PFL denied over 12 months after birth after SDI exhausted — appeal options?
So I'm in a situation I didn't see coming and I'm really hoping someone has dealt with this. My daughter was born last November and I had a pregnancy disability claim that ran through most of the winter. By the time I transitioned to bonding, I was already pretty far into the year and honestly just kept pushing the PFL bonding claim back because I was exhausted and thought I had time. I finally filed but EDD sent back a denial saying my bonding leave has to be used within 12 months of her birth and I'm now past that window. I still have weeks left that I never used. Is there any point in appealing this? The denial came with an Appeal Form (DE 1000A) and said I have 30 days to submit it. I don't even know what grounds I'd appeal on but losing those weeks feels really wrong when I had a valid SDI claim running right before this. Has anyone appealed a PFL denial like this and had it go anywhere?
80 comments

Victoria Charity
Part D on my mom's care claim had been sitting unmatched for over two weeks, and nobody at EDD could tell me why over the phone because I couldn't get through. Tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and finally reached a live EDD agent. Video on getting a person on EDD's Paid Family Leave line: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up the claim and found Part D had been submitted by the doctor's office with a slightly wrong receipt number, so it never matched. They flagged it and told me to have my mom's doctor resubmit it in SDI Online with the correct number.
0 coins
Jasmine Quinn
That Part D fix sounds useful, but I keep seeing Claimyr mentioned and I'm not sure it isn't just someone marketing a service in these threads. What actually happened when you used it, and did you end up talking to an actual EDD employee?
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
Thought the same thing as the person above when I first saw Claimyr posted somewhere else. Tried it anyway because my Notice of Computation (DE 429DF) showed a weekly amount that didn't match what I expected from my wages. The agent I reached confirmed the base period they used and walked me through which quarter had my highest wages. That was an actual EDD employee, not a third party.
0 coins
Jasmine Quinn
Okay, the base period detail is specific enough that I believe it. I'm going to look into it, because I have a question about my own proof of relationship that I haven't been able to get answered.
0 coins
Nora Bennett
The 12-month window on bonding is a hard rule. PFL bonding benefits have to be used within 12 months of the child's birth or placement, and that's written right into how the program works. Appeals on that specific point tend to be difficult because it's not a gray area in EDD's rules. That said, filing the appeal before that 30-day window closes still makes sense, because you don't lose anything by trying and you get a formal review.
0 coins
Evan Kalinowski
AuthorNot sure if this matters for the appeal, but would the fact that I had an active SDI disability claim for a big chunk of that 12 months change anything? Like does EDD account for time spent on disability before bonding?
0 coins
Nora Bennett
Honestly that's the kind of question where I'd say put it in the appeal and let EDD weigh in. The 12-month clock runs from birth regardless of what else was going on, based on what EDD's own materials say, but whether your specific circumstances affect anything is worth raising formally.
0 coins
Ryan Andre
The 30-day deadline on the appeal is firm too. Even if the case feels uncertain, sending the DE 1000A before that window closes is the most important thing right now.
0 coins
Lauren Zeb
I've tried that PFL line more mornings than I can count and usually get a recording telling me to try again. The whole system is set up to wear people down until they give up. So I do have some sympathy here because getting clear answers before the 12-month clock ran out would have required actually reaching someone at EDD.
0 coins
Daniel Washington
Same problem here. Called three times in one week and never got past the hold music.
0 coins
Evan Kalinowski
AuthorThat's exactly what happened to me earlier in the year. I tried to ask EDD a question about timing and couldn't get through, so I made assumptions about how much time I had left. Those assumptions were wrong.
0 coins
Aurora Lacasse
The phone situation is genuinely rough. For what it's worth, sending a Request Claim Update through SDI Online sometimes gets a written answer, which at least creates a record. Might have helped earlier but it's still worth knowing for the appeal stage.
0 coins
Anthony Young
File that appeal. Thirty days goes fast. Put in everything you've got, the SDI claim dates, the bonding start date, everything, and let EDD's appeals process sort it out. Doing nothing gets you nothing.
0 coins
Charlotte White
If the appeal is denied, is there another level after that or is it just over? I'm not in this situation yet but I'm worried about my own timeline.
0 coins
Anthony Young
There's a formal appeal process. File first, worry about the next step if it comes to it.
0 coins
Evan Kalinowski
AuthorFiling it this week. At least I won't be sitting here wondering what would have happened.
0 coins
Admin_Masters
Okay so just to make sure I understand, the 12 months starts from the actual birth date, not from when the SDI pregnancy claim ended? Because I've seen people say both things and I want to get this right for my own situation, I'm about five months postpartum and trying to plan my bonding leave.
0 coins
Nora Bennett
From the birth date, yes. The pregnancy disability claim ending doesn't reset the clock or start a new one for bonding. So for a November birth you'd have through the following November.
0 coins
Admin_Masters
Okay that's really helpful, I'm going to go schedule my bonding leave dates now because I do not want to end up in this situation.
0 coins
Ryan Andre
Planning it out now is exactly right. The eight weeks don't have to be taken all at once either, so you have flexibility, but the whole thing has to land within that 12-month window.
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
Worth knowing that PFL has no waiting period, in case that comes up during the appeal or when anyone else is timing their claim. Pregnancy disability has seven days unpaid at the start, PFL doesn't. Some people assume bonding has the same gap and plan around it unnecessarily.
0 coins
Ella Thompson
wait for real? i thought pfl had the waiting period too, i told my coworker she should expect that when she files her bonding claim
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
Tell her not to plan around it. No waiting period for PFL.
0 coins
Ella Thompson
gonna text her right now, glad i saw this
0 coins
JacksonHarris
My bonding claim went through fine but it was close, we filed it like two weeks before the year was up, anyway the thing nobody told me was that the eight weeks of PFL is a combined limit across bonding and care claims in the same 12 months. We used five weeks bonding and I didn't realize that affects how much is left if something else comes up.
0 coins
Charlotte White
Wait, combined? So if I used all eight weeks bonding with my baby I can't also take weeks later to care for a sick parent in the same year?
0 coins
JacksonHarris
That's what EDD told me when I called, yeah. It's one pool of eight weeks total, not eight for each reason.
0 coins
Nora Bennett
That's right. It's a 12-month total, not a per-reason total. So someone who used all eight on bonding would have nothing left for a care claim in that same window.
0 coins
Ryan Andre
The first payment on my bonding claim was issued a few days later than my Notice of Computation had led me to expect, and I couldn't tell if something was wrong. I tried phoning EDD but got nowhere. Ended up using Claimyr to reach an agent, and she looked at my claim and told me the payment had been issued and gave me the exact date it was sent. It had just taken a couple of extra days to show up on my end.
0 coins
Lauren Zeb
What did you have ready when the agent answered? I always wonder if I need account numbers or just my Social.
0 coins
Ryan Andre
I had my Social Security number, my claim ID from SDI Online, and the receipt number from when I originally filed. Having all three meant she could pull everything up right away.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
been trying that line since tuesday morning. four attempts, same recording every time. good to know there are other ways
0 coins
Royal_GM_Mark
Can you even file a bonding claim that far out or does SDI Online block it once the 12 months are up? Just curious if the system let it through and EDD denied it after, or if it rejected it at the filing stage.
0 coins
Evan Kalinowski
AuthorSDI Online let me file it. The denial came afterward in the mail, not at the submission step.
0 coins
Royal_GM_Mark
That's kind of a rough design lol, you'd think it would at least warn you at the filing stage.
0 coins
Nora Bennett
The filing system accepting it doesn't mean EDD approved it. The eligibility decision is a separate step that happens after the claim is submitted. The notice that comes in the mail is where the actual determination shows up.
0 coins
Amelia Cartwright
For the appeal, write down the timeline clearly. Date of birth, first day of SDI claim, last day of SDI, date you tried to file PFL. Keep it factual and brief.
0 coins
Evan Kalinowski
AuthorShould I include anything about not being able to reach EDD during that period to ask about timing? Or does that not factor into an appeal?
0 coins
Amelia Cartwright
Include it. Anything relevant to your situation goes in. Let the appeals reviewer decide what matters.
0 coins
Charlotte White
Does the appeal have to be on the DE 1000A form specifically or can you write a letter?
0 coins
Amelia Cartwright
The DE 1000A is the form they send with the denial. Use it, and attach whatever documents support your case.
0 coins
Chris King
Someone I know went through almost this exact situation, missed the window by just a few weeks and appealed it! She didn't win the appeal but she said the process was clear and the reviewer actually read everything she submitted, so at least it felt like a real review and not just automatic.
0 coins
Evan Kalinowski
AuthorThat's actually helpful to hear. I'm not expecting to win but I want to know I at least tried.
0 coins
Chris King
That was her feeling too! And who knows, your situation with the SDI claim running so long before might read differently to a reviewer.
0 coins
Anthony Young
Weeks remaining in the 12 months was something I needed to nail down before filing my second stint of bonding leave. Couldn't get a straight answer from the EDD line after multiple tries. Used Claimyr and reached an agent who counted out exactly how many of my eight weeks had been paid and how many were left in my window.
0 coins
Rachel Clark
I want to know if my care claim for my dad used any of the same 12-month pool as my earlier bonding weeks, because I'm not sure I tracked it right. Going to try Claimyr for that.
0 coins
Anthony Young
Have your claim IDs for both claims and the dates each one started. The agent can see all of it on their end.
0 coins
Zachary Hughes
The DE 2501FP is what birth mothers get to move from pregnancy disability into bonding, right? I want to make sure I understand that transition because I'm about six weeks out from my due date and I don't want to miss anything.
0 coins
Ryan Andre
Yes, the DE 2501FP is specifically for new mothers transitioning from pregnancy disability to bonding. EDD sends it to you when the disability claim ends, and you submit it within 41 days of the bonding start date. No extra proof of relationship required.
0 coins
Zachary Hughes
That 41-day window is good to know. So I should file it pretty much as soon as the pregnancy disability ends?
0 coins
Ryan Andre
File it as soon as you know your bonding start date. You don't have to wait until the last minute, and earlier means you're less likely to miss anything.
0 coins
Evan Kalinowski
AuthorI wish I had been more careful about that 41-day window earlier in the year. It's one of those deadlines that sounds manageable until you're exhausted with a newborn and time disappears.
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
Start date and the 41-day deadline were both things I had to confirm on my care claim because the online status wasn't adding up to what I expected. Got a live EDD agent through Claimyr and she told me the start date EDD had on file, which was actually one day off from what I'd put in. She said to watch for a notice in the mail with the corrected date.
0 coins
Zachary Hughes
My bonding claim has a start date I'm also not 100% sure EDD recorded right, so I tried Claimyr too. The agent told me exactly which weeks had been marked paid and when the next payment cycle was due, so I could see the start date was correct from the payment pattern.
0 coins
Admin_Masters
Trying to get through on that line is its own ordeal. I called four days in a row once and gave up each time.
0 coins
Daniel Washington
The appeals form isn't complicated. Fill it out, state your case, mail it before the 30 days are up. Worrying about whether it'll work is a problem for after you've filed it.
0 coins
Charlotte White
Is certified mail worth it for something like this, just to have proof it arrived?
0 coins
Daniel Washington
Wouldn't hurt. Peace of mind is worth the few bucks.
0 coins
Aurora Lacasse
Filing the appeal also gives you a chance to ask EDD to look at whether the SDI period should factor into anything. I don't know if it changes the outcome but appeals reviewers do read the full context, not just the date.
0 coins
Evan Kalinowski
AuthorThat framing helps. I've been thinking of the appeal as a long shot, but framing it as EDD reviewing the full picture makes it feel more like a real step.
0 coins
Aurora Lacasse
It is a real step. The worst outcome is the same denial, but you'll know you gave EDD the whole story.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
Direct deposit or debit card for PFL payments, is that something you choose when you file or does EDD assign it? I set mine up through SDI Online but I'm not sure if I did it right.
0 coins
Ryan Andre
You choose it in SDI Online when you file. Direct deposit is only available for claims filed through SDI Online, not paper claims. If EDD doesn't have a bank account on file it defaults to a debit card.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
Mine shows direct deposit in SDI Online so I think I'm fine, just wanted to confirm it doesn't change mid-claim or anything.
0 coins
Ryan Andre
It stays with what you set at filing unless you change it in SDI Online.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
the denial being in the mail is the worst part because you lose days just waiting to see what it says and then the 30-day appeal window is already ticking
0 coins
Nora Bennett
The 30 days runs from the date on the denial notice, not from when you receive it, so opening it the day it arrives matters.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
didnt know that, checking the postmark from now on
0 coins
Jasmine Quinn
That date on the notice is worth photographing right when you open it, just to have a record of what it said and when.
0 coins
Lauren Zeb
If the appeal doesn't go your way, the denial itself, the DE 2514, tells you what EDD determined and why. Reading that carefully before you write the appeal statement is worth the time because you can respond directly to their reasoning.
0 coins
Evan Kalinowski
AuthorMine does say specifically that the 12-month period from date of birth had elapsed. So I know exactly what I'm responding to.
0 coins
Lauren Zeb
Then put your SDI dates front and center in the appeal. Make EDD account for the fact that you were on a valid claim for a significant part of that window.
0 coins
Admin_Masters
I didn't realize until reading this thread that someone who does intermittent bonding days, like a few days a week, still has to report those work days and wages to EDD each time. I thought you just filed once and they paid you for however many days you weren't working.
0 coins
Nora Bennett
EDD sends a Continued Claim Certification after you file and start working intermittently, and you have to send it back or payments stop. Any wages, even ones not paid out yet, get reported.
0 coins
Admin_Masters
So every time I take a bonding day off I need to track it and report it. Good to know before I set up my intermittent schedule.
0 coins
Aurora Lacasse
The reporting part is what a lot of people miss. The claim doesn't run on autopilot once you're doing partial weeks.
0 coins
Rachel Clark
Has anyone had an overpayment notice come after a denial? I'm wondering if EDD will say she was paid for weeks that now fall outside the window and try to claw some of it back.
0 coins
Evan Kalinowski
AuthorI actually hadn't thought about that. I didn't receive any payments yet because the denial came before the first payment was issued. But that's worth knowing about.
0 coins
Rachel Clark
If the denial is that no payment was issued, you're probably fine. It's when payments go out and then get reversed that the overpayment notices show up.
0 coins
Amelia Cartwright
An overpayment notice can be appealed the same way a denial can, with the DE 1000A and within 30 days. Worth knowing if one does arrive.
0 coins