Back to California Paid Family Leave

Geoff Richards

PFL claim disqualified no notice of determination appeal form 1000a — where do I even start?

So I'm kind of freaking out right now. Filed my PFL bonding claim back in October for my daughter and everything seemed fine at first, got my Notice of Computation and thought I was good to go. Then out of nowhere the payments just stopped. When I checked SDI Online it was showing my claim as disqualified but there was nothing in the mail, no letter explaining why, nothing. I've been waiting three weeks thinking something was just delayed. My coworker said I should have gotten a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination and an appeal form with it but I never received either. Do I just wait longer or is there a way to appeal without the actual form? I still have weeks left in my bonding window and I don't want to lose them.

The same thing happened to a neighbor of mine last year and I helped her sort through it. The notice you're looking for is the DE 2514, that's the determination letter EDD sends when a claim isn't approved. It comes with the Appeal Form DE 1000A attached. If yours never arrived, you can appeal in SDI Online or just download the DE 1000A from EDD's site and mail it in. The key thing is the 30-day window runs from when EDD issued the determination, not when you received it, so I would not wait any longer.

0 coins

Wait so the 30 days started when they made the decision, not when I got the letter? That's terrifying because I don't even know when they decided.

0 coins

Exactly the concern. Log into SDI Online right now and use Request Claim Update to ask EDD the date the determination was issued. That tells you how much time you have left to appeal.

0 coins

Ok logging in now. I had no idea the clock started on their end.

0 coins

The DE 1000A is the appeal form and it doesn't require the original notice to submit it. EDD's site lists it under the PFL forms section. You fill it out with your name, claim ID, and the reason you disagree with the determination, then send it to the address on EDD's Office Locator for your area or submit online.

0 coins

Is there a specific reason you have to give? Like do you need to explain the whole situation or can you just say you disagree?

0 coins

You should explain why you think the decision is wrong, whatever you know about your situation. The more specific the better, but you don't need legal language, just your own account of the facts.

0 coins

I'm not sure if this matters but I think you can also ask EDD to send you a copy of the determination if you never got it, so you know exactly what they said the reason was before you write the appeal.

0 coins

Two weeks of going back part time after my daughter was born, and my second payment never showed up. I'd been calling the PFL line every morning and either got a busy signal or the recording cut me off. Finally tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and ended up talking to an actual EDD agent. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. I'd been reporting my intermittent days but the agent said EDD hadn't received my DE 2580GF for the second week. She walked me through what was missing and I had the form resubmitted by that afternoon.

0 coins

That Claimyr thing sounds like something someone pays to have you post about. EDD's phone line is what it is and I don't see how a third party fixes that.

0 coins

I thought the same thing honestly! But I'd been trying that line for eight days straight and tried it out of pure desperation. The agent I reached told me the payment method on my claim had been set to check even though I'd chosen direct deposit in SDI Online, which is why nothing was hitting my bank. Got it corrected on the spot!

0 coins

Alright fair. If the agent actually spotted something like that I guess it's worth trying. Might give it a shot when I'm ready to ask about my own situation.

0 coins

I didn't even know you could check the payment method setting through a call. Good to know that can get fixed.

0 coins

EDD disqualifying someone with no explanation mailed is unfortunately not rare. The DE 2514 sometimes goes to an old address or just gets lost. The 30-day appeal window is brutal when that happens.

0 coins

Does EDD update the status in SDI Online at the same time they mail the notice? Because if so at least you'd see the date it was issued.

0 coins

In my experience the SDI Online status changes around the same time, yeah. That's how I found out about my own denial before the letter ever came.

0 coins

Sending the appeal before the letter arrives seems scary but it's the right move here.

0 coins

Don't sit on this. File the appeal now, even without the letter. Put in writing that you never received the DE 2514 and that you're appealing the disqualification. That's your record that you acted within the window.

0 coins

That's what I'll do. I'd rather appeal too early than miss the cutoff while waiting for mail that may never show.

0 coins

Agreed. Paper trail matters. Send it certified mail if you're mailing it so you have proof of the date.

0 coins

I'm going through something similar right now and I'm so confused. My PFL bonding claim just says disqualified and I haven't gotten anything by mail either. Does the disqualification mean I lose all my remaining bonding weeks or just that I can't get paid until I appeal?

0 coins

You can appeal and if EDD reverses the determination those weeks can still be paid, as long as you're within the 12 months from the birth or placement date. The appeal stops the clock on the decision, not on the bonding window itself.

0 coins

Ok so the 12 months keeps running even during an appeal. I really need to get that form in.

0 coins

The good news is both of you found out quickly enough to still appeal. That 30-day window goes fast but you have it.

0 coins

EDD sent me a DE 2514 once for a care claim and the reason listed was something I could have easily cleared up with a document. The appeal form asks you to state why you disagree and I just attached the missing document with mine. Went fine.

0 coins

Did you send the document separately or attach it right to the appeal form?

0 coins

Attached it directly to the form. One envelope, one submission. EDD's address for appeals is on the determination letter if you have it, or the Office Locator on EDD's site.

0 coins

This is helpful to know. If the reason on mine turns out to be a document issue I'll do the same thing.

0 coins

edd does this thing where they just quietly disqualify you and act like the notice is optional lol. file the appeal regardless, dont wait for the letter

0 coins

That's exactly what it felt like. Quietly disqualified with no warning.

0 coins

yeah happened to my roommate too, he just filed the de 1000a without having the original notice and it was fine

0 coins

Waiting for the proof of relationship to get matched on my bonding claim, been nine days. Used Claimyr to reach someone at EDD when the online status hadn't changed and I wanted to know if the birth certificate had been received. Quick question though, what did you say when the agent picked up, like how did you start the conversation?

0 coins

I just gave them my Social Security number and claim ID right away and said what I needed to know. The agent pulled up the claim immediately and went from there.

0 coins

Got it, that's straightforward. My agent confirmed the birth certificate was in the system but hadn't been matched to the claim yet. She said to give it a couple more days and check SDI Online.

0 coins

been trying that line myself since tuesday, every morning, keeps cutting me off after the menu. three days now

0 coins

Submit the DE 1000A as soon as possible and state clearly that the determination letter never arrived. Keep a copy of everything you send. If you used SDI Online to file the appeal, screenshot the confirmation.

0 coins

Screenshot the confirmation, yes. I would not have thought to do that.

0 coins

You'd be surprised how often that screenshot becomes the only proof you filed in time.

0 coins

October 14th I filed my own bonding claim. By November 3rd I had my Notice of Computation with the weekly benefit amount. What I didn't know is that the determination is a separate step and can go differently. If the status in SDI Online says disqualified, the DE 2514 is what explains why, and you need that reason before you can write a strong appeal.

0 coins

I requested a copy of the DE 2514 through SDI Online this morning using the Request Claim Update option. Hoping they respond fast.

0 coins

Good move. That date on the determination is what you need to calculate how much of the 30 days you still have.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation and the actual eligibility determination are two different things and I think a lot of people assume the first one means they're approved. It doesn't confirm anything about the final decision.

0 coins

I'm not sure if this applies here but I thought if EDD sends a determination notice and you never get it, they'd still expect you to appeal within 30 days of when they sent it. Is that really true? That seems really unfair if the letter got lost.

0 coins

That's unfortunately how it works. The 30 days runs from EDD's issue date. The best thing to do is appeal right away and explain in the form that the notice was never received. EDD can take that into account.

0 coins

That's really worrying. I had no idea the timer starts even if you never saw the letter.

0 coins

The explanation in the form matters more than people think. Put it plainly, say the letter didn't come, and appeal anyway.

0 coins

In SDI Online you can submit a Request Claim Update to ask EDD for the date the DE 2514 was issued. That's the fastest way to find out exactly where you stand with the 30-day window without waiting for a letter that may not come.

0 coins

I didn't know the Request Claim Update could ask something that specific. I thought it was just for general status.

0 coins

You can write anything as your question. Be specific: say you're asking for the issue date of the DE 2514 on your claim and your claim ID.

0 coins

Proof of relationship on my bonding claim got held up for two weeks and I couldn't get a straight answer through SDI Online messages. Used Claimyr to reach EDD and the agent told me the Declaration of Paternity I'd uploaded hadn't been matched to the claim yet, it was sitting unmatched in the system. She confirmed it was there and said it should clear within a few business days.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation came through but now the claim shows something unexpected. I want to ask EDD directly what's on the determination before I write the appeal. Going to try Claimyr for that. What should I have ready when the agent picks up?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, your claim ID from the SDI Online confirmation page, and know the specific question you want answered. The agent pulled mine up fast once I had all three.

0 coins

That unmatched document issue sounds like exactly what might have caused my own disqualification. Hadn't considered that.

0 coins

If the reason for disqualification turns out to be a proof of relationship issue, uploading the document in SDI Online after the fact won't undo the determination. You'd need to include it with the appeal or resubmit it and reference the appeal number. The appeal is what gets the case reconsidered.

0 coins

So uploading to SDI Online on its own doesn't fix the disqualification. Got it. The appeal has to happen regardless.

0 coins

Right, the appeal is the formal step. Documents can support it but they don't replace it.

0 coins

My bonding claim got approved no problem but I remember being terrified when it went past 10 days with no movement. I can only imagine seeing the word disqualified without any explanation. Filing the appeal right away is definitely the move here.

0 coins

Honestly it's been one of the more stressful things I've dealt with. The appeal is going in today.

0 coins

Good! And keep an eye on SDI Online after you submit. The status usually updates once the appeal is received.

0 coins

Something worth mentioning: PFL has no waiting period before benefits start, unlike disability. No seven unpaid days before the first check. So if someone told you there's a waiting period for PFL, that's not right.

0 coins

wait i thought there was a waiting period, my sister told me that

0 coins

That's the disability program, not PFL. Different thing entirely. PFL starts paying from day one of the claim.

0 coins

ok good to know ill tell her she was mixing them up

0 coins

Disqualified on my care claim two months ago and I genuinely didn't know you could appeal without the original notice. Filed the DE 1000A from EDD's site and cited the reason from memory. Still waiting on the outcome.

0 coins

Two months waiting on appeal outcome is a long time. Hope it resolves soon.

0 coins

yeah me too. they don't tell you how long it takes so you just sit with it

0 coins

The DE 1000A has a line for explaining your situation in your own words. Use it. The appeals office reads these and a clear, calm explanation of why you disagree with the determination goes a long way.

0 coins

Is there a word limit or length limit on that section?

0 coins

Not that I've ever seen. Write what you need to, just keep it factual and to the point.

0 coins

Attaching any supporting documents you have is wise too. If the disqualification was about proof of relationship or missing information, include everything that shows otherwise.

0 coins

Update for anyone following: I submitted the DE 1000A this afternoon through SDI Online and explained in writing that the DE 2514 never arrived by mail. Also sent a Request Claim Update asking EDD to confirm the determination date. I feel a lot better having it in writing. I'll post again when I hear anything back.

0 coins

Well done. You acted quickly and have a clear record now. That's exactly the right approach.

0 coins

Make sure you saved or printed the confirmation of the appeal submission. You'll want that if the date is ever questioned.

0 coins

Fingers crossed the appeal goes your way. The fact that you got the form in without the letter arriving shows you did everything you could.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure