Back to California Paid Family Leave

Dylan Fisher

Does PFL and SDI share the same maximum benefit amount, or are they calculated differently?

So I've been trying to figure this out and I keep going in circles. I had a pregnancy disability claim earlier this year and now I'm transitioning to the PFL bonding portion. My HR person mentioned the weekly amount might be different between the two and I honestly can't tell if that's true or not. Does PFL and SDI share the same maximum benefit amount, or does bonding pay out at a different rate? My Notice of Computation came in for the pregnancy claim but I haven't gotten one yet for the PFL side. Are they even calculated from the same base period? Sorry if this is a jumbled question, I have a newborn and a toddler and my brain is not working.

Eleven days after my bonding claim went active, SDI Online still showed the payment date as pending, so I put in a Request Claim Update and got no response after a week. Eventually I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live agent on the line, and the agent pulled up my claim and told me the first payment had actually issued three days earlier but the SDI Online display just hadn't refreshed. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

Used Claimyr myself back when my bonding payments went quiet for two weeks. Agent confirmed which weeks had been paid and told me the next payment would issue once EDD received my Continued Claim Certification. Good to know the SDI Online display can lag like that, that explains a lot.

0 coins

Wait, what did they say the next one was tied to, your certification form coming in?

0 coins

Yeah exactly, they were waiting on the DE 2580GF. Once I sent that in the payment moved same day.

0 coins

Does the display lag happen a lot? I keep refreshing mine every hour and nothing's changing and I'm starting to spiral.

0 coins

To your base period question: both your pregnancy disability claim and your PFL bonding claim draw from the same type of base period, which is the highest-earning quarter within a 12-month window that runs from roughly five to eighteen months before your claim starts. Because your bonding claim starts right after your disability claim ends, the two claims are likely looking at the same or very similar periods. That said, the actual weekly amounts can differ if the base periods land differently, and the Notice of Computation for the bonding side will show you exactly what EDD calculated. Wait for that letter before assuming the amounts match.

0 coins

Thank you, that makes sense. So I should just wait for the second Notice of Computation instead of assuming it's the same number?

0 coins

Exactly. The calculator on EDD's site gives an estimate, but the real figure comes from your notice. Don't worry until you see it.

0 coins

This is the part nobody told me when I transitioned from my disability claim to bonding. I just assumed same amount, same deal. Got a small surprise when my notice arrived.

0 coins

Worth pointing out from EDD's own materials: both Disability Insurance and PFL benefits are calculated as roughly 70 to 90 percent of your wages from the base period quarter, depending on your income level. So the formula is the same in structure. But your HR person isn't entirely wrong either, because the starting dates of the two claims can shift which quarter lands as your highest, and that shifts the weekly amount. The estimate tool on EDD's site can run both scenarios if you plug in different start dates.

0 coins

I think I read somewhere that PFL pays less than disability, like a lower percentage, is that actually true or did I read it wrong?

0 coins

They use the same percentage range, 70 to 90 percent depending on your wages. The old rule had PFL at 60 to 70 percent, but California updated it. If you're seeing older articles they might still quote the old numbers.

0 coins

Oh, that's a relief. Thanks for clearing that up. I had a whole panicked note written to HR about it.

0 coins

Your HR person probably heard the old rule. Same formula now for both. Check your notice when it shows up, that's your real number.

0 coins

Got it. Appreciate the straight answer.

0 coins

both programs pull from the same wage calculation, pfl just used to be lower. they fixed that a few years back. same max now.

0 coins

wait so they literally use the exact same number for the cap? i thought pfl was always gonna be a little less

0 coins

yeah same structure. your own wages determine where you land within the range. the max is the max either way.

0 coins

For what it's worth on the base period math: if your pregnancy disability claim started in, say, February, your base period for that claim looks back to roughly August of the prior year through July. Your bonding claim that starts right after will likely look at a very similar window, though the exact quarter EDD lands on as your highest can shift by a few months. Run both start dates through the benefits calculator on EDD's site and compare the estimates side by side.

0 coins

I didn't know the calculator let you do that. Going to try it right now, anyway.

0 coins

Yes, just plug in the bonding claim start date instead of the disability start date and it recalculates. Gives you a rough comparison before the notice arrives.

0 coins

Around week six of my bonding leave I lost track of exactly how many of the eight weeks I'd used because I'd taken some days intermittently before going full-time leave. I tried Claimyr to reach a PFL agent directly and she looked up my claim and told me I had two weeks and three days remaining in my 12-month window. That was the clearest answer I'd gotten after spending three mornings on the phone getting cut off.

0 coins

I'll be honest, reads like a marketing comment to me. EDD's line is impossible and suddenly someone has a perfect answer? Not buying it.

0 coins

Had the same thought at first. Then I tried it on my own care claim because my mom's situation was dragging on. Agent confirmed the DE 2500E had issued and told me what date it had been mailed. That's not something you get from a recording.

0 coins

Hm. If it actually pulls up account details like that I may give it a shot. I need to know whether my proof of relationship even made it into their system.

0 coins

Knowing the exact days remaining helped me plan the last stretch of leave. That's really all I used the call for.

0 coins

No waiting period on PFL either, which trips people up when they come off a disability claim. Disability has seven unpaid days at the start. Bonding doesn't.

0 coins

Wait, really? I was planning for seven unpaid days on my bonding claim because my coworker said to expect it. So that's wrong?

0 coins

Correct. PFL has no waiting period. EDD's own materials say so directly. Your coworker is thinking of the disability claim that probably came before.

0 coins

This tripped me up too! I sat there budgeting for a gap week that never happened. Bonding payments started right away once the claim processed.

0 coins

The notice will tell you everything. Just wait for it.

0 coins

Yeah I'm trying to be patient. Hard with a newborn.

0 coins

My bonding claim notice came about a week after I submitted the claim. The number was a little different from my disability claim, not by a lot, but different enough to matter for budgeting. Plan for a slight difference just in case.

0 coins

How different are we talking? Like a significant drop?

0 coins

For me it was maybe a small shift. Really depends on your wages and which quarter EDD uses. Use the calculator on EDD's site to get a range, then you won't be caught off guard.

0 coins

This is the right advice. The base period overlap can go either way, and sometimes the bonding notice actually comes out a bit higher if a good-earning quarter shifted in.

0 coins

The 41-day thing nearly caught me off guard on my bonding claim. My disability claim wrapped up and I honestly thought I had more time before filing for bonding. I ended up using Claimyr to reach someone at EDD and the agent pulled up my claim's start date and confirmed exactly when my 41-day window closed, so I knew I hadn't missed it. That was the one thing I really needed to hear.

0 coins

What did you have ready when you got on the line with the agent? Like did they need your receipt number or anything?

0 coins

Yep, had my receipt number and the date my disability claim ended. Agent found everything fast once I gave those two things.

0 coins

Been trying that line myself every morning for going on two weeks. Got a recording every time.

0 coins

I'm confused about something related. If I take some PFL days now for bonding and then later my dad gets sick and I need to file a care claim, do those come from the same eight weeks? I thought they were separate.

0 coins

They draw from the same eight weeks within any 12-month period, all types of PFL together. So if you use five weeks bonding with the baby, you have three weeks left for a care claim if it's within that same 12-month window. It's one shared bank, not separate buckets.

0 coins

Oh wow, I completely had that wrong. I thought I had eight weeks bonding and then another eight for a care claim. That's a big difference in planning.

0 coins

same, i thought each reason got its own eight weeks. good to know before i make any plans

0 coins

Exactly, one pool for the whole year. Plan accordingly before you use up bonding time you might need later.

0 coins

Don't forget your proof of relationship if you're a non-birth parent. Birth certificate or the Declaration of Paternity. No proof, no payment.

0 coins

I uploaded the birth certificate when I filed, so hopefully that's covered.

0 coins

Good. Check SDI Online to confirm it's showing as received. If it's still pending after a couple weeks, send a Request Claim Update.

0 coins

Something my claims processor neighbor told me that I didn't know: when you file the PFL bonding claim as a birth mother coming off disability, there's actually a specific form for that transition, the DE 2501FP. You don't need to upload any documents with it. That's different from what a dad or a partner files.

0 coins

I am the birth mother so this applies to me! EDD mailed me that form after my disability claim closed. I sent it back and I'm now waiting on the PFL side to process.

0 coins

That's exactly right. The DE 2501FP is for new mothers coming off a pregnancy disability claim, and EDD sends it to you. You're on the right track.

0 coins

I'm a birth mother too and I had no idea this was a separate form. I was about to file from scratch in SDI Online.

0 coins

The 70 to 90 percent range is based on your income relative to the state average wage. Lower earners get closer to 90 percent of their wages replaced, higher earners get closer to 70 percent. EDD's calculator on their site will put you roughly in the right spot.

0 coins

So higher earners don't necessarily hit the maximum even if their wages are high?

0 coins

They hit the maximum, but as a percentage of their wages it's lower because the cap exists. If your wages are above a certain point you're at the max dollar amount but that's a smaller slice of your total pay. The notice will show you where you land.

0 coins

Both programs, same math, same general maximum, same calculation period. The only practical difference is that disability starts with seven unpaid days and PFL doesn't. Everything else runs parallel.

0 coins

That's the clearest summary I've seen in this whole thread, thank you.

0 coins

Dead right, and that one difference is the one everyone gets confused about every time.

0 coins

pfl also covers more than just bonding. care claims, military assist. same eight weeks total though.

0 coins

wait military assist is a thing through pfl? i had no idea

0 coins

yeah if a family member is deploying to a foreign country on covered active duty orders. not super common but it's there.

0 coins

Payments can go on debit card, direct deposit or check depending on what you set up when you filed. Direct deposit is only available on SDI Online claims.

0 coins

Is it too late to switch to direct deposit after filing?

0 coins

You can update it in SDI Online under your claim. Do it before the first payment issues if you can.

0 coins

PFL and your disability claim are paid separately, so you should never see them overlap on the same day. If your disability claim is still technically active when bonding starts, sort that out first or you could get an overpayment.

0 coins

My disability claim had a clear end date on the notice before I sent back the DE 2501FP, so I think there's no overlap. But I'll double-check in SDI Online.

0 coins

Good call. As long as the disability claim shows closed and the PFL start date is the day after, you're fine.

0 coins

You can appeal within 30 days if the notice comes back and the amount looks wrong. Keep that form.

0 coins

Noted, keeping everything.

0 coins

EDD's site has a benefits calculator that runs the estimate based on your wages. Worth doing before the notice arrives just so you're not totally in the dark on your budget.

0 coins

Just ran it after someone mentioned it above. Got a rough number that at least lets me plan. Fingers crossed the notice matches.

0 coins

The notice usually lands within a week or so of the claim activating. You won't be waiting long.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure