Back to California Disability

Callum Savage

SDI pregnancy claim denied not losing wages teacher summer contract — what does that even mean?

Filed my SDI pregnancy claim about four weeks before my due date, everything looked fine, and then I got a Notice of Determination saying I'm denied because I'm not losing wages. I'm a teacher on a summer contract, so technically my school district is still paying me over the summer even though I'm on leave before the baby comes. I genuinely don't understand this. I'm clearly unable to work a classroom right now, my midwife submitted the medical certification, the whole thing went through SDI Online. How is it possible I don't qualify? Has anyone else been denied for this reason? The notice says I have 30 days to appeal and there's an Appeal Form DE 1000A included. I really want to appeal but I don't know what to argue or what documentation to actually send in. Do I just mail it back and explain my situation or is there more to it?

Summer contract payments tripped up my own SDI claim years ago, though I was an aide, not a teacher. The way EDD looks at it, if wages are still coming in from your employer during the period you're claiming disability, they may determine you aren't losing wages for those days. The appeal is absolutely the right move. With the DE 1000A, write a detailed explanation of exactly what your contract covers, whether those summer payments are for work you already performed during the school year rather than current work. That distinction has mattered in cases I've seen discussed here.

0 coins

My district pays us on a 12-month spread even though we only work 10 months. So technically the money coming in is for work I already did. Would I just explain that in the appeal letter?

0 coins

Exactly that. Attach your contract or a letter from HR that shows the pay is deferred compensation from the school year, not pay for current summer duties. The more clearly you document it the better.

0 coins

HR gave me a letter last week for something else, I'll ask them to write one specifically for the appeal. Thank you for this, it actually makes sense now.

0 coins

Weeks paid showing on my claim were off, so I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com). Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and told me exactly which weeks had been paid and which were still open, so I knew what I was actually appealing versus what had already processed. For your situation, knowing which weeks EDD flagged as the wage-loss issue could help you focus your appeal letter on the right dates rather than writing a general argument.

0 coins

Every time I've tried that disability line it either rings forever or cuts me off after the hold music. How did you actually end up speaking to someone, because I've tried at least a dozen mornings and gotten nowhere.

0 coins

It's a service that waits on hold with EDD in your place until a live agent picks up, then your phone rings. I was skeptical about the hold time too, but an actual EDD agent answered and went through my claim week by week.

0 coins

Had a similar wage question on my own injury claim. After I finally reached an EDD agent, she confirmed the quarter they were using for my base period and it turned out they had the right quarter after all. The issue was something else entirely on my end.

0 coins

Okay that's interesting. I've been trying to find out why my own claim shows pending so long, might give it a shot.

0 coins

Appeals aren't as scary as they sound. Mail the DE 1000A to the return address printed on that denial notice, attach whatever your HR department gives you, and write plainly what your pay arrangement is. Don't overthink the wording, just be clear and factual.

0 coins

The notice has two different addresses on it, one for EDD and one listed under the appeal section. I should use the one under the appeal section, right?

0 coins

Yes. The address on the appeal section is where it goes. Not the general EDD address.

0 coins

EDD's pregnancy guidance on its site says benefits can start up to four weeks before the due date when a provider certifies it, and earlier if there are complications, reduced hours, or unsafe conditions. The denial here seems to hinge on the wage-loss test, not on whether you're medically eligible. Those are two separate issues and your appeal should address the wage-loss piece directly, not re-argue the medical certification.

0 coins

This is a really useful distinction. I assumed if the medical cert was fine the rest would follow automatically. Good to know the wage-loss piece is evaluated separately.

0 coins

They can deny on either ground independently. Medical eligibility and financial eligibility are both required, and EDD's notice will usually say which one it's denying on.

0 coins

Mine says specifically 'not unemployed, underemployed, or suffering wage loss' so it really is just the wage question. The medical cert was accepted.

0 coins

My pregnancy claim went through fine but I honestly had no idea the wage-loss thing was even part of it until a friend of mine got denied for almost the same reason a year ago. She was a school counselor on the same kind of 12-month pay schedule. She appealed and won, so it is possible. Keep all your pay stubs from this summer too, they can show that the amount hasn't changed even though you stopped showing up.

0 coins

That's really encouraging about your friend. Did she just mail the appeal form or did she have to go to a hearing?

0 coins

She just mailed it with documentation the first time and it got resolved before it ever went to a hearing. No promises that's how yours will go but it doesn't always escalate.

0 coins

I'm kind of confused reading this whole thread, not sure if I'm misunderstanding. Does the waiting period count differently for pregnancy? Like does the seven-day wait still apply even if you get denied on wages first and then appeal successfully?

0 coins

The seven-day waiting period is the first week of a new claim that isn't payable, it's not processing time and it's not connected to the denial. If the appeal succeeds and EDD finds you eligible, that waiting period still runs from your claim start date, so the first seven days remain unpaid. It doesn't get added back because of the denial.

0 coins

Ah okay so I had it backwards. I thought a denial reset the clock somehow. Good to know it doesn't.

0 coins

Genuinely didn't know that either. So even if I win the appeal my first seven days are still the waiting period and won't be paid. That's fine, I just want the rest of it.

0 coins

DE 2525XX came up on my claim when my recovery ran longer than expected. Called EDD through Claimyr and the agent confirmed the extension form had been received and was matched to my claim. Knowing it was actually in the system saved me from sending a duplicate. For your appeal, once it's resolved and you're approved, keep that extension form in mind if your leave goes past what your midwife originally certified.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? Keep seeing it mentioned and not sure what it is.

0 coins

It's a service that gets on the line with EDD for you and rings your phone when an agent answers. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

Oh that's actually useful. I've been trying to get through about whether my own extension was filed correctly by my doctor's office. Might use that.

0 coins

Appealing a denial when you're a week away from your due date is a lot of pressure. File the appeal before the 30-day window closes no matter what, even if your documentation isn't perfect yet. A late appeal needs reasons for the delay and those get reviewed by an administrative law judge. Don't miss the deadline waiting for HR to get the letter perfect.

0 coins

The notice is dated three weeks ago and I haven't done anything yet. I really need to move this week.

0 coins

This week. Yes.

0 coins

Filing it imperfect and on time is always better than perfect and late. You can send follow-up documentation after if needed.

0 coins

Pay stubs from June and July showing identical amounts to what you earned during the school year support the deferred compensation argument. If the gross on your summer stubs matches your school-year stubs exactly, that strengthens the case that nothing changed on your employer's end and the money isn't pay for current summer work.

0 coins

My stubs are all the same amount every month, twelve equal payments across the year. That should help.

0 coins

Document it that way in the appeal letter explicitly. Twelve equal disbursements across twelve months for ten months of work. Put that in writing so EDD doesn't have to infer it.

0 coins

my sister had almost the same thing happen with her school job and she just mailed the form with a note from her principal explaining the pay schedule and it got sorted. not fast but it worked

0 coins

Good to know it doesn't have to be complicated documentation.

0 coins

yeah she stressed about it way more than she needed to. a clear simple explanation was enough

0 coins

The Notice of Computation came in the mail before my claim was finalized and I thought it meant I was approved. It doesn't, it just shows your potential weekly amount. If you get one while your appeal is pending, don't take it as an approval notice!

0 coins

I actually did get a Notice of Computation before the denial. So that's why I was so confused when the denial came after.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation and the Notice of Determination are two separate things. The first shows your potential benefit amount based on your earnings, the second tells you whether EDD has approved or denied the claim. Getting one doesn't guarantee the other.

0 coins

Exactly! Confused me too on my own claim. Two different notices with similar names.

0 coins

Every teacher I know in this situation gets told the same thing by EDD and most of them have to appeal. It's not a rare situation, the summer pay structure causes this denial regularly. File the appeal, include the HR letter, and expect it to take some time.

0 coins

That's both frustrating and reassuring. At least I'm not the only one and there's a known path forward.

0 coins

Known path, annoying process. File and wait.

0 coins

Claim start date on mine was wrong, off by almost two weeks, which threw off everything downstream. Ended up getting it sorted after I reached an EDD agent through Claimyr. The agent looked at the claim and confirmed the actual start date they had on file, which turned out to be different from what I'd entered. Worth double-checking yours when you're in SDI Online just to make sure your disability start date matches what your midwife certified.

0 coins

Got through EDD's disability line using Claimyr on my own claim too, honestly relieved I did. The agent confirmed my DE 2593 had been received and logged, because I'd mailed it in and had no idea if it even got there. Once I knew EDD had it I could stop worrying about that piece.

0 coins

What did EDD say about the timeline after they had the form?

0 coins

The agent said the form was in the system and that if anything changed I'd get a notice. No specific date, just that it was received.

0 coins

Checking my claim start date right now in SDI Online. I hadn't thought about that potentially being off.

0 coins

late appeal needs an explanation for the delay so just file it now even if you're tired and overwhelmed. the judge looks at why you were late if it's past 30 days

0 coins

Filing this week, I keep saying it and I mean it this time.

0 coins

0 coins

Notice of Computation on my injury claim listed a weekly amount that seemed too low, so I used Claimyr to reach an EDD agent and ask about it. The agent told me which quarter they'd used as the highest-paid quarter in my base period and it turned out one quarter was just lighter because I'd had a slow month. The amount on the notice was correct. For your appeal, once it's resolved, make sure the Notice of Computation reflects your actual teaching salary and not just the summer disbursement amount.

0 coins

Reads like a pitch. What line were you calling and how many times had you tried before that worked.

0 coins

I had the same doubt when I first saw it mentioned. After six mornings of that line cutting out on me I tried it on my own claim, asked the agent about my payment method since my direct deposit hadn't shown up yet. She confirmed the deposit had been issued to the account on file and gave me the date. That was an EDD agent, not anyone else.

0 coins

Alright. I'll think about it.

0 coins

Filing the appeal paperwork and sending the HR deferred-compensation letter together as one package is cleaner than mailing them separately. Put the denial notice date and your name on every page just so nothing gets separated.

0 coins

Makes sense. I'll put my claim ID on every page too just in case.

0 coins

Claim ID, name, the date of the denial notice. All of it on each page, yes.

0 coins

Unemployment crossed my mind when I first heard about the denial, like could you file for unemployment while the appeal is on. But you can't, right? Since you're still medically unable to work you can't claim you're available for work.

0 coins

You can't receive unemployment and disability for the same days, and unemployment requires that you be able and available to work every week you claim it. Someone still out on a pregnancy disability can't meet that standard, so DI is the right path and the appeal is the right move here.

0 coins

Right, that's what I figured. Just wanted someone to confirm because I'd read something vague about it.

0 coins

Good to know I shouldn't even try that route while the appeal is active. Just focus on the appeal.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is a nightmare for everyone on this thread and everyone not on it. I'm glad there are options. For your appeal, don't forget the 30 days runs from the date printed on the notice, not the date you received it in the mail.

0 coins

The date on the notice is three weeks ago. I really am cutting it close.

0 coins

Get it in the mail tomorrow, certified if you can. Don't wait for anything else.

0 coins

The midwife submitting the certification was the right provider. Licensed midwives, nurse-midwives and nurse practitioners are all on EDD's list for pregnancy and postpartum conditions. That piece of your claim is solid, the denial really is just about the wage-loss question, which the HR letter and your pay stubs should address.

0 coins

That's a relief to hear about the midwife. Someone in my birth class said I might need an OB to certify it and I panicked.

0 coins

Midwife is fine for pregnancy and childbirth. The concern about an OB isn't accurate for California EDD.

0 coins

EDD's list includes licensed midwives, nurse-midwives and nurse practitioners specifically for pregnancy, childbirth and postpartum conditions. Your midwife qualifies.

0 coins

Hope the appeal goes well. Post back when you hear something.

0 coins

I will. Filing tomorrow, certified mail, with the HR letter. Thank you all, genuinely.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure