Back to California Disability

Lukas Fitzgerald

SDI false statement penalty week after disqualified previous claim — what happens next?

So I'm in a really confusing situation and I can't find a clear answer anywhere. I had a previous SDI claim that got disqualified, and now I'm looking at what EDD is calling a false statement penalty week on top of that. I didn't intentionally give wrong information — I just didn't understand what I was supposed to report when I went back to work part time near the end of that claim. Now I've had to file a new claim because I'm out again for a different reason entirely, and I'm terrified the penalty week is going to follow me into this new claim or that I'm going to be disqualified again. Does a false statement penalty week carry over to a completely separate disability claim? And does the disqualification from the first claim affect whether EDD will approve the new one? I've been trying to call the SDI line to ask but I cannot get through to anyone. I'm going out of my mind a little bit.

Filing again after a disqualification is genuinely stressful, and I'm sorry you're dealing with this on top of a new medical situation. The new claim is evaluated on its own merits — your current medical condition, your doctor's certification, and whether you have enough wages in your base period. A prior disqualification doesn't automatically block a new claim. The penalty week is a separate matter, and EDD will address it as part of your record when they process things. Keep your paperwork from both claims organized so you can reference dates quickly.

0 coins

Does that mean the penalty week just sits there and doesn't affect the new claim at all, or does EDD still apply it somehow?

0 coins

My understanding is EDD handles the penalty separately from eligibility, but honestly the specifics of how it applies across claims is exactly the kind of thing to confirm with EDD directly because individual records can vary.

0 coins

the part about the new claim being evaluated on its own actually helps me too, im in a weird overlap situation and was scared the old one would just sink everything

0 coins

The start date on my claim had an error, and I'd been going in circles for days trying to reach anyone on that SDI line, so I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and ended up talking to an actual EDD agent. Video on getting a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my record and confirmed the claim's start date was off by four days from what I'd entered, which explained why the first payable week didn't line up with what my doctor had certified. We got that clarified on the spot. For something like a penalty week crossing into a new claim, that's exactly the kind of thing an agent can look at on your actual record rather than you guessing from general info online.

0 coins

Claimyr worked for me too and I'm glad you brought it up. My medical certification was the issue — the agent told me EDD had received it but it hadn't been matched to my claim yet because the receipt number my doctor's office used didn't match what SDI Online had for me. Once I gave them the right one over the phone they were able to flag it. Can I ask, did the agent say whether they corrected the start date right then or if a notice would come?

0 coins

She said a notice would come in the mail with the corrected computation and to watch for it within about two weeks. She didn't change anything on the spot, just confirmed what the system showed.

0 coins

The receipt number mismatch is such a common thing and nobody warns you about it when you file. Glad the agent was able to sort it out for you.

0 coins

The SDI phone line is a full-time job on its own. I've called at 8 a.m., I've called at 4:45 p.m., I've tried Tuesdays, Thursdays, whatever day people on other forums swear by — still hit a recording that dumps me. Something about penalty weeks specifically seems like you really do need a live person to explain what's on your actual record.

0 coins

Same. That line does not care what time you call.

0 coins

I stopped expecting to get through. Now I just use the Request Claim Update in SDI Online and wait.

0 coins

The online message thing works sometimes but for something this tangled I'd want to actually hear what's on the account.

0 coins

Disqualification and a penalty week are two different things in EDD's system. The disqualification was on that claim. The penalty week is a flag on your record for the false statement finding. Whether or how EDD applies that penalty week to your new claim — that's not something anyone here can promise you one way or the other. You need EDD to look at your specific record. File your new claim properly, get your doctor's certification in, and then get EDD on the phone.

0 coins

I didn't realize they were tracked separately like that. I thought the whole thing was one big mess together.

0 coins

They're related but not the same. The disqualification ended that claim. The penalty week is EDD's way of handling the false statement finding itself, and it can show up on a later claim.

0 coins

That distinction actually makes sense now that I think about it. I was confusing the two in my head reading the original question.

0 coins

For context on what 'base period' means here: the wages EDD looks at for your new claim come from a 12-month window ending about 17 months before you file, the highest single quarter of that window is what drives your weekly amount. If the work you did during and after the first claim falls in that base period, it counts toward your new claim's benefit calculation. The Notice of Computation will show exactly which quarter EDD used.

0 coins

So the wages from before the first claim AND after it could both be in the base period for the new claim? That actually sounds like it might help me.

0 coins

Possibly, yes. It depends on the dates. Use the calculator on EDD's site to get a rough estimate, but the Notice of Computation is what's official.

0 coins

The base period explanation on EDD's site is worth reading if you haven't, they lay out all four quarters and which one they'd pick.

0 coins

ok wait so if she didnt mean to mess up the reporting does edd still stick her with the penalty week? like intent doesnt matter?

0 coins

EDD's false statement finding and what happens after is documented in the notice they send, and if she disagrees with it she can appeal within 30 days of the date on that notice. The appeal process is the right place to raise the question of intent.

0 coins

oh so theres actually a way to push back, i didnt know that

0 coins

I did get a notice about the penalty week. I didn't realize I had 30 days to appeal it. I need to check the date on that letter right now.

0 coins

Appeal within 30 days of the notice date. If that window passed, the appeal form asks for your reasons for the delay and an administrative law judge looks at it. Missing the deadline isn't automatically the end.

0 coins

The notice date was about three weeks ago so I might still be in the window. What do I need to send with the appeal form?

0 coins

The DE 1000A form, or a detailed letter if you can't find the form, mailed to the return address on that notice. Write out exactly what you reported and when.

0 coins

Keep copies of everything you mail. I've learned that the hard way with EDD paperwork.

0 coins

not sure if this is dumb to ask but — could filing the appeal hurt the new claim somehow? like would EDD look at the fact that shes appealing and use it against her?

0 coins

Appealing a determination is your right under the SDI process and the new claim goes through its own eligibility review. One doesn't block the other.

0 coins

ok that actually makes me feel better. i was scared it would look bad.

0 coins

Totally normal worry. EDD processes are confusing enough without feeling like every move might backfire.

0 coins

Notice of Computation on my claim had a number that didn't match what I expected at all. Spent three mornings hitting that disability line and got nowhere, so I went through Claimyr and got an EDD agent on the phone. The agent told me EDD had used my Q2 wages to calculate the weekly amount instead of Q3, which was my higher quarter, and explained that the base period window for my claim start date put Q3 just outside the range. Sent me to appeal if I thought the dates were off. For the penalty week question here, an agent can actually read you what your record shows.

0 coins

Claimyr just sounds like an ad somebody planted in here, honestly. How is a third-party service supposed to get you through a government line that hangs up on everyone?

0 coins

I thought the same thing when I first saw it. Tried it anyway after a week of that line cutting out on me. Agent told me my DE 2593 was flagged as past due on their end even though I'd mailed it in time, and that I should resend it with the postmark date written on the form. I was talking to an actual EDD person.

0 coins

huh. ok. if the line is still doing that to me tomorrow morning i might just try it.

0 coins

Have your claim ID and Social Security number ready when you get on.

0 coins

The appeal form is the DE 1000A. You mail it to the address on the notice, not to EDD's general address. Include a short, clear statement of what you reported, when you reported it, and why you believe the false statement finding was an error. Keep it factual.

0 coins

Should I include pay stubs from the weeks I was working part time?

0 coins

Yes. Anything that shows what you actually earned and when you reported it strengthens your case.

0 coins

Scan everything before you mail it. You want a copy of exactly what the appeals office receives.

0 coins

My claim went into a weird limbo after a prior issue on my account and I panicked thinking the whole thing was ruined. It wasn't — EDD looked at the new medical certification and the new dates and processed it as a fresh claim. The stuff from before showed up in my record but it didn't stop the new claim from moving forward.

0 coins

This is actually really reassuring to hear from someone who went through it.

0 coins

The fear that old stuff will haunt every future claim is so real. Glad yours worked out.

0 coins

How long did it take for the new claim to start showing progress after you filed?

0 coins

About 12 days after my doctor submitted the certification I saw something change in SDI Online. Then the Notice of Computation came a few days after that.

0 coins

There's a thing worth flagging about the medical certification step because it tripped me up: after you file Part A in SDI Online you get a receipt number, and your doctor needs that exact number to find your claim on their end and submit the certification. If your provider doesn't have it, the certification can sit in EDD's system without ever matching to your claim. Worth double-checking before you assume EDD hasn't received it.

0 coins

My new doctor's office said they submitted it already but I haven't seen anything update. I should probably give them that receipt number.

0 coins

Yes, call them and ask which receipt number they used. If it's wrong it explains the delay.

0 coins

took me forever to figure that one out on my claim. nobody tells you at the start.

0 coins

Weeks on my current claim stopped updating and I couldn't tell if EDD had paid some of them or not. Got on the phone with an agent through Claimyr and she went through week by week. Two weeks had been issued and I just hadn't gotten the payment notification in SDI Online yet, and one week was still pending because they were waiting on a certification period to close out. That was actually useful to know rather than just staring at 'pending' and guessing.

0 coins

Did she say whether the pending week would clear on its own or if you had to do something?

0 coins

She said it would update once the certification period ended and no action was needed from me. So I waited.

0 coins

been trying that line myself off and on for eight days straight. not once got a person.

0 coins

If you're still inside the 30-day appeal window you should mail that DE 1000A today, not next week. EDD's processing times mean you don't want to cut it close.

0 coins

I looked at the notice — the date on it is 26 days ago. Mailing it tomorrow morning.

0 coins

Good. Use certified mail so you have the postmark.

0 coins

Exactly. That postmark is your proof you filed in time.

0 coins

DE 2525XX from my doctor's office was sitting somewhere in limbo — my claim showed the final payment notice had gone out but nobody had submitted the extension form yet. I ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr and they confirmed EDD hadn't received the DE 2525XX from my provider yet. The agent told me my doctor needs to submit it through SDI Online and that my benefits would stay paused until it came in.

0 coins

The DE 2525XX is exactly what I need to ask about — my provider keeps saying they sent it but nothing has changed in SDI Online. I'm going to try Claimyr for it. What should I have ready when I get on with the agent?

0 coins

Have your claim ID, the date your doctor says they submitted it, and the name of the provider's office. The agent can check whether anything from that office is showing on the claim.

0 coins

I didn't even know extensions had their own form. Good to know for later if my current claim goes long.

0 coins

Your doctor's office would be the one to initiate that, not you. Worth making sure they know it goes through SDI Online, not by mail.

0 coins

Honestly a false statement penalty week is EDD's way of saying they think you owe them something for wrong info on a claim. If you genuinely didn't understand what to report, say that plainly in your appeal. Judges see these cases regularly.

0 coins

I didn't even know I was making a false statement. I thought reporting part-time hours at the end of the claim period was fine the way I did it.

0 coins

That kind of honest mistake is exactly what an appeal is for. Write it out plainly.

0 coins

Include any documentation showing what you understood the reporting rules to be at the time, if you have anything like a letter or guidance you received.

0 coins

wait can someone clarify — is the waiting period the same thing as the penalty week? i always get those mixed up

0 coins

The first seven days of any new DI claim are a waiting period. No payment for those days, every new claim. It has nothing to do with false statements. The penalty week from a false statement finding is a separate thing EDD imposes based on what happened on a prior claim.

0 coins

oh ok so theyre totally unrelated, got it

0 coins

Two different things, same confusing name. The waiting period is basically built into every SDI claim from day one.

0 coins

Filing the appeal and filing the new claim at the same time feels overwhelming but you're doing the right things. Keep the timelines for each one separate in your notes — the appeal deadline is 30 days from the penalty notice, the new claim has its own 49-day window from when your disability started.

0 coins

I filed the new claim already so I'm good there. The appeal is what I was dropping the ball on.

0 coins

Get that in tomorrow and you'll have both moving forward.

0 coins

Two things at once with EDD is a lot. Hope it smooths out soon.

0 coins

The SDI Online message system — Request Claim Update in myEDD — is worth using in parallel with the phone. You pick the request type, write out your question, and EDD responds in writing. For something like a penalty week affecting a new claim, having their answer in writing is useful if anything comes up later in the process.

0 coins

I didn't know you could send a message that specific through there. I thought it was just for general status questions.

0 coins

You can describe your situation in some detail. It won't be as fast as a phone call but you'll have a record of their response.

0 coins

Always keep the written record. EDD's online messages are easier to reference later than trying to remember what someone said on a phone call.

0 coins

For what it's worth, the agent I spoke to was clear that whatever is on your record from a prior claim, the new claim's eligibility review starts fresh. The old stuff doesn't automatically carry a 'denied' signal into the new one. What carries over is any open penalty or balance EDD needs to resolve on your account.

0 coins

That's what I needed to hear. My new claim should stand on its own then, even with the mess from before.

0 coins

File clean, get your doctor's certification in fast, and let the new claim process. Deal with the appeal on its own track.

0 coins

Two separate tracks is a good way to think about it. You're not fighting one battle, you're managing two things that happen to be happening at the same time.

0 coins

EDD having a penalty week system AND a disqualification system AND a waiting period that all sound similar but do completely different things is a design for maximum confusion, I swear. No wonder people mix them up.

0 coins

Each one has its own trigger and its own remedy. Penalty week needs an appeal, waiting period just passes, disqualification is about eligibility. Same word energy, very different situations.

0 coins

Tell that to the person who spent six months thinking their waiting period was a penalty.

0 coins

been there

0 coins

To close the loop on the false statement question: if you appeal and the administrative law judge agrees the reporting error was a mistake rather than intentional, EDD can remove the penalty week. That's the actual purpose of the appeal process. It's not just a formality.

0 coins

So there's a real chance the penalty week gets removed entirely if the appeal goes well?

0 coins

Yes, that's one possible outcome. No guarantees, but raising the lack of intent is the right argument to make.

0 coins

Document everything you have about what you understood the reporting process to be at the time. The more specific, the better.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure