Back to California Paid Family Leave

Zara Rashid

Can employer require PTO before paid family leave for caregiving in California?

So my mom has been dealing with a pretty rough health situation and her doctor cleared me to take time off to care for her. I went ahead and filed a PFL care claim through SDI Online maybe two weeks ago, got the receipt number, and I know the doctor still needs to send in Part D. But my manager pulled me aside yesterday and said I have to burn through all my vacation and sick time first before EDD will even start paying me. I had honestly never heard that before. Is that actually a California EDD rule? Like, does EDD require you to use up your PTO before PFL kicks in? Or is this just my company's own policy? I don't want to push back on HR if it's a real requirement, but it also feels off because I need that PTO buffer for other things. Would love to know what anyone else has experienced with this.

Your employer can set that as their own policy. EDD doesn't require it. PFL pays once your claim is eligible regardless of whether you've taken any vacation or sick time. The rule about not exceeding your normal wages when combining PTO and PFL is real, but that's a cap, not a sequence your job controls for EDD's purposes.

0 coins

The cap part is what I wasn't clear on. So my job can make me use PTO first as a company rule, but EDD still starts paying from day one of my approved leave, they just check I'm not getting more than my normal wage total?

0 coins

Exactly. EDD pays its share; your employer's internal policy determines what they put in on their end. Ask HR to put that policy in writing so you have it.

0 coins

That makes sense, I'll ask HR for something written. Appreciate it.

0 coins

Wait, I'm kind of confused now. I thought PFL had like a waiting week where nothing gets paid, same as regular disability? So wouldn't the PTO thing kind of fill that gap anyway?

0 coins

PFL doesn't have an unpaid waiting week. That seven-day wait belongs to Disability Insurance for your own illness or injury, not to Paid Family Leave. Bonding and care claims under PFL start paying from the first eligible day.

0 coins

Oh wow, I had that completely backwards. I kept reading about the waiting period and assumed it applied to everything under SDI.

0 coins

Really common mix-up, don't feel bad. The two programs run on the same SDI system but have different rules.

0 coins

About two weeks after my care claim was filed, the weekly benefit amount on my Notice of Computation (DE 429DF) looked lower than what the online calculator had estimated, so I wanted to get clarity before assuming it was final. I tried the EDD Paid Family Leave line for three mornings straight and never got past the automated system. Eventually I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live EDD agent on the line. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my claim and walked me through which base period quarter was used to calculate the weekly amount, and it matched the notice once I understood which wages were included. The PTO question your employer raised is separate from EDD's calculation completely.

0 coins

Can I ask, when you reached the agent, did they explain anything about how to dispute the amount if the notice doesn't match what you expected?

0 coins

She said the Notice of Computation isn't an approval, just the potential weekly amount, and to look at which quarter's wages fed into it. If I disagreed I could appeal within 30 days using the form that comes with any denial notice. No dispute process for the computation itself, just check your wages match the base period.

0 coins

been trying that line since tuesday, four different times. good to know there's another way people are getting through.

0 coins

Your manager probably mixed up the company leave policy with what EDD actually does. Employers do this all the time and half of them don't even know the difference between PFL benefits and job-protected leave under CFRA.

0 coins

That's what I'm thinking. She kept using 'family leave' like it was all one thing. I'll bring up the distinction when I talk to HR.

0 coins

Get it in writing like the other person said. HR sometimes walks things back when they realize the employee actually looked it up.

0 coins

I'm in a similar boat, filing a care claim for my dad right now. I don't fully understand the PTO overlap thing. If my employer makes me use two weeks of vacation first, does that mean EDD only pays me for six weeks out of the eight? Or does the PTO time count separately?

0 coins

PTO your employer pays you doesn't eat into your eight PFL weeks. EDD pays its eight weeks of PFL benefits on the eligible days of leave you take. Your employer deciding to also pay you PTO during some of those days is a separate layer. The combined amount just can't be more than your normal wages.

0 coins

So I could potentially receive both PTO from work and PFL from EDD at the same time, as long as I don't go over what I normally make? That's actually better than I thought.

0 coins

That's how it worked for my wife's situation. The employer paid out PTO at the same time, EDD paid PFL, and the total didn't exceed her regular pay.

0 coins

Thank you, that's really reassuring. I was worried I'd lose weeks from EDD if my job forced PTO first.

0 coins

In my experience, whatever policy your company has goes in the handbook. If it says you burn PTO first, that's your company talking, not EDD. EDD doesn't tell your employer what order to do things in.

0 coins

Yeah, I've seen that at a few different jobs. It's always been a company call, never an EDD rule.

0 coins

Exactly. And some employers don't require it at all. Depends entirely on where you work.

0 coins

my work tried the same thing when i took leave for my grandma, said i had to use all my pto first or they wouldnt approve the leave. turned out they couldnt stop edd from paying me tho, they just controlled their own side of it

0 coins

This is kind of exactly what I needed to hear. So EDD runs on its own track and my employer controls their own track.

0 coins

yeah pretty much. edd doesnt care what your job does with your pto, they just check if youre eligible and what your wages were

0 coins

Worth clarifying for the thread, the rule about combined wages is that your PTO plus PFL together can't exceed your normal pay. EDD actually says the wages excluded are overtime, so your base regular pay is the ceiling. How your employer implements it on their side is their own policy call.

0 coins

That's the right read. The cap exists but EDD isn't policing your employer's internal sequence, only the total doesn't exceed normal wages rule.

0 coins

So if someone's normal wage is, say, whatever they make in a week, the two combined can't go above that. But either source could be paying first.

0 coins

Right, it's a cap on the combined amount, not a required order of payments.

0 coins

November 3rd my care claim finally moved from pending, and I had a question about which exact weeks EDD had marked as paid and when the following payment would issue. I'd been redialing that 877 number before 8 a.m. for a week and kept hitting a recording. Tried Claimyr and an agent picked up the line. She confirmed payment had issued for weeks one and two on October 28th and that the next would process after EDD received my Continued Claim Certification. Knowing that exact date helped me plan around the PTO my employer had already pulled from my balance.

0 coins

I want to know if EDD can tell you on the phone when to expect each payment on a care claim. My Part D is in and I'm trying to figure out my own timeline. Might give Claimyr a shot.

0 coins

Have your receipt number and the date your leave started ready. The agent had my claim pulled up fast and could see the payment history right there. She just read me what was on it.

0 coins

i've been punching that 877 number in every morning this week. still nothing. maybe ill try what youre talking about.

0 coins

Employer-mandated PTO before PFL is a pretty standard policy move. The frustrating part is that some HR departments tell you it's EDD's rule when it isn't. EDD just sets the benefit amount and eligibility. Your employer decides their own leave policy on top of that.

0 coins

My manager specifically said 'that's how EDD works,' which is why I second-guessed myself and came here.

0 coins

HR gets that wrong often. The cap on combined wages is real but the sequence is theirs to set, not EDD's.

0 coins

Classic. Half the time HR doesn't know what EDD's rules actually are and the employee finds out the hard way.

0 coins

Part D is the piece that holds care claims up the most! Make sure your mom's doctor has your receipt number so they can submit it in SDI Online. That's what gets things moving on EDD's end.

0 coins

Her doctor's office mentioned they were planning to mail it. Is SDI Online submission faster?

0 coins

EDD says they can mail it or use SDI Online with your receipt number, and it needs to reach EDD within 41 days of your leave starting. I'd drop that receipt number off at the office so they have the option.

0 coins

I'll take the receipt number to them when Mom has her next appointment. Good call.

0 coins

your employer requiring pto first isn't unusual but the way your manager framed it as an EDD rule is what trips people up lol. check your employee handbook, it should spell out the exact policy

0 coins

Just dug out the handbook. It does say 'concurrent use of accrued leave' which I guess means they run them at the same time, not necessarily that I have to drain PTO before PFL starts.

0 coins

if it says concurrent that might actually be better for you, means they go together. worth asking HR to clarify exactly what 'concurrent' means in their policy.

0 coins

Concurrent and sequential are very different things. If your handbook says concurrent, that's actually a good outcome because you're not losing PTO weeks, they overlap with the PFL weeks.

0 coins

Got into a whole thing with my HR over the same question when I took leave for my father-in-law. They insisted I had to clear out my sick bank first. I just asked them to show me in writing where EDD required that, and they couldn't, anyway, turns out it was just company policy.

0 coins

This is my plan exactly. I'm going to ask HR to point me to the EDD source for what they're claiming.

0 coins

Good luck, they tend to back off when they realize you're asking the right questions.

0 coins

About a week into my care claim, the DE 2500E hadn't shown up in SDI Online and I wanted to know if the first payment had actually been issued before I could see it reflected. I tried the PFL line myself a few afternoons but could never reach anyone. Used Claimyr and an agent confirmed the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification had gone out the previous day, payment was issued, and explained the SDI Online view sometimes lags behind a day. Knowing that it was already in process helped me decide to hold off on the PTO conversion my employer wanted to do at the same time.

0 coins

The DE 2500E showing up late in SDI Online happened with my care claim too. I used Claimyr for my own situation, an agent confirmed a payment date that the online view wasn't showing yet, and then I went back to my employer with that date in hand to sort out how the PTO overlap would work. Much easier to have an actual date to give them.

0 coins

The lag between when EDD issues a payment and when SDI Online updates is annoying. Good to know you can confirm it by phone.

0 coins

Exactly, having a confirmed date from the agent versus waiting on the online update made the HR conversation a lot easier to manage.

0 coins

four mornings i sat on that line before i stopped wasting my time. if something is actually getting people to an agent i don't have questions about it.

0 coins

To answer your original question directly, PFL does not require you to exhaust PTO first. That is an employer policy, not an EDD rule. What EDD does say is that if you receive wages from your employer, including PTO payments, those combined with PFL cannot exceed your regular wages excluding overtime. Everything beyond that is between you and your employer.

0 coins

Is there a place on EDD's site where this is written out clearly, so I could show my own HR if they push back?

0 coins

The Paid Family Leave Benefits and Payments FAQs on edd.ca.gov cover it. Look under the section about combining wages with benefits. That's the clearest place to point someone.

0 coins

Thank you, I'll pull that up before my HR meeting on Monday.

0 coins

My sister's employer told her the exact same thing. After she asked HR to show her the EDD policy they were citing, they couldn't, and they clarified it was their company policy. Knowing the difference was the whole thing.

0 coins

Really glad I asked here before HR made me do something I didn't have to do.

0 coins

Always worth verifying. EDD's rules and your employer's rules are two separate things.

0 coins

EDD doesn't care what your job does with your time-off bank. They care about your wages and your eligibility. Your employer runs their own leave policy on their end. Those are two different systems.

0 coins

Is there any situation where EDD would actually require you to use PTO first before they pay out PFL?

0 coins

EDD has no such requirement. Some people confuse this with CFRA or FMLA leave, where certain rules about concurrent use of paid leave can apply, but that's a job-protection law question, not an EDD payment question.

0 coins

So CFRA might have a rule about PTO sequencing but EDD's PFL program itself doesn't. That's the distinction.

0 coins

Right. For EDD's PFL payment purposes, PTO first or concurrent is entirely your employer's call.

0 coins

the concurrent use thing in your handbook is probably cfra related, some employers bundle cfra leave and edd pfl together and use pto to run at the same time. your hr should be able to explain which law each piece of their policy comes from

0 coins

I didn't even know CFRA and PFL were different things until this thread honestly. PFL is the EDD payment side, CFRA is the job protection side, correct?

0 coins

You've got it. PFL provides the benefit payment but EDD itself says it doesn't protect your job. CFRA or FMLA is what protects the job, and those are your employer's and those laws' territory. For specifics on CFRA coverage, HR or the Civil Rights Department's site is the right place to ask.

0 coins

That's really helpful framing. So I should be asking HR two separate questions, one about EDD's PFL payment rules and one about CFRA job protection.

0 coins

Your employer is allowed to set that policy. It's not unusual. The issue is when they misrepresent it as an EDD mandate, which it isn't.

0 coins

Exactly. Company policy dressed up as a government requirement is a trick.

0 coins

Not always a trick. Sometimes HR just doesn't know the difference. Either way, check the actual EDD rules.

0 coins

Your care claim should start moving faster once Part D lands at EDD! The 41-day window from your leave start date is the deadline to watch, so make sure the doctor's office knows that clock is running.

0 coins

I let them know today when I dropped off the receipt number. The person at the front desk said they'd submit it online within the week, so I should still be well within 41 days.

0 coins

Perfect! Once Part D is in, you're in good shape on the documentation side.

0 coins

Had the same PTO question at my job. HR backed down when I asked them to put the EDD policy requirement in an email. They couldn't.

0 coins

This is my plan for tomorrow. Email first, so there's a record.

0 coins

Good. Having it in writing either way is worth it.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure