Back to California Paid Family Leave

Natasha Volkov

PFL denied full wage continuation but employer did not pay — what to do now?

So I'm in kind of a mess and not sure where to turn. My company has a wage continuation policy where they're supposed to top up my PFL benefit to 100% of my salary while I'm out bonding with my new baby. The idea is PFL pays its share and my employer covers the difference so I still get my full paycheck. The problem is EDD sent me a determination that said my PFL benefit amount is reduced because of the wage continuation — I think they counted it as wages or something? — but then my employer hasn't actually paid me the top-up at all. So now I'm getting less from EDD and nothing from my employer, which means I'm way below my normal pay. I don't even fully understand the determination letter. Has anyone dealt with this? Do I fight EDD, fight my employer, or both? I'm really worried because rent is due in two weeks.

DE 2500E on my account said the first payment was issued but the amount looked wrong, so I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone on the PFL line. The agent pulled up the payment and confirmed the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification matched what EDD had on file. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM — anyway the agent said my wages weren't being reported by my employer so the benefit amount was based solely on my base period. Might be worth calling to find out exactly what EDD has on record for your wage continuation situation.

0 coins

Reads like a paid plug to me. EDD's line is useless, nothing gets through, so I don't buy that some service just magically lands you an agent.

0 coins

Thought the same thing when my crew foreman mentioned it, but I tried it myself on a Monday morning after three weeks of that line disconnecting on me. Agent picked up and told me my claim's start date and confirmed EDD had received everything within the 41 days. That's real. I was surprised.

0 coins

Alright, fair. If the line keeps hanging up on me anyway I might as well try it.

0 coins

My determination letter came in the mail two days ago. I still don't understand why the wage continuation affected my PFL amount if my employer never actually paid it.

0 coins

The key piece here is that PFL can be combined with sick leave, vacation, or other paid time off your employer provides, but your wages from your employer plus the PFL benefit together cannot exceed your normal weekly wages. EDD accounts for reported wages in that calculation. If your employer reported the wage continuation as paid when it wasn't, or if EDD anticipated it, that could explain a reduced benefit. The fight with your employer is a separate matter from EDD entirely.

0 coins

So EDD might have reduced my benefit because they expected my employer to pay the top-up, even though the employer hasn't? That seems really unfair.

0 coins

Unfair, yes, but EDD goes by what's reported to them. Your employer not paying what they promised is an employment matter, not an EDD matter. HR and possibly a labor board complaint are your routes there.

0 coins

Does HR have to fix it immediately if you tell them? Or can they just say they'll get to it? I'm asking because my situation is kind of similar and I don't know how hard to push.

0 coins

The DE 2514 is the Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination, which is what EDD sends when a benefit is reduced or denied. It comes with an Appeal Form, the DE 1000A. You have 30 days from the date on that notice to appeal if you disagree with how EDD calculated your benefit. Worth reading that notice very carefully to see exactly what wages EDD said you received.

0 coins

The letter I got does say DE 2514 at the top. It lists a wage amount that I definitely have not received from my employer. So EDD is calculating my benefit as if I got paid when I didn't.

0 coins

Then your appeal should state clearly that the wages listed were not actually paid to you and include anything that proves it, like a pay stub showing no top-up was deposited. The 30-day window on that DE 1000A is firm so don't sit on it.

0 coins

30 days goes fast with a newborn, just want to flag that. File the appeal first, figure out the details second.

0 coins

Two different problems running at the same time here. EDD reduced your benefit based on wages they believe you received. Your employer promised those wages and didn't pay them. Those are independent claims and the resolution of one doesn't automatically fix the other. For the EDD side, the appeal is your tool. For the employer side, the California Labor Commissioner's office handles wage disputes.

0 coins

I hadn't thought about the Labor Commissioner. That's actually helpful. Can I do both at the same time, the EDD appeal and the labor complaint?

0 coins

Nothing stops you from doing both simultaneously. They operate completely independently of each other.

0 coins

Filing both at once makes sense here. Waiting on one while the other moves could cost you time and money you don't have right now.

0 coins

Pay stubs are going to be your most useful documents for both the EDD appeal and any labor complaint. Pull every stub from your leave period. If the top-up payments never appear in your bank statements or on your stubs, that's your proof that the wage continuation was not paid. Date and amount gaps will be obvious.

0 coins

My bank statements are clean, nothing from the employer beyond my last pre-leave paycheck. So the gap is very clear.

0 coins

Perfect documentation then. Bank statement showing no deposit plus a pay stub showing zero top-up wages equals exactly what EDD and the Labor Commissioner need to see.

0 coins

Screenshots of your SDI Online payment history could also help show what EDD issued versus what you should have gotten.

0 coins

Intermittent days reporting got messy on my claim, the DE 2580GF came and I wasn't sure which weeks to report, so I used Claimyr and got someone on the EDD Paid Family Leave line. The agent told me exactly which days were still pending and which had been processed already. Way less guessing than trying to read SDI Online on my own.

0 coins

When you got through, did the agent just read off the pending weeks or did they actually explain what to do next with the DE 2580GF anyway?

0 coins

Just read them off, the specific days pending and which were cleared. Told me to return the certification form for the remaining ones. That was it, pretty direct.

0 coins

been trying the EDD line most mornings for two weeks now and it just cuts off every time, no queue, nothing.

0 coins

Appeal first, ask questions second. The 30-day deadline on the DE 1000A doesn't wait for you to figure everything out. You can supplement your appeal with documents later but you can't refile if the window closes.

0 coins

Filed the appeal online this afternoon. Used the DE 1000A link in my myEDD account. I wrote that the wages EDD listed were never paid to me and attached my bank statement.

0 coins

Good. Now send something to your employer in writing too, email or letter, stating the top-up was not paid and asking when it will be.

0 coins

Great move filing today! Paper trail with the employer matters a lot if you end up with the Labor Commissioner later.

0 coins

your employer not paying you what they said they would is wild honestly, like whats the point of a wage continuation policy if they just dont do it

0 coins

Companies write those policies for recruiting. When it costs them money they find reasons to slow it down.

0 coins

yeah exactly, happened to my coworker too, company dragged their feet for like a month before paying anything

0 coins

EDD bases the PFL benefit on what wages are reported for your claim period. If your employer reported or will report the wage continuation amount, EDD uses that figure. If the employer never pays it and you appealed, EDD may adjust the benefit. But those two processes do not automatically sync, so you have to follow both tracks separately.

0 coins

Is there a scenario where EDD adjusts the benefit AND the employer eventually pays, so you'd end up overpaid? I'm worried about that happening to me in a similar setup.

0 coins

Possible, yes. If that happened, EDD would issue an overpayment notice. That's another thing you could appeal. Keep records of everything paid and when so the timeline is clear.

0 coins

My HR actually told me today they miscalculated the top-up amount and that's why they haven't paid. They're 'processing a correction.' I emailed back asking for the amount and the payment date in writing.

0 coins

Written confirmation from HR is the right move. Verbal promises from HR about pay get forgotten fast. Email works, keeps a timestamp.

0 coins

HR responded and confirmed the corrected amount in writing. Still waiting on the actual deposit though.

0 coins

If it doesn't hit by the date they gave you, forward that email chain to the Labor Commissioner. Done waiting.

0 coins

EDD appeal and labor complaint filed on the same week. I did that once. EDD ruled in about six weeks, Labor Commissioner took longer. Both in my favor in the end. No guarantees yours goes the same way, but it can work.

0 coins

That's really good to hear. I didn't know EDD appeal rulings could take that long though. Six weeks on no wages is rough.

0 coins

Rough, yes. That's how it went for me. If EDD owes you money and the appeal wins, they issue what they owe from the original claim date.

0 coins

DE 2514 on my claim said my benefit was partially denied for a reason I didn't agree with. Tried calling EDD for weeks, never got through. Ended up using Claimyr to reach someone on the PFL line. Agent confirmed the specific determination on file and told me what the denial reason code on that DE 2514 referred to.

0 coins

My own notice showed a figure I want to check against what EDD actually has coded. Would try Claimyr for that. What do you need on hand when you go through it?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, your claim ID from SDI Online, and your DE 2514 in front of you. The agent asked for all three right away.

0 coins

My determination letter finally makes a little more sense after reading this thread. The denial code on mine matches the wage continuation issue exactly.

0 coins

Wage continuation policies are really common in certain industries but how employers administer them varies a lot. Some pay it automatically, some require you to submit paperwork to HR every pay period while you're out. Worth double-checking whether HR needed something from you to trigger the payment that nobody told you about.

0 coins

HR just confirmed it was a payroll calculation error on their end, not a missing form from me. So at least I didn't miss a step.

0 coins

Okay good, so the error is on them entirely. That actually makes your labor complaint stronger if they don't fix it promptly.

0 coins

Payroll calculation error is fixable. At least it isn't a policy dispute, those drag on forever.

0 coins

Can EDD see when my employer pays the top-up after the fact? Like if my employer pays me the wage continuation in a lump sum later, will EDD automatically know and reduce my benefit retroactively?

0 coins

EDD can receive wage information from employers. If a lump sum payment is reported to EDD, it could affect your benefit calculation for that period. That's exactly why keeping your own records of what was paid and when is so important.

0 coins

The rule is that your PFL plus wages cannot exceed your normal weekly wages. If the lump sum gets reported for the weeks EDD already paid, EDD may send an overpayment notice. Appealing that notice is possible if you think the calculation is wrong.

0 coins

Okay so I need to track every payment date carefully. Got it. This whole thing is way more complicated than I expected when I went on leave.

0 coins

HR delayed mine too by almost three weeks, didn't tell me anything, I had to email twice to get any response. The delay messed up my budget for the whole first month. Anyway, the EDD part sorted out but I never did the labor complaint, probably should have.

0 coins

For anyone wondering, HR eventually paid in full including the weeks they skipped. Took more emails than I should have needed.

0 coins

Glad it worked out but that delay is not okay. Hope things smooth out for the original poster too.

0 coins

The benefit calculator on EDD's site helped me figure out what my weekly amount should have been before all the wage continuation stuff got added in. Might help you see the gap between what you should be getting from EDD and what they're actually paying!

0 coins

Ran the calculator earlier this week. The expected amount is definitely higher than what EDD has been paying me.

0 coins

That gap might be the exact number you cite in your appeal! Use whatever the calculator shows as a reference point.

0 coins

The official amount comes from the Notice of Computation, not the calculator. The calculator is an estimate. Cite the DE 429DF for the actual figure.

0 coins

sent HR three emails in two days once and finally cc'd my manager and suddenly they responded that afternoon. sometimes you have to involve someone above HR to make anything move.

0 coins

Copied my manager on the latest email this morning. Response came within two hours. Worth trying for sure.

0 coins

yeah manager loop usually works, HR knows someone is watching then.

0 coins

The PFL benefit is there to cover your wage loss from not working. When your employer adds wage continuation on top, EDD accounts for the combined total so it doesn't exceed your normal pay. The issue you're describing is that EDD acted on a wage continuation that never actually landed in your account.

0 coins

That's exactly the problem in one sentence. EDD reduced my benefit for wages I haven't received.

0 coins

Your appeal is essentially telling EDD those wages were not paid during the benefit period. Bank statement and pay stub together make that argument cleanly.

0 coins

Simple case if the proof is right there in black and white. EDD appeal reviewers see paper, they don't take your word for it.

0 coins

did you get your notice of computation at least? want to make sure edd even has the right base period wages before all the wage continuation stuff came into the picture

0 coins

Yeah the DE 429DF came about a week after I filed. The base period wages look right. The issue only started when the employer wage continuation got factored in.

0 coins

ok good at least the base is right, that wouldve been a whole other problem to fix

0 coins

The appeal confirmation in SDI Online usually shows up within a day or two of submitting online. Keep an eye on your claim status so you know EDD actually received it and has it connected to your claim ID.

0 coins

Checked SDI Online this morning and the appeal does show as received. Feeling slightly less panicked than I was when I first posted this.

0 coins

That's the status you want to see. Now it's in their hands and you've done everything you can on the EDD side for the moment.

0 coins

Follow up with HR once more in writing asking for a confirmed payment date. Keep that thread going in parallel.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure