Back to California Paid Family Leave

Daniel Rivera

Can I get paid family leave while receiving unemployment benefits?

So I filed for unemployment about three weeks ago after getting laid off, and I just found out my mom needs someone with her full time for a while, she's been having some serious health issues. I want to take PFL to care for her but I'm already getting unemployment checks. Can I get paid family leave while receiving unemployment benefits at the same time? Or do I have to pick one? I really need to figure this out fast because she needs me starting next week and I don't want to lose the unemployment money if PFL won't cover the whole thing anyway.

You can't collect both at the same time, unfortunately. EDD won't pay PFL and unemployment for the same days. The idea is that unemployment means you're available and looking for work, while PFL means you're not available because you're caring for a family member. You'd need to stop certifying for unemployment and file a PFL care claim instead. The care claim is for people who are losing wages, so the fact that you were laid off rather than employed complicates things, actually. EDD looks at whether you had SDI withheld from wages in your base period.

0 coins

Wait so do I have to have a current job to file PFL? I was laid off, I still had CASDI taken out of my paychecks all year before that.

0 coins

The eligibility rule, as EDD states it, is that you need to be employed or actively looking for work when the leave starts, plus at least $300 in base period wages with SDI withheld. Someone laid off and already collecting unemployment is actively looking for work by definition, so the wage requirement is the piece to check. If you had SDI withheld during your base period, that matters more than whether you're currently employed.

0 coins

Exactly right. The base period wages with CASDI withheld are the key. File the PFL care claim and EDD will determine eligibility based on that. You just can't have both running at once.

0 coins

EDD is not going to let you double dip, trust me on that one. Had a buddy who thought the same thing and EDD caught it and sent him an overpayment notice. Stop the unemployment claim the day your PFL starts, don't overlap them even by one day.

0 coins

An overpayment notice sounds terrifying. So I literally just stop certifying for unemployment when I file PFL?

0 coins

Yeah that's the move. Don't certify for unemployment for any day you're also claiming PFL. One or the other per day.

0 coins

Your buddy should appeal if the overlap was an honest mistake. The overpayment notice does have an appeal form on it.

0 coins

Weeks remaining in the 12-month window mattered on my care claim and I had no way to get a straight answer from EDD's site, so I went through Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got to an agent. The video for anyone who hasn't heard of it: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. Agent pulled up my claim and told me I had used three of my eight weeks on a previous bonding claim earlier in the year, so only five were left for the care claim. That changed my whole plan.

0 coins

Claimyr worked the same way for me and I was relieved to finally hear a human voice at EDD. Called about the DE 2500E, wanted to know when the first payment information would actually show. Agent said the electronic benefit payment notification had been generated and my direct deposit would reflect it within two business days. Couldn't have gotten that from the website.

0 coins

Wait, what did they say about the DE 2500E exactly? Like was it already issued or still pending?

0 coins

Already issued, it was in the system, just hadn't hit my bank yet. That was the thing I needed to hear.

0 coins

So the eight weeks total is shared across bonding AND care claims in the same 12 months? I had no idea they weren't separate. I thought each type had its own eight weeks.

0 coins

To answer the concern above about the eight weeks: PFL gives you eight weeks total within any 12-month period, and that covers bonding, care and military assist all together. It's one pool. So if you used four weeks bonding with a baby this spring, you'd only have four weeks left for a care claim during the same 12 months. A lot of people assume each type of claim gets its own eight weeks and that's not how EDD runs it.

0 coins

That is really important and I had it completely wrong. So I need to look at any PFL I took in the past year before I even file for my mom?

0 coins

Exactly. Check your SDI Online claim history in myEDD. If you haven't taken any PFL in the last 12 months you have the full eight weeks available.

0 coins

Hadn't even thought about this. I did take two weeks bonding when my youngest was born in February so I'd only have six weeks left. Good to know before I file.

0 coins

you cant get unemployment and pfl at the same time edd will catch it. pick pfl if you need to care for your mom, the money is usually better than unemployment anyway depending on your wages

0 coins

The benefit amount for PFL is based on your highest earning quarter in your base period, roughly 70 to 90 percent of those wages. Unemployment is calculated differently. So yes, for some people PFL pays more, for others less. Worth checking EDD's benefits calculator online before you decide.

0 coins

yeah exactly check the calculator first before you assume pfl is better

0 coins

I'm kind of in a similar spot and I keep second-guessing myself. If I stop certifying for unemployment to file PFL, and then PFL gets denied, can I go back to unemployment? I'm scared to lose both.

0 coins

If PFL is denied, EDD sends a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination with an Appeal Form. You'd have 30 days to appeal. As for going back to unemployment, that would depend on whether you still meet unemployment eligibility at that point. EDD runs those two programs separately so you'd have to re-engage with unemployment on their terms.

0 coins

Appeal within 30 days, okay. At least there's a window. I just don't want to be caught with nothing.

0 coins

Filing PFL is the right call if you genuinely can't work because you're caring for someone. The appeal option is there if something goes wrong.

0 coins

Had a moment of total panic about whether I'd filed my care claim in time. Filed it on the 39th day after my leave started and I wasn't sure if that was okay. Claimyr got me to an agent who looked it up and said my claim's start date put me right at day 39, still within the 41-day window, so I was fine. Huge relief. The agent also confirmed EDD had received Part D from my dad's doctor.

0 coins

The 41-day deadline concern is so reasonable, I worried about that too. At first I thought the agent might be affiliated with a marketing service of some kind rather than actually from EDD. But my neighbor had tried it after weeks of unanswered attempts and said the person who answered walked her through her DE 2580GF reporting for intermittent days, confirmed which days were logged and which weren't, and gave her the exact dates. That convinced me and I ended up phoning EDD the same way for my own claim.

0 coins

So the 41 days is firm? No grace period beyond that?

0 coins

EDD's rule is 41 days from when the leave starts. File by then or risk losing benefits for the days before you filed.

0 coins

File as early as you can, honestly. Day 39 was too close for comfort.

0 coins

You cannot get unemployment and PFL at the same time. That's the bottom line. EDD will find out and you'll owe money back.

0 coins

Makes sense. Not worth the risk of an overpayment notice.

0 coins

Exactly. File PFL, stop the unemployment certifications. Simple.

0 coins

My cousin tried to run them together for like two weeks before someone at EDD flagged it. Had to pay back the unemployment she received during those days. It was a whole stressful thing. Not worth it at all, just switch over cleanly.

0 coins

This is a good cautionary note. The overlap issue usually comes up when someone certifies for unemployment without realizing their PFL start date covers those same days. Keep the dates clean.

0 coins

Yes! She didn't even realize she'd overlapped, it wasn't intentional. But EDD still issued the overpayment notice.

0 coins

Care claim needs Part C and Part D. Part C is your mom's statement, mailed on paper. Part D is her doctor's certification. Doctor can mail it or submit it through SDI Online with your receipt number. Don't upload either one online.

0 coins

Got it, so the doctor needs my receipt number. Where do I find that again?

0 coins

On the confirmation page when you finish filing in SDI Online. Write it down or take a screenshot. Give it to the doctor's office so they can submit Part D.

0 coins

Is Part D due at the same time I file or can the doctor send it later?

0 coins

Has to reach EDD within 41 days of when your leave started. Get the receipt number to the doctor's office right away so they don't miss the window.

0 coins

Also just so you know, PFL doesn't protect your job. I found this out the hard way. It pays you but EDD is very clear that job protection comes from CFRA or FMLA, not PFL itself. So if you're laid off already this doesn't affect you, but for anyone who's employed, talk to your HR about CFRA separately.

0 coins

Accurate point. EDD actually states it plainly on their site: PFL provides benefit payments but not job protection. CFRA is the separate California law that may protect the job, and whether it applies depends on the employer and the situation.

0 coins

Yeah I wish someone had told me that before I took PFL at my last job lol. Ended up okay but I didn't understand what I was actually protected by.

0 coins

So I need to go to HR and ask about CFRA specifically, separate from filing PFL with EDD?

0 coins

Yep, two separate things. EDD handles the money, your employer handles the job protection question under CFRA.

0 coins

pfl no waiting period either, unlike disability which has seven days unpaid at the start. people mix those up all the time

0 coins

EDD actually states that clearly. PFL has no benefit waiting period. The seven-day wait is disability insurance, completely different program.

0 coins

right just wanted to flag it since people get confused

0 coins

For the care claim, sections one through five are completed in SDI Online. After that Part C and Part D are on paper. Part C goes to your mom to fill out and mail. Part D goes to her doctor. Never upload them in SDI Online, it can delay the whole thing.

0 coins

So I do NOT upload Part C and Part D even though SDI Online probably has an upload option?

0 coins

Correct. Mail only for those two forms, or the doctor submits Part D through SDI Online with your receipt number. The claimant uploading them is what causes problems.

0 coins

EDD's guidance on this is specific and consistent: don't upload Part C or Part D. The paper route is what they want.

0 coins

Payment method on my care claim took me by surprise when my first payment didn't arrive the way I expected. Couldn't get anyone on the phone for three days running, tried early mornings and afternoons. Used Claimyr to reach an EDD agent and she told me my payment method was set to debit card rather than direct deposit because I hadn't enrolled in direct deposit through SDI Online before the first payment processed. She walked me through what to do in myEDD to update it going forward.

0 coins

What did you need to have ready when you phoned?

0 coins

Claim ID, Social Security number and the week in question. Agent had everything pulled up within a minute of me giving those.

0 coins

been trying that line most mornings for two weeks and cant get through. good to know there are other ways in

0 coins

To answer the original question directly: unemployment and PFL on the same day is not allowed. But if unemployment is active and you pause it to file PFL, you'll want to make sure you tell EDD the day PFL starts so there's no question about the gap.

0 coins

Pausing unemployment is the right word for it, right? Like I stop certifying but the claim stays open?

0 coins

Honestly I'm not 100 percent sure how unemployment handles the pause on their end. That's worth checking with EDD directly or through the unemployment side of myEDD. What I know for sure is you can't certify for both on the same days.

0 coins

Phoning EDD's PFL line to ask how the switchover works for your specific situation would give you the clearest answer. Worth doing before the leave starts.

0 coins

Is there any difference in how long PFL takes to process a care claim versus a bonding claim? I keep reading it can take up to 14 days but I wasn't sure if care claims take longer because of the Part D requirement.

0 coins

EDD says deciding a claim can take up to 14 days, and that's after they have a properly completed claim. For a care claim that means after Part D arrives. So the 14 days doesn't really start until Part D is in. That's why getting the receipt number to the doctor fast matters so much.

0 coins

Part D being late is the most common reason care claims take longer than bonding claims. Bonding just needs the proof of relationship, which you can upload in SDI Online yourself.

0 coins

Okay so the 14-day clock basically starts when EDD has everything they need, not when I file.

0 coins

For anyone wondering about the base period wages question that came up earlier: the base period looks at your earnings 5 to 18 months before the claim starts, specifically the highest earning quarter within that 12-month window. So wages from before a layoff can still count. The calculator on EDD's site gives you an estimate if you plug in your quarterly earnings.

0 coins

This is actually helpful because I had decent wages before the layoff. Might be worth filing the care claim even if unemployment is a bit less per week.

0 coins

Plug your highest quarter wages into EDD's calculator and compare it to your weekly unemployment amount. That'll make the decision obvious.

0 coins

EDD's site has the calculator right there, easy to find.

0 coins

Direct deposit is available if you filed through SDI Online. Debit card is the default if you didn't set it up before the first payment. Worth checking your payment preference in myEDD now rather than after the first payment lands somewhere unexpected.

0 coins

Setting up direct deposit now, before I even file. Good heads up.

0 coins

Do it in myEDD under the SDI Online claim settings. Much easier than sorting it out after the fact.

0 coins

EDD won't pay PFL and unemployment for the same days. That's it. File one, stop the other. The more complicated you make this the more room for error.

0 coins

Appreciated. Keeping it simple. Stop unemployment, file PFL care claim, give the doctor my receipt number.

0 coins

That's the whole plan right there.

0 coins

You'll get a Notice of Computation in the mail once EDD has your claim, and that shows your potential weekly benefit amount. Doesn't mean you're approved, just lets you know what the payment would be if everything goes through.

0 coins

I got confused by that notice and thought it meant I was approved. It doesn't, right?

0 coins

Correct. The Notice of Computation shows what your weekly benefit amount would be, not that EDD has approved the claim. The actual approval comes through payments or a separate determination notice.

0 coins

Yeah I thought I was approved when I got mine too. The language is a little misleading.

0 coins

Update for anyone following: filed the PFL care claim this morning in SDI Online and got my receipt number. Already texted it to my mom's doctor's office so they can submit Part D. Stopped certifying for unemployment as of today. Fingers crossed the 14 days goes fast.

0 coins

Keep that receipt number somewhere safe in case the doctor's office needs it again.

0 coins

Good move stopping unemployment the same day. Clean break.

0 coins

Check SDI Online in a few days to see if the status has updated. If it stays pending past 14 days, send a Request Claim Update through SDI Online or phone EDD's PFL line at 1-877-238-4373.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure