Got a PFL overpayment letter because employer paid bonding leave at same time
So this is stressful and I'm not sure how to handle it. I took eight weeks of bonding leave after our second kid arrived in August, filed my PFL claim through SDI Online, everything seemed fine. Then HR tells me the company was also paying me full salary the whole time as part of some enhanced parental leave benefit they rolled out this year. I didn't think those two things would conflict — I figured PFL was its own thing. Now I have a letter from EDD saying there's an overpayment because my wages plus PFL exceeded what I normally make. I honestly didn't know this was even a rule. The letter came with an appeal form. Do I just pay it back? Can I fight it? Has anyone dealt with this exact situation where your employer's paid leave and PFL overlapped?
86 comments

Laura Lopez
Weeks paid on my claim got confusing around the same time my employer switched payroll systems, so I ended up with a question EDD's website couldn't answer for me. I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and reached a live person at EDD's Paid Family Leave line. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my claim and told me exactly which two weeks had been paid, what the amounts were, and when the next payment was scheduled. That let me match everything against what my employer had paid me those same weeks and figure out where the overlap was before EDD sent anything else my way.
0 coins
Victoria Brown
Payment dates are exactly what I need to pin down on my own claim. My employer's leave ran the first four weeks and I have no idea which of those weeks EDD also paid. I'd want an agent to tell me the specific payment dates. If I try Claimyr, what should I have ready?
0 coins
Laura Lopez
Have your SDI Online receipt number and your Social Security number. The agent will want to confirm identity and then pull the claim right up. Having a calendar with your employer's pay periods helps too so you can compare on the spot.
0 coins
Samuel Robinson
Knowing the exact paid weeks before the overpayment letter lands would have saved me a lot of back-and-forth with EDD. Good thinking to get ahead of it.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
The rule to ask EDD about is whether your combined wages and PFL exceeded your normal weekly pay during any given week. EDD's own guidance says wages, excluding overtime, plus PFL can't add up to more than what you normally earn. If your employer paid full salary and EDD also paid PFL on the same days, the overlap is the problem. The overpayment amount should correspond to the weeks where the total went over.
0 coins
Gabriel Freeman
AuthorSo it's calculated week by week, not just a lump sum comparison? That changes how I read the letter.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
Exactly. Each week stands on its own. The letter should break it down by week if EDD did it correctly. Worth checking whether the weeks they flagged match the weeks your employer actually paid you.
0 coins
Brianna Muhammad
What counts as 'normal wages' though? Is it what I make in an average week or specifically my base pay without any bonuses or anything extra?
0 coins
Camila Castillo
The figure to use is wages excluding overtime. If you're salaried with no variable pay it's usually straightforward. For anything more complicated, calling EDD directly is the right move since they'd look at your specific base period.
0 coins
JaylinCharles
Appeal if anything looks wrong. You have 30 days from the date on the letter to file. The appeal form DE 1000A came with the letter. Don't wait thinking it'll sort itself out.
0 coins
Gabriel Freeman
Author30 days from the letter date — noted. Mine is dated two weeks ago so I need to move.
0 coins
JaylinCharles
Don't cut it close. Mail it or file it online, just get it in.
0 coins
Eloise Kendrick
File online if you can. Mail gets lost.
0 coins
Lucas Schmidt
EDD's phone line is a nightmare but the question you have is too specific for a web form answer. The overpayment calculation, whether your employer's leave counts as wages, how the weeks were applied — an agent needs to walk through your actual claim. Spent three mornings redialing before I gave up and found another way.
0 coins
Freya Collins
Three mornings sounds about right. I hit that wall too when I had a question about intermittent days. Eventually got through but it took way too many tries.
0 coins
Lucas Schmidt
And even when you do get through the hold time is long. For something as specific as an overpayment breakdown you really need that agent to have your claim on the screen.
0 coins
LongPeri
The DE 2500E came in my portal a couple weeks after I filed, but I wasn't sure if it meant I was approved or just that a payment was coming. I used Claimyr and finally talked to someone at EDD who explained that the DE 2500E is the electronic benefit payment notification for my first payment, not a formal approval of the whole claim. Really helped me stop spiraling about it.
0 coins
Freya Collins
The employer leave overlap is exactly what tripped up my claim too, and I've used Claimyr as well. After the agent told me I'd used five of my eight weeks in the first leave stretch, I went back and counted the weeks my employer covered independently. Turns out I had three weeks of PFL left in my 12-month window, which completely changed what I thought I owed back.
0 coins
Oscar O'Neil
Eight weeks total for all PFL in 12 months — I didn't know bonding and care shared the same pool until I read this thread. Assumed they were separate.
0 coins
Freya Collins
They do share it. Five weeks bonding means only three left if a care claim comes up in the same 12 months. It catches people off guard.
0 coins
Brianna Muhammad
So if my partner already used some weeks bonding before I filed, do we share that limit or is it per person?
0 coins
Camila Castillo
Each parent files their own claim and has their own eight-week limit. Your partner's weeks don't count against yours.
0 coins
Sara Hellquiem
Your employer paying you during leave doesn't automatically mean PFL is wrong to pay too. The issue is whether the two together put you over your normal pay. If your employer had a true salary continuation benefit, ask HR in writing how it was categorized — whether it was treated as wages or something else. That answer matters for the appeal.
0 coins
Gabriel Freeman
AuthorHR told me verbally it was a 'top-up' benefit. I'll get that in writing like you said.
0 coins
Sara Hellquiem
Get the policy document too if they have one. Something official is better than a letter written after the fact.
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
The appeal goes to an administrative law judge if you file it. Document everything: your employer's pay stubs for those weeks, the PFL payment amounts from SDI Online, and anything HR gives you about how the leave benefit was classified. A clear week-by-week comparison is what the judge wants to see.
0 coins
Victoria Brown
Does SDI Online actually show the PFL payment amounts broken out by week? I've only seen a total.
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
In SDI Online under your claim ID there's a payment history section. It lists each payment with dates. Cross-referencing those dates with your employer's pay periods is how you build the comparison.
0 coins
Laura Lopez
Payment history by date is in there. That's how I confirmed which weeks EDD paid before my agent also confirmed it.
0 coins
Oscar O'Neil
Went through something similar last year, not exactly the same but close enough. My salon pays me for two weeks of holiday leave and I took PFL right after a holiday week. EDD flagged that the holiday pay counted as wages and the overlap bumped me over. I had no idea paid time off even factored in.
0 coins
Gabriel Freeman
AuthorSo any wages paid by your employer during PFL weeks can trigger this? Even if they're a different category of leave?
0 coins
Oscar O'Neil
That's what EDD told me. The test is total dollars in versus your normal weekly amount, not what the employer called the payment.
0 coins
Liv Park
sick leave too i think. any employer pay that overlaps those weeks.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
Paid time off, sick leave, vacation — if your employer pays it for the same days as PFL and the total exceeds normal wages, it creates an overpayment. The type of leave your employer calls it doesn't change how EDD counts it.
0 coins
Leeann Blackstein
Two days a week back at the warehouse since month three, and I wasn't sure if I had to report those days to EDD or just let the claim run out. Used Claimyr and reached an agent who looked at my claim and said a DE 2580GF had already been mailed because EDD saw I'd returned to part-time. The agent said I had to fill it out and send it back or payments would stop. Got it done that same afternoon.
0 coins
Ryder Greene
Honestly I'm a little skeptical about reaching a live EDD agent that easily — I've hit the busy signal so many times on that 877 number that I stopped counting. What actually happened when you tried it?
0 coins
Leeann Blackstein
Tried the line myself for two weeks before that, same thing every morning. With Claimyr I ended up actually talking to an EDD agent. She was real, had my claim on screen, answered my question about the DE 2580GF right then.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
I've used Claimyr too for my own intermittent reporting question! The agent confirmed my claim start date and told me the 41-day filing window had closed on a specific date, which explained why one of my weeks wasn't covered. That cleared up so much confusion.
0 coins
Ryder Greene
Okay that's more detail than I expected. I'll give it a shot — my question is whether my claim shows any intermittent weeks still pending.
0 coins
Theodore Nelson
wait so if your boss pays you full salary and edd also pays you pfl thats automatically an overpayment? or only if you go over what you normally make
0 coins
Camila Castillo
Only if the two together put you above your normal pay. If your employer paid half and PFL paid half and together they equal your usual paycheck, that's fine. It's when the total exceeds your regular wages that EDD calls it an overpayment.
0 coins
Theodore Nelson
ok so its not automatic, it depends on the total. that makes more sense
0 coins
Brianna Muhammad
Is there any way to avoid paying it all back at once? I don't have the kind of money sitting around to write a check for weeks of overpayment. Can you do a payment plan with EDD?
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
EDD does have options for repayment arrangements. The overpayment notice should have contact information or instructions for requesting one. You can also appeal first and see how the amount shakes out before agreeing to repay anything.
0 coins
JaylinCharles
Appeal first. If the number changes, you don't want to have already paid the wrong amount.
0 coins
Brianna Muhammad
That makes sense. I'll appeal and then worry about payment after I know the real number.
0 coins
AaliyahAli
Took two attempts to get the overpayment amount corrected on mine. First appeal, they knocked it down. Never promise a waiver but it's worth filing if the math looks off.
0 coins
Gabriel Freeman
AuthorTwo attempts is what I'm bracing for. At least it's not impossible.
0 coins
AaliyahAli
Not impossible. Just tedious.
0 coins
Ellie Simpson
The 30-day appeal window is firm. File it even if you're still gathering documents, because a late appeal is much harder to pursue.
0 coins
LongPeri
Assumed there was more time than 30 days. That deadline would have caught me completely off guard.
0 coins
Ellie Simpson
30 days from the date on the notice. Mark it on your calendar now.
0 coins
Gabriel Freeman
AuthorAlready done. Filing this week regardless of whether HR gets me documents in time.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
My employer's parental leave topped up PFL to 100 percent of salary, which the HR benefits summary said was designed to work alongside PFL. The overpayment letter still came! Turned out HR's math was slightly off one week. So even a carefully designed top-up can trip the wire.
0 coins
Sara Hellquiem
HR's math and EDD's math don't always agree because they're using different base figures. HR uses your current salary, EDD uses your base period wages. If those differ, the numbers won't line up perfectly.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
That's exactly what happened to me. My salary went up this year but my base period was from last year, so the two calculations were slightly out of sync.
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
This is why getting the actual weekly benefit amount from your Notice of Computation and sharing it with HR before leave starts can prevent the whole mess. A lot of HR teams will adjust the top-up once they see the exact PFL amount.
0 coins
Freya Collins
For the appeal, ask yourself whether EDD's calculation of your normal wages matches what you actually make. EDD uses your base period, which is wages from roughly 5 to 18 months before your claim. If you got a raise after the base period, your PFL weekly amount might be based on lower wages than what your employer is now paying you, which makes the top-up look like an overpayment even when HR thought they had it right.
0 coins
Gabriel Freeman
AuthorGot a raise in January. My base period predates that by months. This might be exactly the disconnect you're describing.
0 coins
Freya Collins
Worth spelling that out clearly in your appeal. The base period wages versus current salary discrepancy is a legit argument for why the numbers looked like an overpayment but weren't necessarily improper.
0 coins
Lucas Schmidt
EDD's calculator on their site can at least show you what your base period wages imply for your weekly benefit amount. Run the numbers yourself before the appeal hearing so you're not surprised.
0 coins
Victoria Brown
The calculator is at edd.ca.gov? I'll look for it on their site.
0 coins
Lucas Schmidt
Yep, edd.ca.gov, look for the PFL benefit calculator. Gives you an estimate based on your quarterly wages. Not the final number but close enough to sanity-check EDD's figure.
0 coins
Samuel Robinson
Flagging something I got wrong before someone else does: PFL doesn't have a waiting period. No unpaid first week the way disability does. So if you were expecting a 7-day gap and your employer was paying you during what you thought was the waiting period, that's a separate confusion worth clearing up.
0 coins
LongPeri
Thought PFL had the same seven-day wait as SDI. That would have changed how I planned the whole thing.
0 coins
Samuel Robinson
Different programs, different rules. PFL starts from day one of leave with no gap.
0 coins
Oscar O'Neil
My stylist friend thought the same thing. Good thing she asked before she planned her leave dates around it.
0 coins
Liv Park
the appeal form DE 1000A, do you mail it or can you do it online
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
Both options exist. SDI Online lets you submit appeals, or you can mail the paper DE 1000A to the address printed on the form. Online is faster for confirmation.
0 coins
Liv Park
ok going online then
0 coins
Eloise Kendrick
EDD won't negotiate on the amount without an appeal. The letter is not an invitation to call and explain yourself. File the form first.
0 coins
Gabriel Freeman
AuthorLearned that the hard way with a different EDD issue years ago. Filing the form before anything else.
0 coins
Eloise Kendrick
Good. The appeal creates the record. Calling doesn't.
0 coins
Ryder Greene
Does your employer know EDD sent an overpayment notice? HR might be able to reclassify the payment or provide a letter explaining their benefit was intended as a supplement, not a wage continuation. That kind of documentation has helped people I know in similar situations.
0 coins
Gabriel Freeman
AuthorHR doesn't know yet. I'm going to bring them the overpayment letter and ask them to put in writing how the benefit was structured. Good call.
0 coins
Sara Hellquiem
Ask HR specifically whether they documented the leave payment as supplemental to PFL or as a wage replacement. Those are two different things in an appeal.
0 coins
Victoria Brown
For the week-by-week comparison: pull your pay stubs showing the employer payment dates, your SDI Online payment history showing EDD payment dates, and line them up. Any week where the two columns together exceed your normal weekly pay is a week to explain or dispute. If even one week was miscalculated, the total comes down.
0 coins
Gabriel Freeman
AuthorThis is exactly the spreadsheet I'm going to build this weekend.
0 coins
Victoria Brown
Add a column for your normal weekly base pay. Three columns total: EDD paid, employer paid, normal pay. Any row where column one plus column two beats column three is a problem row.
0 coins
Brianna Muhammad
California EDD taxes — does the amount you have to pay back affect your taxes? Like if you got a 1099-G and already reported the PFL income and now you're paying some back, does that change anything?
0 coins
Laura Lopez
EDD sends a 1099-G in January for benefits paid. If you repay an overpayment in a later year, that gets complicated and is really a question for a tax professional, not something to guess at.
0 coins
Brianna Muhammad
Makes sense, I'll ask my accountant. Just wanted to know if it was something to worry about.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
California doesn't tax PFL at the state level but the federal question on repayment is exactly the kind of thing a tax professional needs to answer for your specific situation.
0 coins
Oscar O'Neil
Sending good vibes your way. Overpayment letters feel so official and scary but they're more common than people think when employer leave overlaps PFL. You're not in trouble, you just have paperwork to do.
0 coins
Gabriel Freeman
AuthorHonestly this thread helped a lot. I went from panicking to having an actual action plan. Filing the appeal this week, getting HR documentation, building the week-by-week comparison.
0 coins
Samuel Robinson
Solid plan. The appeal is the move.
0 coins