Back to California Disability

Henry Delgado

SDI eligibility seasonal firefighter no SDI deducted from paychecks — what are my options?

So I worked a seasonal firefighting contract this past summer, about four months total, and now I'm dealing with a hand injury that's going to keep me out of work for a while. I went to file a disability claim on SDI Online and hit a wall — when I looked back at my pay stubs from the fire season, there's no CASDI deduction anywhere on them. Not a single paycheck. I don't totally understand how that happens. My friends who work regular jobs all have it taken out automatically. Is it possible my employer just didn't withhold it? Or does seasonal or contract firefighting work get excluded from SDI somehow? I genuinely don't know if I'm even eligible to file or if I'd just get denied. I filed a partial claim anyway just to have something in the system, but I haven't had my doctor submit the medical certification yet because I don't want to put him through the work if the claim is going nowhere. Has anyone dealt with this — seasonal work, no SDI withheld, and tried to claim disability? What actually happened?

Waiting period question was actually the thing that tripped me up when I filed last year, so I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get an agent on EDD's disability line. The agent told me my waiting period ran from the first day of my disability, and the first day EDD could actually pay me was day eight. Video on reaching someone live on the EDD disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

Used it on my own claim too. Asked the agent when my first payment was issued and she gave me the exact date right off the account. Helped me figure out the debit card timing.

0 coins

Wait, what date did she give you? Like the date EDD processed it or the date it hit the card?

0 coins

The date EDD issued the payment. Card timing after that she said was separate from EDD's end.

0 coins

Okay but back to my actual question — none of this addresses the no-SDI-withheld situation. Am I even able to file?

0 coins

Whether the CASDI deduction showed up on your checks isn't actually what EDD looks at first. The question is whether your wages from that employer were subject to SDI at all. Seasonal firefighting hired through certain government contracts sometimes falls under a different classification. You'd need at least $300 in SDI-covered wages in the base period to be eligible. If those wages weren't covered, the claim won't go through regardless of the injury.

0 coins

So my paystubs not showing CASDI could actually mean my wages weren't SDI-covered wages at all, not just that someone forgot to deduct it?

0 coins

Exactly. Two different things. Missing deduction could be an employer error, or it could mean the position was exempt. Your base period wages are what EDD checks against.

0 coins

How do you even find out which one it is without calling EDD for an hour straight?

0 coins

EDD's phone line has eaten probably six of my mornings this year alone. You call, it rings forever, then the system kicks you off. Seasonal work SDI questions are exactly the kind of thing you can't just solve from the website.

0 coins

That's what I'm scared of. I already sat on hold for 45 minutes and got nothing.

0 coins

Same line for years. It doesn't get better. File the SDI Online inquiry and wait, or find another way in.

0 coins

Before assuming the worst: your employer may have made a payroll error. If CASDI should have been withheld and wasn't, there's a process for that. EDD can look into whether wages were misclassified. Worth checking your employment paperwork to see if the position was listed as state civil service, federal, or private contract.

0 coins

Mine was a private contract through a staffing company that placed workers with a fire agency. Does that change things?

0 coins

Private contractor placing you changes the picture. The staffing company is usually the employer of record, and private employers generally do withhold CASDI. That missing deduction looks more like an error than an exemption.

0 coins

If it was the staffing company's error, EDD still needs confirmation of covered wages before they can process the claim. The staffing company's records would have to line up.

0 coins

Base period math matters a lot here. The 12-month base period EDD uses goes back roughly 5 to 18 months from your claim start date, taken in four quarters. If your four months of fire season fall mostly or entirely within that window, and those wages count as SDI-covered, you'd have enough to work with. But if the claim start date puts that work outside the base period, there might be little in there even if it was covered.

0 coins

My injury happened in early November so the claim start would be around then. Fire season was June through September. Does that fall in the right window?

0 coins

June through September would likely land inside the base period for a November claim start. Run the numbers on EDD's disability benefits calculator on their site to get a rough picture before you file the full claim.

0 coins

I did that calculator when I was figuring out my own claim. It's pretty straightforward once you have your quarterly wages handy.

0 coins

Quarter used in the base period was something I had to phone EDD about on my own claim. I'd been trying that line every morning for a week and getting nowhere, so I ended up reaching an agent through Claimyr. She told me exactly which quarter they used and what my wages showed on their end for that period.

0 coins

Reads like a marketing comment if I'm being straight. How would any third party get you through EDD's disability line when everyone else is stuck?

0 coins

Thought the same thing until I tried it myself after two weeks of nothing. Agent confirmed which weeks of my claim were showing as paid on their side, cleared up why one week wasn't in there. Not a pitch, just what happened.

0 coins

Alright. I'll look at it. Got a base period question of my own I haven't been able to get answered.

0 coins

Seasonal work getting classified wrong happens more than people think. If the staffing company didn't withhold CASDI and should have, that's on them, not necessarily a reason your claim dies. File the medical certification and let EDD make the call. You can appeal a denial.

0 coins

You think I should have my doctor send in the medical certification even before this is sorted out?

0 coins

Yes. Clock on the 49-day deadline doesn't stop while you wait for answers. Get it in.

0 coins

That 49 days goes fast. Don't sit on it.

0 coins

my employer never withheld casdi either one season and i just filed anyway and edd figured it out on their end tbh

0 coins

Did you actually get approved or did it just go pending forever?

0 coins

got a notice of computation eventually so something went through

0 coins

If you're still uncertain, the SDI Online message center inside myEDD lets you send EDD a written question on the claim. Sometimes you get a response faster than the phone line, lol. At least it's documented.

0 coins

I didn't know you could message them through there. I've only been looking at the claim status screen.

0 coins

Yeah open the claim ID and there should be a Request Claim Update option. Pick the type and write your question out.

0 coins

Used that when my doctor's office was slow. Got a reply in a few days.

0 coins

Payment method was something I nearly overlooked on my own disability claim. I reached EDD's disability line through Claimyr and the agent confirmed my payment was set to go to a Money Network prepaid debit card since I hadn't set up direct deposit through SDI Online. Worth knowing before the first payment hits and you're not sure where to look.

0 coins

How long had you been trying that line before you used it? And did the agent tell you anything about timing on the payment itself?

0 coins

I had tried several mornings across two weeks before that. The agent said the payment date was on the account but didn't give a guarantee on when the card would update, since that part is on Money Network's end.

0 coins

been trying that line since tuesday. every time it just dumps me after the hold music.

0 coins

Worth clarifying something from earlier in this thread: even if CASDI wasn't withheld, EDD can verify covered wages through employer records. The deduction showing up on your stub is evidence, but it's not the only evidence. EDD has other ways to verify what wages were subject to SDI.

0 coins

So the absence of a CASDI line on my stubs isn't automatically a denial? EDD could still find covered wages?

0 coins

Right. It triggers a question about the employer's records, not an automatic no. If the staffing company should have withheld it, that's the employer's side of the problem.

0 coins

EDD may request wage records from the employer directly. Keep copies of everything you have.

0 coins

Don't forget the 49-day window runs from when the disability started, not from when you filed. If the injury was early November, count from there.

0 coins

Okay so I started the claim but my doctor hasn't submitted the medical certification yet. Does his 49 days run from when I filed or from day one of the injury?

0 coins

The certification deadline is 49 days from the first day of disability, same as the claim filing deadline. Both run from the disability start, not from each other.

0 coins

I almost got that wrong on mine. Really glad someone told me before I lost too much time.

0 coins

My cousin did seasonal fruit harvest work and ran into something similar, no SDI deducted, then got hurt and needed to file. The whole thing came down to whether the labor contractor had them classified right. EDD ended up requesting records from the contractor. Took a while but it moved.

0 coins

That's actually kind of reassuring. So EDD does investigate the employer side of it rather than just denying outright?

0 coins

From what she went through, yes, they dug into the employer's records. She didn't get a quick answer but she wasn't just denied on day one either.

0 coins

EDD's process on misclassification stuff is slow but it's real. File and let them do their job.

0 coins

Medical cert for my claim was sitting unmatched for ten days and I had no idea why, so I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr. Turned out my provider had used a different form receipt number than the one SDI Online gave me when I filed. Agent found it on the account right away.

0 coins

Receipt number thing is what I wanted to ask about. If the number on the certification doesn't match, does EDD just reject the whole form or does it sit pending? Might try that for my own claim.

0 coins

Have your receipt number from when you filed ready, and your provider's contact info if EDD needs to reach them. Agent said it was sitting unmatched rather than rejected, so it hadn't disappeared.

0 coins

This is a good warning for me too. When my doctor's office submits, I need to make sure they have the right receipt number from my SDI Online filing.

0 coins

If EDD does deny the claim because of the missing CASDI, you have 30 days from the date on the Notice of Determination to appeal! The DE 1000A appeal form comes with the notice. Don't skip that if it comes to it.

0 coins

Good to know. I'd been worried that a denial was just the end of the road.

0 coins

Not at all! Appeal form is right on the notice, and you can write a detailed letter instead if you misplace it. Just mail it to the return address on the notice.

0 coins

Filed with similar wage questions and got the Notice of Computation anyway. EDD sorts the wage side out before that comes.

0 coins

You got a Notice of Computation even with the wage question hanging? That's hopeful.

0 coins

Yeah it came and showed a weekly amount. Didn't mean I was approved but it meant they found wages to work with.

0 coins

seasonal work and sdi is confusing every year on this forum. nobody has the same answer because the employer classification is always different

0 coins

True, and that's exactly why the staffing company paperwork matters so much here. The answer really does depend on how that employer classified the position.

0 coins

Ask EDD directly. That's the only answer that counts on your specific claim.

0 coins

Physical therapist tried to certify my claim once and EDD rejected it. Had to get my actual doctor to do it. Just flagging that in case your hand situation involves a PT — make sure it's your physician or someone on EDD's approved list.

0 coins

Mine is my hand surgeon so that should be fine, but I didn't even know PT wasn't on the list.

0 coins

Physical therapists aren't authorized to certify disability claims under EDD's rules. The list includes physicians, nurse practitioners, physician assistants and a few others, but not PTs. Good thing you caught that.

0 coins

Yeah found that out the hard way. Cost me a week.

0 coins

Even if this claim turns out complicated, filing now protects your spot in the timeline. If EDD finds covered wages and you haven't filed, you can't go back and get those weeks covered. Get everything in and let them make the call.

0 coins

That's what I keep telling myself. Better to have filed and get sorted than to wait and lose the window.

0 coins

Correct call. File, get the cert in, let EDD do what they do.

0 coins

One more thing worth checking: the CASDI deduction on private employer checks in California is funded by the employee. If the staffing company genuinely made a payroll error, there are forms through EDD to dispute that. It's a separate path from just filing the disability claim, but the two can run at the same time.

0 coins

I didn't know you could dispute the missing deduction separately. Where would I even start with that?

0 coins

EDD's site has information on it under their employer section. Worth a look alongside the disability claim, not instead of it.

0 coins

Keep all your pay stubs. That documentation is what any dispute would rest on.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure