SDI overpayment part-time income after giving birth — what do I do?
So I had my baby in September and was on SDI for the pregnancy and postpartum period. Around week six I started picking up a few hours a week doing remote bookkeeping work from home because honestly we needed the money and I thought as long as I reported it we'd be fine. I did report the hours every time I certified, or at least I thought I did it right. Now I got this letter saying I was overpaid and I owe money back. I don't even understand how they calculated it. The amount they're saying I owe seems way higher than what I actually earned those weeks. Has anyone dealt with an SDI overpayment after going back to part-time work while still on a postpartum claim? Do I appeal or just pay it? I'm terrified of making it worse.
76 comments

Abigail bergen
Reporting partial earnings while still on a postpartum SDI claim is the right instinct, but there's a timing piece that trips a lot of people up. EDD calculates what you should have received for each partial week based on what you reported, and if the numbers they have don't match what you certified, an overpayment notice follows. The first thing to check is whether the hours and dollars you reported on each certification match your actual pay stubs for those weeks. If there's a discrepancy in EDD's favor, you have 30 days from the date on that notice to appeal using the DE 1000A form.
0 coins
Kirsuktow DarkBlade
AuthorThe notice is dated about two weeks ago, so I still have time. What do I actually include with the appeal? Just the pay stubs?
0 coins
Abigail bergen
Pay stubs are essential. Add anything you printed or saved from SDI Online showing what you certified each week, and write a clear explanation of what you reported and when. The more specific the better.
0 coins
Kirsuktow DarkBlade
AuthorOkay. I didn't save screenshots of my certifications, which I'm now realizing was a mistake. Is there any way to see that history in SDI Online?
0 coins
Ahooker-Equator
Notice of Determination came in the mail after I filed an appeal on a DI overpayment from last year. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live person at EDD's disability line after a week of calling and getting cut off every single time. The agent pulled up my file and confirmed the Notice of Determination had been issued and told me it included an Appeal Form DE 1000A. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Turned out EDD had a different earnings figure for one week than what my pay stubs showed, which is exactly why I needed to get the actual form in hand before the 30 days ran out.
0 coins
Anderson Prospero
Claimyr worked well on my end too. The claim start date on my file was off by two days from what I'd put when I filed, and the agent found it and told me which date they had on record. That small gap was what was holding things up for me.
0 coins
Tyrone Hill
The start date being off by two days, did EDD fix it on that same call or did they send something in the mail?
0 coins
Anderson Prospero
They said to watch for a notice in the mail and to compare it with what I had. The agent didn't change anything on the call, just confirmed what the system showed.
0 coins
Toot-n-Mighty
I've tried that line before 8 and after 4 and everywhere in between. Gets to the same recording every time. Glad something actually worked for someone.
0 coins
Lena Kowalski
August 14 was my partial return date and I had three different weekly amounts that quarter. When the overpayment notice landed I went line by line through every certification I'd submitted and compared it to my direct deposit records. EDD had the right weeks but the dollar figure on one of them was off, probably because I rounded my hours instead of using the exact minutes. Even small rounding differences can create an overpayment on paper.
0 coins
Kirsuktow DarkBlade
AuthorYou rounded the hours? I think I may have done something similar. How did you correct it?
0 coins
Lena Kowalski
Filed the appeal with the exact figures from my pay stubs and a note explaining the rounding. The DE 1000A has a space for a written explanation, use all of it.
0 coins
DeShawn Washington
The instructions on the DE 1000A also say you can attach a separate letter if you need more room, so don't feel like you're limited to that one box.
0 coins
Mei-Ling Chen
Wait, so if you report your part-time hours but EDD still sends an overpayment notice, that doesn't automatically mean you did something wrong, right? Like they might just have a different number?
0 coins
Abigail bergen
Exactly. The notice is EDD's calculation, not a final judgment. That's why the appeal exists. If your records show you were paid the right amount, the appeal is how you prove it.
0 coins
Mei-Ling Chen
That is way less scary than I thought. I assumed the notice meant they'd already decided you cheated or something.
0 coins
Sofía Rodríguez
Thirty days goes fast when you're home with a newborn. Mail the appeal the same week you get the notice, not the week before the deadline.
0 coins
Kirsuktow DarkBlade
AuthorMine is two weeks old so I have about two weeks left. How long does the appeal process take?
0 coins
Sofía Rodríguez
Nobody knows. Can take a while. Keep copies of everything you send.
0 coins
Aiden O'Connor
I'm on a postpartum claim right now and I'm scared to pick up any part-time work at all after reading this. I thought as long as you reported it you were protected? Or is partial work always going to end up triggering an overpayment notice?
0 coins
Abigail bergen
Reporting is the right step, but the amount you report has to be exact, not approximate. EDD compares what you certified against your actual wages for those weeks. Accurate reporting, with the right dollar amount for each week, is what keeps you protected.
0 coins
Aiden O'Connor
So I'd need to know the exact amount every week before I certify? Not just hours but dollars?
0 coins
Abigail bergen
Both, ideally. EDD is matching what you say you earned to what shows up in their wage records eventually, so the more precise the better.
0 coins
Zoe Papadopoulos
Your pay stubs are your best friend here! Keep every single one from any week you work while on SDI.
0 coins
Jamal Brown
my sister had the same thing happen after her c section and she just paid it without appealing and i always thought she should have fought it because the number seemed wrong to us
0 coins
Fatima Al-Rashid
If the number is wrong, paying without appealing is giving money back that you don't owe. The appeal exists for exactly that reason.
0 coins
Jamal Brown
yeah i know but she was exhausted and just wanted it done
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
Receipt number on my claim had a mismatch issue early on and I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr to sort it out. The agent confirmed which receipt number was actually tied to my file and that was the piece my provider needed to submit the medical certification correctly. Everything moved after that.
0 coins
Aaliyah Jackson
Claimyr sounds like it might just be an ad in disguise, what exactly is it?
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
It's a service that waits on EDD's phone line in your place and rings you once an actual EDD employee picks up. That's it.
0 coins
Aaliyah Jackson
Hm. Okay, I've been trying to get through about an overpayment question for a week. I guess I'll see if it does what it says.
0 coins
KylieRose
Redialing that line from my car between drop-offs for about five mornings and not once getting past the recording. Good to know there's another way.
0 coins
Toot-n-Mighty
The overpayment notice doesn't tell you HOW they got the number, which is what I find infuriating. You have to basically reverse-engineer their math from your own records to even know what to dispute.
0 coins
Lena Kowalski
That's true. What I did was take my weekly benefit amount from the Notice of Computation and work backward from whatever EDD said I was paid versus what my records showed I should have gotten. The gap usually points to which week had a data problem.
0 coins
Toot-n-Mighty
That's actually useful, I didn't think to start from the Notice of Computation figure.
0 coins
Tyrone Hill
The postpartum SDI period is typically six weeks for a vaginal birth or eight weeks for a cesarean, with the provider able to extend it beyond that for complications. If you were still within your certified period when you started working those few hours, the partial week rules kick in, and those calculations can be really easy to get wrong when you're running on no sleep.
0 coins
Kirsuktow DarkBlade
AuthorMine was a c-section and my doctor certified eight weeks. I started the part-time work at week six, so I was still within the certified period. That's exactly when this happened.
0 coins
Tyrone Hill
So your two weeks of part-time work overlapped with the last two weeks of your certified eight-week period. That's the stretch EDD is probably looking at. Those certifications are the ones to pull and compare.
0 coins
Aiden O'Connor
Does the type of birth actually change anything about how EDD handles part-time earnings within the certified period?
0 coins
Abigail bergen
The birth type affects how long the provider typically certifies, six weeks versus eight, but the rules around reporting partial earnings work the same way regardless.
0 coins
Miguel Hernández
Appeal letters go to the return address printed on the notice itself, not to EDD's general address. Worth double-checking before you seal the envelope.
0 coins
Kirsuktow DarkBlade
AuthorGood catch, I almost assumed it went to the same address as the original claim stuff.
0 coins
Miguel Hernández
Different offices handle different things. The notice tells you exactly where.
0 coins
Sasha Ivanov
Patients don't always realize their SDI payments can overlap with income for the same week in a way that creates a paper overpayment even when nothing dishonest happened. The appeal is genuinely the right path when you have documentation showing what you actually earned.
0 coins
Aiden O'Connor
Does it help to have your doctor write anything or is this strictly a wages-and-certifications matter at this point?
0 coins
Sasha Ivanov
For an earnings dispute, it's the wage records and what you certified. The medical side is a separate piece.
0 coins
KylieRose
Two kids and my wife just had our second so we're in the thick of this, anyway, what happens to your SDI payments while the appeal is pending? Do they just stop?
0 coins
Abigail bergen
Filing an appeal doesn't automatically stop any current payments. The overpayment amount stays on the books, but the appeal puts the dispute into a formal review. EDD mails information about the process.
0 coins
KylieRose
Okay so it's not like filing the appeal cuts everything off. That was my fear, anyway.
0 coins
Anderson Prospero
The base period quarters that EDD uses to calculate your benefit amount are fixed when the claim opens. Part-time earnings during your claim period don't change your original weekly benefit amount on the Notice of Computation, they just affect what you're entitled to for the specific weeks you worked. So the overpayment is about those weeks, not your whole claim.
0 coins
Kirsuktow DarkBlade
AuthorThat actually helps me understand what I'm dealing with. So it's only the weeks I reported earnings, not the entire claim, that they're reviewing?
0 coins
Anderson Prospero
Right. EDD is looking at the specific weeks your certified earnings didn't match what they calculated you should have received.
0 coins
Liam Murphy
Payment date on my file was showing wrong in SDI Online and I ended up talking to a live EDD agent about it. Used Claimyr to get through after trying that line for three mornings. Agent pulled up the specific week and told me the payment had been issued and the date it went out. It cleared up faster than I thought once I knew the actual issued date.
0 coins
Mei-Ling Chen
On that call, did you need to have your claim ID ready or just your Social?
0 coins
Liam Murphy
Had both ready but mainly needed the claim ID. Agent asked for it right away.
0 coins
Amara Okafor
been dialing that number off and on for about two weeks trying to reach someone. still nothing.
0 coins
Aaliyah Jackson
Honestly even if you end up owing some of it back, the amount you owe might be less than what the notice says if you can show even one week was calculated wrong. It's worth running the numbers.
0 coins
Lena Kowalski
That was exactly my situation. EDD's total on the notice was based on a figure that was off for one week, and once that week was corrected the actual amount came down.
0 coins
Kirsuktow DarkBlade
AuthorSo even a partial correction could lower the total? That changes my thinking on whether it's worth going through the whole appeal.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Rashid
Pay the undisputed part while you appeal the rest? I'm not sure if that's even how it works with EDD.
0 coins
Abigail bergen
The notice will say what your options are. The 30-day appeal deadline is the hard deadline, so if you disagree with any part of it, file the appeal first and ask EDD about payment arrangements separately.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Rashid
Makes sense. Deadline first, everything else second.
0 coins
Zoe Papadopoulos
Went through an overpayment notice on my maternity SDI claim last spring and the appeal form really isn't as scary as it looks! You're basically just telling EDD your side with your paperwork attached. The administrative law judge process is there for exactly these situations.
0 coins
Kirsuktow DarkBlade
AuthorDid your appeal go all the way to a hearing or did it get resolved before that?
0 coins
Zoe Papadopoulos
Mine got resolved before the hearing, EDD reviewed the documents I sent and adjusted the amount. Not everyone gets that result but it's possible!
0 coins
Tyrone Hill
Good reminder that not every appeal ends up in front of a judge. Sometimes the documentation is enough on its own.
0 coins
DeShawn Washington
EDD's site has information on exactly what gets compared for partial week payments. It's worth reading before you write your appeal explanation so you're addressing the right variables in your letter.
0 coins
Kirsuktow DarkBlade
AuthorI didn't even think to look at the site for this. I've been so focused on the letter itself.
0 coins
DeShawn Washington
The appeal is stronger when it's written in EDD's own terms. Reading what they say about partial week calculations first helps you frame your argument.
0 coins
Jamal Brown
does appealing an overpayment mean you have to show up somewhere in person or can you do it all by mail
0 coins
Abigail bergen
You mail the appeal to the address on the notice. If it goes to a hearing before an administrative law judge, that step may involve a scheduled appearance, but the initial appeal is by mail.
0 coins
Jamal Brown
ok good because getting somewhere in person with a new baby sounds like a whole situation
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
The certification history should be visible in your SDI Online account. Log into myEDD, go to SDI Online, and your past certifications should be there under your claim. That would answer your question about whether screenshots are available.
0 coins
Kirsuktow DarkBlade
AuthorI just checked and I can see the certifications! The dollar amounts I entered are right there. This is going to be really helpful for the appeal.
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
Pull those and print them or save them before you do anything else. Having that record is what makes the comparison concrete.
0 coins
Tyrone Hill
That's the key piece right there. If what you certified matches your pay stubs, your appeal basically writes itself.
0 coins