Back to California Paid Family Leave

Niko Ramsey

Can I request an alternate base period for PFL wage calculation if my income was low last year?

So I'm trying to figure out my potential PFL benefit amount before I file a bonding claim next month. My daughter is due in late January and I took a semester off from my TA position earlier this year, so my earnings in what would be the standard base period are pretty thin. Someone in a parenting group mentioned that for disability claims you can sometimes use more recent wages, and now I'm down a rabbit hole trying to figure out if the same thing applies to PFL. Can I request an alternate base period for PFL wage calculation, or is PFL stuck using whatever the standard four quarters pull up? I went to EDD's site and found the calculator at edd.ca.gov but I couldn't find a clear yes or no on the alternate base period question specifically for PFL. Would love to know if anyone has actually asked EDD about this or found something definitive.

The Notice of Computation showed up about ten days after I filed my bonding claim, and the weekly amount on it looked way off. Figured the base period they used didn't capture my overtime stretch from two winters ago. Tried the EDD line Tuesday and Wednesday mornings, got the busy signal both times, so I went through Claimyr (claimyr.com) instead and got an agent on the PFL line. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. Agent pulled up my Notice of Computation and read back the four quarters they used, the highest one included. That cleared up why the amount was what it was.

0 coins

Two straight weeks hitting that line at 8 a.m. and it either rang busy or cut me off after the hold music. Hard to believe that service actually gets you to a live person. What did the agent say exactly when you asked about the base period quarters?

0 coins

Agent read me the exact quarters on my claim and what the high quarter was. That was enough to see the overtime from two years ago fell outside the window. Wasn't what I wanted to hear but at least I knew.

0 coins

Had a similar problem getting through, so I tried Claimyr for my own care claim. Got an agent who told me the payment for the week of November 3rd had been issued and what date it went out. Had been staring at the pending screen for days.

0 coins

The alternate base period question is one I looked into pretty carefully before filing my own PFL bonding claim. What EDD's calculator and the PFL guide (DE 2530) describe is wages from the highest quarter of a 12-month base period made up of four quarters, pulled from 5 to 18 months before the claim starts. That's the standard calculation and the only one described in the PFL materials I found on edd.ca.gov. An alternate base period isn't mentioned in the PFL facts the way it sometimes comes up in other programs. If your TA wages were thin in those quarters, the Notice of Computation will show the actual number and you can run the estimate on EDD's calculator first with what you do have.

0 coins

That 5 to 18 months window is what's tripping me up. My low-earnings semester landed right in the middle of that range, so there's no avoiding it in the standard period. I'll run the calculator but it sounds like there's no alternate route here.

0 coins

That's my read too. The calculator will at least tell you the estimate before you file, so you're not surprised by the Notice of Computation.

0 coins

Wait, so there's genuinely no alternate base period option for PFL at all? I keep seeing people mention it in disability threads and assumed it carried over. That's kind of a big deal if your income shifted.

0 coins

The base period question caught me off guard with my care claim for my father last spring. I'd switched from full-time to part-time about 18 months before I filed, so the wages EDD pulled weren't reflective of what I'd normally earn. The Notice of Computation came and the amount was lower than I'd hoped, but the agent I eventually spoke with confirmed those were the correct quarters under the standard calculation. No alternate period was offered. What helped me was checking the estimate on EDD's calculator ahead of time so I had a realistic number going in.

0 coins

That's actually reassuring in a strange way, that the lower number on the notice wasn't a mistake, just the quarters they're required to use. Did the agent say anything about whether you could appeal the computation?

0 coins

The agent said to look at the Notice of Computation carefully and if I disagreed with it I had 30 days to appeal using the Appeal Form, the DE 1000A. But since the quarters were correct, I didn't see grounds for one.

0 coins

I'm not sure I understand what an appeal on the Notice of Computation would even accomplish if the quarters EDD used are technically right. Like, can you appeal the math if the base period rule itself is the problem? I'd hate to file something that goes nowhere.

0 coins

My understanding is an appeal is for when EDD made an error, not for disputing the rule itself. If the quarters are right and the formula was applied correctly, an appeal probably wouldn't change anything. But I'm not an expert, that's just what made sense to me.

0 coins

ugh we went through this with my wife's bonding claim after our second was born. the number on the notice was lower than expected because of some part-time months she had. no alternate period that I could find anywhere. we just planned around whatever the notice showed, anyway.

0 coins

Part-time months hitting the base period seems to be the common thread here. How far off was the estimate from what you'd expected?

0 coins

maybe 30 percent lower than what she gets weekly at her regular hours. not nothing but we made it work, anyway.

0 coins

I've been going back and forth on this same question for weeks. My hours got cut to almost nothing about a year ago and then ramped back up recently, so I'm terrified my benefit amount will be almost nothing because of those months. Is there any way to flag that for EDD when you file, like a note explaining the dip?

0 coins

There's no field in SDI Online to add an explanation about wage dips. The base period quarters are determined by when you file, not by what caused the low earnings. The Notice of Computation will reflect whatever wages were reported for those quarters.

0 coins

So there's literally nothing to do except accept whatever the notice says? I feel like I should at least try calling EDD to ask if there's any flexibility before I file.

0 coins

You can call. The answer will be the same quarters.

0 coins

i thought there was a waiting period for pfl before benefits kick in, is that right? my coworker swore she had to wait a week before her payments started when she took bonding leave last year

0 coins

PFL doesn't have a waiting period. That seven-day unpaid gap is part of Disability Insurance, not PFL. Your coworker may have been thinking of a pregnancy disability claim, which does have an unpaid period at the start. PFL bonding benefits begin from the first day of leave.

0 coins

oh wow i had no idea they were different. i probably would've planned my finances wrong if i hadn't seen this. thanks for clearing that up

0 coins

That mix-up is everywhere. DI waiting period, PFL no waiting period. Different programs.

0 coins

spent three mornings in a row on that 877 number getting cut off. every single time. eventually just sent a Request Claim Update through SDI Online asking about my base period quarters and got a message back a few days later. slower but at least it went somewhere.

0 coins

That's good to know about the Request Claim Update option. Did they actually address the specific quarters question or just give a generic response?

0 coins

They confirmed which quarters were used and what the high quarter wage was. No alternate period mentioned, no other options. But at least it was in writing.

0 coins

How long did the written response take?

0 coins

About four days. Not fast but it got there.

0 coins

Payments on my bonding claim went off the rails around week five. one week showed pending, then the next one posted, then the first one caught up two days later and I couldnt tell which weeks had actually been paid. Tried the EDD line a few times and couldnt get through so I used Claimyr and got an agent on. Agent went through my claim week by week and told me exactly which weeks were paid and what date the next payment was due to issue.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? Genuine question.

0 coins

You call and it stays on the line with EDD in your place, and your phone rings once an agent picks up. That's about it.

0 coins

Huh. My claim's been showing one week pending for over a week now. Might ask about that.

0 coins

my payments got out of order like that too. maddening to try to track, anyway.

0 coins

the base period thing is so frustrating when you had a weird income year. i had the same issue with my care claim for my mom. the quarters they picked just didnt capture my better earning months at all

0 coins

Did you end up filing anyway with the lower benefit amount or did you delay?

0 coins

filed anyway. mom needed care, couldnt wait around hoping the quarters would shift. the amount was lower but it was something

0 coins

For anyone tracking the math: the base period runs from 5 to 18 months before your claim start date, and EDD uses the highest quarter within that 12-month period. If your highest earning quarter falls outside that window, there's no mechanism in the PFL rules to bring it in. The Notice of Computation is the first place you see the actual figure they arrived at.

0 coins

The 5 to 18 month range is what makes it tricky. For me the high quarter is about 22 months back, which puts it just outside the window. Sounds like that's just how it lands.

0 coins

So there's no way to extend the lookback even a little? Even if the wages were reported to EDD?

0 coins

Not based on anything in the PFL rules. The window is set. The Notice of Computation will show what they found within it.

0 coins

the 41-day deadline caught me completely off guard when I filed my care claim. I started caring for my dad before I realized I had to file within 41 days of when the leave started, not 41 days from whenever I got around to it. cut it very close. if you're filing based on a care situation, don't sit on it

0 coins

I'm filing for bonding, not a care claim, but good to know that clock starts at the first day of leave. I'd been thinking I had 41 days from the birth but that's the same thing essentially.

0 coins

Exactly the same rule. First day of leave is day one of the 41 days.

0 coins

Does the 41-day clock apply to getting proof of relationship in too or just the initial filing?

0 coins

The 41-day deadline is for filing the claim itself. The proof of relationship, like a birth certificate or Declaration of Paternity, is separate. File the claim on time first, then get the proof of relationship submitted.

0 coins

base period questions are exhausting to untangle. ran into it myself. notice came, number was lower than I wanted, that was it.

0 coins

Same. Nothing you can do about it once the quarters are set.

0 coins

My bonding claim went smoother than I expected on the wage side! The Notice of Computation matched pretty closely to what the EDD calculator estimated, so running the calculator ahead of time was definitely worth doing. If your estimate looks low going in, at least you're not surprised.

0 coins

That's encouraging. I'll run it again with the actual quarters that will count and try to plan around whatever it shows.

0 coins

The calculator is right there on EDD's site, just punch in the quarters that fall in your window and it gives you a number to work with!

0 coins

PFL won't cover the same days as disability or unemployment. Worth knowing if you have any overlap in your situation.

0 coins

My pregnancy disability claim will end before the bonding starts so I don't think there's an overlap issue, but good to flag.

0 coins

Good. Some people try to stack them and it doesn't work.

0 coins

The Electronic Benefit Payment Notification, the DE 2500E, was what I was waiting on to know my first payment info on my care claim for my spouse. Couldn't reach anyone by phone after three attempts across two days. Tried Claimyr and got through to an agent who confirmed the DE 2500E had been issued and told me the payment details it reflected.

0 coins

Used Claimyr myself for a bonding claim question. Agent checked and told me exactly how many of the eight weeks I'd used and how many were still available in my 12-month window. That was the piece I needed.

0 coins

How did that work, did the agent have all the week counts right there?

0 coins

Yep, pulled it right up. Told me the weeks used, the weeks remaining, and the date the 12-month window closes. Took maybe two minutes once I was on with them.

0 coins

The eight-week total being shared across bonding and care in the same 12 months was something I hadn't realized until this thread. Good to know the agent can tell you exactly where you stand on that count.

0 coins

I keep reading that bonding and care claims share the same eight weeks and that worries me. We might need to do a care claim for my wife's mom later this year after I use some weeks bonding with the baby. I think I'd have fewer weeks left for the care claim, right? I'm not sure how that gets tracked.

0 coins

You have eight weeks total within any 12-month period across bonding, care and military assist together. If you use four weeks bonding, you have four weeks left for care in that same 12 months. It's one pool, not separate allowances for each reason.

0 coins

That changes my planning a lot. I had assumed each type got its own eight weeks. So I should probably be careful about how many bonding weeks I actually take.

0 coins

You can also take the bonding weeks in pieces rather than all at once, which helps with spreading out the time off. Just be sure to report any days you work back to EDD.

0 coins

My client was asking me this exact thing last week while I was doing her hair. She'd had a rough income year and was worried her PFL would be almost nothing. I told her to run the calculator on EDD's site first so she had a real number before she panicked.

0 coins

That calculator really does seem like the best starting point. At least you know what the quarters are going to produce before the notice arrives.

0 coins

Exactly, go in with eyes open! She actually came back and said the estimate wasn't as bad as she feared once she punched in the actual quarters.

0 coins

one thing nobody mentioned yet. if you took time off in the middle of your base period for any kind of leave, those weeks of no wages just show up as zeroes in whatever quarter they fall. nothing you can do about it in the PFL calculation, the quarters are what they are.

0 coins

My semester off as a TA was pretty much zero wages for about four months, so yeah, one of my quarters is basically empty. That's the reality I'm working with.

0 coins

same thing happened to me with a gap between gig jobs. the quarter just shows whatever you actually earned, no adjustments

0 coins

Correct. The wages reported to EDD for each quarter are what the base period uses. There's no mechanism in PFL to substitute or exclude a quarter because of leave or gaps.

0 coins

EDD won't tell you what you wanted to hear on the alternate base period. They'll tell you what the quarters show. Run the calculator, file on time, read the Notice of Computation when it comes.

0 coins

Pretty much the whole thread in one paragraph. Appreciate the bluntness.

0 coins

You asked a clear question. The answer is no alternate period for PFL.

0 coins

Is there any reason to delay filing until a quarter with better wages falls into the base period window? Like if I wait a few months would different quarters get picked up?

0 coins

The base period shifts when your claim start date shifts, so yes, if you file three months later, you pick up a different set of quarters. Whether that helps or hurts depends on what your earnings looked like in those quarters. Run the EDD calculator with both start dates and compare.

0 coins

Oh I hadn't thought about it that way. So I could actually model two different start dates on the calculator and see which one gives a higher estimate?

0 coins

Exactly. Put in the quarters that would apply to each start date and compare the outputs. Keep the 41-day clock in mind though. You can't start leave and then delay the filing past 41 days hoping the quarters shift.

0 coins

This is a really useful point I hadn't considered. I'll run the calculator with my actual due date as the start and then maybe a date two or three months later and see what comes out.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure