Back to California Disability

Avery Saint

SDI payments child support deducted twice how to avoid double garnishment

So this is kind of a mess and I'm not even sure who to ask about it. I've been out on disability since my back surgery in September and my SDI payments started coming through on the Money Network card. The problem is my child support order is already being withheld from my regular paycheck by my employer, and now it looks like the county is also pulling support from my SDI payments. So I'm getting hit twice, once from the job (which I'm still technically employed at, just out on leave) and once from the SDI benefit itself. My employer's payroll is still running the garnishment even though I'm not earning wages right now, which is probably an error on their end, but the SDI side is also getting hit. Has anyone dealt with this? I need to figure out how to stop the double deduction before my next payment drops because I'm barely covering rent as it is.

December 3rd is the date I'd focus on if I were you: that's when county support enforcement systems typically catch up to a new income source. The SDI garnishment is coming from EDD responding to an earnings withholding order, which is separate from whatever your employer's payroll is doing. The employer side is almost certainly running on autopilot because payroll didn't get updated when you went on leave. Talk to HR today and show them you're on SDI and not drawing wages, so they can suspend the payroll deduction.

0 coins

HR actually told me they'd look into it but haven't heard back. I think they just don't know how to handle the SDI piece.

0 coins

Put it in writing to HR, email or a formal memo. A paper trail matters if the double deduction has to be sorted out later.

0 coins

HR moves slow. Give them a deadline or nothing happens.

0 coins

DE 2525XX came back from my doctor's office later than I expected, and I wasn't sure if EDD had even received it. I ended up reaching a live EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) because the phone line just rang and rang every morning for two weeks straight. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the extension form was sitting there, received but not yet matched to my claim, and told me what week it covered. Video on getting through to a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Anyway I know that's slightly different from the double garnishment thing but I wanted to flag it since my situation involved payments getting held up and I was also dealing with support obligations at the same time.

0 coins

Payment method on my own claim was something I'd gotten wrong, thought it defaulted to a check. Claimyr got me to an agent who confirmed the card had already been issued under Money Network and told me which address it was sent to. I'd been waiting at the wrong mailbox for three weeks.

0 coins

Three weeks waiting on a card that went somewhere else sounds awful.

0 coins

Wait so the agent actually confirmed the card was already out? Does that mean EDD won't reissue it or do you have to request a new one through SDI Online?

0 coins

The double withholding situation you're describing has two separate legal tracks. The SDI garnishment goes through EDD because a court or county DCSS served EDD with an earnings withholding order directly. Your employer's garnishment runs off a separate order served to payroll. They don't automatically cancel each other. You'd need to contact DCSS and show them you're on SDI leave, that wages from the job are zero right now, and ask them to suspend or redirect the employer withholding until you're back earning again.

0 coins

So DCSS is the place to call, not EDD? I wasn't sure which agency was actually holding the lever on the employer side.

0 coins

DCSS handles enforcement of the support order. EDD is just responding to the withholding order they received. Two different agencies, two different conversations.

0 coins

Good luck getting DCSS on the phone too. government lines are all the same nightmare.

0 coins

My cousin went through something kind of like this but hers was just the SDI side, not a double hit. She didn't realize the support order she had automatically attached to any state benefit income, not just wages. The DCSS worker she talked to actually knew exactly what to do once she explained she was on disability leave.

0 coins

DCSS knowing what to do sounds optimistic but okay.

0 coins

Ha, I know, but she got it sorted within two weeks so maybe she got lucky with who answered.

0 coins

The 20-day window is what caught me off guard on my own claim. EDD sent the DE 2593 and I nearly missed it. But on the garnishment question, I'd also note that SDI Online doesn't show withholding details as far as I've ever seen. You'd need to look at your payment breakdown on the Money Network side or contact EDD directly to understand exactly what's being deducted before it hits the card.

0 coins

I didn't even know to check the Money Network side separately. I'd just been looking at what landed in my account.

0 coins

The Money Network statement shows each transaction, including any deductions before the net deposit. Worth pulling that up.

0 coins

Start date on my claim was recorded wrong, one day off, which mattered for figuring out the waiting period. I tried the EDD line for days before I used Claimyr to get a live agent. The agent found the recorded start date and confirmed it matched what my doctor had certified, so the one-day thing turned out to be a display issue. If you're trying to reach EDD about the garnishment deductions showing on your SDI payments, actually getting a person who can read the payment history on your account makes a real difference.

0 coins

Spent eleven mornings trying that line before 9 and got the busy signal every single time. I'm skeptical that any service actually breaks through, given how locked up that line is on a normal day.

0 coins

Fourteen mornings myself before I tried it. The agent I ended up talking to was EDD staff, not anyone else, and they read me the dates right off my claim.

0 coins

My Notice of Determination came and I genuinely couldn't tell from it whether the denial was about eligibility or timing. EDD's agent confirmed it was a timing issue on the certification, not a full denial, so I knew to appeal within the 30 days rather than just refile.

0 coins

Noted on actually getting a person to read the payment breakdown. That's exactly what I need.

0 coins

employer payroll garnishment while youre on leave is almost definitely an error on their side. ive seen that happen when HR doesnt update payroll status. bug them every day until they fix it

0 coins

Every day is right. Silence from HR means nothing got fixed.

0 coins

Yeah I've been too patient about it. Going to send HR a written notice today.

0 coins

Worth knowing that EDD responds to whatever withholding order it received, they don't negotiate the amount or the frequency. If you think the amount being pulled from SDI is wrong compared to what the order says, the court that issued the order or DCSS is where you'd challenge it, not EDD.

0 coins

That actually clears something up. I was wondering if EDD could just adjust the deduction on their end.

0 coins

EDD has no discretion on a court-ordered garnishment. They deduct what the order says. The order is what needs to change.

0 coins

Get the actual withholding order documents from DCSS. See what each one says. You can't fix a double deduction without knowing which order authorized what.

0 coins

I don't even have copies of the original orders. DCSS should be able to pull those?

0 coins

They have them. Request the file, it's your right.

0 coins

I'm confused about something. If SDI benefits count as income for child support purposes, does that mean the support amount itself could get recalculated while you're on disability? Like would they lower the obligation because you're earning less? Or does the existing order just stay fixed no matter what?

0 coins

A support modification is a separate legal process through the court. The existing order stays in force until a judge changes it. DCSS can help you file for a modification if your income has dropped significantly, but nothing changes automatically.

0 coins

Oh I had no idea a modification was even possible. I thought the order was just fixed forever. That's actually useful to know.

0 coins

Family law attorney or even a legal aid clinic would be worth a free consult for the modification piece. That's outside what EDD can help with.

0 coins

Notice of Computation on my claim had a question I couldn't sort out from the form itself, so I ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr to ask about which quarter of wages they'd used for my benefit calculation. The agent went through the base period and told me the exact quarter they'd pulled, which let me verify the amount made sense against my pay history. For the garnishment problem: the payment breakdown you see in SDI Online under your claim won't show withholding line items, so you'd need to either contact EDD or look at your Money Network statement to see the net figure.

0 coins

What even is Claimyr, I keep seeing it mentioned.

0 coins

You reach EDD's disability line and your phone rings when a live agent picks up. That's the whole thing, no waiting on hold yourself.

0 coins

Alright, I need to find out why my pending weeks haven't moved in three weeks. Might actually give that a try.

0 coins

The Money Network statement tip is solid. That's where I found the deduction line I didn't understand on my own payment.

0 coins

your best move is probably a three-way call or at least a conference between HR, DCSS, and you. get everyone on the same page at once instead of you being the messenger back and forth

0 coins

Honestly that's a good idea I hadn't thought of. At least then HR can hear directly from DCSS what the order says.

0 coins

Confirm any agreement in writing after that call. Verbal fixes disappear.

0 coins

SDI Online let me request a claim update when I had a question about payment timing and EDD responded within a few days! Might be worth using the Request Claim Update feature for your situation too if you can't get through on the phone.

0 coins

I didn't know that feature existed in SDI Online. Going to look for it today.

0 coins

In myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ you can open your claim and find Request Claim Update from there. Super useful!

0 coins

been dealing with a support order on my own sdi payments for two months. DCSS was the only office that could actually adjust anything. EDD just does what the order says.

0 coins

Two months is a long time to be dealing with that. Did DCSS actually resolve it or still ongoing?

0 coins

mostly resolved. they suspended the employer side once I sent the leave paperwork. took about three weeks.

0 coins

The employer running a wage garnishment when you have no wages is a pretty clear payroll error. That part at least should be fixable without anyone at DCSS getting involved.

0 coins

Agreed. Zero wages, no basis for a wage garnishment. HR needs to suspend that the moment they confirm the leave dates.

0 coins

Should have been caught automatically. Someone in payroll dropped the ball.

0 coins

Also worth asking DCSS whether they want a letter from EDD confirming you're on disability leave. Some county offices ask for that before they'll put any hold on the employer side.

0 coins

I'll ask them that when I call. I can probably get something out of SDI Online to show the claim is active.

0 coins

A printed claim confirmation from SDI Online should work for most county offices. DCSS will tell you if they need a different format.

0 coins

not sure if this overlaps but does the waiting period affect when the support deduction starts on the sdi side? like do they wait for the first actual payment or does the order trigger from the claim start date

0 coins

The withholding order attaches to payments, not to the claim itself. The first seven days are unpaid, so there's nothing to deduct from during that time. Deductions start with the first actual benefit payment.

0 coins

oh that makes sense, I was worried they might try to charge arrears from the claim start date somehow.

0 coins

Arrears on an SDI claim would have to come through a separate enforcement action, not automatically from the payment stream.

0 coins

DCSS has a web portal in most counties. Faster than the phone line.

0 coins

Didn't know that. I'll check if my county has one.

0 coins

Get the double withholding sorted before it compounds. If you're overpaying support through two channels at once, you're building a credit with DCSS but depleting your disability income in the meantime. Document every payment and every conversation.

0 coins

That's a good framing. At least the overpayment might mean I'm ahead on support, but I need that money to live on right now.

0 coins

DCSS can apply excess payments to future obligations. It won't be lost, but you'll need records to make them account for it.

0 coins

Keeping a dated log of every call, every email, every payment amount is what saves you if this goes to a court review.

0 coins

Has anyone mentioned that if you think EDD's deduction amount doesn't match the court order, you can send EDD a written inquiry through Ask EDD? That's EDD's online contact form. Might at least get you a written record of what withholding order EDD has on file.

0 coins

Ask EDD being an option is helpful. I want a paper trail on everything so I'll use that too.

0 coins

Ask EDD responses can take a week or more but the written record is worth it. Use it alongside the phone, not instead of it.

0 coins

You got three things to handle: get HR to suspend the payroll garnishment now that you're on leave, get DCSS to confirm which orders are active and for which income source, and get a copy of what order EDD has on file. Work them all at once.

0 coins

This is basically my action list now. Thank you. HR today, DCSS tomorrow, Ask EDD after that.

0 coins

Good. Keep everything in writing.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure