Back to California Paid Family Leave

Gianna Scott

How long does PFL appeal take after denial for employer paycheck situation

So my PFL claim got denied and I'm honestly not sure what to do next. I was caring for my dad who had a pretty serious health issue and needed me there full time for several weeks. Filed everything through SDI Online, got Part C and Part D in, thought I did everything right. Then I got a denial notice in the mail and I'm kind of panicking. The notice mentioned something about wages and I think it has to do with the fact that my employer was still paying me my regular paycheck during part of my leave, but I'm not totally sure if that's even why they denied it. I filed an appeal using the form that came with the denial notice, the DE 1000A, and sent it back already. Now I'm just sitting here not knowing how long this takes or what to expect. Has anyone gone through a PFL appeal after a denial? How long does PFL appeal take after denial for employer paycheck situations like this where you were still getting paid? Did you have to do anything else after sending the form?

Receipt number on my care claim went missing somehow after I submitted in SDI Online, so I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone at EDD on the phone. The agent pulled up my claim right there and confirmed the receipt number was actually recorded fine, it just wasn't showing in my dashboard view. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. Anyway on the appeal question: you filed the DE 1000A so the clock is running. EDD doesn't publish a fixed timeline for how long an appeal hearing takes to schedule, so I'd just watch your mail for the hearing notice.

0 coins

That receipt number thing is wild. Did the agent say anything about whether Part D had been matched to the claim at that point?

0 coins

She said Part D was received and matched, that was actually the first thing she checked. Big relief when she said it.

0 coins

been dialing that PFL number since tuesday morning, haven't gotten a person once. might have to look into that

0 coins

You filed the DE 1000A, which is exactly the right step. The form comes with the Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination (DE 2514) for a reason. The 30-day window to appeal is from the date on that notice, so as long as you mailed it within 30 days you are in good shape. After that, an Administrative Law Judge schedules a hearing and you receive notice of it by mail. EDD doesn't give a set number of days for how long that scheduling takes.

0 coins

The notice I got was dated about three weeks ago and I mailed the form the next day, so I should be within 30 days. That part at least I did right.

0 coins

Then your appeal is filed and you wait for the hearing notice. Keep the original denial notice and any documents you submitted with the claim. You may want to bring them to the hearing.

0 coins

Wait, does the hearing happen in person or can it be by phone? I'm caring for my mom right now and I genuinely cannot leave the house easily.

0 coins

The employer paycheck piece is worth understanding before the hearing. PFL is meant to replace wages you're losing. If your employer kept paying you full wages the whole time, EDD may have determined there were no lost wages to replace. That's a question worth writing down clearly before the hearing so you can explain the actual overlap between your pay and your leave days.

0 coins

My employer paid me for the first week and then it stopped. So there were definitely weeks I had no income at all. I didn't explain that clearly when I filed, which might be part of the problem.

0 coins

That distinction matters a lot. At the hearing you can lay that out week by week. Bring any pay stubs covering your leave period if you have them.

0 coins

ugh I had no idea that the paycheck situation could affect PFL like that, I always assumed it was just about whether you were on leave or not

0 coins

Tried that PFL line probably thirty times over two weeks for my own denied claim and got the busy signal or the system hung up on me every single time. Eventually used Claimyr to get through. The agent looked at my Notice of Computation and told me the weekly benefit amount on it, which I'd been second-guessing because I thought the figure seemed low for what I earned. She confirmed the amount and told me to check the benefits calculator on EDD's site if I wanted to compare it against my wages from that quarter.

0 coins

i need to know if my claim even has a Notice of Computation generated yet, it's been 11 days since I filed and nothing in my SDI Online. gonna try Claimyr for that, what should I have ready?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, your claim ID from the SDI Online confirmation page, and the date your leave started. That's all the agent needed from me.

0 coins

11 days and no notice at all is stressful. EDD says deciding can take up to 14 so you're right at the edge of that window.

0 coins

You can appeal online or by mail. You already mailed the DE 1000A, so it's in. The hearing is usually by phone or video, not in person. Bring documentation of which days your employer paid you and which days they didn't.

0 coins

By phone, that's such a relief to hear. I was really worried about the in-person part for my own claim.

0 coins

I didn't know the hearing could be by phone. That changes things, I was dreading trying to get to an office.

0 coins

The DE 2514 that came with your denial is worth reading closely. It will state the specific reason for the denial in EDD's language. If it says something about wages paid by the employer equaling or exceeding the weekly benefit amount for those weeks, that is different from a full denial of the whole claim. The appeal form DE 1000A lets you write your reasoning, so if you have more detail about which weeks were unpaid, that belongs in there or in a written statement you bring to the hearing.

0 coins

I did read it but honestly the language was confusing. I think it said something about concurrent wages. I'll read it again more carefully with what you just explained in mind.

0 coins

Concurrent wages means wages paid at the same time as the PFL period. EDD won't pay PFL for a day your employer already paid you in full. But days you were off without pay from your employer should be separate.

0 coins

Exactly. The hearing is your chance to show which days were which. A simple calendar with pay dates marked can be more persuasive than trying to explain it verbally.

0 coins

You sent the form, that's the main thing. Now you wait for the mail. Don't send it again, don't file a new claim. Just keep the paperwork you have.

0 coins

I was actually wondering if I should refile. Good to know I shouldn't.

0 coins

Filing twice would just create a mess. One appeal, wait it out.

0 coins

My coworker went through a PFL appeal last year and she said the hearing was scheduled maybe six or seven weeks after she sent the DE 1000A, but she told me it can vary a lot. She went into it with a list of dates her employer did and didn't pay her and that apparently made a huge difference. The judge asked her about it right away.

0 coins

Six or seven weeks is longer than I hoped but good to have a rough idea. I'll definitely put together that date list.

0 coins

I've seen people mention anywhere from a few weeks to a couple of months. The dates from the coworker above make sense as a data point but it really does vary.

0 coins

the date list idea is smart, I'd do that too

0 coins

EDD denied my claim on wages too. Appeals get scheduled when they get scheduled. Keep the DE 2514 somewhere you can find it.

0 coins

Short but accurate. The denial notice is the document you'll need.

0 coins

Heard stories of people losing theirs and having to request a copy. Don't do that.

0 coins

Can I ask something that might be a dumb question: if the appeal is decided in your favor, do they pay back all the weeks they originally denied? Or just going forward?

0 coins

If the appeal goes in your favor, the weeks that were wrongly denied would typically be paid out for the period covered. EDD doesn't just pay forward from the hearing date.

0 coins

Oh that actually makes sense and is a huge relief. I was worried it would only count from whenever they decide.

0 coins

The appeal covers the original claim period. That's the whole point of it. What you were owed during that time is what's being decided.

0 coins

edd denials are so stressful, my roommate waited forever on his and it was for a dumb reason too. hope yours goes better

0 coins

Thanks, I really hope so too. At least I know I did file the appeal in time.

0 coins

yeah getting it in on time is the big thing, rest is just waiting

0 coins

October 14 was when I mailed my own DE 1000A after a denial earlier this year. The hearing notice came about 45 days later. My situation involved wages paid by my employer during the first three weeks, which is exactly what you're describing. I brought a printed payroll summary showing the zero-pay weeks and the judge focused on that immediately.

0 coins

45 days is helpful, thank you. And the payroll summary idea is exactly what I need to do. I can print that from our HR portal.

0 coins

Get it stamped or on official letterhead if you can. Shows it's not something you made yourself.

0 coins

The employer payroll records piece is exactly the kind of documentation the hearing is designed for. You have a real case to make with the right paperwork.

0 coins

The good news is you already did the hardest part by actually sending the DE 1000A! A lot of people get the denial and just give up. You're in the process now.

0 coins

Honestly I almost did give up because the whole thing felt overwhelming. Glad I didn't.

0 coins

Sending that form is the step most people skip. The fact that you did it and in time is worth something.

0 coins

For the hearing, have these ready: the original DE 2514 denial notice, any pay stubs from your leave period, and a written summary of which days your employer paid you versus which days you had no income. The judge will have your claim file but your documents are yours to present.

0 coins

Written summary, pay stubs, denial notice. Got it. I'm going to put that together this week while I wait for the hearing notice.

0 coins

Add the Part C and Part D copies if you have them. Shows the care claim documentation was complete.

0 coins

Good point. If EDD received them before the denial date, that matters for the record.

0 coins

Weeks on my payment schedule weren't matching what I expected after my first PFL payment came in. Used Claimyr to get an agent and she told me exactly which weeks had been paid and confirmed when the next payment was scheduled based on my claim.

0 coins

That payment schedule thing tripped me up on my own care claim too. Used Claimyr for it and once the agent said which weeks were marked paid, I could see the proof of relationship document had been received that same week, so the matching went through fine. Meant I could stop wondering if the form got lost.

0 coins

I've been trying that number on my lunch break three days running and it just cuts off. Good to know there's a way through.

0 coins

14 is right that the matching part can be a source of confusion. Once I knew which weeks the agent was seeing on her end it cleared up why the total looked different from what I calculated.

0 coins

does your employer have to give you your job back after PFL ends? I keep seeing people mention CFRA but I don't understand how they're different

0 coins

PFL pays the benefit but doesn't protect your job. That's the short version. CFRA is what gives job protection for eligible employees, but whether it covers your situation is between you and your employer's HR.

0 coins

oh wow I thought PFL covered both. I should probably talk to HR before I file then.

0 coins

A lot of people assume they're the same thing. They're not. PFL is EDD's money. The job part is a separate law entirely.

0 coins

I mixed these up myself when I went on bonding leave. HR had to explain it to me. Worth a 10 minute conversation with them before you go out.

0 coins

Tried reaching the PFL line four mornings in a row for my care claim, got disconnected every time before anyone picked up. At the end of my rope with it, honestly.

0 coins

That line is a full-time job to get through. I went through the same thing before I found Claimyr.

0 coins

How does that actually work? Like what is Claimyr doing?

0 coins

You give it your info and it stays on hold with EDD while you go do something else. When an actual EDD person picks up, your phone rings and you're talking to them. That's basically it.

0 coins

Used Claimyr for the DE 2500E on my claim, the agent confirmed when the first payment was coming and which bank account it was going to, since I'd put in a direct deposit and wasn't sure if SDI Online had saved it correctly. Turned out the account number had gone through fine. Would've been guessing otherwise.

0 coins

ok that is actually useful, I had no idea that was a thing. the question I'd ask is whether my Part D was actually received because the status hasn't changed in 10 days

0 coins

the waiting is the worst part honestly. filed my own appeal weeks ago and still nothing in the mail

0 coins

How long has it been for you? Trying to get a sense of what's normal.

0 coins

going on five weeks now. a few people told me six to eight so I'm still in that window I guess

0 coins

Five weeks is well within the range I've seen mentioned. The 45 days I mentioned from my own situation is probably a reasonable midpoint.

0 coins

Has anyone appealed and lost? Curious what happens after that.

0 coins

If the first appeal is denied, there is a further appeals process. The notice from that decision would explain the next step available to you.

0 coins

There are multiple levels of review above the initial hearing. Most people don't need them, but they exist. The key is reading each notice carefully when it comes and acting within whatever deadline it states.

0 coins

Good to know there's not just one shot at it.

0 coins

Don't sit around waiting and forget to check the mail every day. The hearing notice comes with a date and time and you have to respond or confirm it. Miss that and you lose the hearing.

0 coins

I did not know you have to confirm it. I'll be watching the mail every day.

0 coins

Read whatever it says carefully. The instructions on the notice tell you what to do and by when.

0 coins

that is a really important point, I nearly missed something similar on my own claim just not expecting anything to come

0 coins

Update: got the hearing notice today, 38 days after I sent the DE 1000A. Hearing is by phone in about two weeks. I'm putting together my pay stubs and a week-by-week calendar of when my employer paid me and when they didn't. Feel a lot better having a plan.

0 coins

38 days to the notice, then two more weeks to the hearing. That tracks closely with what I went through.

0 coins

The week-by-week calendar is exactly the right approach. Present it clearly and let the dates speak for themselves.

0 coins

Good luck at the hearing. Bring everything organized and have the DE 2514 in front of you when the judge starts talking.

0 coins

38 days. Good to have a real number for the record here.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure