Back to California Paid Family Leave

Sasha Reese

EDD says I worked while on PFL and owe money how to fix this

So I got this notice in the mail last week and I'm honestly kind of panicking. It says I collected PFL benefits during weeks where EDD thinks I was working and earning wages, so now there's an overpayment and I owe the money back. The thing is I did go back part time for like three weeks but I thought I reported it? Or maybe I didn't do it right, I'm not totally sure. I filed my bonding claim through SDI Online back in the spring when my daughter was born. I never got a Continued Claim Certification form so I just kept collecting and figured it was fine. Now I have no idea if I should appeal this or just pay it or what. Has anyone dealt with an overpayment notice like this before? Do I actually have a shot at fixing it if I genuinely didn't understand how to report the wages?

An appeal is exactly the right question to ask yourself first. The notice EDD mailed you should have an Appeal Form included, the DE 1000A, and you have 30 days from the date on that notice to send it in. If you genuinely reported your wages and EDD didn't apply them correctly, that is worth appealing. If you didn't report and the wages are real, the overpayment itself is probably accurate, but you can still appeal the amount if something looks off.

0 coins

DE 1000A, writing that down. The notice is dated about two weeks ago so I still have time. Do I need to prove I tried to report or is just saying I thought I did enough?

0 coins

Gather whatever you have: pay stubs from those weeks, any SDI Online activity showing you logged in, anything at all. The more you bring to an appeal the better your position.

0 coins

Appeals are way less scary than they sound. You just explain what happened.

0 coins

The Continued Claim Certification, the DE 2580GF, is what EDD sends when they know you went back part time. It says on EDD's site that any return to work and any wages, even ones not yet paid, are supposed to be reported by you. If the form never came, that doesn't erase the reporting requirement, unfortunately. Worth noting in your appeal though.

0 coins

So waiting for the form was my mistake? I genuinely didn't know I was supposed to report without it.

0 coins

The obligation to report sits with the claimant regardless of whether the certification form arrives. That said, if you can show you weren't told clearly, it's still a fair point for an appeal.

0 coins

Wait so you have to report wages even if EDD hasn't sent you a form yet? That's really confusing, I'm about to start a bonding claim and I might go back part time too.

0 coins

Yes, you report any work and wages to EDD as they happen. The DE 2580GF is EDD's response to that report, not the trigger for it. Better to know that now before you start.

0 coins

Start date on my bonding claim was wrong in the system, which is how I ended up with a week of benefits I apparently wasn't owed. I tried the EDD line for three mornings before giving up. Eventually I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through, and when the agent pulled up my claim she confirmed the start date EDD had on file didn't match the date I entered on the form. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

My claim has the same kind of date issue and I think it's causing payment problems. I'll try that for it. What should I have ready when I call?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, the receipt number from SDI Online, and the DE 2501F or any confirmation email showing the date you put down. The agent looked right at my claim and read me the date they had on file so it was quick once I got to her.

0 coins

Three mornings on the EDD line before giving up is exactly what I'm worried about. I've been dreading even trying.

0 coins

If the wages were real, the overpayment is probably real too, and I say that as someone who's dealt with EDD being wrong in the other direction. The frustrating part is proving anything after the fact.

0 coins

Yeah that's what scares me. I know I did go back for a few weeks, I just don't know if I actually hit submit on the report or just thought about it.

0 coins

Pull up your SDI Online history. If you submitted anything it should show there. If it's blank, you've got your answer.

0 coins

SDI Online history, hadn't thought to check that. Going to look right now.

0 coins

My cousin went through almost this exact thing after her bonding leave. She owed back a few weeks because she went back to the salon part time and didn't know to report until after she got the overpayment notice. She ended up just paying it in installments because the amount of the overpayment wasn't something she disputed, just the stress of it.

0 coins

Can you actually pay it in installments? That's good to know if it comes to that.

0 coins

EDD does have options for repayment arrangements. The overpayment notice itself should explain your options, and you can also ask EDD directly when you contact them.

0 coins

That's what my cousin did, she just contacted EDD and worked it out. It took a bit but she got there.

0 coins

Appeal it anyway even if the wages were real. You have nothing to lose by putting your explanation in writing and making them look at it.

0 coins

That's honestly the most reassuring thing I've read here. I keep thinking if I appeal and lose I'll be worse off somehow.

0 coins

You can't be worse off than the notice you already have. Appeal.

0 coins

Agreed. The 30-day window is there for exactly this, and your story about not receiving the DE 2580GF is a real part of your case.

0 coins

Payment method on my claim got stuck on the old debit card after I switched to direct deposit in SDI Online. Spent two weeks thinking I was just waiting on processing. Used Claimyr to get an agent and she confirmed the payment method hadn't updated on their end, even though SDI Online showed direct deposit for me. She flagged it while I was on the phone.

0 coins

The payment method thing is actually what happened to me too, bonding claim just sitting there. Used Claimyr after my account showed the same thing and the agent told me which weeks were still showing as pending so I knew exactly what was held up. Went back into SDI Online and submitted what they needed. Anyway it got sorted.

0 coins

how long were you trying the line before that? ive been hitting it every morning for a week and cant get through

0 coins

Honestly more mornings than I want to count. The direct deposit question was the one thing I really needed confirmed before I could move on.

0 coins

August 14th is when my own bonding claim's first payment issued, and I'd started leave July 29th. Telling you that just to give a sense of timing. The window between filing and first payment can feel long when you're watching for it.

0 coins

That's about two weeks, which tracks with what people say. Did you have any wage reporting hiccups during that period?

0 coins

I took all eight weeks at once so there was nothing to report partway through. Straightforward in that sense.

0 coins

Wish I'd done it that way. Going back part time seemed like the right call at the time.

0 coins

Worth double-checking: the overpayment notice should itemize which exact weeks they're claiming you worked and collected. If any of those weeks your wages plus the PFL benefit didn't actually exceed your normal wages, that's another thing worth raising in an appeal.

0 coins

I didn't even think to look at it that closely. I kind of just saw the total amount and started spiraling.

0 coins

Read each week listed separately. Sometimes the math on these notices is off, or they've flagged a week where you barely worked and the wages were tiny.

0 coins

The itemized breakdown is exactly what to focus on. If even one week looks wrong, note it specifically on the DE 1000A.

0 coins

You said you thought you reported, so there's genuinely a chance your report got submitted and something went wrong on EDD's end! It happens. Check SDI Online for any submission history before you assume the worst.

0 coins

I really hope you're right. Logging in now to check the history.

0 coins

Fingers crossed something is there! Even a partial record helps.

0 coins

Don't ignore the notice while you decide. The 30-day clock on the DE 1000A runs from the date printed on the notice, not the day you got it in the mail.

0 coins

That's a really good point. Mine is dated the 8th and today is the 19th so I've used some of that window already.

0 coins

Then file the appeal this week. You can send it by mail or submit it online, whichever is faster for you right now.

0 coins

Receipt number on a bonding claim is easy to lose track of if you didn't save it from SDI Online when you filed. That came up for me because I needed it to check my claim status after the confirmation page disappeared. Tried the EDD line several times on different days. Claimyr got me to an agent and she read me the receipt number right off the claim and confirmed when the claim had been received on their end.

0 coins

Not sure I buy that the EDD line just picks up for anyone. I've dialed that number on maybe fifteen different mornings and it's ended the same way every time.

0 coins

I didn't believe it either after what I'd been through on that line. But the agent was real and she worked for EDD, read me my own claim data back to me. That's what happened.

0 coins

Agent confirmed the receipt number and the date EDD received the claim. That's the kind of thing that takes ten minutes if you get through, and apparently Claimyr makes that happen. I had the same question about a DE 2514 that showed up on a care claim I filed for my mom. Got an agent through Claimyr who pulled up the notice and told me exactly what determination EDD had entered and that I had 30 days to appeal if I disagreed.

0 coins

my bonding claim just says pending still and its been eleven days. is that normal or should i be doing something

0 coins

Deciding a claim can take up to 14 days, so eleven days is still within the normal range. If it passes 14, send a Request Claim Update through SDI Online.

0 coins

ok good. i was about to try calling every hour

0 coins

The Request Claim Update in SDI Online is genuinely the cleaner move if the 14 days pass. You put your question in writing and it goes right to the claim.

0 coins

Can I ask a dumb question: does PFL have a waiting period like disability does? Someone at work told me there are like seven days you don't get paid at the start.

0 coins

PFL has no waiting period at all. That seven-day unpaid stretch is a Disability Insurance thing, not PFL. Benefits start from day one of your leave.

0 coins

Oh wow, I had no idea they were different. That would have been a nasty surprise.

0 coins

So many people mix those two up! Different programs, different rules, same SDI system basically.

0 coins

It's genuinely confusing because they both live under the SDI umbrella and even share some forms. But EDD is clear that PFL has no waiting period.

0 coins

The appeal form itself is pretty short. You write what happened, attach anything you have, sign it, send it. No need to write an essay.

0 coins

That's a relief, I was imagining something much more involved.

0 coins

Just be specific about which weeks you're disputing and why. That's really it.

0 coins

Overpayments from unreported wages are more common than people think, especially on intermittent claims. The good news is EDD does look at appeals and you can present your side. Keep everything factual and document any weeks where you question their math.

0 coins

Factual and documented, got it. I'm going to pull every pay stub from that period.

0 coins

Pay stubs plus any texts or emails from your employer about your schedule that spring. The more of a paper trail the better.

0 coins

Your employer also reports wages to the state, which is usually how EDD finds out about unreported earnings on PFL claims. That's not an accusation, just useful context for why they know what they know.

0 coins

That actually makes total sense now. I wondered how they caught it.

0 coins

Yep, wage reporting to the state is routine and EDD cross-references it. It's not personal, it's automated.

0 coins

Which is also why the appeal is worth doing even if the wages are real: sometimes the cross-reference catches a week wrong or attributes wages to the wrong period.

0 coins

Wherever this lands for you, the fact that you're looking into it now and have time left on the 30-day window means you're in a reasonable position. File the DE 1000A, explain what happened, attach what you have.

0 coins

Filed the appeal online this afternoon. Wrote out what I remembered, attached three pay stubs, and explained that the DE 2580GF never arrived. Feel better having done it.

0 coins

Well done. Keep a copy of everything you submitted and note the date. If you don't hear back, you can follow up through SDI Online.

0 coins

That's exactly the right move. Now you just wait and see what they come back with.

0 coins

late to this but can you split an overpayment into installments or is it all at once

0 coins

EDD does offer repayment arrangements. Contact EDD directly to ask about your options; the overpayment notice should also lay out what's available to you.

0 coins

ok thanks. was worried it had to be a lump sum.

0 coins

Hoping for a good update from you! Sounds like you did everything right once you understood what was needed.

0 coins

Thank you. I'll report back once I hear something from EDD. At least now I know the 30-day deadline was the thing to watch and I didn't miss it.

0 coins

Good outcome regardless, you got the appeal in.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure