Back to California Paid Family Leave

Anastasia Smirnova

Can pay pregnancy disability SDI if I applied for PFL too early

So I'm kind of a mess right now and hoping someone can help me sort this out. I had my baby three weeks ago and I was on pregnancy disability through EDD before the birth. When I was about 36 weeks pregnant I got confused and filed for PFL bonding thinking I needed to get ahead of it, but my pregnancy disability claim was still active. Now I'm worried I messed everything up. My disability claim ended about a week after the birth and I want to make sure I still get paid for bonding. Did filing PFL early cancel my pregnancy disability or overlap with it? Can EDD still pay pregnancy disability SDI if I applied for PFL too early? I haven't gotten any denial notice yet but I'm scared one is coming. SDI Online just shows the PFL claim as pending and I don't know what to do.

41 days after your bonding leave actually started is the deadline that matters, not when you filed. Filing before your pregnancy disability ended doesn't automatically cancel your disability payments. EDD won't pay both at the same time, but the pregnancy disability claim should have run its course first. Watch for a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination in the mail; if it shows the bonding start date as before your disability ended, that's what you'd appeal.

0 coins

The 41-day deadline you mentioned, does that count from the day my disability ended or from the actual birth date?

0 coins

Bonding leave typically starts right after the disability period ends for a birth mother. So the 41 days would run from when you actually began your bonding leave, which in your case is probably the day after your pregnancy disability claim closed.

0 coins

ok that makes more sense. i didn't realize they were two separate start dates like that.

0 coins

A denial notice came on my bonding claim last month, DE 2514, said my start date was off by nine days because I'd filed before my disability period closed, almost the same thing you're describing. I tried the EDD line for days before I found Claimyr (claimyr.com) and finally got a live person at PFL. The agent pulled up my claim and said the determination had gone out but the appeal window was still open, 30 days from the date on the notice. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. I filed the appeal with the DE 1000A and explained that my disability claim hadn't ended yet when I filed PFL. Still waiting to hear back but at least I know exactly where things stand now.

0 coins

The receipt number question is exactly what tripped me up too! I used Claimyr for my own bonding claim after losing the receipt number off my confirmation page, and the agent read it right back to me from the claim. After that I could track everything in SDI Online without guessing.

0 coins

How long had you been trying the EDD line before that?

0 coins

Tried eight mornings in a row before the agent answered. After the first three I stopped counting rings because the line just ended the call every time around the same point.

0 coins

30 days from the notice date, that's tight, anyway did you send the DE 1000A by mail or online?

0 coins

Mailed it to the address on the determination notice itself. The notice tells you exactly where it goes.

0 coins

PFL and pregnancy disability don't overlap in payment. EDD will not issue PFL benefits for the same days it already paid disability. Filing the bonding claim early is common and doesn't erase the disability payments. The issue is usually just the start date EDD records for bonding.

0 coins

Does EDD automatically adjust the bonding start date to after my disability ended, or do I have to tell them?

0 coins

You'd need to contact EDD if the start date on the determination looks wrong. They don't automatically fix it.

0 coins

im so glad someone said this, i was scared early filing deleted the whole disability period

0 coins

EDD's phone line is an absolute joke. Called at 8:01 three mornings straight and got a busy signal or a recording that cut off every single time. If you need to actually speak to someone about this overlap situation, good luck doing it the normal way.

0 coins

Sounds about right for that line.

0 coins

ive had the same thing happen, call drops right at the menu, i just gave up and sent a request claim update in sdi online

0 coins

The claim update request is what I ended up doing too but you don't always get a real answer, just a generic email saying they'll look into it.

0 coins

The DE 2501FP, the new mother form, is the one a birth mother uses to move from pregnancy disability to bonding. EDD mails it out when the disability claim ends. If you already filed the regular PFL bonding claim online before that form arrived, you might end up with two claim records. Worth confirming with EDD which one they're processing so you're not waiting on the wrong one.

0 coins

Nobody told me about the DE 2501FP, I just went into SDI Online and filed the PFL claim myself. Is it too late to use that form now?

0 coins

If EDD mailed you the DE 2501FP and you haven't sent it in yet, fill it out and return it. If EDD is already processing the SDI Online filing, contact them to clarify which claim they're working from so you don't end up with a duplicate.

0 coins

The DE 2501FP doesn't require a birth certificate or other proof of relationship documents, which is one reason EDD sends it specifically to birth mothers. That paperwork step you'd skip is not nothing.

0 coins

okay, I haven't gotten the form in the mail yet, but I'll watch for it and ask EDD which claim they have on file.

0 coins

Part D not" received sat on my care claim for my dad for two weeks after his doctor submitted it online. I ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr and she confirmed they had matched Part D to my claim that morning but it'hadn t updated yet in SDI Online. She also read me exactly what the proof of relationship document on file was so I knew nothing was missing. Really helped me stop spiraling about whether'I d messed up thesubmission.

0 coins

Eight calls over two weeks and the line either cut me off or said to try again, so I have my doubts anything gets through on that number. Did you actually end up speaking with someone who works for EDD, not a third party?

0 coins

Yes, the agent I spoke with worked at EDD. She knew my claim ID, the dates, and read me what was in the system. It wasn't a third party, it was an actual EDD staffer.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation on my care claim showed a weekly amount I didn't expect. I used Claimyr too and the agent confirmed the figure came from my highest-earning quarter in the base period and that the notice itself was the official record. After that I knew the amount was right and stopped second-guessing it.

0 coins

The agent confirmed the Part D was matched the same day you called, or had it been in the system earlier and just not showing?

0 coins

She said it had been received and matched that morning. So it was already done, SDI Online just hadn't caught up yet.

0 coins

Curious whether the pregnancy disability waiting period is the same seven days that some people mention for PFL, or whether it works differently for the disability side.

0 coins

PFL has no waiting period at all. EDD is clear about that. The seven-day unpaid period belongs to the Disability Insurance side, not to PFL bonding.

0 coins

oh interesting, so once the disability claim closes and bonding starts there's no additional waiting week before PFL kicks in?

0 coins

That's correct. PFL bonding benefits can start the day after the disability period ends with no gap week.

0 coins

Don't file the same PFL claim twice. If you already submitted it in SDI Online, let it sit and wait for the determination. Filing again won't speed it up, it'll just create a mess.

0 coins

I haven't resubmitted, just been watching the status. Still shows pending.

0 coins

Pending is normal for the first couple weeks. If it goes past 14 days with nothing, send a Request Claim Update through SDI Online.

0 coins

14 days felt like forever when I was waiting. Hang in there.

0 coins

The overlap thing confused me too when I first filed. I thought filing PFL early meant I was turning off my disability payments lol. Had to read the EDD site like three times before I got that they're completely separate claims.

0 coins

same exact panic, i thought i broke my own disability claim by touching the pfl page

0 coins

Right, like why isn't this explained more clearly when you're inside SDI Online filing? You just have to figure it out.

0 coins

EDD's instructions have never been what you'd call intuitive.

0 coins

February 3rd was my bonding start date and the Notice of Computation arrived on February 11th. If you haven't gotten yours yet, it usually comes within about a week or two of the claim going in. It shows your potential weekly benefit but it isn't an approval, just so you're not confused when it shows up.

0 coins

Mine still hasn't come and it's been about ten days since I filed. Is that still normal?

0 coins

Ten days is still within normal range. If you don't see it by day 14 or 15, that's when I'd send a Request Claim Update in SDI Online asking about it.

0 coins

Mine came on day 12 and I nearly missed it in the mail pile. Check EDD's calculator on their site if you want a rough estimate of the amount while you wait.

0 coins

Payment was supposed to cover my second week of bonding and nothing showed up in SDI Online, no deposit, no status change, nothing. I'd been trying the EDD line every morning for a week and a half. Eventually I got through to an agent using Claimyr. What it does is stay on the line with EDD while you do other things, then your phone rings when an actual EDD employee picks up. The agent told me the payment for that week had been issued two days earlier and gave me the exact date it processed. I realized I'd just been looking at the wrong claim ID in SDI Online the whole time.

0 coins

Wait, what exactly is Claimyr? Is it an app or something you call?

0 coins

You go through their site and they handle the hold time, then you get the agent live when EDD picks up. That's about all there is to it. For me I wanted to ask why a specific week wasn't showing as paid.

0 coins

That would be useful for me, I need to ask EDD when my bonding claim's start date was recorded because the date I put in and what SDI Online shows don't match.

0 coins

Wrong claim ID will get you every time. Easy mistake when you've got disability and PFL both in the system.

0 coins

the question about whether disability can still pay if you filed pfl too early, yes it can. they just won't pay both for the same day.

0 coins

That's actually the clearest answer I've seen so far. Thank you.

0 coins

been there. different claim, same panic.

0 coins

Is the proof of relationship document something a birth mother has to submit or does EDD already have it from the hospital or something, anyway I've been wondering this since my wife's claim is next month.

0 coins

A birth mother using the DE 2501FP doesn't need to submit a separate proof of relationship document. That form is specifically for her and EDD already links it to the pregnancy disability claim. A father or other parent filing through SDI Online does need to upload something, like a birth certificate.

0 coins

oh good because we were going to try to track down a copy this week and apparently we don't need to, that saves a step anyway

0 coins

EDD not paying both claims for the same days is the one rule they enforce pretty reliably, in my experience.

0 coins

Low bar but sure, that's something.

0 coins

You take what you can get.

0 coins

The eight weeks of PFL bonding, does that have to be used in one block or can you go back to work part time and stretch it out over a few months?

0 coins

You can break the eight weeks up. They just have to be used within 12 months of the birth. If you plan to work some days, you'd note that on your claim and report any wages to EDD. EDD will send a Continued Claim Certification to fill out when you do that.

0 coins

Good to know. My job offered me a partial return at week five and I didn't want to lose the remaining weeks.

0 coins

The 12-month window is the thing to watch. As long as you're inside it, you can take the weeks in pieces.

0 coins

someone at my job told me pfl and cfra are the same thing and i just want to flag that theyre not the same, pfl is the pay and cfra is about keeping your job

0 coins

Exactly right. PFL pays you but EDD says outright that it doesn't protect your job. CFRA is what handles job protection, and whether it applies is between you and your employer.

0 coins

yeah i learned the hard way that having pfl approved doesnt automatically mean your job is waiting

0 coins

Does that mean someone could collect PFL and still lose their job legally, or does CFRA always run at the same time?

0 coins

Whether CFRA applies depends on the employer's size and other factors those laws set. PFL doesn't trigger it automatically. That's a question for your employer's HR, not EDD.

0 coins

Hope your disability payments land correctly. The overlap situation sounds stressful but it sounds fixable.

0 coins

Thank you, I really needed to hear that.

0 coins

If a DE 2514 denial does show up, the appeal form is the DE 1000A and the deadline is 30 days from the date printed on the notice, not the date you receive it. Mailing it late because you thought the clock started when it arrived is a mistake that can cost you the appeal.

0 coins

30 days from the date on the notice itself, got it. I'll open anything from EDD the day it arrives just to be safe.

0 coins

The notice will also say where to send the appeal. Don't use a general EDD address; use the one listed on that specific form.

0 coins

i almost missed my own 30-day window because i assumed it was 30 days from when i got it in the mail. its not, its from the date they printed on it

0 coins

Bonding claim and pregnancy disability claim are always two separate files in EDD's system. Having both doesn't mean you did something wrong. It's how it's supposed to work for a birth mother.

0 coins

Genuinely relieved to read that. I thought I'd created some kind of problem by having two things open.

0 coins

You didn't. Just make sure the dates don't overlap when you get the determination.

0 coins

SDI Online is not great at showing you the full picture when you've got two claim types in there. The status page shows each one separately and it's easy to mix up which is which if the claim IDs look similar.

0 coins

Keeping a note of both claim IDs separately somewhere offline is worth doing from the start.

0 coins

yes, I wish someone had told me that before I spent a week staring at the wrong claim's status page lol

0 coins

Update from me: I called this morning and the person I reached confirmed my pregnancy disability claim paid out through its end date and the PFL bonding claim is still in review. No denial issued yet. They said to watch for the Notice of Computation and the determination. Feeling a lot less panicked. Thank you all.

0 coins

Glad you got a real answer. The determination notice should tell you everything about the bonding start date they've recorded.

0 coins

That's the right outcome. The two claims paying their own separate periods is exactly how it should work for a birth mother.

0 coins

Great news.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure