Back to California Disability

Angelica Smith

SDI overpayment while receiving full paycheck from employer — what actually happened to me

Filing date was August 4th, disability start July 28th. My employer ended up paying me my full regular wages for the entire first three weeks I was out, which I honestly didn't think would be a problem since I was still disabled and couldn't work. EDD processed my SDI claim and payments started coming in. Now I have an overpayment notice sitting on my kitchen table and I'm trying to figure out how this happened and what I can do about it. I did report when I went back to work, but I never reported the employer wages during the time I was out because I genuinely didn't know that mattered. Has anyone dealt with an SDI overpayment while receiving full paycheck from employer at the same time? Did you appeal it or just pay it back? The notice says I have 30 days from the issue date to appeal and I'm already at day 8.

Your Notice of Computation should have your weekly benefit amount on it. The overpayment notice itself, the DE 2517, will show which weeks EDD is saying were overpaid and by how much. The first thing I'd do is compare those weeks to your pay stubs from your employer. If your employer paid you full wages for those same weeks and you also received SDI, that is likely why the notice came. EDD can determine that benefits weren't due if wages were covering the same days. The appeal deadline is 30 days from the date printed on the notice, so you have time, but gather those pay stubs and your claim forms now.

0 coins

Pay stubs are already pulled. The overlap is exactly three weeks, which lines up with what the notice says. I just wasn't sure if appealing made sense or if I'd lose.

0 coins

The appeal form is the DE 1000A and it comes with the notice. If you misplaced it, a detailed letter mailed to the return address on the notice works too. Write out exactly what happened, week by week, with the pay stubs attached.

0 coins

DE 1000A is in the envelope, good. I'll write up the timeline tonight.

0 coins

EDD sent me an overpayment notice last year for about two weeks of payments. I fought that line for DAYS. Mornings, afternoons, never once got a person. Eventually gave up and just mailed the appeal form in with my explanation and they adjusted it after a few weeks. Mail works but you have no idea what's happening until a letter shows up.

0 coins

That's the worst part. No confirmation, nothing. Just waiting.

0 coins

Exactly. And the 30 day clock is still running while you wait to hear anything.

0 coins

Does mailing it count as filed on the day you send it, or when they receive it? Not sure if that matters for the deadline.

0 coins

The deadline is 30 days from the date on the notice. Mail it well before that date so there's no question. Certified mail gives you a record if it comes up later.

0 coins

Payment date on my last claim was sitting unresolved for a couple weeks and I couldn't get anyone on that line. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got to an EDD agent without spending half my morning redialing. Agent pulled up my claim and told me the payment had been issued on the 14th and was pending transfer to the card. That was the answer I needed. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

When you got through, did you have your claim ID and Social Security number ready, or did they ask for something else?

0 coins

Claim ID, Social Security number, and the last four of my debit card. Had all three ready and the agent moved fast.

0 coins

been trying that line since tuesday. every time it just ends the call. three mornings in a row now.

0 coins

Wait, so if your employer pays you during your disability leave, does that automatically disqualify the SDI claim? Or is it just certain situations? I'm pregnant and my company said they might pay me for a few weeks and I don't want to end up with an overpayment later. Really worried about this now.

0 coins

Whether employer wages affect your SDI depends on how EDD looks at the specific weeks. The safest thing is to report any wages to EDD as you receive them so there's no surprise notice after the fact. For pregnancy, start there and let EDD sort out what's payable.

0 coins

So I should report even if I'm not sure yet whether my employer will pay me? Just disclose it and let EDD decide?

0 coins

Yes, report it. EDD makes the call on what's payable. Much easier to have them adjust during the claim than deal with an overpayment notice six weeks later.

0 coins

Okay, that makes sense. I'll report whatever my employer gives me as it comes in.

0 coins

Dealt with one of these a couple years back. EDD doesn't care why it happened, just that it did. Appeal if you think there's a factual error in which weeks they flagged. If the overlap is real and documented, paying it back is usually the faster road.

0 coins

The overlap is real, so I might be looking at paying some back. The question is whether the amount they calculated is right.

0 coins

That's worth checking. The notice breaks down the weeks and amounts. Go line by line against your pay stubs and your SDI payment history in SDI Online.

0 coins

SDI Online shows my payment history by week. I'll cross-reference tonight and see if their math matches mine.

0 coins

My cousin went through something similar after her maternity leave situation got complicated. She just paid it back and said the appeals process felt overwhelming. But I keep hearing people say you absolutely should appeal if the numbers are off. What does the appeal actually involve, is it like a hearing or just paperwork?

0 coins

An appeal goes to an administrative law judge. It can be a phone or in-person hearing. You present your documents, explain your side, and the judge decides. It's more formal than just mailing a letter, but it's the right path if you believe EDD made a factual error.

0 coins

If you just want them to look at the calculation again, the appeal form is the place to say that. Write what weeks you believe are correct, attach the pay stubs, and let them review. It doesn't always go to a full hearing.

0 coins

That's less intimidating than I thought. I'll pass that along.

0 coins

The DE 2593 on my claim never got returned in time and I ended up with a mess. I used Claimyr and talked to an agent who confirmed they had received it after all, just not processed yet. Saved me from filing something I didn't need to.

0 coins

My DE 2593 is due in about a week and I haven't sent it yet. Going to try Claimyr to make sure EDD has everything they need on file before the deadline. What should I have ready when I call?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, your claim ID from SDI Online, and the return date written on the form itself. The agent can see what they've received on their end.

0 coins

been waiting on mine too, anyway I didn't realize there was a 20 day window on that form, almost missed it last time.

0 coins

The 20 days goes fast, especially when you're recovering and not watching dates. Set a phone reminder the day you get it.

0 coins

my work paid me during my leave too and i never reported it. nothing ever happened but that was a few years back. not saying dont report, just saying it doesnt always catch up with you

0 coins

That's not advice anyone should follow. EDD cross-checks wage records with the Employment Development Department. It catching up later just means a bigger notice.

0 coins

fair enough i guess. wasnt trying to tell anyone to hide it

0 coins

EDD does match wage records, so wages paid by an employer during the same weeks as SDI payments can show up on audits. Reporting them upfront is the cleaner path.

0 coins

I'm kind of in this situation right now, not exactly the same but close. I went on disability for a back thing and my employer kept me on payroll for two weeks because it was a small company and my boss felt bad. I didn't report those two weeks. Now I'm reading this thread and panicking. Is it too late to self-report?

0 coins

You can contact EDD through SDI Online's Request Claim Update or through Ask EDD to report wages you didn't report at the time. Getting out ahead of it is better than waiting for a notice. What you owe, if anything, EDD will determine.

0 coins

Okay. I'm going to log into myEDD tonight and send a message. I'd rather deal with it now than get a surprise letter.

0 coins

That's the right move. At least you're on the right side of it.

0 coins

The 30 day appeal window really is firm. A friend of mine missed it by four days and had to explain to an administrative law judge why she was late. They do consider late appeals but you need to give reasons for the delay and the judge decides if they're good enough!

0 coins

Day 8 for me. I'm not waiting much longer. Getting the appeal letter done this week.

0 coins

If a late appeal becomes necessary, the form still goes to the return address on the notice. Write out why it was late and what happened. The judge reviews that before anything else.

0 coins

Overpayment notice I got earlier this year had the wrong weeks on it entirely. My employer never paid me during my disability, so the whole thing seemed like an error. EDD disability line was useless for me, couldn't get through for weeks. Used Claimyr and landed on the phone with an actual EDD agent. She pulled up my Notice of Determination and confirmed the notice had been generated from a reporting mismatch, not actual wages. Told me to appeal with documentation and EDD would review it.

0 coins

A reporting mismatch is exactly what I'm worried about on my own claim. Ended up speaking to an EDD agent through Claimyr too, and when I asked which weeks they had me marked as paid versus pending, she went through each one. Two weeks showed as paid that I hadn't received yet, so she flagged it for me to watch.

0 coins

Two weeks showing as paid when you hadn't received anything yet, did the payments end up coming through after that?

0 coins

They did, about five days after that call. The agent said the payment had been issued and to give it a few business days.

0 coins

reporting mismatch sounds exactly like what may have happened on mine too. i've been trying to get someone on the line for three weeks and all i get is the recording.

0 coins

Appeal form, pay stubs for the overlapping weeks, and a written timeline are the three things to have ready before you do anything else. The timeline should show each week, what your employer paid, and what SDI paid. Keep it factual, no editorializing.

0 coins

Timeline is essentially done in my head. Writing it out tonight. Three weeks, specific amounts on each side, no fluff.

0 coins

Attaching the actual pay stubs rather than just summarizing the amounts makes the appeal stronger. EDD can see the figures directly.

0 coins

Does the overpayment notice come before or after a Notice of Determination? I thought the DE 2517 was the denial letter and something else was the overpayment demand. Getting confused about which form is which.

0 coins

The DE 2517 is the Notice of Determination, which tells you a claim or period wasn't payable and why. An overpayment notice is separate and tells you what EDD says you were paid that you weren't entitled to. You can get both on the same situation, one saying the weeks weren't payable and one saying to repay what was already issued.

0 coins

Ohh, so the DE 2517 explains the decision and then a separate letter says here's what you owe. Got it.

0 coins

Mine came as one envelope with both things in it. Knocked me over when I opened it.

0 coins

my wife was out for surgery last spring and her employer did the same thing, paid her for a few weeks. we reported it and EDD just adjusted the claim, reduced the benefit for those weeks, it wasn't a huge drama, anyway just saying reporting it at the time is way less stressful than the overpayment letter later

0 coins

That's how it's supposed to work. EDD adjusts rather than pays out and then claws it back later.

0 coins

Wish I had known that when I filed. Live and learn.

0 coins

Curious whether SDI has any provision for someone who truly didn't know employer wages during leave had to be reported. Like if the error was innocent, does that change anything about the appeal?

0 coins

An appeal is based on whether the determination was factually correct, not on intent. If you genuinely believe the weeks EDD says were overpaid were actually payable, you make that case. The circumstances of why wages weren't reported can be part of the narrative you write, but the appeal decision turns on the facts of each week.

0 coins

So it's not a forgiveness process, it's more of a factual review. That's useful to understand going in.

0 coins

If the overlap is real and the amounts are right, an appeal is unlikely to erase the overpayment. It's the right step if you believe EDD has the wrong weeks or wrong amounts.

0 coins

The waiting period isn't the same as the first seven days of processing. The first seven days of a new claim are just non-payable, full stop. Doesn't mean anything went wrong. Saw someone above imply it was a delay.

0 coins

Correct. The seven-day waiting period is built into every new DI claim and nothing can be paid for those days. It's not about how long EDD takes to process anything.

0 coins

I definitely confused those two when I first filed. I thought my claim was stuck when actually EDD was just at day four of the waiting period.

0 coins

Pay the amount that's clearly correct and appeal the rest if anything looks off. Sitting on an overpayment notice doesn't make it smaller and the appeal window is real.

0 coins

Planning to appeal the full notice because I'm not confident in their week-by-week math. If some of it sticks after appeal, I'll deal with that then.

0 coins

Reasonable approach. At minimum the appeal forces a review of the calculation.

0 coins

Has anyone had EDD waive an overpayment rather than making them pay it back? I've read that might be possible in some cases and wonder if it applies here!

0 coins

An overpayment can be appealed and that appeal might result in a reduction if EDD's calculation was off. No one can promise a waiver. The notice itself will say what options are available, and the appeal is the formal path to dispute it.

0 coins

The notice and the Appeal Form DE 1000A are what to focus on. Everything that can be done flows from the return address and deadline on that notice.

0 coins

Got it, the notice is the starting point for everything. Will look more carefully at ours!

0 coins

Three weeks of overlap between employer wages and SDI does seem like the kind of thing EDD flags through wage matching. The fact that you're already at day 8 of the 30 day window, the appeal letter really should go out before the end of the week.

0 coins

Sending it Thursday. Pay stubs, timeline, DE 1000A. That's the plan.

0 coins

Certified mail. Keep the receipt.

0 coins

What if EDD mailed the overpayment notice to an old address and you didn't get it right away? Is the 30 days from when they mailed it or when you actually read it?

0 coins

The 30 days runs from the date printed on the notice, not from when you open it. If you got it late due to an address issue, write that in your explanation when you submit the appeal. A late appeal can be considered if there are reasons, and the judge looks at them.

0 coins

So address problems don't stop the clock. Good to know, keeping my address current in SDI Online from now on.

0 coins

I did not realize the address in SDI Online was the one they used for mailing. Updating mine right now just in case.

0 coins

is there a way to set up a payment plan if you do owe money back? like do you have to pay it all at once

0 coins

The overpayment notice says what options are available on that specific notice. EDD handles repayment terms case by case, so read the notice for what it says about how to pay and whether installments are an option.

0 coins

ok ill read the whole thing more carefully

0 coins

Mine had a few options listed at the bottom. Worth reading that section carefully before doing anything.

0 coins

Update from me: EDD sent a follow-up letter after I mailed my appeal form and it asked for the pay stubs I hadn't attached the first time. So even if you think you attached everything, they may still come back for more. Leave time for a round trip.

0 coins

Attach everything in the first envelope. Pay stubs, the timeline, any employer letters confirming the wage continuation. Less back and forth.

0 coins

Adding an employer letter to my packet. Good call.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure