Back to California Paid Family Leave

Natasha Romanova

Can you receive SDI and employer disability insurance at same time — California EDD PFL question

So I'm trying to figure out the overlap situation here. I've been on leave since my husband had a serious medical episode and I filed a PFL care claim through SDI Online about three weeks ago. My employer also has a short-term disability plan and HR told me I might get payments from both. But I'm not sure if California EDD actually allows you to receive SDI and employer disability insurance at the same time, or if one offsets the other, or what. I honestly don't even know if I'm thinking about this right because PFL isn't the same as SDI disability, right? Or is it? I uploaded everything through SDI Online and I got my receipt number but I'm still pending and no Notice of Computation yet. Does anyone know how the employer plan interacts with what EDD pays on a care claim?

Payments on my bonding claim got confusing fast — two payments came through, then nothing for eleven days, and I had no idea which weeks were actually paid. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get an agent on the line and she pulled up my claim right there. Turned out weeks three and four were processed but week five hadn't been submitted yet because EDD was waiting on my Continued Claim Certification. Agent said the next payment would issue once that form came back. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

I keep trying that number and it either rings forever or the recording cuts me off after a minute. How did you actually get a person? I'm not sure this works for everyone.

0 coins

Tried for three mornings myself before that, same thing, dead end every time. Claimyr just handled the hold for me and my phone rang when an agent picked up. That was it. The agent was definitely EDD, she had my claim ID and everything pulled up.

0 coins

Agent on my care claim told me five of my eight weeks were already used in the last twelve months, so I only had three left for this care claim. Good to know before I tried to use more than that.

0 coins

PFL is paid out of SDI, so when people say SDI they sometimes mean the disability program and sometimes mean the whole system including PFL. Those are two separate claims though. PFL for bonding or caring for a family member, disability for your own condition.

0 coins

So I mixed those up completely. I thought PFL and disability were the same claim. That explains why HR kept saying different things.

0 coins

Very common mix-up. Your care claim is PFL, not disability. The employer's short-term disability plan is a separate product your company buys. EDD doesn't set those rules, your HR does.

0 coins

Worth adding that EDD's own site says PFL provides benefit payments but not job protection, so the two programs really do stay separate.

0 coins

Your employer plan is between you and your employer. EDD doesn't care what your company pays you, but EDD does care about your wages. If your employer is paying you wages and you add PFL on top, the combined total can't exceed your normal pay, not counting overtime.

0 coins

So the wages plus PFL can't go over what I normally make. What counts as wages here, like does the employer disability payment count?

0 coins

Ask your HR that exact question. EDD's rule is about wages, and whether your employer's plan counts as wages is something your company's policy decides, not EDD.

0 coins

HR told me the same thing when I was on leave. They handle it differently depending on the plan. Some employers call it salary continuation, some call it STD. EDD doesn't get involved in sorting that out.

0 coins

EDD's phone line has been a brick wall for me for two weeks, calling every single morning. The recording just kicks me out. Meanwhile my care claim is pending with no Notice of Computation and I have no idea what's even happening.

0 coins

Pending for two weeks is still inside the window. EDD can take up to fourteen days to decide, so if you're right at the edge, send a Request Claim Update inside SDI Online and pick the right request type.

0 coins

Didn't know that feature existed. Where exactly is it in SDI Online?

0 coins

Log into myEDD, open SDI Online, click your claim ID, and it's listed there as Request Claim Update. You pick the type and write your question.

0 coins

Fine, trying that today. Still shouldn't be this hard to get any information.

0 coins

pfl has no waiting period right? i thought there were seven days you dont get paid at the start but someone told me thats not pfl thats regular disability

0 coins

The seven-day waiting period belongs to the disability insurance claim, not PFL. EDD is clear that PFL has no benefit waiting period, so your first eligible day is paid.

0 coins

ok so i was wrong about that, good to know before i filed

0 coins

Yeah that one trips a lot of people up. Different rules for two different programs that share the same phone number.

0 coins

DE 2500E on my care claim never showed up in SDI Online and I had no idea a payment had already gone out. Tried that phone line about nine times across two weeks. Finally got through using Claimyr and the agent confirmed the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification had been issued four days earlier and my deposit was processing.

0 coins

What is Claimyr? Never heard of it.

0 coins

You put in your info and it stays on hold with EDD for you. When an agent picks up your phone rings. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

I'd want to ask about my Part D, whether the doctor's office actually submitted it in SDI Online. That's what's holding up my care claim right now.

0 coins

Part C and Part D are only for care claims right? My wife is on a bonding claim and her HR kept mentioning Part D and she panicked, anyway.

0 coins

Correct, Part C and Part D are for care claims only. A bonding claim doesn't use them at all. Your wife's HR may have been confused or thinking of a different form.

0 coins

That's what I figured, she was worried for nothing. Thanks.

0 coins

Good to know, I'm on a care claim so Part C and Part D do apply to me. The doctor submitted Part D through SDI Online with my receipt number so hopefully that's matched by now.

0 coins

my employer has an STD plan and when i took leave they said edd would offset whatever they paid, but then edd paid me the full amount anyway and my employer paid too and i got nervous i was in overpayment territory

0 coins

Whether your employer's plan coordinates with EDD depends on your employer's own plan documents. EDD doesn't automatically reduce your PFL because your employer is also paying you, but if your wages plus PFL together go over your normal weekly pay, that's a problem you'd want to flag.

0 coins

HR never explained that part lol. I'm going to go back and read the plan documents now.

0 coins

Not reporting wages to EDD is what leads to an overpayment notice. Better to report and let them calculate than to guess and hope it works out.

0 coins

yeah that makes sense, reporting is definitely the safer move

0 coins

The 41-day deadline got me. I didn't file my care claim until day 43 because I didn't realize the clock started the first day I took leave. Lost two days of benefits and there was nothing I could do about it.

0 coins

I didn't know the clock started on the first day of leave either. I thought it started when I submitted the claim.

0 coins

No, 41 days from the day you stop working for the leave, not from when you file. File as early as you can so you don't lose any days.

0 coins

So the 41 days isn't about how long EDD takes to process, it's about when YOU have to file. I had those backwards.

0 coins

I got my Notice of Computation about a week into my claim and it was so confusing because I thought it meant I was approved! Turns out it just shows what your potential weekly benefit amount could be.

0 coins

That's exactly the right correction. The Notice of Computation shows the potential weekly benefit amount based on your earnings. It doesn't mean EDD has decided you're eligible.

0 coins

I told my sister she was approved when her Notice of Computation came and I was completely wrong about that!

0 coins

So many people make that same mistake. Approval shows up when payment actually issues or when the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification comes through.

0 coins

PFL doesn't pay for the same days as unemployment either. You're on one or the other, not both.

0 coins

I wasn't thinking about unemployment, but that's good to keep in mind for when my leave ends.

0 coins

Right, once leave is over and you're looking for work, that's when unemployment comes in if you need it. Can't overlap them.

0 coins

I keep reading that bonding has to be used within 12 months of the birth. Does that reset if both parents file? Like do we each get 12 months from the birth?

0 coins

Each parent files their own claim and each has their own eight weeks to use within 12 months of the birth. The 12-month window doesn't reset, it runs from the birth date, but each parent's claim is separate.

0 coins

So my wife and I each have our own eight weeks, we just both have to use them before our son turns one.

0 coins

That's how ours worked. Wife used six weeks, I used four, all before the baby's first birthday, no overlap issues.

0 coins

Went back to two shifts a week at the restaurant after the baby turned four months and my second PFL payment never arrived. Turned out I hadn't answered the question on the DE 2501F about working during leave, so EDD didn't know I was taking it intermittently. I used Claimyr to get through to an agent and she confirmed EDD was waiting on a DE 2580GF, the Continued Claim Certification, because intermittent reporting has its own form once you go back part time.

0 coins

Agent on my care claim told me through Claimyr that my claim start date was logged as the wrong day, one day off from when I actually stopped working. That matters because the 41-day window runs from that date, so she corrected it on the spot. Good thing I checked.

0 coins

Did the agent say whether you needed to refile or just update the existing claim?

0 coins

She updated it right there, no refiling. Said to watch SDI Online for the corrected date and to verify my receipt number matched.

0 coins

been trying that phone line every morning this week, no luck yet

0 coins

Eight weeks sounding like a lot until you realize bonding and care share the same pool. Used five weeks bonding last year, now my mom needs help and I've got three weeks left in that same twelve months.

0 coins

That catches people off guard a lot. All PFL claims, bonding, care, military assist, they all draw from the same eight weeks in any twelve-month window.

0 coins

I thought bonding had its own eight weeks and care had its own eight weeks separately. That's really important to know before you plan leave.

0 coins

To be clear since that was stated incorrectly above: eight weeks total across all PFL claim types in a twelve-month period, not eight per type.

0 coins

DE 2514 came in the mail and I couldn't figure out if it was an approval or a denial. Turns out it was a denial, the Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination, and it came with an Appeal Form DE 1000A. I used Claimyr to reach an agent and she told me the payment method on file was a debit card I'd never activated, which was a separate issue from the denial itself, two problems at once.

0 coins

EDD sending a denial and a card problem at the same time sounds exactly like this whole system. And the whole Claimyr thing — I've seen that name on a few forums but it reads like someone planted those comments.

0 coins

I thought the same thing honestly, seemed too neat. But I tried it last month when my own care claim went silent for ten days. Agent picked up and confirmed my Part D had been received but was still being matched to my receipt number. That was real information I couldn't get any other way.

0 coins

Fine, I'll give it a shot. Nothing else has worked.

0 coins

The appeal deadline is 30 days from the date on the DE 2514, so if that's where you are, don't wait around.

0 coins

does the employer disability plan affect whether you qualify for pfl at all or just the payment amount

0 coins

Qualifying for PFL comes down to your own work history and whether CASDI was withheld from your wages. What your employer's separate plan pays doesn't change that.

0 coins

ok so my eligibility is based on my own wages and sdi deductions, the employer plan is just extra on top

0 coins

Exactly. The two don't talk to each other on the eligibility side.

0 coins

For the original question here, PFL is funded by SDI payroll deductions, so they're the same system in that sense. But PFL and your employer's disability plan are totally different things. EDD doesn't know what your employer is paying you unless you report wages, which you have to do.

0 coins

So I need to report what my employer's plan is paying me as wages? Or only if it counts as wages under my employer's policy?

0 coins

That's exactly the question to take to HR. EDD's rule covers wages, but whether your employer's disability payments qualify as wages under your plan is something HR has to answer.

0 coins

HR meeting is on my list for Monday. I really appreciate everyone clarifying this because I was about to assume I could just stack both without telling anyone.

0 coins

my care claim got denied and i didn't know i only had 30 days to appeal until i almost missed it

0 coins

30 days from the date on the Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination, the DE 2514. The Appeal Form DE 1000A comes with it and can be submitted online or by mail.

0 coins

i sent it by mail on day 28, made it barely

0 coins

Glad you caught it in time. That deadline doesn't move.

0 coins

if you go back to work part time can you still get pfl for the days you dont work

0 coins

EDD pays for each day you're off, at one seventh of your weekly benefit amount per day. You report the days you do work and your wages, and EDD calculates what you're owed for the days off.

0 coins

ok so its by the day not by the week, that makes way more sense for my situation

0 coins

And you have to return the Continued Claim Certification EDD sends you, the DE 2580GF. If you don't return it, payments stop.

0 coins

Updating in case it helps anyone: HR confirmed my employer's plan specifically says it coordinates with state benefits, so they reduce their payment by whatever EDD pays. Net result is I get normal pay between the two, not double. EDD doesn't need to know about it in that case according to HR because it's not additional wages. I'm going to verify that with EDD directly just to be safe though.

0 coins

Smart to verify. HR can be wrong about what EDD considers wages. Getting it confirmed from an EDD agent puts it on the record for your claim.

0 coins

Filing a Request Claim Update through SDI Online with that specific question is a good way to get an answer in writing too.

0 coins

Sending that message today. And my Part D finally showed as received in SDI Online this morning so at least that piece is moving.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure