SDI payment disallowed for returning to work but doctor has not released me yet
So my situation is kind of confusing and I'm honestly panicking a little. I've been on SDI since I had a procedure done on my back about six weeks ago and my claim was going okay, payments coming in, everything seemed fine. Then two weeks ago I got a notice saying my payment was disallowed because EDD has me marked as having returned to work. The problem is I have NOT gone back to work. My doctor has not released me and actually extended my time off because I'm still having complications. I reported everything honestly and I'm not sure where this information even came from. Has anyone dealt with this? My employer might have reported something to EDD but I genuinely haven't worked a single day. I tried calling the EDD disability line at 1-800-480-3287 but I can't get through, it just cuts me off after the automated stuff. I'm terrified I'm going to lose my benefits while I'm still physically unable to work and my doctor literally has paperwork saying so.
79 comments

Sergio Neal
That disallowance notice should have an Appeal Form DE 1000A attached. You have 30 days from the date on the notice to file it. Do it now before you spend more time worrying. Send it back with a letter explaining you haven't returned to work and attach anything your doctor has in writing.
0 coins
Leslie Parker
AuthorThe notice date is from 11 days ago so I still have time. Does the doctor's written extension paperwork count as something I can attach to the appeal?
0 coins
Sergio Neal
Absolutely attach it. Anything that shows your status as still unable to work is relevant. The more you send the better.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
The form is the DE 1000A and the return address is printed right on the notice itself. Send the appeal there, not to a general EDD address. Keep a copy of everything you mail.
0 coins
Juan Moreno
EDD marks people returned to work sometimes when an employer files a payroll report or something similar. It doesn't mean you actually went back, it means their system picked up something. The frustrating part is you have to prove a negative, which is ridiculous, but that's where you are. Appeal immediately.
0 coins
Leslie Parker
AuthorThat's what I figured, something from payroll must have triggered it. My employer knew I was out so I'm not sure why they'd report anything but maybe it was automatic.
0 coins
Amy Fleming
Payroll systems run on their own schedule. HR probably didn't update it in time. Happens more than you'd think.
0 coins
Alice Pierce
Filing the appeal with a note explaining the payroll report situation is exactly the right move. The appeal is where you get to tell your side.
0 coins
Esteban Tate
Receipt number on my own claim got mismatched somehow and I had four days of going in circles in SDI Online before I finally reached someone. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is what I ended up using to get a live agent on EDD's disability line. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and found that the receipt number my provider used didn't match the one SDI Online generated for me when I filed. Took about two minutes once I had someone on the phone. They told me my provider would need to refile the certification with the correct number.
0 coins
Ivanna St. Pierre
Every single morning last week I called that number and got the recording that says to try again, then it ends the call. Something like Claimyr sounds like it would just have the same problem hitting that same wall, honestly. How did it actually land you with a person?
0 coins
Esteban Tate
The line hangs up on me every time too, that's exactly why I tried it. Claimyr stays on that line for you and your phone rings once an EDD agent picks up. I ended up talking to someone in maybe an hour, which was more than I'd managed in four days of trying myself.
0 coins
Elin Robinson
Used it too when my payment dates were all over the place. The agent I spoke with told me the exact date my last payment was issued and which weeks it covered. That's what I needed and I had it in one call.
0 coins
Atticus Domingo
The rule here is that EDD needs to show you were actually working, not just that an employer reported something. Your doctor's continued certification and the DE 2525XX your physician would have submitted for your extension are your documentation. EDD's own site says you can appeal a denial within 30 days of the notice date using the DE 1000A.
0 coins
Leslie Parker
AuthorI didn't know the extension form had a specific name. It's the DE 2525XX? My doctor submitted something through SDI Online but I'm not sure which form it was.
0 coins
Atticus Domingo
That's the Physician/Practitioner's Supplementary Certificate, the DE 2525XX, what your provider submits when you need more time beyond the original certification period. If they filed it through SDI Online it's already in the system, which works in your favor for the appeal.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
Confirming that. The DE 2525XX is what documents the extension. If EDD has it on file and the disallowance still happened, the appeal should reference that form specifically and the date it was submitted.
0 coins
Beth Ford
ugh this is exactly why I tell everyone I know who files SDI to screenshot everything in SDI Online at every step. take a screenshot the day you file, the day the medical cert goes in, every payment, everything. so much easier to appeal when you have a record of what the system showed when.
0 coins
Leslie Parker
AuthorI wish I had done that more consistently. I have the initial confirmation and a couple of payment screens but not everything.
0 coins
Beth Ford
whatever you have is better than nothing. bring it all. even partial records help show the timeline of what was happening on your claim.
0 coins
Morita Montoya
Screenshots are genuinely so useful! I had a similar issue and the timestamp on a screenshot of my claim status page helped so much when I had to explain the sequence of events.
0 coins
Kingston Bellamy
wait so if the doctor hasnt released you but EDD is saying you returned to work, does that mean EDD thinks you lied on your certifications? im on SDI right now too and reading this is making me nervous about my own claim, not sure what triggers these things
0 coins
Sergio Neal
EDD flagging a return to work doesn't automatically mean fraud. It usually means conflicting information hit their system, often from employer wage reports. The appeal process exists for exactly this situation.
0 coins
Kingston Bellamy
okay that makes me feel a little better. still scary to read about though.
0 coins
Alice Pierce
Your claim is separate and shouldn't be affected by someone else's situation. Keep certifying and keep your doctor's paperwork current, that's the main thing.
0 coins
Joy Olmedo
I had a disallowance on mine once too, different reason, employer reported wages in a quarter that overlapped my claim dates. Filed the appeal and included my time cards showing I was home. Administrative law judge ruled in my favor. Takes a while but it works.
0 coins
Leslie Parker
AuthorThe time cards are a good idea. I have texts with my supervisor from the days I was definitely home recovering, would those count for anything?
0 coins
Joy Olmedo
I'd include them. Anything that shows you were home and not working helps the judge understand the timeline.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
Contemporaneous records like texts or emails from that period can support an appeal. They're not official but they add context to your account of events.
0 coins
Elin Robinson
Payment date question on my own claim took me two weeks and I finally got an answer by using Claimyr to get through to a live EDD agent on the disability line. The agent looked at my claim and confirmed the specific date my most recent payment was issued and told me which weeks were included in it. For your situation I'd still file the appeal first since the 30 days is the hard deadline.
0 coins
Beth Ford
wait what is Claimyr, I don't think I've heard of it before?
0 coins
Elin Robinson
You hand it your EDD phone session, basically it stays on the line until an agent at EDD picks up and then your phone rings. No sitting on hold yourself for hours.
0 coins
Beth Ford
oh that's interesting. I've been trying to figure out if the medical cert my hairstyling school instructor submitted for me was actually accepted because SDI Online just says pending. that might be exactly what I need to ask about.
0 coins
Isaiah Cross
Appeal deadline is real. Everything else can wait, that can't.
0 coins
Leslie Parker
AuthorFiling it this week for sure. I already wrote a draft of the explanation letter.
0 coins
Isaiah Cross
Good. Send it certified so you have proof of the date.
0 coins
Kiara Greene
my cousin had literally the same thing happen, payment stopped, employer messed up a report or something, she appealed it and eventually got backpaid for the weeks they cut off. wasnt fast but she got it
0 coins
Leslie Parker
AuthorBackpay for the weeks that were cut off is what I'm hoping for too. Good to know that's possible.
0 coins
Kiara Greene
yeah it took a while but she got every week. just dont stop the appeal process even if it feels like nothing is happening
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
Worth clarifying one thing about appeals, the 30 days starts from the date printed on the notice itself, not the date you received it. So if it sat in the mail for a few days, your window is a little shorter than you might think. Check that date carefully.
0 coins
Leslie Parker
AuthorThe notice is dated 11 days ago so I have about 19 days left. Filing this week.
0 coins
Atticus Domingo
That's correct about the date. EDD's appeals info confirms the 30 days runs from the notice issue date. Mailing it certified with a postmark well before that date is the safest approach.
0 coins
Paloma Clark
19 days is enough time if you move on it now.
0 coins
Ivanna St. Pierre
something i got confused about early on was whether a disallowance is the same as a denial of the whole claim. its not right? the original claim was approved, this is just about specific weeks?
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
You're right that they're different. A disallowance of a payment period means EDD determined those specific weeks weren't payable. It doesn't necessarily affect the whole claim. The appeal would address those particular weeks.
0 coins
Ivanna St. Pierre
okay good, i thought maybe i was wrong about that. so the original claim stays intact while the appeal is pending?
0 coins
Atticus Domingo
The claim itself isn't revoked by a disallowance notice. The appeal is specifically about the disputed payment period. Continue certifying through SDI Online normally while the appeal is in process.
0 coins
Heather Tyson
been dealing with edd for months now. appeals do get resolved. slow, but they do.
0 coins
Leslie Parker
AuthorThat's reassuring to hear. I just need to keep pushing forward.
0 coins
Heather Tyson
yeah keep everything. every piece of paper they send you, file it.
0 coins
Juan Moreno
anyone who says the EDD phone line is manageable has not tried calling the disability line in the last year. i have called at 8am, i have called at 4pm, i have tried every day for a week before. it either says no agents available or just ends the call. filing through SDI Online or the Request Claim Update feature is sometimes the only realistic option when you cant get through by phone.
0 coins
Joy Olmedo
Request Claim Update in SDI Online is what I use now. You pick the category, write your question, and at least there's a record of you asking.
0 coins
Juan Moreno
exactly. and it doesn't cut you off mid-sentence like the phone does.
0 coins
Paloma Clark
the Request Claim Update feature is under your claim ID in myEDD. worth using while waiting on the appeal.
0 coins
Raul Neal
DE 2593 came to our house when my wife was out on her claim and I almost missed the 20-day return window because I didn't know what it was. called the disability line maybe six times that week, nothing. ended up using Claimyr to get through and the agent confirmed my wife's claim was on automatic payment and the form had to be back in 20 days or benefits would stop. got it in with two days to spare.
0 coins
Kingston Bellamy
I've actually used it on my own claim too and I'm glad I did. When I called, the agent pulled up my record and said my waiting period had already been counted from my claim start date, which meant the first payable day was day eight. I had thought the waiting period was just processing time and that cleared it up completely.
0 coins
Paloma Clark
wait so the 7-day waiting period isn't just EDD being slow, it's actually a set non-payable period?
0 coins
Kingston Bellamy
right, the agent told me it's built into every new claim, day one through seven are just not payable, it's not about how long EDD takes to process anything. the first day benefits can actually pay out is day eight.
0 coins
Morita Montoya
For the appeal letter itself, being really specific about dates helps so much! Like, write out exactly which days you were home recovering and which days EDD is claiming you returned to work. The more specific the better when an administrative law judge is reading it!
0 coins
Leslie Parker
AuthorI'm doing exactly that. I have a calendar where I tracked my recovery appointments and rest days so I can lay out the timeline clearly.
0 coins
Morita Montoya
That calendar is perfect evidence! Bring a copy of it with the appeal.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
A detailed personal calendar with appointment dates and physician visits listed by date is a solid way to establish a timeline for the appeal record.
0 coins
Amy Fleming
Does your employer know EDD flagged you as returned to work? Might be worth a conversation with HR to find out if they filed something by mistake and whether they'd correct it.
0 coins
Leslie Parker
AuthorI hadn't thought about going to HR directly. If they filed something incorrectly they might be willing to put something in writing saying it was an error.
0 coins
Amy Fleming
A written statement from HR saying the wage report was filed in error would be strong support for your appeal. Worth asking before you send anything in.
0 coins
Sergio Neal
An employer correction letter isn't required but it strengthens the appeal considerably if you can get one. HR departments can and do submit corrections.
0 coins
Alice Pierce
Keep certifying every period as normal while the appeal is pending. Don't stop certifying thinking the appeal will cover everything. The appeal addresses the disallowed weeks but you still need to stay current on the ongoing certification so the rest of the claim doesn't lapse.
0 coins
Leslie Parker
AuthorReally glad someone said this. I wasn't sure if I should pause certifying while this was going on. I'll keep doing it as normal.
0 coins
Alice Pierce
Pausing certification could create a gap that's harder to explain later. Keep going.
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
Notice of Determination I got last year had a different reason than return to work but the appeal form and the process were the same. Filed on a Thursday, kept certifying, used Claimyr to get through to EDD when I wanted to confirm the appeal had been received, and the agent told me the notice showed the determination and that I should watch for a hearing notice by mail. Knowing it was at least logged in the system helped me stop checking SDI Online every twenty minutes.
0 coins
Isaiah Cross
An appeal confirmation from an agent sounds like marketing for a phone service. That's what I thought when someone mentioned it.
0 coins
Jenna Sloan
I had the same doubt, figured it was just another thing that wouldn't work. Tried it after two weeks of the line ending the call on me and the agent pulled up my record and told me exactly which weeks were showing as paid and which were still pending on my claim. That answered what I'd been trying to figure out for days.
0 coins
Isaiah Cross
Alright. I'll give it a shot when my own extension paperwork situation gets complicated enough that I actually need a person.
0 coins
Esteban Tate
One more thing on the appeal, you can also write a plain detailed letter if you've misplaced the DE 1000A. The instructions on EDD's appeals page say a detailed letter works as the appeal document if the form is gone. Mail it to the return address on the disallowance notice.
0 coins
Leslie Parker
AuthorI still have the form so I'll use it, but it's good to know the letter works too in case someone else runs into this.
0 coins
Atticus Domingo
That's accurate. EDD's appeals information states that a detailed letter can substitute for the DE 1000A if the form isn't available. The letter needs to explain clearly what you're disputing and why.
0 coins
Beth Ford
your employer not releasing you doesnt mean much to EDD unless your doctor hasnt released you, which is the key thing here. the medical release is what EDD cares about. the employer release is a job protection issue which is a whole separate thing, different agencies handle that.
0 coins
Leslie Parker
AuthorRight, I meant my doctor hasn't released me medically. My employer has nothing to do with the doctor's decision, I just want to be clear I'm still under medical orders to not work.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
That distinction is important for the appeal too. The focus should be on the medical certification and your physician's current status of your condition, not on any employer documentation.
0 coins
Beth Ford
exactly. the doctor's paperwork is the core of the SDI appeal here. everything else is secondary.
0 coins