Can you apply for PFL while SDI denial is under appeal?
So my wife's short-term disability claim got denied and we filed an appeal right away, but we also just had our second kid two weeks ago. I've been burning through my own PTO and I'm wondering if she can apply for PFL bonding on top of the appeal or if that messes everything up. Like does EDD treat them as completely separate things or does the pending appeal block a PFL bonding claim from going through? Really stressed about the gap in income here and nobody I've called has given me a clear answer. Anyone dealt with this before?
81 comments

Aisha Rahman
Weeks remaining on a PFL bonding claim were the exact thing I had to call about, because my wife used some weeks on our first kid and we weren't sure how many were left for this new baby's bonding. Ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live person at EDD after too many mornings of hitting that recording that just ends the call. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up the account and confirmed two weeks had been used in the prior 12-month period, so six were left for bonding with this baby. The DI denial and the appeal were a separate matter the agent said nothing about affecting the PFL side.
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
Pulled up my own account after reading this and had the same question about weeks left. Used Claimyr on a different claim last spring when payment timing was unclear. The agent confirmed the DE 2500E had already been issued and told me which day the first payment would process, so I knew exactly what to look for.
0 coins
Yuki Sato
how many mornings did you try before you just gave up and did that? ive been at it since tuesday and the line just cuts me off every single time
0 coins
Aisha Rahman
Four mornings straight before I tried something different. Each time same thing, got about two minutes in and the line dropped.
0 coins
Yuki Sato
ugh ok noted
0 coins
Carmen Flores
The two programs really do run on separate tracks. A denial on a Disability Insurance claim and an appeal of that denial don't put a hold on a PFL bonding claim. Your wife files her PFL bonding claim in SDI Online through myEDD, provides the proof of relationship, and EDD evaluates it on its own eligibility criteria, which are about base period wages with SDI withheld, not about whether a DI claim was approved or denied.
0 coins
QuantumQueen
AuthorThat's actually a relief. So she just goes into myEDD and starts the bonding application fresh, not connected to the DI appeal at all?
0 coins
Carmen Flores
Exactly right. The bonding claim is its own filing. She'll need a proof of relationship document, something like a birth certificate or Declaration of Paternity, and the application asks for the child's date of birth. She files no earlier than the first day of family leave.
0 coins
Andre Dubois
Wait, I'm confused now. I thought if EDD already denied one claim they might flag the account or something? Or is that not a thing?
0 coins
Carmen Flores
The DI denial is for her own disability claim. PFL bonding is for a different purpose entirely. EDD doesn't cross-deny them. File the bonding claim and let EDD decide it on its own merits.
0 coins
Andre Dubois
ok that actually makes more sense, I was overthinking it
0 coins
CyberSamurai
41 days is what caught me when I went through something similar. The bonding claim has to be filed within 41 days of when family leave starts, or you can lose benefits for days before you filed. That deadline is in EDD's own materials and it doesn't pause while something else is on appeal. If your wife's leave started the day of the birth, that clock is already running.
0 coins
QuantumQueen
AuthorTwo weeks ago was the birth, so I've got to get her moving on this today. Didn't realize the clock was ticking separately from everything else going on with the appeal.
0 coins
CyberSamurai
File today if possible. The 41 days counts from when leave started, not from when you discovered the deadline. SDI Online through myEDD is fastest.
0 coins
Zoe Alexopoulos
Is the 41 days calendar days or business days? I keep second-guessing myself on this one.
0 coins
CyberSamurai
Calendar days, not business days. So every day counts including weekends.
0 coins
Jamal Carter
EDD's phone line for PFL is 1-877-238-4373 by the way. Not that you'll get through on the first try, or the fifth. But at least have the number.
0 coins
Mei Liu
Tried that number eight times last month. Twice it didn't even ring, just went to a tone. EDD's phone situation is a joke.
0 coins
Jamal Carter
Yeah it's not exactly a smooth experience. Tried early morning, tried after lunch, tried Fridays. Same result most days.
0 coins
Liam O'Donnell
Same. Eventually gave up and sent a Request Claim Update through SDI Online instead.
0 coins
Amara Nwosu
Start date on my care claim got questioned because I entered it wrong when I filed, which pushed the 41-day window into question too. Tried calling for three days, mornings and afternoons, nothing got through. Used Claimyr to reach an EDD agent and they checked the actual start date on file and confirmed the 41 days had been met, that the form had come in on day 38. Huge relief because I'd been convinced I'd blown the deadline.
0 coins
AstroExplorer
I've tried that line probably a dozen times over two weeks and have never once reached a person. How does something like Claimyr actually change that outcome? Sounds too convenient to me.
0 coins
Amara Nwosu
Honestly I had the same feeling before I tried it. What it does is stay on the line with EDD while you do other things, and when an actual agent picks up, your phone rings and you're on. That's the whole thing. I talked to a real EDD employee who had access to my claim.
0 coins
Giovanni Moretti
Used it too when my DE 2580GF situation got complicated. I'd gone back to part time and wasn't sure my intermittent days had been reported correctly. The agent walked through the form, confirmed which days were showing as reported and which weeks still needed certification. That cleared up two weeks of guessing.
0 coins
AstroExplorer
Alright, I'll try it. I've been going in circles on this for a while and I need an actual answer about my own claim.
0 coins
QuantumQueen
AuthorMight be worth it for my wife's situation too if the bonding claim gets stuck pending.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Farsi
PFL doesn't have a waiting period. No unpaid first week the way disability does. First eligible day pays. Worth knowing before she files so there's no surprise when the payment comes sooner than expected.
0 coins
Zoe Alexopoulos
Wait, really? I thought there was a week you don't get paid no matter what. So PFL just starts paying from day one?
0 coins
Fatima Al-Farsi
That's the disability waiting period, seven days. PFL has no waiting period. Different program, different rules.
0 coins
Andre Dubois
I definitely had these mixed up. Good to know before I file mine next month.
0 coins
Dylan Cooper
The base period wages question is worth checking before filing. PFL eligibility requires at least 300 dollars in wages with SDI withheld during the base period, which covers wages roughly 5 to 18 months before the claim starts. The DI denial doesn't change that calculation. If her wages qualified her for the DI claim in the first place, they almost certainly meet the PFL threshold too.
0 coins
QuantumQueen
AuthorShe's been working the same job for three years, so wages shouldn't be the issue. The DI claim got denied on a different basis, something about documentation they said was incomplete.
0 coins
Dylan Cooper
Documentation issues on a DI claim have no bearing on the PFL eligibility standard, so she should be in good shape on that side.
0 coins
Mei Liu
EDD denying for 'incomplete documentation' is real vague. Hope the appeal goes your way.
0 coins
Sofia Perez
December 3rd was when my PFL payment went to the wrong method because I hadn't updated my direct deposit in SDI Online before filing. Spent two weeks sorting that out, so double-check the payment method before submitting the bonding claim.
0 coins
QuantumQueen
AuthorGood catch. She set up myEDD a while ago for the DI claim, so that might already be in there, but I'll have her verify before hitting submit.
0 coins
Sofia Perez
The payment method on the DI claim doesn't carry over automatically to a new PFL claim in every case. Have her confirm it during the PFL filing steps.
0 coins
Dmitry Smirnov
Appeal takes however long it takes. PFL keeps moving on its own calendar. File both.
0 coins
QuantumQueen
AuthorShort and to the point. Yeah, filing both.
0 coins
Dmitry Smirnov
That's the move.
0 coins
ElectricDreamer
Payment method on my bonding claim was what finally made me pick up the phone, because SDI Online showed debit card but I had set up direct deposit and I didn't know which one EDD actually had. Used Claimyr to get through to someone in EDD's PFL line since my own attempts were going nowhere, two full weeks of trying mornings before work. The agent confirmed direct deposit was on file and was the active method, and told me the debit card option had not been activated. So I knew the deposit was coming to the right place.
0 coins
Sofia Perez
What exactly does Claimyr do, I haven't heard of it before?
0 coins
ElectricDreamer
You give it your info and it waits on hold with EDD's line for you. When an agent picks up on their end, you get a ring and you're talking to them directly. That's pretty much it.
0 coins
Sofia Perez
That's useful to know. I'd want to ask about why a payment that was supposed to come in mid-November hasn't posted yet, that would be worth a try.
0 coins
Ava Johnson
been trying that edd number since monday. maybe ill try what you used
0 coins
Zoe Alexopoulos
Can she file the PFL bonding claim if the DI appeal is still open? Like will EDD let both things exist at the same time for the same person?
0 coins
Carmen Flores
They can coexist. PFL and DI are separate claims. EDD won't deny PFL just because a DI appeal is pending. The only rule is that she can't be paid both on the same day, but that's a payment overlap issue, not a filing block.
0 coins
Zoe Alexopoulos
Oh, that's the piece I was missing. So it's not about whether you can file, it's about not getting paid for the same day twice.
0 coins
Carmen Flores
Exactly. File the PFL bonding claim now. EDD works out any overlap on the payment side.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
Birth certificate is what you need for proof of relationship on a bonding claim for a dad. Get a certified copy ordered if you don't have one yet. Some counties take a few weeks.
0 coins
QuantumQueen
AuthorWe have one from the hospital. That work or does it need to be a certified county copy?
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
Hospital copy worked for my claim. The certified one is a backup if EDD asks for more. Usually the hospital copy does the job.
0 coins
CyberSamurai
EDD's materials also list a Declaration of Paternity form CS-909 as an accepted proof of relationship option, so there are a few routes if the hospital copy causes any issue.
0 coins
Giovanni Moretti
PFL weekly benefit amount won't be on the DI denial notice. She'll get her own Notice of Computation for the PFL claim, which is what tells her the weekly amount for bonding. Keep an eye for that in the mail after she files.
0 coins
Zoe Alexopoulos
Is the Notice of Computation the approval, or is there a separate letter that actually says approved?
0 coins
Giovanni Moretti
The Notice of Computation shows potential weekly benefit but doesn't mean the claim is approved. The first payment is really the confirmation. If EDD decides she doesn't qualify, she'd get a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination instead.
0 coins
Andre Dubois
I did not know that distinction. I assumed the notice meant everything was fine.
0 coins
AstroExplorer
Eight weeks total sounds like a lot but it goes fast with a newborn. File as soon as possible so she gets the full amount without losing days to the 41-day window.
0 coins
QuantumQueen
AuthorFiling tonight. Appreciate the reminder.
0 coins
AstroExplorer
The myEDD portal at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ is where to start. Should take maybe 20 minutes if she has the info ready.
0 coins
Yuki Sato
does the appeal automatically pause anything or does edd just keep both cases open at the same time
0 coins
Carmen Flores
EDD keeps them open at the same time. The appeal on a DI claim goes to a separate process and doesn't freeze other claims.
0 coins
Yuki Sato
ok good thats what i was hoping
0 coins
Liam O'Donnell
PFL is wages-based, not health-based. The DI denial being about documentation doesn't touch PFL eligibility at all.
0 coins
QuantumQueen
AuthorClearer now than it was this morning, that's for sure.
0 coins
Liam O'Donnell
File today. 41 days moves fast.
0 coins
Ava Johnson
been here reading and my wife is in a similar spot, different circumstances but the pending situation is the same. sending her this thread.
0 coins
QuantumQueen
AuthorHope it helps her too. This thread answered more than the EDD phone line ever did for me.
0 coins
Ava Johnson
she asked about the waiting period thing and i could actually tell her the answer for once
0 coins
Dylan Cooper
Filing both at the same time is the right call. The PFL bonding claim gets reviewed on its own. The appeal stays on its own track. EDD has handled weirder combinations than this.
0 coins
Jamal Carter
EDD has handled weirder things, that I'll believe. Whether they handled them well is a different question.
0 coins
Dylan Cooper
Fair. But the systems at least don't block each other, which is the practical point.
0 coins
Mei Liu
Filing and hoping is basically the EDD experience in a nutshell.
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
EDD's benefit calculator on edd.ca.gov gives an estimate of the weekly amount before she files. Worth running that number so you know what to expect before the Notice of Computation arrives.
0 coins
QuantumQueen
AuthorDidn't know that existed. Running it now.
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
Use wages from the past year or so as inputs. The notice will have the real figure once EDD processes the claim, but the calculator gets you in the ballpark.
0 coins
Amara Nwosu
One more thing about the 41 days: even if her PFL bonding claim gets approved after the appeal is over, days lost before she filed are gone. EDD won't go back and pay days that fell outside the 41-day window.
0 coins
QuantumQueen
AuthorFiling tonight. Not losing a single day over paperwork timing.
0 coins
CyberSamurai
That's exactly the right priority. The appeal timeline has nothing to do with when the 41-day clock started.
0 coins
Zoe Alexopoulos
Is there any exception to the 41-day rule or is it strict?
0 coins
CyberSamurai
EDD's materials don't describe exceptions to the 41-day rule. File on time and don't count on an extension.
0 coins