Back to California Paid Family Leave

Chloe Green

California EDD PFL claim denied filed more than 12 months after birth — is there anything I can do?

My daughter was born in January of last year and I never got around to filing my PFL bonding claim. I know, I know. Life got completely chaotic and I kept putting it off, and now EDD sent me a denial notice. The denial says I'm outside the window for bonding benefits. I guess I always assumed I had more time since the eight weeks sounded like something I could use whenever. Is there any way to appeal this or am I just completely out of luck? I uploaded her birth certificate thinking maybe that would help but I haven't heard anything back. Has anyone been through this?

The Notice of Computation on my claim had a weekly amount that looked wrong to me, so I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone on the phone since I'd spent three mornings hitting redial and getting nowhere. Actually ended up talking to an EDD agent who pulled up my claim and confirmed the computation was based on my correct base period wages, the number just looked low because one of my higher-earning quarters fell outside the window. That part's done now. Anyway, your situation is different but EDD's rule on bonding is the 12-month window from birth or placement, full stop. If you filed after that, the denial is going to stick on appeal unless you can show EDD got the dates wrong. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's Paid Family Leave line: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

What did you have ready when the agent picked up, claim ID and what else?

0 coins

Receipt number, my SSN, and I had the Notice of Computation in front of me so I could read back the weekly amount. That was enough for them to pull everything up.

0 coins

Been trying that line since Tuesday. Four attempts, same recording every time. Good to know someone actually got through.

0 coins

Filing after the 12-month window is exactly why EDD sends the denial. The rule is that bonding benefits have to be used within 12 months of the child's birth or placement, so if your daughter was born in January of last year and you filed this year, you are past that point. The appeal form is the DE 1000A and you have 30 days from the denial notice to submit it, but unless the denial got the birth date or the filing date wrong, the outcome on appeal is not likely to be different.

0 coins

The 12-month part is what I didn't understand. I thought the eight weeks was a separate deadline from some other rule.

0 coins

They're connected. The eight weeks is how much you can receive, but every one of those weeks has to fall inside that 12-month period after the birth. Once that period closes, the unused weeks are gone.

0 coins

So there's no hardship exception or anything like that? I'm asking because I'm in a somewhat similar situation and I'm getting nervous.

0 coins

EDD's published rule doesn't list exceptions to the 12-month window. You could appeal and explain your circumstances, but I wouldn't count on a different result. If your 12 months haven't closed yet, file now.

0 coins

Just to make sure I understand the timeline here: your daughter was born in January of last year, so the 12-month window would have closed this past January. If you filed your PFL bonding claim after January of this year, the denial is correct on the dates. When exactly did you file?

0 coins

Filed in March. So yes, two months past the cutoff. This is really discouraging to read.

0 coins

Two months past is tough. The 30-day appeal window on that DE 2514 is worth using if you believe EDD has any date wrong, but if the dates are as you described, the appeal is mostly to get a formal hearing on record.

0 coins

Filing the appeal doesn't cost anything and at least gets your situation in front of someone. Worth doing even if the odds aren't great.

0 coins

Uploaded the birth certificate after a denial doesn't do much. The document EDD needed was your claim, filed before the window closed.

0 coins

Yeah I think I was grasping at something to do. It seemed like maybe showing she existed would help.

0 coins

EDD knows she exists. The problem is the date you filed, not proof of the birth.

0 coins

Rough lesson. I kept pushing mine close to the wire too and my wife was texting me to just file already. Anyway.

0 coins

Two payments came in on my bonding claim and then the third one didn't show up when I expected it, so I used Claimyr to reach an agent. She walked me through which weeks had posted as paid and told me the third payment was pending because I'd reported some part-time hours and the certification had to process first. Knowing the specific weeks cleared up my own confusion a lot. On the original question here, the 12-month rule applies to every bonding week claimed, so even one week filed after the window closes gets denied.

0 coins

My bonding claim has a pending week that I can't figure out either. Going to try Claimyr for it. What should I have ready before I call?

0 coins

Have your claim ID or receipt number handy, and know which specific weeks you're asking about. The agent pulled up my claim by the receipt number and could see each week's status right away.

0 coins

Good to know. I've been staring at SDI Online trying to figure out the same pending week situation.

0 coins

The pending certification thing tripped me up too. Once I returned the DE 2580GF it cleared within a few days.

0 coins

The DE 1000A, which is the Appeal Form, is included with the denial notice EDD sends. EDD's rule as published is that bonding benefits must be used within 12 months of the child's birth. An appeal is worth filing within those 30 days if any factual part of the denial is wrong, but the 12-month window itself is the rule, not an interpretation EDD applied incorrectly to your case.

0 coins

The denial notice did come with an appeal form. I'll at least fill it out and submit it, since I have nothing to lose at this point.

0 coins

That's the right move. In the appeal, be clear about the dates and explain the circumstances. It won't change the rule, but your situation goes on record.

0 coins

January birth, March filing. That's 14 months from birth to claim. The math on the denial is correct.

0 coins

cant believe nobody told you about the 12 month thing before this, thats rough. most people dont know and just assume they have forever

0 coins

Genuinely nobody warned me. I didn't even look it up until I got the denial letter.

0 coins

edd doesnt exactly send reminders. you kind of have to already know to look it up

0 coins

This comes up a lot. The eight weeks sounds unlimited in time because nobody says it expires. EDD's materials do say it but you have to read the fine print.

0 coins

File the appeal anyway. 30 days from the notice date, use the DE 1000A. Even if it doesn't reverse, you'll have a hearing and can explain what happened. Nothing to lose by trying.

0 coins

Is there anything specific I should say in the appeal that might help, or just explain the timeline?

0 coins

Explain the timeline, state the circumstances that caused the delay, and say exactly what you're asking for. Keep it straightforward.

0 coins

Does the appeal have to be mailed or can you do it online? I might need this information at some point.

0 coins

The DE 1000A can be submitted online or by mail. The denial notice will show where to send the paper version if you go that route.

0 coins

The DE 2500E on my claim showed a payment date that didn't match what had actually landed in my account, so I used Claimyr and got an EDD agent on the phone. She confirmed the payment had been issued on the date the form showed and told me direct deposit can take a couple of business days to clear after the issue date. That cleared it up for me. Separate from that, the 12-month rule here is firm, the agent on my claim mentioned that bonding weeks can't be backdated past the window even if you have all your documents ready.

0 coins

The payment date thing on the DE 2500E happened to me too! Used Claimyr as well and the agent confirmed my direct deposit issue date, then I just waited the extra days and it showed up. Once she told me the date it posted I stopped worrying!

0 coins

Three weeks of trying to get through on that line before I found this thread. Good to know there's another way.

0 coins

The direct deposit delay thing is useful to know for the future, even if my current situation is kind of a lost cause at this point.

0 coins

From a documentation standpoint: keep the denial notice, note the 30-day appeal deadline date, and send the DE 1000A before that date if you're going to appeal. After 30 days the denial is final.

0 coins

The notice came last week so I still have time. Going to get the appeal in this week.

0 coins

Good. Send it with some record of delivery if you mail it, so you have proof of the date.

0 coins

The online submission through SDI Online is probably easiest and you get a confirmation.

0 coins

I had no idea the 12-month clock starts at the birth date and not at whenever you decide to file. I always thought the eight weeks just sat there waiting for you. This thread is making me want to go check my own situation.

0 coins

The 12 months is firm and it starts at birth or placement. If you have a bonding claim you haven't used yet, check how many months have passed since the birth.

0 coins

My youngest is nine months old and I haven't filed yet. Going to do it this week.

0 coins

File now. You still have time but not a lot of cushion.

0 coins

yeah dont wait, seriously

0 coins

If the appeal doesn't go through, is there any other program or anything that might cover this? I'm asking for myself more than for the original poster because my situation is a little similar and I'm worried.

0 coins

PFL bonding is the specific benefit for new parents and it has that 12-month window. If that window closes without a claim, those weeks are gone. There isn't a separate program that steps in for missed PFL bonding.

0 coins

So the answer is basically file on time or you're out. That's clarifying even though it's not what I hoped to hear.

0 coins

File as early as the first day of your leave, that's the safest approach. EDD's own guidance says no earlier than the first day of family leave and no later than 41 days after it starts.

0 coins

The denial is right if your dates are what you said. Appeal won't hurt but go in knowing what you're working with.

0 coins

Yeah I'm not expecting a miracle. I just want to try before I give up completely.

0 coins

That's the right call. Send it in and see what happens.

0 coins

the 41-day thing and the 12-month thing are two different deadlines and both matter. people mix them up

0 coins

Worth clarifying: 41 days is how long you have from the start of your leave to file the claim. The 12 months is how long you have to actually take the bonding weeks after the birth. Miss either one and you lose benefits.

0 coins

yeah thats what i meant, two separate clocks

0 coins

I didn't know about the 41-day one at all. I was already past both by the time I filed.

0 coins

For anyone who hasn't filed yet and their baby is under 12 months, the SDI Online process is actually pretty quick once you have the birth certificate or proof of relationship ready. Don't wait like so many people in this thread did!

0 coins

Filed mine at five weeks postpartum and got the Notice of Computation within about a week. The online process was straightforward.

0 coins

Took me maybe 20 minutes to file in SDI Online. Wished I'd done it on day one of leave instead of waiting three weeks. Anyway.

0 coins

Appeal it. You've got nothing to lose and 30 days to do it. Even if it doesn't work out, at least you tried.

0 coins

Sending it in this week. Thank you everyone for being so honest about how this probably ends.

0 coins

Good luck. Knowing is better than wondering.

0 coins

For anyone reading this later: EDD's Paid Family Leave guide, the DE 2530, states the 12-month limit clearly. It's worth downloading and reading before you file so you know the deadlines going in.

0 coins

Didn't know that document existed. Looking it up now.

0 coins

It's on EDD's site and lays out all the bonding, care, and military assist rules in one place. Worth having on hand.

0 coins

Adding this to my list of things to read before my 12 months run out.

0 coins

If the appeal does somehow produce a different result, please come back and say so. It would help a lot of people in similar situations to know what made the difference.

0 coins

I will. Not holding my breath but I'll update if anything happens.

0 coins

If it reverses, it'll be because a date was wrong, not because of circumstances. Keep that in mind when you write the appeal.

0 coins

File the appeal before the 30 days close and state the facts clearly. If the dates are what you've described, prepare for the denial to hold. But you should still file it.

0 coins

Confirmed I'm doing that. The notice came eight days ago so I still have time.

0 coins

Then get it in this week and keep a copy of everything you submit.

0 coins

The lesson from this thread is pretty clear: file the PFL bonding claim as soon as your leave starts. The 12-month window sounds long but it closes before most new parents expect it to.

0 coins

Sent this thread to my brother in law whose wife is due in February. He had no idea about any of this. Anyway.

0 coins

Sharing this everywhere I can! So many parents don't know the clock starts at birth, not at whenever you get around to filing.

0 coins

Glad I found this before my own window closed.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure