Back to California Disability

Daniel Price

SDI tax in California — does EDD disability count as income?

Been going back and forth on this since I got my first payment last month and I genuinely cannot figure out what the deal is. I had rotator cuff surgery in September and filed my SDI claim through SDI Online, got approved, payments started coming to my Money Network card, everything seemed fine. Then someone at Thanksgiving mentioned I might owe taxes on it and now I'm spiraling a little. I work in construction so my whole life I've had the CASDI deduction taken out of every paycheck. Now I'm actually collecting and I have no idea whether California EDD disability payments are taxable income. Is SDI tax handled differently at the state and federal level? Do I need to do anything now or just wait until I file my return? Nobody at work seems to know either.

Waiting period question tripped me up too when I was sorting out my own claim, so I phoned EDD. The hold times were brutal every morning I tried, so I ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through — ended up talking to an EDD agent who confirmed the first seven days of my claim are a non-payable waiting period, not processing time, and that the eighth day is the first one they'd ever pay me for. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ On your actual question about SDI tax: California does not tax SDI benefits — the state considers them non-taxable. The federal side is murkier and genuinely depends on your situation, so I wouldn't take anyone's word for it here, including mine. EDD has a tax information page worth checking, and if you're not sure how it applies to your return, a tax professional is the right call.

0 coins

Worth knowing the state piece is settled at least. The federal part is what always makes people nervous.

0 coins

Appreciate the state clarification — that's the part I was most worried about since California income tax isn't nothing. Still going to look up the EDD tax page before I do anything.

0 coins

Had the same Thanksgiving conversation scenario, almost word for word. The California side is clean — SDI is not taxable by the state. I looked it up on EDD's site after someone scared me about it last year during my own back injury claim. For federal I ended up talking to a tax person because I had some other income overlapping and the answer wasn't simple. Point is, don't just assume one way or the other on the federal question.

0 coins

The overlapping income thing is exactly my situation — I did some part-time hours in October before I had to fully stop, so my year is messy. Tax professional it is.

0 coins

Partial work during a claim adds layers. Report whatever you earned to EDD too if you haven't already, the payments for those weeks get adjusted.

0 coins

Already reported the October hours when I certified. SDI Online walked me through it. Just wasn't sure how that all gets treated come tax time.

0 coins

49 days caught me off guard when I first filed — I didn't realize there was a deadline at all for getting the medical certification in. I kept assuming my doctor's office would just do it whenever. The rule is the provider has 49 days from when your disability started to submit through SDI Online, and if they miss it you can run into real problems with the claim. Not directly about taxes but I see people mix up 'my claim is approved' with 'I'm good to file my taxes on this' and they're different questions entirely.

0 coins

The 49-day thing is real and I nearly missed it. Called my surgeon's office on day 44 and they hadn't done anything yet.

0 coins

Does the 49 days run from the date you filed or the date the disability actually started?

0 coins

Disability start date, not the filing date. The file window is also 49 days from the start, so both clocks run from the same point.

0 coins

Can I clear something up? My coworker keeps saying SDI payments show up on a 1099-G and that everyone gets one. I honestly don't know if that's true and I don't want to tell him he's wrong if he isn't.

0 coins

Whether a 1099-G comes is a tax question that really should go to EDD's tax information page or a tax professional — it's not a simple yes or no for everyone. I wouldn't just assume you will or won't get one.

0 coins

Fair, I'll stop guessing and look it up properly before he has me filing something I shouldn't.

0 coins

Same situation — my husband said I'd definitely get a 1099-G and I just went along with it. Going to actually check now.

0 coins

Eight weeks into recovery from a C-section here, still on SDI, wondering about this too. The CASDI deduction has been coming out of my pay for years and my understanding was that because employees pay into it themselves, the state can't then also tax you on the benefit. That's how my HR person explained it anyway. For the federal part I genuinely have no idea.

0 coins

The California piece your HR person explained lines up with what EDD says. Federal is the part to get real guidance on.

0 coins

Planning to ask a CPA once my claim wraps up and I know what the total amount was. Easier to do it all at once.

0 coins

Isn't SDI the same as unemployment for tax purposes? I thought all EDD payments got reported the same way.

0 coins

SDI disability and unemployment are completely different programs with different rules. You also can't collect both at the same time — if you're unable to work, you're on disability, not unemployment. The tax treatment isn't the same either, though the specifics on the federal side are worth verifying with a pro or on EDD's tax page.

0 coins

Okay that actually helps, I had no idea they were separate. I've never filed either one before so I assumed EDD just had one pool of money for everything.

0 coins

A lot of people assume that. EDD runs SDI, unemployment, Paid Family Leave — they're all distinct programs with their own rules and you can only collect one at a time.

0 coins

My claim started in August after a knee replacement. The Notice of Computation came pretty quickly and showed my weekly amount, which was more than I expected. I did the math on my base period wages and it tracked. Just for taxes I pulled everything into a folder and I'm going to let my accountant handle it. I figure I can tell him the total SDI payments I received and he can sort out the federal angle.

0 coins

How did you figure out your base period? I looked at my Notice of Computation but wasn't totally sure which quarters fed into it.

0 coins

My notice showed the highest-earning quarter they used. EDD also has a calculator on their site where you can plug in wages and get an estimate — that helped me understand the math before the notice even arrived.

0 coins

Going to find that calculator. I want to understand my own numbers before I talk to anyone.

0 coins

Base period question on my own claim — the quarter EDD pulled was not the one I expected and I couldn't figure out the math from the notice alone. EDD's disability line was busy every time I tried for about a week. Eventually got through using Claimyr and the agent pulled up my claim, told me exactly which quarter they'd used and what the wages were from that quarter that set my weekly amount. Lined up with what the notice said once I understood which quarter it was.

0 coins

Find the EDD disability calculator online too — once you know which quarter to plug in it makes the whole thing click.

0 coins

That's what I did after the call. The calculator on EDD's site plus knowing the actual quarter made it make sense.

0 coins

Did the agent explain why that quarter and not an earlier one?

0 coins

The agent said it was the highest-paid quarter within the 12-month base period. Didn't go into more than that, just confirmed the quarter and the wages they had on file.

0 coins

Does PFL work the same way for taxes? I'm about to transition off my pregnancy disability into bonding leave and I keep lumping the two together in my head.

0 coins

PFL and SDI disability are two separate claims and programs. For taxes the same principle applies — California doesn't tax either one at the state level, and the federal side is worth looking up or asking a professional about rather than assuming. But please don't treat them as identical on your return.

0 coins

I figured they were similar since they're both EDD and both show up on the same card. Good to know to keep them separate on paperwork.

0 coins

The Money Network card can have payments from more than one claim loaded onto it, which is probably why it feels like one thing. The underlying programs really are separate.

0 coins

Nobody's said this clearly yet: for California state taxes, SDI benefits are not counted as taxable income. EDD's own site says this. The federal answer is not in these facts and you should get it from a tax professional or EDD's tax information page, not from a forum.

0 coins

This is the most direct answer in the whole thread, appreciate it.

0 coins

Should have been in the first reply honestly. People come in panicking and walk out more confused than when they started.

0 coins

I get why it's confusing — the CASDI deduction comes out of wages all year and then you get a benefit and start wondering what category it falls into. The California answer is clear. Federal, get a pro.

0 coins

My physical therapist actually tried to certify my last claim and the office told me they'd submitted it. Took three weeks for EDD to get back to me and when they did it was a problem with the certification. I never connected the dots until later.

0 coins

Physical therapists aren't on EDD's list of providers who can certify a disability claim. The list includes physicians, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, chiropractors, and a few others — a PT isn't one of them. If your PT submitted something and EDD didn't accept it, that's likely why.

0 coins

That explains so much. My actual doctor ended up submitting it after and everything went through. I just never understood what happened.

0 coins

I almost made the same mistake, my PT offered to 'take care of it' and I didn't know enough to question it at the time.

0 coins

W-2 came for last year and I panicked when I didn't see SDI on it the way I expected. Filed a question through Ask EDD but honestly wasn't sure I was asking the right thing. The state tax question for California is actually answered pretty directly on EDD's site — look under their tax information section.

0 coins

Is Ask EDD good for this kind of question or is it better to just call?

0 coins

Ask EDD worked fine for me for general questions but it took a few days to get a response. For something time-sensitive I'd call the disability line at 1-800-480-3287 — they're there weekdays 8 to 5.

0 coins

Tried calling EDD three mornings in a row this week about something unrelated to taxes — my direct deposit information and whether they had it right. Got through on the third try and the agent confirmed my payment method had me set for direct deposit, not the Money Network card. I was relieved because I'd been watching for the card in the mail without realizing I'd actually set up direct deposit in SDI Online when I filed.

0 coins

You can switch between direct deposit and the card?

0 coins

You can set it when you file on SDI Online if you're filing a new claim. I set it up and then forgot I had, which is why I was confused.

0 coins

I didn't know the card was Money Network now. I keep seeing people mention a Bank of America EDD card and I was looking for one.

0 coins

The card is Money Network, not Bank of America. That changed a while back.

0 coins

For anyone still confused about the state vs. federal split: California not taxing SDI is consistent and has been for a long time. The federal piece is the variable one, and that's exactly why the right answer is 'talk to a tax professional' rather than 'yes' or 'no' on a forum. Giving a definitive federal answer here would be doing someone a disservice.

0 coins

Makes sense. I'm going to stop looking for a yes/no answer on the federal side and just get a CPA.

0 coins

That's the right move. Bring your Notice of Computation and anything else EDD sent you so they have the full picture.

0 coins

Payment method was the thing I had to get sorted — my form showed I'd been set up for the Money Network card but I wanted direct deposit. Spent two mornings not getting through on the phone. Used Claimyr and talked to an EDD agent who confirmed the payment method on my claim and told me how to update it through SDI Online. Got it changed before my next payment came.

0 coins

Did you have to do anything in SDI Online first or did the agent handle the change?

0 coins

The agent told me where to go in SDI Online to update it myself. The change showed on my next payment.

0 coins

Going to try updating mine — I didn't realize direct deposit was an option when I first filed.

0 coins

For the base period math, I want to flag that the quarterly wages EDD uses to calculate your weekly benefit are from your base period, which runs about 5 to 18 months before your claim start date. I had a quarter where I worked a ton of overtime and I was hoping that one would count — it did, because it happened to be my highest-earning quarter in the base period. EDD takes the best quarter and builds your rate from there.

0 coins

Does EDD tell you on the notice which quarter they used?

0 coins

The Notice of Computation lays out your weekly and maximum benefit amounts. If the specific quarter isn't obvious to you from that, the calculator on EDD's site lets you work backward.

0 coins

My overtime from last winter is what I'm hoping counted. Going to run the numbers through the calculator.

0 coins

Federal SDI tax question is genuinely one of those things where the answer depends on enough individual factors that I'd feel bad giving a firm answer either way. EDD's tax information section addresses it in general terms. If the answer matters for a real return you're filing, the right resource is a tax professional who can look at your whole income picture.

0 coins

This is honestly more helpful than a confident wrong answer would be.

0 coins

Exactly. I'd rather someone get it right than feel settled because a stranger on the internet said yes or no.

0 coins

Medical certification for my own injury claim took longer than I expected to get sorted. The provider's office said they'd submitted it but SDI Online still showed pending almost two weeks later. I ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr, and the agent pulled up my claim and said the certification hadn't been received yet — the office had the wrong receipt number on file. Got the office the right one and the certification came through two days later.

0 coins

That receipt number issue trips so many people up. You have to give the provider the exact number SDI Online showed you after you filed Part A.

0 coins

Learned that the hard way. Now I write it down and send it to the office in a message so there's a record.

0 coins

Does the office look it up on their end through SDI Online or do they need you to give it to them?

0 coins

They need you to give it to them — it's how they find your specific claim in the system to match the certification to.

0 coins

Can workers' comp and SDI run at the same time? My cousin got hurt at work and filed both — I've been telling him that's not how it works but I'm not totally sure I'm right.

0 coins

EDD's own language on this is that it's not common to receive both at the same time, and there are exceptions. Not something to assume one way or the other — your cousin should ask EDD directly about how the two interact on his specific case.

0 coins

I'll stop guessing and tell him to call EDD.

0 coins

DE 2593 showed up in my mailbox after my fifth automatic payment — I didn't know that form was coming and nearly missed the 20-day window to return it. It's the continued eligibility questionnaire EDD sends to confirm you're still out of work. If you don't send it back in time you can lose benefits. Worth watching for it if you're on automatic payment.

0 coins

Twenty days is not much time if you're not expecting it. Good to know.

0 coins

I saw it and thought it was junk mail initially. Open everything EDD sends.

0 coins

I had the same near-miss. Opened it on day 17 and mailed it the same afternoon.

0 coins

Adding 'watch for DE 2593' to my mental list. I'm still early in my claim so it'll be a while but I want to know what's coming.

0 coins

The CASDI line on a paystub — does the percentage change year to year? Someone at work said the deduction rate went up and I want to know what I'm actually paying into.

0 coins

The SDI contribution rate can change. What your paystub shows is what's being taken out. For the specific current rate, EDD's site has that information — not something to rely on a forum for since it can shift.

0 coins

Makes sense, I'll check my pay stub and look it up on EDD's site rather than taking someone's word for it.

0 coins

For the original question about SDI and taxes — the short version that holds: California state tax doesn't apply to SDI benefits. For federal you need your own tax professional because the answer is not one-size-fits-all. EDD has tax information on edd.ca.gov worth reading before that appointment.

0 coins

Think I have everything I need now. State: not taxable. Federal: get a CPA, bring the Notice of Computation and total payments received. EDD's tax page for background.

0 coins

That's the right takeaway. Good luck with the return and hope the shoulder heals up well.

0 coins

Bring documentation of your partial October wages too if you reported them during the claim. Your CPA will want the full picture.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure