Why is PFL benefit amount same as SDI different base period — how does that work in California?
Okay so I filed my SDI claim after my c-section and got my Notice of Computation and the weekly amount made sense based on what I was earning. Now I'm getting ready to file for PFL to bond with my baby and I looked it up and people are saying the PFL amount might be different from what I got on SDI, something about a different base period being used. How is that possible if it's the same EDD, same job, same paystubs? Did anyone else have their PFL come out different and can someone explain how the base periods work for each one because I'm completely confused about why they wouldn't just use the same wages?
84 comments

Sean Murphy
Payment method on my own claim took a few tries to sort out, so I ended up talking to EDD directly — I went through Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone on the phone because the 1-800-480-3287 line just kept ending the call before I got anywhere. The agent confirmed my payment was set for the Money Network debit card and walked me through switching it to direct deposit in SDI Online. Video on getting a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. On the base period question, though: EDD calculates each claim from the highest-paid quarter in a 12-month base period that ends about five to eighteen months before that claim's start date. If your SDI started right after delivery and your PFL starts eight weeks later, those are two different claim start dates, so the base period windows can shift, which is why the weekly amounts sometimes come out different.
0 coins
Zara Khan
Honestly I'd given up on that phone number entirely. How did you actually reach someone? I tried eight mornings in a row and it either rang until it disconnected or told me to try again later.
0 coins
Sean Murphy
Claimyr holds the line in your place and your phone rings once an agent picks up. Tried everything else first so I figured why not.
0 coins
Zara Khan
Alright, that is more than I expected. I keep getting dropped before I even hear a menu. My situation was that a Notice of Determination arrived saying my claim wasn't payable and I had no idea what I did wrong.
0 coins
Luca Ferrari
Went through that determination notice thing myself. The agent I finally reached told me I had 30 days from the date on the notice to appeal using the DE 1000A and to include a detailed explanation of why I disagreed. That clock starts the day on the notice, not the day you get it, so do not sit on it.
0 coins
Nia Davis
The base period thing confused me too when I was researching mine. Each claim type picks up wages from a 12-month window made up of four quarters, and that window is pegged to the claim's own start date, not to when you last filed something. So a pregnancy SDI that starts in, say, January uses different quarters than a PFL bonding claim that starts in March of the same year. If your earnings shifted a lot between those quarters, the weekly amounts can land differently even though it's the same employer and the same paystubs.
0 coins
Anastasia Popov
Wait so the base period can literally shift just because the two claims start a few weeks apart? That's wild. My c-section SDI and my PFL are only about six to eight weeks apart so I guess that's what's happening.
0 coins
Nia Davis
Exactly. Even a one-month gap between start dates can drop one full quarter out of the window and pull in a different one. EDD's benefit calculator on their site lets you punch in an estimated start date and see which quarters it uses, which really helped me understand it before my Notice of Computation arrived.
0 coins
Mateo Martinez
the calculator is actually useful for this, agreed
0 coins
Zara Khan
I had no idea PFL and SDI could land on different benefit amounts until mine did. My SDI for the pregnancy itself was based on the period when I was working the most overtime, then by the time PFL started the base period had shifted enough that one of those high overtime quarters had rolled out. The notices for each claim showed me exactly which quarters EDD used and what wages they counted.
0 coins
Anastasia Popov
That's really helpful, so the Notice of Computation for the PFL will show its own quarters separate from the SDI one? I should just wait for that and compare them.
0 coins
Zara Khan
Yes, each claim gets its own Notice of Computation. The one for PFL will list the base period quarters and the wage amounts EDD has on file for that window. If anything looks off you can check your pay stubs against it.
0 coins
QuantumQueen
not sure but do you have to do anything to trigger the PFL notice or does it come automatically after you file the claim, I'm not clear on the steps
0 coins
Aisha Rahman
Filing the PFL claim is a separate step in SDI Online. You don't just get it after SDI ends. Bonding claim, different form, different process. I didn't know that the first time and lost a couple of weeks waiting for something that was never coming.
0 coins
QuantumQueen
oh that's what I was confused about, I thought EDD would just automatically switch me over. so I have to actually go into myEDD and start a new claim for PFL?
0 coins
Aisha Rahman
Yep. Log into myEDD, open SDI Online, file the PFL claim yourself. Don't wait for them to do it.
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
and file it before the bonding period window closes, there are deadlines that apply to PFL claims same as SDI
0 coins
Yuki Sato
Came here to say exactly this. I missed a chunk of my bonding leave with my first because I thought it was automatic. Second kid I filed PFL right away and it was fine, anyway lesson learned I guess.
0 coins
Carmen Flores
Something worth knowing about the base period — if your wages were higher or lower in certain quarters because of seasonal work or a job change, that can swing the weekly amount more than people expect. I work construction so my earnings bounce around by season and my two notices had noticeably different amounts. Not wrong, just the math on different quarters.
0 coins
Andre Dubois
yeah seasonal stuff messes with this a lot, i work in a kitchen and my slow months are brutal for the base period calculation
0 coins
Sean Murphy
The Notice of Computation is worth reading carefully when it arrives. It lists the specific wages EDD pulled for each quarter. If the number for any quarter doesn't match your records, that's the thing to follow up on.
0 coins
Carmen Flores
Exactly. My stubs matched what EDD had on file, it was just that my slow quarter had rotated into the base period for the second claim. Nothing wrong with EDD's math, it's just how the window falls.
0 coins
CyberSamurai
Medical certification on my recent claim went in late because the office submitted it under the wrong receipt number, so I called EDD. Getting through took a few tries before I went through Claimyr and spoke to an agent directly. She checked the claim and confirmed the certification was sitting unmatched — she told me to have the provider's office re-submit using the receipt number from my original SDI Online filing so it could be matched to my claim.
0 coins
Carmen Flores
What's Claimyr? Haven't heard of that one.
0 coins
CyberSamurai
You call EDD through it and you end up with a live agent rather than a dead line. That's about all there is to it.
0 coins
Carmen Flores
Got it. I've got a question about whether the medical cert my doctor submitted actually came through — I'd been wondering if something like this happened on mine. Might look into that.
0 coins
Zoe Alexopoulos
The receipt number matching thing is so easy to get wrong. My doctor's office had to re-submit mine too. Once it was matched the pending status cleared within a few days.
0 coins
Luca Ferrari
I genuinely do not understand why EDD can't just show you which quarters they used in SDI Online while the claim is active instead of making you wait for the paper notice. The whole system is frustrating when you're trying to plan and you have zero information until a letter shows up.
0 coins
Jamal Carter
The notice shows up when it shows up. Trying to get ahead of it on the phone is how people lose whole mornings.
0 coins
Luca Ferrari
Believe me I know. I've lost more than a few mornings on that line. The notice is at least clear once you have it in hand.
0 coins
Anastasia Popov
Is there anything I can do in SDI Online while I wait, or is it really just wait for the Notice of Computation in the mail?
0 coins
Zara Khan
You can send a message through the Request Claim Update function in SDI Online if you have a specific question about your claim, but for the actual base period details the Notice of Computation is the document that has all of it laid out.
0 coins
Mei Liu
EDD using a different base period window for PFL than for SDI isn't a bug. It's just the way the calculation works. Two claims, two start dates, two windows. The math is the same, the inputs just shift.
0 coins
Anastasia Popov
That actually makes it click for me. Same formula, different data going in because the timing changed.
0 coins
Mei Liu
Right. And if the quarters that fall into the PFL window happened to have lower wages than the ones in the SDI window, the PFL amount will be lower. Nothing you can do about which quarters fall in, that's set by the start date.
0 coins
Liam O'Donnell
My SDI amount was noticeably higher than my PFL amount and I panicked for a whole day thinking EDD made an error! Turned out my highest overtime quarter was just outside the PFL base period window. Once I looked at both notices side by side it was completely obvious which quarters each one used.
0 coins
Anastasia Popov
This is exactly what I think is happening to me. Did you do anything or just accept the PFL amount?
0 coins
Liam O'Donnell
Checked my pay stubs against what EDD listed on the PFL Notice of Computation. The wages matched perfectly, so there was nothing to dispute. The base period just caught a different stretch of time.
0 coins
Mateo Martinez
good to know comparing the two notices side by side is the move
0 coins
Zoe Alexopoulos
My stylist friend went through this and thought EDD had made a mistake on her PFL. She called and they confirmed the wages on the notice were correct. The lesson I took from hers is to always pull out both Notices of Computation and look at which quarters are listed on each one before you assume something is wrong.
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
Comparing the two notices really is the fastest way to see what happened. No point calling EDD before you've done that because an agent is just going to read you back those same quarters.
0 coins
Zoe Alexopoulos
Exactly. She saved herself a second call once she did that. The quarters told the whole story.
0 coins
Andre Dubois
wait does the pfl base period always shift later than sdi or could it also shift earlier depending on when you file
0 coins
Nia Davis
It depends on the gap between claim start dates. If PFL starts a few months after SDI, the window slides forward in time. How much it slides depends on exactly when each claim begins.
0 coins
Andre Dubois
ok so its just pure timing, got it
0 coins
Sean Murphy
The base period for any claim goes back five to eighteen months from that claim's specific start date. So yes, it's entirely about when each claim starts, not about a fixed rule that one always comes before the other.
0 coins
Nia Davis
EDD's waiting period thing was something I got wrong on my claim. I thought the seven days was just processing lag, so I didn't start tracking my benefits until after what I expected to be two full weeks of pay. Ended up confused about why the first payment seemed low. Anyway — I'd been trying the EDD line for days and got nowhere, so I went through Claimyr to talk to someone. The agent told me my claim start date was set to the date EDD received my filing, which meant the waiting period had been running from that date, and the first payment covered day eight onward.
0 coins
Amara Nwosu
Claimyr worked well for my situation too, was glad I tried it. The agent confirmed my claim's start date matched the date I had on my DE 2501, which I'd been second-guessing.
0 coins
AstroExplorer
how did you know what date to expect for the start, was it on the receipt they gave you when you filed
0 coins
Amara Nwosu
The receipt from SDI Online showed the date I submitted. That matched what the agent confirmed on my claim. If yours doesn't match what you expect, that's worth following up on.
0 coins
QuantumQueen
the waiting period being non-payable is different from processing time, right? so even if EDD processes your claim fast you still wait seven days before anything is owed
0 coins
Nia Davis
Correct. The first seven days of a new claim are always a non-payable waiting period, that's just the rule. First payable day is day eight. It has nothing to do with how fast EDD processes anything.
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
Base period quarter pulling in the wrong direction cost me more than I expected on my PFL, so I actually got on the phone with EDD. Tried Claimyr to get through since the line had been impossible for me all week. The agent pulled up my claim and told me exactly which quarter they'd used as the highest earner in my base period, and the wages in it were accurate — it was just a lower-earning period than the one that had anchored my SDI claim.
0 coins
Giovanni Moretti
Honestly this reads like a sponsored post or something. Getting through to EDD on the phone is not that simple.
0 coins
AstroExplorer
I thought the same thing for a while but I actually tried it after seeing it mentioned somewhere. Ended up with an agent who checked the receipt number on my medical cert submission and confirmed it had been matched to the right claim. So it's real, at least for me.
0 coins
Giovanni Moretti
alright fair enough. I've been dialing that line since Tuesday and getting nowhere so I guess I'll give it a shot.
0 coins
Yuki Sato
The quarter thing is brutal when you had one really strong earning period that lands outside the PFL window. Nothing wrong with EDD's numbers, just the timing being what it is.
0 coins
Amara Nwosu
There's a calculator on EDD's site that estimates your benefit amount based on a start date you enter. If you punch in your expected PFL start date you can see roughly which quarters it will pull from and what the weekly amount might look like. Helped me set realistic expectations before my Notice of Computation arrived.
0 coins
Anastasia Popov
I didn't know there was a calculator for this. I'm going to try it with my PFL start date and see how it compares to my SDI amount.
0 coins
Amara Nwosu
Find it under the disability benefits section on EDD's site. Enter the start date and it will show you an estimated range. The actual amount on your notice may differ but it should be close.
0 coins
Liam O'Donnell
The calculator was surprisingly accurate for mine! Within a small margin of my actual Notice of Computation.
0 coins
Jamal Carter
People come in expecting PFL and SDI to match and then get surprised when they don't. They're separate claims with separate base period windows. No rule says they have to be the same number.
0 coins
Anastasia Popov
Nobody told me that before I filed SDI. I just assumed PFL would use the same wages automatically.
0 coins
Jamal Carter
Most people assume that. It's not how it works.
0 coins
Aisha Rahman
I made the same assumption. The notices clear it up fast once you have them both in front of you.
0 coins
Yuki Sato
So if someone had a really slow quarter right before their PFL start date, that could actually drag the weekly amount down even if their SDI was solid — the bad quarter rotates into the base period, the good one rotates out. That's what happened to my wife. Anyway, nothing she could do about it.
0 coins
Zoe Alexopoulos
That happened to a client of mine, one slow quarter pulled in and her PFL ended up lower than her SDI by a noticeable amount. Frustrating but accurate.
0 coins
Yuki Sato
Exactly. And it's not like you can choose your start date to game the base period, you bond when the baby's here. Anyway.
0 coins
QuantumQueen
I'm not sure if I'm reading this right but — does the base period for PFL always look at wages that are further back in time than the SDI base period, or could they overlap? I thought I understood but now I'm second-guessing myself.
0 coins
Nia Davis
They can overlap or not depending on timing. If your PFL starts right after SDI ends, the windows will be close together and might share some quarters. If there's more of a gap between them the windows diverge more. The key is each one is calculated from its own start date.
0 coins
QuantumQueen
Okay so it's not always further back, it's just shifted by however many weeks or months are between the two claim start dates. That makes more sense.
0 coins
Zara Khan
Your Notice of Computation for each claim will list the specific quarters. That's the clearest way to see exactly which wages EDD used for each one.
0 coins
Giovanni Moretti
My coworker told me EDD uses the most recent quarters for PFL, like the ones right before you file, and I repeated that to two people before I found out it's not accurate. The base period goes back quite a ways from the claim start date — EDD's looking at wages from roughly five to eighteen months prior, not the most recent pay period.
0 coins
Aisha Rahman
A lot of people get that wrong. It's not your most recent check, it's a window that ended months ago.
0 coins
Giovanni Moretti
Yeah I felt dumb when I realized. The Notice of Computation made it obvious once I saw the actual quarters listed.
0 coins
CyberSamurai
The quarter dates on the Notice of Computation are the clearest thing on the whole document. Once you see them you understand why the amount is what it is.
0 coins
AstroExplorer
been sitting on a pending SDI claim for two weeks. anyone know if the base period confusion applies during the pending stage or does that all get calculated after EDD approves it
0 coins
Nia Davis
The base period calculation is done when EDD processes the claim and issues the Notice of Computation. While the claim is pending you won't see the amount yet. The notice arrives separately once the claim is reviewed.
0 coins
AstroExplorer
ok so just wait for the notice. that's what i figured but wasn't sure
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
Two weeks pending is pretty normal when the claim is recent. If your medical certification went in and EDD has both parts, it usually moves within about 14 days of receiving everything.
0 coins
Anastasia Popov
Thank you everyone, this whole thread helped me so much. So what I understand now is: PFL starts later than SDI, so the base period window shifts, and if my higher earning quarters aren't in that new window the amount will be different. I'll wait for my PFL Notice of Computation and compare it to my SDI one to see which quarters each used. And I actually need to file the PFL claim myself in SDI Online, it doesn't happen automatically.
0 coins
Zara Khan
You've got it exactly right. File the PFL claim yourself in myEDD, watch for your Notice of Computation, and compare the quarters listed on each one. That's all there is to it.
0 coins
Liam O'Donnell
You're going to be totally fine! And congratulations on the new baby!
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
Comparing both notices is the smartest move. Everything you said is accurate.
0 coins