit card in the mail.

0 coins

The debit card wait is its own kind of stress. My Notice of Computation showed up before I even had the card. Used Claimyr myself, asked about the weekly benefit amount on the notice, and the agent walked me through which quarter they pulled wages from.

0 coins

four times in one morning is wild, that line is so unreliable

0 coins

Two days already issued and you didn't know, that must have been a relief to hear. I've been dialing most of this week and can't get past the opening menu.

0 coins

For the appeal statement itself, keep it simple and factual! Something like 'I misread question X and answered yes in error. I was not receiving sick leave during this period.' Then attach whatever your employer can give you. Short and clear works better than long and detailed here.

0 coins

Should I try to explain why I misread it, or just state the correction?

0 coins

Just state the correction and back it up with the employer note. EDD doesn't need the story of why, just the accurate answer.

0 coins

Agreed. A factual correction with supporting documentation is cleaner than a lengthy explanation.

0 coins

Can I ask something kind of related? If EDD says the appeal goes to a hearing, does that mean an in-person thing or is it by phone? The whole idea of a hearing sounds terrifying to me.

0 coins

Hearings are conducted by the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board and can be by phone. The notice you get will tell you the format and date.

0 coins

Okay, a phone hearing is less scary than I imagined. Thank you for clarifying that.

0 coins

I had a hearing on a different EDD issue and the whole thing was way less intimidating than it sounds. You just explain your side.

0 coins

I'm a little skeptical that a wrong checkbox answer is enough to get a denial reversed. EDD doesn't just take your word for it. What actually makes them flip the determination?

0 coins

An employer letter confirming no sick leave was paid during the period is what gives EDD something concrete to act on, not just the correction itself.

0 coins

The denial is based on the information EDD had at the time. New documentation they didn't have changes what they're deciding on. That's the whole point of the appeal window.

0 coins

Fair, I hadn't thought about it that way. So it's really about giving them new info, not arguing with their original decision.

0 coins

Weeks remaining question was why I finally reached EDD, because I'd already used some bonding weeks after my son was born and then needed to know what was left before my wife filed her own claim. Got through to an agent using Claimyr after two weeks of dropped calls. The agent confirmed how many weeks I had used and how many remained in my 12-month window.

0 coins

I called that line for three days running last month and it kept dropping me after the language menu. Hard to believe you got a live person. What made the difference?

0 coins

Claimyr holds the line so my phone rings when an agent picks up. I wasn't doing anything different on EDD's end, I just wasn't the one waiting.

0 coins

wait both parents can file separate bonding claims on the same baby

0 coins

Agent confirmed the weeks left and that helped you plan around your wife's claim too, that's really useful to know. Each parent does file their own separate PFL bonding claim, so both of you each have up to eight weeks, but those eight weeks are shared across bonding, care and military assist within your own 12 months.

0 coins

Before mailing or submitting anything, make sure the DE 1000A has the claim ID and determination date written exactly as they appear on the DE 2514. Mismatched reference numbers can slow processing.

0 coins

Good catch. I'll double-check that before I submit.

0 coins

Same for any attachments. Label each page with your name and claim ID so nothing gets separated.

0 coins

the sick leave question is a tricky one on that form. a lot of people answer it wrong in both directions.

0 coins

Does the form ask about sick leave that was paid by the employer, or any sick leave at all including unpaid? Because that might matter for how the correction is worded.

0 coins

The relevant factor for PFL purposes is wages received during the claim period, so paid sick leave that substitutes for wages is what EDD is asking about. Unpaid time off is different.

0 coins

yeah thats where people get confused, they think any time off counts

0 coins

Start date on my care claim had been entered wrong somewhere and I had no idea until I noticed the 41-day deadline calculation looked off in my head. Reached EDD through Claimyr and the agent confirmed the actual start date on file and told me the 41 days from that date, so I knew exactly where I stood.

0 coins

What is Claimyr? I keep seeing it mentioned and I've been dialing EDD every morning this week with nothing to show for it.

0 coins

You give it your info and it does the holding while you go about your day, then your phone rings when an EDD agent is on the line. That's really the whole thing.

0 coins

Huh. I want to push back on whether the 41-day start date even matters after the fact, but honestly my bigger issue right now is that I can't reach anyone to ask about my pending care claim. I'll try it.

0 coins

Reapplying after an appeal gets denied is a separate question entirely and you're nowhere near that yet. Focus on the appeal, get the employer letter, submit before day 30. Cross the other bridge if you get there.

0 coins

You're right, I'm getting way ahead of myself worrying about what happens if the appeal fails.

0 coins

Exactly. One step.

0 coins

Two things worth knowing about the PFL appeal process: you can appeal online through SDI Online, and EDD is supposed to send you an acknowledgment that the appeal was received. If you don't see that acknowledgment within a few days, check that it went through before the 30-day window closes.

0 coins

Is the acknowledgment by email or does it show up in SDI Online?

0 coins

It should appear in your SDI Online claim activity. Keep an eye on the claim status after you submit.

0 coins

Checking in because I never saw an acknowledgment on mine and panicked, but it had just not updated yet when I looked. Showed up the next day.

0 coins

If the appeal comes back denied, then you look at whether refiling makes sense given where you are in the 12-month window. No point mapping that out now when you haven't even submitted the appeal yet.

0 coins

True. I need to stop spiraling and just get the DE 1000A submitted with the employer letter.

0 coins

That's the right call. Get it in and then give EDD time to work through it.

0 coins

did you answer wrong because the form just assumes you have sick leave available? i feel like that form has questions that assume things about your job

0 coins

Yeah kind of, I think I read it too fast and thought it was asking if I had sick leave available through my job, not whether I actually used it. Total misread on my part.

0 coins

That's such a common mix-up! The question is about leave actually received during the claim period, not what your employer offers. Easy to misread under stress.

0 coins

Submit the appeal. Employer confirmation letter with it. Don't refile until you have an answer. That's the whole plan.

0 coins

Okay. Appeal with employer letter, wait for the response. I'll get it in today. Thank you everyone, this thread helped me stop catastrophizing and actually take a step.

0 coins

You've got this. The appeal window is still open and you have a clear correctable error to point to.

0 coins

Good luck, check SDI Online for the acknowledgment after you submit, anyway.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure