Back to California Paid Family Leave

Brianna Schmidt

Is PFL different from employer baby bonding leave? Trying to figure out what I actually have

My company has something in our benefits packet called 'baby bonding leave' and I just found out about California EDD's Paid Family Leave program and now I'm completely confused about whether these are the same thing or two totally separate things. I go on leave in about six weeks when my wife is due and I honestly don't know which one pays me, which one protects my job, or if I'm supposed to file with EDD at all. HR gave me a one-pager that mentions both and I'm more confused than before I read it. Can someone explain the difference? Like is PFL different from employer baby bonding leave or are they the same program with different names?

Fourteen days after I filed my bonding claim, the Notice of Computation showed up in SDI Online and I had no idea what it meant, so I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone at EDD on the phone. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the weekly benefit amount on the DE 429DF and confirmed it was based on my highest-earning quarter in the base period. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. What I learned from that call: the Notice of Computation is not an approval, it just shows what you'd get if EDD finds you eligible. The actual approval comes later, and if you're denied you get a DE 2514 instead. Those two things are completely separate.

0 coins

The weekly benefit amount on my own notice was what I couldn't make sense of either. Used Claimyr the same way and once the agent picked up she told me exactly which date my first payment was issued, so I knew to watch for it.

0 coins

been trying that line for three mornings, hangs up every time. glad something worked for you two

0 coins

To answer your actual question: PFL and your employer's baby bonding leave are two separate things that can run at the same time. California EDD's PFL pays you a wage replacement, somewhere between 70 and 90 percent of your normal wages depending on your income, for up to eight weeks. Your employer's leave is whatever your company promises in its own policy. Neither one is the other. PFL does not protect your job. Job protection, if you have it, comes from CFRA or FMLA, and that is between you and your employer, not EDD.

0 coins

So my company's leave policy is what keeps my job safe, and EDD's PFL is what actually pays me during that time? I think I've been treating them as one thing this whole time.

0 coins

Exactly right. Think of it as two layers: EDD pays the money, your employer (and CFRA if it applies) handles the job. They work alongside each other, they're not the same thing.

0 coins

HR is the right call for the job protection piece. EDD handles the money side, full stop.

0 coins

You file with EDD yourself through SDI Online. HR doesn't do it for you. Go to myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ and file no earlier than your first day of leave and no later than 41 days after that. Miss that window and you lose benefits for those days.

0 coins

41 days from the first day of leave, not from the birth date? Want to make sure I have the right starting point.

0 coins

First day of your leave is the clock. If you start leave the day after the baby arrives, day one of leave is that day, not the birth. File in that window and you're fine.

0 coins

I didn't realize it was SDI Online inside myEDD, not a separate site. Almost filed in the wrong place I think.

0 coins

Your employer's bonding leave might actually top up EDD's PFL payment, depending on how generous the policy is. Some employers let you use vacation or sick time on top of PFL so you get closer to your full paycheck. But wages plus PFL can't add up to more than your normal pay, so check with HR on how they combine it. It varies a lot by company.

0 coins

Our policy says something about 'coordinating' leave benefits but I didn't know that meant they were capping the total. Good to know before I assume I'm getting double.

0 coins

yeah same thing happened to a coworker, she thought she was getting both payments full size and then realized EDD's amount gets offset lol. def ask HR how they calculate it

0 coins

Tracking which weeks EDD had paid versus which were still pending got confusing on my own bonding claim, so I ended up using Claimyr to reach an agent. She looked at my claim and told me exactly which weeks had been paid out and when the next payment was scheduled to process. That cleared up the gap I was seeing in SDI Online where it looked like a week had been skipped.

0 coins

Not convinced anything gets through on that line. Tried at least six times over two weeks. What made you think it would work?

0 coins

Honestly I'd had the same experience before I tried it. Claimyr handles the hold time for you and your phone rings when an EDD agent picks up. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

Used it myself when I needed to know how many of my eight weeks were left after a care claim ran earlier in the year. Agent confirmed I had three weeks remaining for bonding, which was exactly what I needed to plan the schedule.

0 coins

The employer leave vs EDD thing tripped me up too at first. My company called theirs 'parental leave' and I genuinely thought that was what PFL stood for. They are not the same and EDD does not know or care what your company calls its own policy.

0 coins

same exact confusion here, thought parental leave meant i was already covered and almost didnt file with edd at all

0 coins

Nearly did that myself. File with EDD regardless of what your employer offers. The two exist independently.

0 coins

EDD's program and your employer's are written nowhere near the same page. One's state law, one's an HR document.

0 coins

Eight weeks sounds like a lot until you remember it's one pool for bonding AND care claims in the same 12 months. Use five weeks bonding now and you've got three left if you need a care claim later that year. Anyway just something I found out the hard way.

0 coins

Wait, they share the same eight weeks? I assumed bonding had its own eight and care claims had their own eight.

0 coins

They share it. EDD is clear on that: up to eight weeks total across bonding, care and military assist within any 12-month period. Not eight weeks per type. Someone corrected me on exactly this mistake a while back.

0 coins

This is the part nobody mentions in any HR packet I've ever seen. Good to know before I make plans around numbers that aren't real.

0 coins

CFRA and PFL are not the same law, not the same agency, not the same application. CFRA is job protection from your employer. PFL is money from EDD. You can have both running at once. You can have one without the other. Ask HR about CFRA. File with EDD for PFL.

0 coins

So technically I could get PFL money from EDD but still not have job protection if my employer doesn't offer CFRA or the company is too small?

0 coins

Correct. PFL pays you. It doesn't touch your job. That's the employer's territory.

0 coins

This is the thing that catches people off guard most often. EDD sends money, your employer decides the job. They're in different lanes entirely.

0 coins

PFL doesn't have a waiting period either, which surprised me! With disability I had to wait seven days before anything paid out, but when I moved from my pregnancy disability claim to the bonding claim there was no extra wait. The bonding benefits started right where the disability left off.

0 coins

I told my friend PFL had a waiting period and she almost delayed filing because of that. Glad I found out I was wrong before she missed any days.

0 coins

No waiting period on PFL. That's worth repeating because a lot of people expect one since disability does have unpaid days at the start. Bonding starts paying from day one of leave.

0 coins

the pregnancy disability to bonding handoff is confusing in general, glad its at least not adding an extra unpaid gap

0 coins

if your company has a parental leave policy that pays full salary just check whether they still want you to file with edd anyway. some employers require it and then offset the difference themselves. dont assume filing is optional just because the company is paying you

0 coins

HR at my job was really specific about this. They wanted the EDD claim filed first and then they topped up from their side. Would have been a whole mess if I hadn't asked.

0 coins

Calling HR tomorrow. I genuinely didn't know the employer might require the EDD filing even when they're paying full salary.

0 coins

Two weeks after my bonding payment processed I still couldn't find the DE 2500E in SDI Online, so I tried Claimyr to get someone at EDD. Agent looked at my claim and confirmed the electronic payment notification had gone to the wrong email address on file. Got that updated the same afternoon and saw the payment details the next morning.

0 coins

What even is Claimyr? Haven't heard of it.

0 coins

It waits on EDD's hold line so you don't have to, and when an agent picks up it rings your phone. That's it.

0 coins

Oh ok. I'd want to ask about why my second intermittent week isn't showing as paid. Might try that.

0 coins

Proof of relationship is what EDD needs from every new parent except the birth mother. Birth certificate works once it's issued. If it's not ready yet, a Declaration of Paternity form CS-909 can work too. Upload it in SDI Online, don't mail it.

0 coins

Declaration of Paternity I didn't know was an option. The hospital gave us one to sign and I had no idea it could substitute for the birth certificate while we wait for the official copy.

0 coins

Keep it. If the birth certificate is delayed it's a useful backup for EDD.

0 coins

I'd been waiting to file until I had the birth certificate in hand. didn't realize there was another option.

0 coins

The eight weeks don't have to be taken all at once either. You can break them up and use a few days here, a few there, within 12 months of the birth. So if you want to go back part time for a while you can use PFL for the days you're not working.

0 coins

Is that handled on the same claim or do you have to refile every time you take a day?

0 coins

Same claim. You just report the days you worked and the wages you earned. EDD sends a Continued Claim Certification form to fill out and send back so they know to keep paying.

0 coins

yeah if you dont return that form payments stop, found that out the annoying way

0 coins

Don't file twice if SDI Online gives you a receipt number the first time. I know the pending screen looks like nothing happened but it did. Second filing creates a mess that takes weeks to sort out.

0 coins

Mine said pending for almost nine days with no update. I was about to file again.

0 coins

Don't. Up to 14 days is normal for EDD to decide. Leave it alone.

0 coins

the pending screen is designed to give you anxiety i swear

0 coins

To directly answer your original question since it's gotten a bit buried: PFL is California's state program, administered by EDD, that replaces part of your wages. Your employer's baby bonding leave is whatever your company decided to offer on its own. They can run at the same time. Neither one is a subset of the other.

0 coins

Thank you for pulling it back. I think what I've figured out from this thread is: file with EDD for the money, talk to HR about the job, and do both regardless of what the company policy says.

0 coins

That is exactly the right takeaway.

0 coins

The PFL weekly amount is based on wages from your base period, the 12 months that ended about 5 months before your claim starts. If you changed jobs or had a low-earning quarter recently it could affect what your notice shows. EDD's site has a calculator if you want an estimate before the Notice of Computation arrives.

0 coins

I changed from part time to full time about eight months ago so I was wondering if the base period would catch the lower wages. Sounds like it might.

0 coins

Your highest-earning quarter in that base period is what they use. If your full-time months fall in that highest quarter, it helps. The notice will show you the exact number they're using.

0 coins

If your wife is the birth mom she'll go through SDI for the pregnancy disability part first, then transition to PFL bonding after. That's a different form, the DE 2501FP, and EDD mails it to her when the disability claim winds down. You file your own bonding claim separately as the other parent.

0 coins

We're both planning to take leave. So she files via the pregnancy disability path and I file a separate bonding claim on my own?

0 coins

Exactly. Two separate claims, two separate filings. EDD handles them independently.

0 coins

I didn't realize both parents could have active PFL claims at the same time. I assumed one claim covered the household.

0 coins

The 41-day deadline is from your first day of leave, and I cannot stress enough that this counts calendar days, not business days. I almost let it slide thinking I had extra time for weekends.

0 coins

Calendar days. Writing that down. So if I start leave on a Monday, day 41 is the same day of the week six weeks later?

0 coins

Count it out manually or mark it on a calendar the day leave starts. Don't eyeball it.

0 coins

Filed on day 39 because I kept thinking I had more time. Would have lost two days of benefits if I'd waited one more weekend.

0 coins

Your employer's baby bonding policy is a contract between you and them. EDD has nothing to do with enforcing it or caring whether they follow through. If the company shortchanges you on their own leave, that's HR and possibly an employment attorney, not EDD.

0 coins

Good to know those disputes live in completely different places. EDD can't fix a problem with my company's internal policy.

0 coins

Correct. EDD administers the state program. What your employer promises is their own business.

0 coins

Don't forget payments go out every two weeks once the claim is approved and running. If you're taking all eight weeks straight you'll see one payment every two weeks covering that period. Some people expect weekly deposits and then panic when nothing shows up after day seven.

0 coins

I would absolutely have done that. Good to have the right expectation set before I start staring at my bank account.

0 coins

stared at mine for a full week before the first one hit. the two-week cycle feels like forever when youre not working

0 coins

The one thing i'd add: EDD pays you for the leave days you aren't working. If you pick up any shifts or earn any wages during leave you have to report them. Not reporting is what causes overpayments and those are a nightmare to deal with after the fact anyway.

0 coins

Even if it's just one day back at work during the eight weeks?

0 coins

Even one day. Report it. EDD will adjust the payment for that week. It's easier than sorting out an overpayment notice later.

0 coins

my coworker didnt report three days and got an overpayment letter two months later, was not fun for him

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure