Can I re-establish bonding claim paid family leave 2504rej after a denial?
So my PFL bonding claim got denied a few weeks back, got a DE 2514 in the mail and everything. I was bonding with my daughter who was placed with us through foster care in August. The denial said something about proof of relationship not being sufficient, which I guess makes sense because the foster care agency letter I sent was an older document from before the placement was finalized. I uploaded something that was more of a placement summary than the actual agency letter EDD needs. Anyway I still have weeks of leave left and my daughter is still in my home, the 12 months from placement isn't up yet. Can I re-establish bonding claim paid family leave 2504rej situation and actually get paid for the remaining leave? I appealed but I'm also wondering if I can just refile entirely or if that's even allowed. Anyone been through something like this?
90 comments

Connor O'Neill
DE 2500E on my bonding claim never showed up after my denial got overturned on appeal, so I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com). The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the DE 2500E hadn't been generated yet because the appeal decision was still being processed on their end. She said to give it a few more days and check SDI Online. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM
0 coins
LunarEclipse
My bonding claim got denied too and I'm trying to figure out whether my appeal window is even still open. I want to try Claimyr for that, what should I have ready when I call?
0 coins
Connor O'Neill
Have your claim ID number from SDI Online, your receipt number, and the DE 2514 denial notice in front of you. The agent will want to know the date on the notice because the 30-day appeal window runs from that date.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
Wait the appeal window is only 30 days? I got a DE 2514 like three weeks ago and I haven't done anything yet. That feels really close, is the Appeal Form the DE 1000A?
0 coins
Keisha Brown
Yes, the DE 1000A is the form to use. You can appeal online or by mail. Thirty days from the date on that notice, so if yours arrived three weeks ago, filing this week would be wise.
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
Appealing and refiling are two different things. The appeal is what keeps the door open on the original claim. Refiling starts a brand new one, and EDD won't pay you twice for the same days.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
So I can do both at the same time, the appeal on the denied claim and a new filing for the remaining days?
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
Probably better to let EDD sort out the appeal first before you file again. Otherwise you risk getting two claims overlapping and that's a mess.
0 coins
Amina Toure
The rule as EDD writes it is that benefits must be used within 12 months of the child's placement. As long as that window's still open you haven't lost the ability to claim the remaining weeks, you just need the right document this time.
0 coins
Keisha Brown
For a foster placement the document EDD needs is the foster care agency letter, the official one on the agency's letterhead confirming placement. A placement summary or a case document from a worker isn't the same thing. Have you gone back to the agency to ask for the formal letter?
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
Haven't done that yet, that's actually a really useful distinction. The agency gave me a packet but I just grabbed the first thing that mentioned the placement date.
0 coins
Keisha Brown
Call the agency's licensing worker and specifically ask for a letter confirming the foster placement on official letterhead. Tell them EDD needs it for a PFL claim. Most workers know what that means.
0 coins
Oliver Weber
Our agency had a form letter they kept for exactly this. Took about two days to get.
0 coins
FireflyDreams
EDD's whole system is designed to make you give up. They deny on technicalities, you appeal, you wait, meanwhile no money for weeks. I went through this with a care claim and it took forever just to reach anyone on the phone.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
Yeah the phone situation is brutal. I tried calling three mornings in a row and got the recording every time.
0 coins
Natasha Kuznetsova
Same. Line cuts out at 8:05 no matter what. Gets old fast.
0 coins
FireflyDreams
And the Request Claim Update in SDI Online doesn't help when what you actually need is someone to look at your document and confirm it's the right kind.
0 coins
Javier Morales
Intermittent days while I was appealing my own denial were a whole separate headache, because I went back part-time and wasn't sure if I was supposed to still report those days. Used Claimyr to get through to an agent and she confirmed I still had to report any days I worked, even during the appeal period, and that EDD would send the DE 2580GF once my eligible weeks were confirmed.
0 coins
Emma Anderson
The start date and 41-day deadline piece tripped me up on my claim too. I'd used Claimyr after my own claim got flagged, and the agent confirmed my start date was recorded correctly and that my documents had arrived within the 41-day window, so I was fine there. Big relief because I'd been second-guessing that for days.
0 coins
Malik Thompson
how long have you been trying that line before you found something that worked bc ive been at it for two weeks and nothing
0 coins
Emma Anderson
Honestly more than a week before I tried a different approach. Called at 8 sharp a few times, got disconnected twice, got the high-volume message the rest.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
Does reporting intermittent days change the amount you get per week? Like does EDD recalculate?
0 coins
Javier Morales
Each day you work, EDD pays you for the days you didn't work that week instead of the full week. The DE 2580GF is what you send back to certify it. If you skip sending it your payments stop.
0 coins
Amina Toure
The question about whether you can refile after a 2504rej-type denial comes down to what the denial was actually for. If it was a proof-of-relationship issue and not an eligibility issue, correcting the document and reapplying is a real path, as long as you're still inside the 12 months from placement.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
The DE 2514 said the proof of relationship document was insufficient. It didn't say anything about me being ineligible as a foster parent. So that sounds like exactly what you're describing.
0 coins
Amina Toure
Then your situation is the correctable kind. Get the proper foster care agency letter and either refile through SDI Online or mail the DE 2501F. Keep the original denial notice too in case you end up appealing alongside a new claim.
0 coins
CosmicVoyager
Just make sure the new document actually says what EDD wants to see. If it's vague again you'll get another denial and burn more of your 12-month window.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
Can a foster parent get PFL bonding even if the placement isn't permanent yet? I always assumed you had to have a finalized adoption for the bonding claim to work for a foster situation.
0 coins
Keisha Brown
A foster placement counts on its own. You don't need a finalized adoption. The foster care agency letter is the document EDD accepts to confirm the placement.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
Oh I had no idea that was the case. That changes things for a friend of mine who's been fostering since the spring and thought she couldn't file.
0 coins
Ravi Kapoor
Tell her not to wait. That 12-month window from placement date runs regardless of whether she thinks she's eligible.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
Does the 30-day appeal window start from when you receive the DE 2514 or when it's dated?
0 coins
Keisha Brown
EDD dates these notices and 30 days runs from that date, not from whenever the mail arrived. If there's any gap between the date on the notice and when it reached you, file sooner rather than later.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
Mine was dated about four days before I got it. So I essentially lost four days just in transit.
0 coins
Amina Toure
That's exactly why filing an appeal the same week you receive the denial is worth doing. The Appeal Form in SDI Online is faster than mailing the DE 1000A.
0 coins
Natasha Kuznetsova
The denial notice also comes with the Appeal Form, the DE 1000A, right in the packet. No need to track it down separately.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
Mine had it attached, yes. I just hadn't sent it in yet because I was trying to figure out if the appeal was even worth it versus just refiling.
0 coins
Natasha Kuznetsova
Worth filing the appeal. If the document issue is fixable, the appeal officer will see that.
0 coins
Oliver Weber
Both at the same time isn't necessarily a problem if the timelines are still open.
0 coins
Freya Nielsen
DE 2514 came last week on my care claim and I wasn't sure if that meant I was completely done or if there was something I could still do. Used Claimyr to get through to someone at EDD and ask about the DE 2514 specifically. The agent said the notice meant my claim had been reviewed and not approved, and that I could appeal within 30 days using the DE 1000A. She also told me the specific reason code on mine was about Part D not being received, not about eligibility itself.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
I've tried that line probably eight times across three different mornings and got nowhere, so I'm a little doubtful something like that actually works. What actually happened when you called, like did you just dial straight in?
0 coins
Freya Nielsen
I know it sounds hard to believe. I'd basically given up on the phone line. I ended up speaking with an actual EDD agent who had my claim open in front of her and read me the note about Part D. That's not something you get from the automated system.
0 coins
Omar Mahmoud
The Part D piece matters a lot. On a care claim that's the physician certification, and if it never arrived or wasn't matched to the claim, that's fixable. You can have the doctor resubmit it in SDI Online with the receipt number.
0 coins
Chloe Harris
Payment method on my care claim got set wrong initially and I had to untangle that after my own denial. The agent I spoke with confirmed what method was on file and I was able to correct it before any benefits issued.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
Okay if it actually let someone read back specific claim notes I might try it. The 30-day window on my denial is ticking and I need to know if Part D was received before I decide whether to appeal or just get the doctor to resubmit.
0 coins
Malik Thompson
edd denied my dads bonding claim too but he thought pfl was the same as job protection and almost didnt appeal because he thought it didnt matter, someone needs to tell people those are two different things
0 coins
Keisha Brown
PFL pays you but doesn't protect your job, those are genuinely separate things. Job protection for family leave in California comes from the CFRA, and whether that covers someone is a question for their employer's HR, not EDD.
0 coins
Malik Thompson
yeah his employer covered him through cfra but he thought the edd denial meant he lost that too, took a while to explain they were different
0 coins
Ravi Kapoor
Good he got it sorted. A denial from EDD is about the benefit check, not about whether the leave itself is covered by his employer.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
Genuine question, if you refile instead of appealing, does the new claim count as a fresh 12-month window or does it still tie to the original placement date?
0 coins
Amina Toure
The 12 months runs from the placement date, not the filing date. A new claim doesn't reset the clock. If placement was August and you're filing in November, you still only have until next August to use the eight weeks.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
Oh that's important, so you can't just restart the whole thing by refiling. Good to know before someone tries it.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
This is exactly what I needed to hear. So my August placement means I need to use the weeks before next August, whether I appeal the denied claim or file a new one.
0 coins
Javier Morales
Eight weeks sounds like a lot until you realize it's the total for bonding and care combined in a 12-month period. Someone earlier mentioned refiling, and I want to make sure people know that pool doesn't reset.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
Wait, bonding and care are from the same eight weeks? I thought each one got its own eight weeks.
0 coins
Keisha Brown
They draw from the same pool. EDD gives you up to eight weeks total within any 12-month period across bonding, care and military assist. If you used five weeks bonding you'd have three left for a care claim in the same 12 months.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
That is not how I understood it at all. I need to go check how many weeks I actually have left.
0 coins
CosmicVoyager
Yeah that one catches a lot of people off guard. The EDD site says it pretty plainly but most people don't read it that carefully until they need the second claim.
0 coins
Emma Anderson
For anyone refiling after a denial, the receipt number on the original claim is still useful. Keep it even if you're starting a new SDI Online application. If EDD has any old documents attached to your original claim, the agent can look them up by that number.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
I still have my original receipt number saved. Good to know that might still be useful even if the new claim has its own.
0 coins
Emma Anderson
Exactly. Having both numbers when you contact EDD means they can compare what was submitted on each one.
0 coins
LunarEclipse
Does the foster care agency letter need to have the placement start date on it, or just confirm the placement exists?
0 coins
Keisha Brown
It should confirm both the placement and the date it began. EDD needs that date to know the 12-month bonding window and whether the claim falls within it.
0 coins
Oliver Weber
Our agency letter had the placement date, the child's name, and our names as foster parents. Covered everything EDD asked about.
0 coins
LunarEclipse
Got it, so just asking for a letter isn't enough, specifically asking for placement date confirmation too.
0 coins
NeonNinja
been dealing with a denial on my bonding claim for about six weeks now, the appeal is in but nothing's moved
0 coins
Connor O'Neill
Appeals do take time. Keep checking SDI Online for any status change and make sure your contact information in myEDD is current so the decision letter reaches you.
0 coins
NeonNinja
yeah everything's up to date, just waiting
0 coins
Natasha Kuznetsova
Six weeks is frustrating but appeals go through their own process. Nothing much to do but wait and watch the mailbox.
0 coins
Omar Mahmoud
For anyone unsure whether to appeal or refile after a PFL bonding denial, those two options solve different problems. Appealing says the original decision was wrong. Refiling with the corrected document says here's the information you needed. Which one makes more sense depends on what the denial actually said.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
That's a cleaner way to think about it than I'd seen anywhere else. Appeal if EDD got it wrong, refile if you gave them the wrong document.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
In my case I gave them the wrong document so refiling with the actual foster agency letter is probably the cleaner path, though I might still file the appeal just to keep both open.
0 coins
Omar Mahmoud
Keeping both open while the 12 months is still running isn't a bad move. Just don't submit the same claim twice through SDI Online.
0 coins
Ravi Kapoor
Proof of relationship on a bonding claim is specific. For foster care it's the agency letter. For a birth it's the birth certificate or the Declaration of Paternity. For adoption it's the Adoptive Placement Agreement. Each one is different and EDD expects the right one for the right situation.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
Is the Declaration of Paternity the same as being on the birth certificate, or is it a separate form?
0 coins
Ravi Kapoor
Separate form, the CS-909. If your name is already on the birth certificate you use that. The CS-909 is for when paternity is established separately.
0 coins
Amina Toure
The form number for the Adoptive Placement Agreement is AD-907 for anyone who needs it.
0 coins
Chloe Harris
SDI Online lets you check whether documents are showing as received on your claim. If you refile and upload the foster agency letter, you can confirm it's attached before you do anything else.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
I didn't know you could see that. I'll check tonight. Does it show a received date or just a yes/no?
0 coins
Chloe Harris
It shows the claim status and what's been received. Exact display varies but it'll be clear if something's missing.
0 coins
FireflyDreams
Just know that 'received' in SDI Online doesn't always mean 'reviewed.' I've had things show received and the claim still sat pending for days.
0 coins
Malik Thompson
does pfl have a waiting period like the first week unpaid or is that just disability
0 coins
Keisha Brown
PFL doesn't have a waiting period. That seven-day unpaid period is for Disability Insurance, not for PFL. Benefits under PFL start from day one of your family leave.
0 coins
Malik Thompson
ok thought so but wasnt 100 percent, good to have it confirmed
0 coins
Diego Vargas
I mixed those up too when I first filed. The seven days is only for the pregnancy disability part before bonding, not for bonding itself.
0 coins
Keisha Brown
To be precise, that seven-day wait applies to Disability Insurance claims. Once a birth mother moves from her pregnancy disability claim to the bonding PFL claim, the PFL side has no waiting period of its own.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
Update from me: I went back to the foster agency and they're sending the official letterhead letter with the placement date on it. Going to file the appeal on the original denied claim AND refile through SDI Online with the correct document. Placement was August so I have until next August to use whatever weeks the appeal or new claim covers. Thanks everyone, this thread answered questions I couldn't get answered anywhere else.
0 coins
Connor O'Neill
Filing both at the same time with that window still open is the right call. Keep copies of everything you submit.
0 coins
Amina Toure
Make sure the new claim has the receipt number saved from the confirmation page. You'll want that if you need to follow up.
0 coins
LunarEclipse
August placement gives you a real runway still. Hope the corrected letter gets things moving quickly.
0 coins