Back to California Paid Family Leave

Zoe Papanikolaou

Can I file SDI after already using PFL for postpartum recovery?

So I'm really confused about the order of things and I think I may have done this completely backwards. I had my baby girl in August and my HR told me to file for PFL right away for bonding, so I did. I've been getting PFL payments for about six weeks now. But my midwife just told me that most moms actually file for disability first for the postpartum recovery period and then switch to PFL for bonding. Nobody told me this before I filed. Is it even possible to go back and file SDI now after already using PFL for the postpartum recovery weeks? Or did I mess up my benefits by skipping the disability claim? I'm so worried I lost money by doing this in the wrong order and I don't even know who to ask. My HR is not very helpful on the specifics of EDD stuff.

August 14th the PFL payments stopped showing in SDI Online and I had no idea if the last one had actually gone through. I tried the EDD line maybe eight or nine times across three days, nothing but the recording that cuts you off. Ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live person on the PFL line. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the final payment had issued on the 11th and what date the deposit would hit. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

four days straight on that line and I never got past the automated message, so I find it real hard to believe you just ended up talking to someone. what did you actually do, hit some secret option?

0 coins

no secret option, just used Claimyr. it held the line in my place and my phone rang when an actual EDD worker picked up. I was skeptical too before it worked.

0 coins

used it too when my payment date was a mystery, agent confirmed which week had paid and said the next one was scheduled, so I could actually stop panicking anyway.

0 coins

The midwife is right about the typical order, but let me explain what that actually means for your situation. A birth mother's pregnancy disability claim, which is through Disability Insurance and not PFL, covers the weeks right after delivery when you're physically recovering. After that period ends, you file a separate PFL bonding claim for the remaining weeks with the baby. The two programs are different and they pay at potentially different amounts. PFL is for bonding and does not cover your own medical recovery.

0 coins

Thank you, so does that mean I actually lost the disability weeks entirely because I went straight to PFL?

0 coins

Whether you can still file a DI claim for those postpartum weeks is genuinely something to ask EDD directly, since it depends on the dates involved and whether that window has closed. I would call or send a Request Claim Update through SDI Online explaining the situation.

0 coins

I'm kind of scared about this for my own situation, my wife is due in November and I want to make sure she doesn't do what happened here. So she should file the disability claim first and then separately file for PFL bonding after?

0 coins

For a birth mother, yes, that is the typical order. The pregnancy disability claim comes first for the recovery period, and then she uses the DE 2501FP, which EDD mails to her, to start the PFL bonding claim after that.

0 coins

wait pfl and sdi are two totally different things? i thought they were the same program just different names. been telling people the wrong thing for months lol

0 coins

They come from the same SDI program and you pay into both through that CASDI deduction on your check, but they cover completely different situations. DI is for your own illness or injury, including pregnancy and recovery. PFL is for bonding with a new baby or caring for a sick family member.

0 coins

ok that actually makes sense. so the deduction on the check funds both of them. i never understood why the deduction was called casdi and not cpfl

0 coins

Went through something similar with my second kid. I filed PFL right away and my mom was the one who eventually pointed out I had skipped the disability part. What I did not realize is that the DI claim and the PFL claim each have their own filing window, so contacting EDD quickly really matters once you notice the mix-up.

0 coins

Good to know, so timing is really the thing. How did yours end up getting sorted out?

0 coins

Honestly it took a few phone calls to get anyone to explain it clearly. The situation is specific enough that I would not want to guess at whether the DI window was still open for you, definitely get EDD on the line about it.

0 coins

PFL has no waiting period. DI has a seven-day unpaid period before benefits start. That difference alone can affect what you end up with if you filed PFL first without a DI claim underneath it.

0 coins

Just to add the numbers side: since PFL and DI can pay at different percentages of your wages depending on your income, the actual dollar difference between the two for the same weeks could be meaningful. Worth looking at the calculator on EDD's site and your Notice of Computation to compare.

0 coins

Mine said one weekly amount on the Notice of Computation. Would the DI weekly amount have been the same or different?

0 coins

They both pull from your base period wages but the percentage formula is the same for both programs, so the weekly amount typically comes out the same. The bigger issue is whether you lost the DI recovery weeks entirely by not filing for them.

0 coins

Three weeks before my PFL was supposed to end I tried to figure out how many bonding weeks I had left in the year, since I had also taken a few days for a care claim earlier. EDD's line was a wall every morning I tried. Went through Claimyr and the agent looked up my claim and told me exactly how many of the eight weeks I had used and how many remained in my 12-month period.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly, never heard of it.

0 coins

You hand them the work of staying on hold with EDD's line, and when a live person at EDD picks up, your phone rings. That is the whole thing.

0 coins

Alright that is straightforward enough. I would want to ask them whether my care claim days counted against the same eight weeks as my bonding claim, been trying to figure that out.

0 coins

The whole PFL vs. disability thing tripped up two of my clients in the last year alone! One filed PFL immediately after delivery and the other waited and did it the right way with disability first. The difference in what they walked away with was real, not just a technicality.

0 coins

That's really worrying to hear. Did the one who filed PFL first end up being able to fix it at all?

0 coins

She contacted EDD and they walked her through what options she still had. I genuinely do not know the specifics of what they told her but she said it helped to actually talk to someone rather than trying to read the website.

0 coins

EDD's website is honestly not great at explaining the order of operations for new moms.

0 coins

The 41-day deadline matters here. DI claims need to be filed within 41 days of when the disability began. If your postpartum recovery started in August and it is well past that window, the door on a DI claim for those specific weeks may have closed. Contact EDD and give them the exact dates before assuming either way.

0 coins

The 41 days thing is what I was afraid of. My daughter was born in early August so I need to do the math on that.

0 coins

Do not guess, ask EDD. Give them your daughter's birth date and the date you filed the PFL claim and let them tell you what the DI window looks like from their end.

0 coins

So the 41 days starts from the first day of disability, which for a birth mom would be the delivery date?

0 coins

For a pregnancy disability claim, the disability period typically begins around delivery, yes. But EDD makes the call on the specific dates, not us.

0 coins

My sister went through the whole new mom EDD process last year and the thing that confused her most was that she got two separate receipt numbers, one for the DI claim and a totally different one for the PFL bonding claim after. She thought she had filed the wrong thing twice lol

0 coins

That is actually how it works. The disability claim and the bonding claim are filed separately and each gets its own receipt number and tracking in SDI Online. They run back to back but they are not the same claim.

0 coins

yeah once someone explained that to her she felt better. she thought she had broken something by submitting twice

0 coins

Nobody at EDD is going to proactively tell you that you should have filed disability first. I found that out the hard way with my first kid. The system is set up to process whatever you submit, not to catch your mistakes before you make them.

0 coins

That is so frustrating but accurate. The whole burden of knowing the right order is on the person filing, which is not exactly fair when you just had a baby and are running on no sleep.

0 coins

HR is supposed to help with this and mine also said nothing useful. I had to piece it together from other parents.

0 coins

Before I even submitted my PFL bonding claim I spent three mornings trying to confirm my claim's start date and whether the 41-day window was still open. My phone attempts went nowhere. I ended up using Claimyr to reach EDD's PFL line, and the agent confirmed the exact start date EDD had on file and told me I was still within the 41 days.

0 coins

Used Claimyr for my own claim too and was relieved it worked the way it did. The agent I reached told me the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification, the DE 2500E, had been generated on my claim and what date to expect it. Really helped me stop second-guessing the whole thing.

0 coins

Did they say anything about what comes after the DE 2500E, like the actual payment deposit?

0 coins

The agent said the first payment would issue after the DE 2500E and to watch SDI Online for the status update. That was about the extent of it.

0 coins

So excited to have found this thread! I had no idea that PFL and disability were handled as two completely separate filings! My coworker told me they were basically the same thing and I almost just did PFL only!

0 coins

Glad you found this before filing. For a birth mother, the disability claim covers recovery and the PFL bonding claim follows it. Filing both in the right order makes a real difference.

0 coins

Is there any way to find out if the disability part is worth filing even if I am not sure my recovery will take very long?

0 coins

The number of weeks a pregnancy disability claim covers depends on what the treating physician certifies. File and have your doctor complete the certification; EDD and the physician's statement together determine the period.

0 coins

Payment method question was the one thing I could not sort out in SDI Online after I switched from my DI claim to the PFL bonding claim. The original claim had been set up for direct deposit but I was not sure if that carried over to the PFL claim automatically. Tried Claimyr and the agent confirmed the payment method on the PFL claim was showing direct deposit and that I did not need to do anything further.

0 coins

That sounds way too convenient, like something a company would put out there to get people to sign up for a service. How would they even know what is on your EDD claim?

0 coins

Thought the same thing when I first saw Claimyr mentioned somewhere. Tried it anyway when I could not get EDD on the line after a week of mornings spent dialing. The agent I reached told me the DE 2580GF had been sent out for my intermittent days and that I needed to return it or my benefits would stop. That was an actual EDD worker saying that, not a recording.

0 coins

Okay that is a pretty specific thing for them to have told you. I will probably give it a shot the next time I spend a whole morning getting nowhere on that phone line.

0 coins

been on hold with edd four times this week. nothing. this thread is making me realize i may have also filed in the wrong order after my c-section in july

0 coins

C-section recovery is typically covered under a pregnancy disability claim. If you filed PFL instead, the 41-day question from above applies to you too. Worth acting on this week, not next.

0 coins

yeah i know. just dreading the call. already so tired of trying to reach them

0 coins

The thing nobody warned me about was that the DI claim for pregnancy recovery is filed by the birth mother herself, not through her partner or jointly. I nearly had my husband file a PFL claim on my behalf thinking we could split the recovery period between us somehow, which is not how any of this works.

0 coins

So many people think that! The DI claim is specifically for the person who is physically recovering, so only the birth mother files that one. The partner files their own separate PFL bonding claim if they want to take leave.

0 coins

So if both parents want paid leave after the birth, they each have to file their own separate claims in SDI Online?

0 coins

Each parent files their own claim, yes. The birth mother files DI for recovery and then PFL for bonding. The other parent files PFL for bonding on their own.

0 coins

filing order aside, does anyone know if PFL bonding and a DI claim can overlap at all, or does one have to end before the other starts

0 coins

They cannot pay at the same time. The disability claim covers recovery first, and once that period ends the PFL bonding claim picks up. EDD does not pay both simultaneously.

0 coins

ok so it truly is one then the other, back to back. got it

0 coins

Came home from the hospital and had three forms to figure out, the hospital paperwork, whatever HR sent, and then EDD stuff anyway. Nobody hands you a checklist that says disability first then PFL. you just have to know somehow.

0 coins

That gap between what HR explains and what EDD actually requires trips up so many new parents. Hopefully threads like this save a few people the headache.

0 coins

would be nice if the SDI Online system itself warned you during the PFL filing if it looks like you skipped a disability claim, but I'm not holding my breath anyway.

0 coins

sent a Request Claim Update through SDI Online asking about this exact question last month. took about a week but I got an answer in writing which helped.

0 coins

Good to know that is an option. Did you send it under a specific request type or just write out the question?

0 coins

I picked the closest category and then explained the full situation in the text box. It got routed to someone who answered the actual question.

0 coins

something nobody mentioned yet, if you do end up with a DI claim and a PFL bonding claim back to back, they will show up as two separate claims in SDI Online. do not let that freak you out like it did me

0 coins

Mine just shows the one PFL claim right now. I really hope I can still sort out whether a DI claim was possible for me after all this.

0 coins

Ask EDD. Give them the birth date and the date you first filed. They can at least tell you what the dates show.

0 coins

my coworker had her baby in june and filed pfl immediately and her hr also said nothing about disability first. feels like this is way more common than edd probably knows

0 coins

EDD knows. They process what comes in and do not send warnings. The design of the system puts all of this on the person filing who often just had a baby and has no idea.

0 coins

yeah its wild that the form doesnt even ask if you should be filing disability instead

0 coins

Update: I sent a Request Claim Update through SDI Online two days ago explaining the situation with the dates and that I had filed PFL immediately after delivery without filing a DI claim first. I got a response today saying I should call in to discuss whether a DI claim can still be opened for the recovery period given my specific dates. So at least it is not an automatic no. Really nervous about the call but I am going to try tomorrow morning.

0 coins

That is a better answer than I expected from a written inquiry. Good luck with the call, have your daughter's birth date and your PFL claim's start date ready when you dial.

0 coins

Have the receipt number from your PFL claim handy as well. The agent will likely need it to see what is already on file.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure