Back to California Paid Family Leave

Sofia Ramirez

Does unemployment overpayment get deducted from paid family leave benefits?

So I'm in a kind of stressful situation and I can't find a clear answer anywhere. I had an unemployment claim earlier this year that ended up with an overpayment notice, and I'm still dealing with that. Now I'm about to file a PFL bonding claim because my daughter was just born two weeks ago. Someone told me that EDD will just take whatever I owe from unemployment straight out of my PFL payments, but someone else said the two programs are separate and it doesn't work that way. I genuinely don't know what to believe. Does anyone know if an unemployment overpayment actually gets deducted from paid family leave benefits, or do I just deal with the overpayment separately while getting my PFL normally? I'm already stressed about money right now and I really need to understand this before I file.

Pending status was showing on my claim for a full 15 days after I filed, and I started panicking about whether the 41-day window had somehow reset because of a complication with my start date. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is what I ended up using to actually get someone at EDD Paid Family Leave on the phone. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the start date EDD had on file, which was the date I'd put on the form, and told me I still had time within the 41 days to get everything submitted. That settled it for me.

0 coins

Fourteen mornings I tried that line. Busy signal, then the automated message, then it just ends the call. Hard to believe anyone gets through.

0 coins

Got through on a Tuesday mid-morning, agent picked up after Claimyr held the line. She was definitely EDD, ran through my claim ID and read me the start date right off the system.

0 coins

My bonding claim had the same start-date confusion! The agent I reached through the PFL line told me the DE 2580GF had already been matched to my claim and my intermittent days were logged correctly. Such a relief to hear that from an actual person!

0 coins

Huh. Maybe I'll give it one more shot then.

0 coins

Looked into this exact thing when my PFL care claim was pending. PFL and unemployment are two separate programs with separate payment systems. An overpayment on one doesn't automatically come out of the other, so your PFL bonding payments shouldn't be touched by whatever balance you owe on the unemployment side.

0 coins

That's what I was hoping but I was so scared it wasn't true. So I should just file the PFL bonding claim like normal and handle the overpayment repayment separately?

0 coins

That's how it worked for me. File the bonding claim, deal with the overpayment through the unemployment side. They don't cross-collect automatically between programs the way some people assume.

0 coins

This is right. Had an old UI issue when I took PFL for my son and they never touched my PFL money. Two different buckets.

0 coins

okay so when i was going through my PFL bonding claim after my second was born, a coworker scared me with the same thing, like oh EDD is gonna grab your PFL to cover what you owe from UI. It did NOT happen. My payments came through just fine. File your claim, don't let that stop you.

0 coins

This is making me feel so much better. The person who told me they'd deduct it was pretty confident and I just spiraled.

0 coins

people say stuff confidently all the time and they're just wrong lol. EDD doesn't cross-collect between UI and PFL. go file!

0 coins

Agree. Same experience here, no deduction.

0 coins

The rule worth knowing: PFL is not paid for the same days as unemployment, meaning you can't collect both at the same time for the same period. But that's about concurrent payments, not about an old overpayment balance being taken from future PFL benefits. Those are different situations entirely.

0 coins

Wait so the rule is just that I can't be getting UI and PFL payments at the same time? Not that an old UI debt comes out of PFL?

0 coins

Exactly. The restriction is about receiving both programs' benefits for the same day. A prior overpayment balance on a closed UI claim is a separate matter from your new PFL bonding claim.

0 coins

This is the distinction that gets people. Concurrent payments are blocked, but a past overpayment debt doesn't automatically intercept your PFL. Good clarification.

0 coins

EDD's website says this but good luck finding a human to confirm it when you're worried at midnight.

0 coins

File the bonding claim. You've got a two-week-old, don't sit on it. The 41-day deadline runs from the date your leave started, not from the birth.

0 coins

My leave started the day she was born so I have around 25 days left I think. I'm going to file tonight.

0 coins

Good. Get it done. Keep your receipt number off the confirmation screen.

0 coins

yes save that receipt number, took me a minute to find mine later when I needed it, anyway get the claim in tonight like you said

0 coins

my buddy told me edd takes overpayments from everything and i believed him for like a week before i found out it wasnt true. filed my pfl after and got paid normal. dont stress it

0 coins

Why do people spread that info so confidently, it's so stressful to hear.

0 coins

no idea man. he was totally sure and totally wrong

0 coins

Direct deposit setup on my bonding claim confused me because I wasn't sure if EDD would default to a debit card or use my bank info from SDI Online. I used Claimyr to get on the line with an actual PFL agent and she told me the payment method on my claim was set to debit card because I hadn't enrolled direct deposit through SDI Online yet, and walked me through where to update it. Got that sorted before my first payment.

0 coins

What exactly is Claimyr? I keep seeing it mentioned but I haven't looked it up.

0 coins

It holds the EDD Paid Family Leave line for you so you end up talking to one of their agents. That's really the whole thing.

0 coins

Got it. I have a question about how my base period wages were calculated on my Notice of Computation and I've been putting off dealing with it. Might actually use that for it.

0 coins

The payment method question is a real one. I didn't realize you could set up direct deposit through SDI Online until after my first payment had already gone to the debit card.

0 coins

PFL bonding and UI are administered separately. No automatic offset of an unemployment overpayment against your PFL. File, track your receipt number, upload your proof of relationship.

0 coins

Proof of relationship, is that the birth certificate? She's my biological daughter.

0 coins

Yes, birth certificate works. Or a Declaration of Paternity if that's the situation. Standard for a bonding claim.

0 coins

I have her birth certificate already, I'll upload it when I file tonight.

0 coins

Make sure you upload it in SDI Online with the claim, not separately after the fact if you can avoid it. Keeps everything matched.

0 coins

Called the PFL line six mornings in a row trying to ask something basic about my care claim and either got the busy signal or the automated message that dumps you. The UI overpayment fear I completely understand because nobody can get a straight answer from an actual person.

0 coins

Six mornings sounds about right. I did four before I stopped trying.

0 coins

and they wonder why people post on forums to get answers

0 coins

The forum answer here is actually accurate though: no cross-collection between UI overpayments and PFL. So at least the internet came through this time.

0 coins

You're not the first person to panic about this. The answer is no, they don't deduct it. File and move on.

0 coins

Genuinely relieved. Thank you for being direct about it.

0 coins

That's what this place is for.

0 coins

filed pfl last month, had an old ui issue, payments came through no problem. dont overthink it

0 coins

Thank you, this is reassuring to hear from someone who was actually in the same spot.

0 coins

yeah its fine. file it

0 coins

The part that tripped me up was thinking PFL had a waiting period like unemployment does. Filed expecting to lose the first week of pay and then found out PFL has no waiting period. Pleasantly surprised. Anyway the UI overpayment thing doesn't touch PFL.

0 coins

Wait there's no waiting period with PFL? I thought every EDD program had one.

0 coins

Nope, PFL doesn't have a benefit waiting period. That's disability insurance that has the seven unpaid days thing, not PFL. I mixed them up too at first.

0 coins

Important correction there: the seven-day waiting period is specific to disability insurance, not PFL. PFL pays from the first day of eligible leave.

0 coins

This is one of the most common mix-ups I see. Glad it got flagged.

0 coins

Filing in SDI Online through myEDD, I kept the confirmation page open long enough to write down the receipt number by hand before closing it. Then about two weeks later I called EDD to check on the status because nothing had moved. I tried the phone line several times with no luck, so I ended up using Claimyr to reach a PFL agent. She looked up my claim and found that my receipt number was correctly on file and the claim was in review. She said to watch for the Notice of Computation in the mail.

0 coins

Got through EDD's PFL line myself using Claimyr not long ago. The agent told me a DE 2514 had been issued on my care claim, which I hadn't seen yet, and that I had 30 days from the mailing date to appeal if I disagreed. Didn't even know to look for that notice.

0 coins

Did the agent say anything about why the determination went the way it did?

0 coins

She just said the notice would explain it and to appeal within 30 days using the DE 1000A if I wanted to dispute it. She wasn't going to summarize the whole thing on the phone.

0 coins

30 days to appeal goes fast. Good to know ahead of time.

0 coins

Don't confuse PFL not collecting UI debt with the rule that you can't be on UI and PFL at the same time. Those are two different things. If your UI claim is closed and done, you're fine to get PFL.

0 coins

My UI claim is closed, the overpayment is what's left from it. So I should be totally fine to file PFL now?

0 coins

Yes. Closed claim, overpayment balance is its own thing. PFL bonding for a newborn, file it.

0 coins

Correct. Concurrent benefit restriction only applies to same-day payments from both programs. A closed UI claim with a remaining overpayment balance doesn't block PFL.

0 coins

edd sent me a Notice of Computation after I filed my bonding claim and I had no clue what the weekly amount on it even meant, like whether it was what id actually get or something else. used Claimyr and reached a PFL agent who told me the amount on my DE 429DF was my potential weekly benefit based on my base period wages, and that it wasn't a final approval, just what I could get if eligible, anyway that cleared it up

0 coins

That notice trips everyone up because it looks like an approval letter but it isn't.

0 coins

Sounds like marketing for some service to me. Getting a live PFL agent just like that.

0 coins

I thought the same thing at first, honestly. But I tried it myself when my second payment was late and I actually talked to an EDD agent who told me my proof of relationship document had been received and matched to my claim. After that I stopped being skeptical.

0 coins

Alright, if it's actually EDD on the other end I might try it. Got a question about my own claim anyway.

0 coins

The base period for PFL is the 12 months ending about 5 to 18 months before your claim starts, highest quarter of wages used to calculate the amount. Your Notice of Computation will show what EDD calculated. The calculator on EDD's site gives you an estimate before you file if you want a rough number.

0 coins

I didn't even know there was a calculator on EDD's site. I'll check that before I file tonight so I have some idea what to expect.

0 coins

It's on edd.ca.gov, shouldn't be hard to find. It's not exact but gives you a ballpark before the Notice of Computation arrives.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation came in the mail for me about a week after filing. It's not an approval, as was said above, just the potential weekly amount.

0 coins

also just want to say, your daughter just arrived and you're doing the right thing by sorting this out now instead of later. the 41 days goes faster than you think with a newborn.

0 coins

Thank you, I really needed that reminder. Filing tonight for sure.

0 coins

41 days feels long until it's day 38 and you've been running on no sleep. File as soon as you can.

0 coins

For the bonding claim specifically: proof of relationship document, in your case a birth certificate, goes with the claim in SDI Online. No Part C or Part D for bonding, those are only for care claims. That's a common confusion.

0 coins

I saw Part C and Part D mentioned somewhere and started worrying I needed those too. So bonding is just the birth certificate?

0 coins

Correct. Part C and Part D are for care claims, where a family member is seriously ill. Bonding for a new child is different, just the proof of relationship.

0 coins

Worth underlining: never upload Part C or Part D online anyway even on a care claim, EDD says it can delay things. Those go by mail or the doctor submits Part D in SDI Online with your receipt number.

0 coins

My PFL experience: filed bonding claim for my son, had an old unemployment thing in my history, PFL paid out completely normally! Zero interference. You're going to be fine!

0 coins

Okay at this point I've heard it from enough people. Filing tonight. Thank you all.

0 coins

Go enjoy your daughter! The claim will work itself out.

0 coins

Good luck with the new baby.

0 coins

One thing that stressed me after I filed was not knowing if my proof of relationship had been received. Keep an eye on SDI Online for status updates and if it stays pending past 14 days without movement, send a Request Claim Update through SDI Online.

0 coins

How do I send a Request Claim Update, is that in SDI Online through myEDD?

0 coins

Yes, log into myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/, go into SDI Online, open your claim, and there should be a Request Claim Update option. Pick the type that fits and write your question.

0 coins

14 days is EDD's stated window for deciding a claim. If you hit that mark with no notice and no payment, the Request Claim Update is the right move.

0 coins

edd line is basically impossible to get through on without spending your whole morning trying. forums like this are honestly more reliable for quick answers

0 coins

Spent three hours across two days trying to reach someone about my care claim. The forum answer here is accurate at least, so there's that.

0 coins

yeah at least people here actually answer

0 coins

For the overpayment itself on the UI side, you'll want to handle repayment through that program's process separately. It doesn't go away on its own, but it also doesn't come out of your PFL. Two separate things to manage.

0 coins

Yes I know I need to deal with the overpayment repayment, I just needed to know PFL was safe. This thread confirmed it. Thank you.

0 coins

Good. Take care of both and you'll be squared away on both. Congrats on the new baby.

0 coins

Handle the overpayment through the UI side and collect your PFL without worrying they're connected. That's the bottom line.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure