Back to California Paid Family Leave

Andre Rousseau

How to make up difference between paid family leave and full salary — what are my options?

So I just got my Notice of Computation and the weekly amount is decent but it's definitely not what I normally bring home. I work in marketing and my base salary is pretty solid, so the gap is real. I go out on PFL bonding leave in about three weeks when my partner's maternity leave wraps up, and I've been trying to figure out what I can actually do to close that gap. My employer mentioned something about being able to use PTO alongside PFL but I'm not totally clear on how that works or whether there are limits. Does anyone have experience supplementing PFL to get closer to your normal pay? What did your employer actually allow?

Ask your HR department directly whether they have a supplementation policy. California EDD allows sick leave, vacation, or other paid time off to run alongside PFL, but your employer sets the terms of how that works. The one thing EDD does enforce is that your combined wages from your employer and your PFL benefit can't exceed what you'd normally earn in a week, excluding overtime. So if your PTO plus PFL would push you over your regular weekly pay, EDD adjusts the benefit down.

0 coins

That cap makes sense actually. So in theory if my employer pays out enough PTO to cover the gap, the PFL just shrinks to fill whatever's left under my normal pay. I'll ask HR Monday.

0 coins

Wait, does EDD even know if you're getting PTO at the same time? Do you have to report it somehow?

0 coins

You report any wages you earn to EDD, including paid leave that your employer pays out. Not reporting it can lead to an overpayment, and those are a headache to sort out.

0 coins

Talked to my foreman about this when my youngest was born. His advice was to bank as much PTO as possible before the leave starts. Can't tell you what your company allows but that's what I did. Ended up comfortable enough.

0 coins

Banking it ahead of time is smart. I've got about two weeks saved, which won't cover the full eight but it helps.

0 coins

Two weeks of PTO on top of PFL is better than nothing. Most guys I know just take the hit on the difference.

0 coins

Direct deposit question on my own bonding claim led me to Claimyr (claimyr.com) a few weeks back. I'd filed in SDI Online and selected direct deposit, but after ten days the payment method still showed as pending and I had no idea if it had gone through. Spent most of three mornings trying the PFL line and kept getting the high-volume recording that drops the call. So I tried Claimyr and ended up talking to an EDD agent. She confirmed the direct deposit had been accepted and my bank account was linked correctly, and told me the first payment would issue after the claim cleared its eligibility review. Here's the video they have on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

The receipt number question on my care claim is the one I'd want answered. I filed for my dad and I'm not sure EDD ever matched the number to his Part D. Would Claimyr work for something like that?

0 coins

Have your receipt number ready, the date you filed, and your dad's name as it appears on the claim. The agent can pull up the claim and tell you exactly what's been received. That's the kind of thing they can check on the spot.

0 coins

That payment method limbo is the worst, honestly. I had no idea if my direct deposit was set up right either and I just kept refreshing SDI Online hoping something would change.

0 coins

Good to know there's a way to actually reach someone! I've been dreading making that call for my own claim!

0 coins

The benefit calculator on EDD's site is worth running before your leave starts. Plug in your highest-earning quarter from the base period and you'll get an estimate close to what your Notice of Computation shows. Once you know the gap to your normal weekly pay, you can figure out exactly how much PTO you'd need your employer to pay out to cover it.

0 coins

Already ran the calculator before filing actually. The Notice came in about where it predicted. The gap is roughly a quarter of my normal take-home, give or take.

0 coins

I keep second-guessing whether I entered the right quarter into the calculator. Is it always the highest quarter in the 12 months before the claim, or does EDD pick a different window?

0 coins

EDD looks at a 12-month base period made up of four quarters, and the benefit is based on the highest of those four quarters. The Notice of Computation will spell out exactly which quarter they used for yours.

0 coins

Mine came out lower than the calculator said and I still don't know why. The notice didn't explain it in a way I understood.

0 coins

my job had no supplementation policy at all so i just took the gap and tightened up spending. not ideal but pfl is way better than nothing fr

0 coins

Yeah that's probably where I'll end up if HR says no. PFL covering 70-ish percent is still a lot better than zero.

0 coins

exactly. and 8 weeks goes fast so its like you barely feel it budget wise in the long run

0 coins

Before assuming your employer will top it up, check your offer letter or employee handbook. Some companies have a formal supplementation policy written in; others leave it entirely to manager discretion. Getting it in writing before your leave starts saves arguments later.

0 coins

Pulling up the handbook tonight. Good call.

0 coins

Agreed. HR verbally promising something and then processing it differently once payroll is involved happens more than people expect. Written confirmation is worth the follow-up email.

0 coins

Went through a confusing stretch on my own bonding claim where I wasn't sure EDD had matched my receipt number to anything. Filed in SDI Online and got a confirmation screen, but the status page looked the same for over a week with nothing updating. I tried Claimyr and the agent pulled up the claim on her end. She read me the receipt number EDD had on file and confirmed it matched what I'd written down from the confirmation page. Status moved to a decision within two days after that call.

0 coins

The receipt number matching up is what I needed confirmed on my own claim too. After getting that sorted by an EDD agent, I noticed a DE 2514 had been mailed, so I knew I had 30 days to appeal if I disagreed with the determination. Went ahead and sent the appeal in.

0 coins

been trying that line for days and nothing. what time did you manage to get through

0 coins

The agent I spoke with was EDD's own staff. I didn't track the time specifically, just that it connected during regular hours. The main thing is having your claim ID and the receipt number from your confirmation page on hand before anything.

0 coins

ok might just try it. tired of the recording every single time

0 coins

PFL is a wage replacement benefit, not a full salary replacement. That gap is by design. Your employer topping it up is a favor, not a right.

0 coins

Blunt but accurate.

0 coins

Fair point. I went in knowing it wouldn't be 100%, just trying to minimize the hit.

0 coins

My salon has no policy either way so I basically negotiated with my owner to let me use my accrued tips as a kind of float. Totally informal, not sure how that worked on the EDD side, but it got me through the gap okay.

0 coins

Tips are wages, so they'd count toward your base period earnings and also need to be reported if you receive them while on leave. Might be worth confirming with EDD how yours were handled.

0 coins

Honestly I should have asked more questions at the time but the baby was here and I was just surviving, lol.

0 coins

I'm about to file for PFL bonding for my son and I'm terrified about the income gap. Does PFL have that seven-day waiting period like regular disability? Because if I lose the first week of pay on top of the gap that's going to be rough.

0 coins

PFL doesn't have a waiting period. That seven-day unpaid stretch is for Disability Insurance, which is a separate program. Your PFL bonding benefits start from the first day of leave with no unpaid week at the beginning.

0 coins

Oh thank goodness. I had read something about a waiting period and panicked. That's a relief.

0 coins

I made the same mistake. Spent a week worried about that before someone clarified it. The waiting period is DI, not PFL.

0 coins

Came here partly because I mixed those up too at first. Glad someone asked.

0 coins

Your employer either tops it up or they don't. EDD isn't going to close the gap for you. Figure out your budget for eight weeks and go from there.

0 coins

Somewhat grim but useful framing. Running the numbers now.

0 coins

Better to know before the leave than to be surprised two weeks in.

0 coins

At my retail job they let us stack up to two weeks of PTO on top of PFL, then you're on your own after that. Covered most of the gap for the first two weeks at least. After that I just cut expenses lol.

0 coins

Two weeks of coverage is still something. What did your PTO payout look like on paper, did they just add it to a regular paycheck or was it separate?

0 coins

They processed it as a normal payroll payment, same check as always. The PFL came separately through EDD. So I had two income streams for those weeks.

0 coins

Two streams is cleaner to track than I expected. I kept thinking it would be this whole mess with EDD getting confused about wages but...

0 coins

The Notice of Computation on my bonding claim had an amount that didn't match what I calculated from my own pay stubs, so I needed someone at EDD to actually explain which quarter they'd used. Three days of trying that phone line and I never got through, so I tried Claimyr. The agent told me the base period quarter EDD had on file and what wages were recorded in it. Turned out one paycheck from a secondary gig hadn't been captured, which was why my benefit was lower than I'd figured.

0 coins

Not buying it honestly. I've tried that line maybe a dozen times over two weeks, mornings, afternoons, whatever, and I've never reached a person. How is some service getting through when I can't even stay on hold long enough for the recording to finish

0 coins

The line I kept hitting just played the high-volume message and ended the call. What Claimyr does is essentially sit on the line in my place until a live person picks up, and then my phone rings so I can take it from there. I was skeptical for the same reason you are, but the person I spoke with was definitely an EDD agent, answered questions about my actual claim.

0 coins

Had a care claim for my mom, used Claimyr too. Agent told me EDD had not received the Part D from her doctor yet, even though the office said they'd mailed it. That was useful to know so I could follow up with the office directly.

0 coins

ok fine, that actually addresses something real. if it means i can find out whether EDD got my son's birth certificate i guess ill consider it

0 coins

My sister went back to work part time after six weeks because the income gap was too much! She said EDD had her reporting her days worked and they adjusted the benefit for the weeks she worked. So you can go back part time and still get some PFL, which helps close the gap without burning through all eight weeks at once!

0 coins

That's correct. PFL can be taken intermittently, so going back part time is an option. You report any days worked and wages earned to EDD, and EDD sends a Continued Claim Certification form that you fill out and return. If you don't return it, payments stop.

0 coins

Intermittent is actually something I hadn't thought about. If the gap gets bad enough I could potentially go back a few days a week and stretch the eight weeks out.

0 coins

Exactly! That's what she did and it worked out really well for her budget!

0 coins

I'm confused about whether PFL and CFRA are the same thing or different. I keep seeing CFRA mentioned when people talk about leave and I don't know if I need to file for both.

0 coins

They're different. PFL is the EDD benefit that pays you during leave, up to eight weeks. CFRA is a job protection law that may run at the same time and keeps your position secure, but it doesn't pay you anything on its own. PFL pays; CFRA protects. Talk to HR about whether CFRA applies to your situation, since that depends on your employer and circumstances.

0 coins

So I need to ask HR about CFRA separately and file with EDD for the PFL money. Got it, thank you.

0 coins

This was my exact confusion a month ago. The EDD claim is just for the benefit payment. Job protection is a separate conversation with your employer.

0 coins

Eight weeks sounds like a lot until you're living on 70 percent of your pay. Plan for the worst case where your employer says no to PTO stacking. If you can survive that budget, anything extra is a bonus.

0 coins

Genuinely good advice. I've been budgeting at the full PFL amount with no PTO top-up, and if HR comes through it's just a cushion.

0 coins

That's the right way to look at it.

0 coins

just realized the eight weeks is shared between bonding and care leave right? like if my wife uses six weeks bonding with the baby i only have two left if i need care leave in the same year?

0 coins

Actually each parent files their own separate PFL claim, so your wife's eight weeks and yours are independent of each other. The limit is per claimant, not per household.

0 coins

oh that's a huge relief, i thought we were splitting one pot. so i have my own full eight weeks regardless of what she uses.

0 coins

Correct. The 12-month window for using them runs from your child's birth or placement date, separately for each of you.

0 coins

the gap hit harder than i expected. had a rough second month but pushed through it. nothing clever to add, it just is what it is

0 coins

Appreciated. Sometimes knowing other people made it through the tight stretch is enough.

0 coins

Same. Month two was the hard one for us too.

0 coins

If your employer does agree to supplement, ask payroll to confirm in writing how they'll report the PTO wages. You want both EDD and your employer working from the same picture of what you're earning each week so there are no overpayment surprises later.

0 coins

Written confirmation from payroll, check. I'll ask specifically how they code the PTO weeks on their end.

0 coins

An overpayment notice from EDD is fixable but it's a hassle. Getting it straight beforehand is a better use of your time.

0 coins

How do you even deal with an overpayment if EDD sends one? Do you just pay it back?

0 coins

EDD sends a notice. You can appeal within 30 days if you think the amount is wrong or if you believe you qualified for a waiver. The Appeal Form is the DE 1000A, and it comes with the notice.

0 coins

To bring it back to the original question: the PFL-to-salary gap is basically on you and your employer to solve, not EDD. EDD pays the percentage it pays. Your levers are PTO supplementation if your employer allows it, stretching the leave intermittently to stay partly on payroll, or just budgeting around the smaller amount for eight weeks. None of those is perfect but they're the real options.

0 coins

Pretty solid summary. HR meeting is Monday, I'll know more then. If they say no to supplementation I'll probably go intermittent for the back half of leave.

0 coins

Let us know what HR says. Would be curious whether they have a formal policy or just handle it case by case.

0 coins

Will do. Seems like it really varies company to company from everything in this thread.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure