Back to California Disability

Jean Claude

SDI denied not enough wages past 5 to 18 months — county employee appeal options?

Got a denial notice from EDD last week on my disability claim. The Notice of Determination says I don't have enough wages in the base period, which from what I can tell covers roughly 5 to 18 months before my claim start date. The thing that's throwing me is that I work for the county and my paystubs show CASDI deductions every single pay period, so I know I've been paying into the system. I was out starting mid-October after a procedure that's going to keep me off work for at least six weeks. Filed on SDI Online, got the receipt number to my doctor's office right away, they submitted the medical certification within a few days. Everything seemed fine until the denial landed. Has anyone else run into this as a county employee? Is there a base period calculation I might be misunderstanding, or is this something worth appealing?

County employees can absolutely be covered by SDI, but some counties operate under a Voluntary Plan instead of the state plan, which could affect how your wages are counted or who handles the claim. The denial notice itself should tell you exactly which base period quarters EDD looked at. Check the Notice of Determination carefully for the wage amounts they have on file, compare them to your own pay records, and if the numbers don't match, that discrepancy is exactly what an appeal is for.

0 coins

The notice does list the quarters and the amounts. One quarter is completely blank, which seems wrong because I definitely worked that entire year without any gaps.

0 coins

A blank quarter is a real red flag. Employers report wages to EDD, and if your county didn't report that quarter correctly, your appeal should include your pay stubs or W-2 to show what you actually earned.

0 coins

EDD's appeals page says you have 30 days from the date on the Notice of Determination to file. The DE 1000A appeal form came with the denial, and if you can't find it, a detailed letter mailed to the address on the notice works too.

0 coins

County payroll departments can be a nightmare about reporting wages on time. I got dinged once because my employer submitted quarterly wages two weeks late and EDD processed my claim before the update hit. Ended up with a lower benefit amount than I should have had. The appeal fixed it but it took longer than I would have liked.

0 coins

Late reporting from the county would explain the blank quarter. I had no idea employer reporting timelines could affect this.

0 coins

Yeah it's one of those things nobody tells you. Worth calling payroll directly to ask if they filed on time for that period.

0 coins

Payroll departments don't always know the EDD deadlines either. Get it in writing from them if you can.

0 coins

Notice of Determination came in the mail for me too, said insufficient wages, and I was completely lost on what to do next. Claimyr (claimyr.com) was how I finally reached someone on EDD's disability line after spending a whole week getting nowhere with that phone number. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the Notice of Determination I received was for a denial on my original filing date, and that I had 30 days from the date printed on the notice to appeal with the DE 1000A. Here's EDD's video on reaching a live person at their disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Filed the appeal the next morning with my pay stubs attached.

0 coins

Wait, what's Claimyr exactly? I've been dialing that disability number every morning this week and either getting a busy signal or a recording that just ends the call.

0 coins

It's a service that waits on that line in your place and your phone rings once a real EDD agent picks up. You just talk to them directly from there. If I had known about it sooner I would've had my answer days earlier.

0 coins

Oh that makes sense. My situation is the waiting period, I keep second-guessing whether mine actually started on the right date and I'd really like a person to confirm it.

0 coins

The agent being an actual EDD employee is the part that matters. So whatever they tell you about your own claim is coming straight from EDD's records.

0 coins

The base period for SDI isn't the most recent months, which trips a lot of people up. Wages from about five to eighteen months before your claim starts are what EDD looks at, divided into four quarters. The highest single quarter of wages in that window is what determines your weekly amount. If you were in a gap, promoted recently, or had any leave without pay during that specific window, the numbers can come out lower than expected even if your current pay is solid.

0 coins

That explains a lot actually. I was out for a week of unpaid leave during exactly that period. Could that be what made one quarter look short?

0 coins

Possibly, but unpaid leave itself doesn't erase reported wages, only the actual earnings from that period would be missing. If you earned wages in that quarter they should still be there. The blank quarter is the more concerning part.

0 coins

Does any of this change if the county uses a Voluntary Plan? I'm on a county job too and I genuinely don't know which plan I'm under or who I'd even appeal to.

0 coins

Check your pay stub, it'll say CASDI for the state plan. If it says something else or names the county's own plan, your HR department or the county's benefits office handles the appeal, not EDD directly.

0 coins

Appeal it. Don't sit on that notice. 30 days goes fast and you've got the evidence right there on your pay stubs. I let an overpayment deadline slip once because I thought I had more time. Never again.

0 coins

Mailing it today. DE 1000A and two months of pay stubs showing the CASDI deduction.

0 coins

Good. Keep copies of everything you send.

0 coins

Sending certified mail is worth it so you have proof it got there.

0 coins

Not sure if this is a dumb question but do you have to have a certain minimum in wages, or is it just about which quarters EDD has on file? I thought as long as you paid into SDI you were covered, and now I'm worried about my own claim, I only worked part of the year before my injury.

0 coins

EDD does require at least $300 in wages subject to SDI during the base period to qualify. It's not just about paying in, it's about the recorded amount in those specific quarters. If you have $300 or more in that window you're in the system; less than that and a denial like this one is possible.

0 coins

I definitely earned over $300 total, but it was spread across a lot of small checks. Does that still count?

0 coins

The total across the base period quarters is what matters, not whether it was one check or many. Add up everything from those quarters and compare to what EDD has on file.

0 coins

my county job had the same thing happen, blank quarter, whole thing. i appealed and they found out payroll reported my wages under a slightly wrong employer account number. got fixed but took forever

0 coins

An employer account number error sounds exactly like something a county payroll system would do. I'm going to ask payroll to verify what they filed and under what ID.

0 coins

yeah get them to give you something in writing to attach to the appeal. that helped mine move faster

0 coins

The appeal letter doesn't need to be fancy. I went through this two years ago and wrote maybe three paragraphs explaining that my wages were reported incorrectly, attached my W-2 and three months of pay stubs, and that was enough for EDD to reopen the wage calculation. The key is being specific about which quarter you believe is wrong and why.

0 coins

Three paragraphs and documentation, got it. I was overthinking how formal this needed to be.

0 coins

Does EDD ever just fix the wage reporting error on their end without you having to go through a full appeal hearing?

0 coins

Sometimes the appeal resolves at the administrative level before it ever gets to a hearing. An administrative law judge may look at the documentation and the employer's corrected report together and issue a new decision without a hearing at all.

0 coins

Is there a way to track where the appeal is after you send it in? I'd be checking every day if I were you.

0 coins

Receipt number on my claim got scrambled somehow and my doctor's office had the wrong one for three weeks. Couldn't figure out why my claim wasn't moving. Ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr and the agent confirmed the receipt number on file and told me exactly what number the provider needed to find my claim in SDI Online to submit the certification.

0 coins

EDD having my start date right was something I actually got confirmed too, same thing, reached an agent and they read me the exact date in the system, which matched what I'd put on the form, so that calmed me down a lot. Ended up asking about whether I still needed to do anything else while pending.

0 coins

Did the agent say anything about how long pending usually runs after the certification goes in?

0 coins

They said most payments go out within two weeks once EDD has both parts of the claim complete, but they wouldn't give me a specific date for mine.

0 coins

Knowing whether EDD has the right information on file versus just waiting and guessing is a big deal. At least you found out there was a mismatch before too much time passed.

0 coins

Honestly county jobs trip people up because a lot of them assume the county handles everything the same way private employers do. Some do, some absolutely don't. I work retail now but my last job was with a city department and the SDI setup was totally different, lol. Always worth asking HR which plan you're under before you assume anything.

0 coins

HR told me I was under CASDI when I started, so I always assumed that meant standard EDD. But I never thought about whether the county's reporting to EDD was actually happening correctly on their end.

0 coins

Right, being enrolled in CASDI and having your wages properly reported are two different things. The deduction coming out is on you, the reporting is on them.

0 coins

Blank quarter on the wage record is on the employer, not on you. File the appeal, attach proof of what you earned, and let EDD sort it out. I've seen guys get denied for the same reason on construction jobs when a GC filed late. Every one of them got it corrected on appeal.

0 coins

That's good to hear. I was afraid a denial meant I was out of luck entirely.

0 coins

Denial just means you fight it. You've got 30 days and you've got the evidence.

0 coins

Are you worried about money in the meantime? Like if the appeal takes a few weeks, is there any bridge or do you just have to wait? I'm asking for myself too, I'd be really stressed about bills if my claim got denied.

0 coins

There isn't a bridge payment during an appeal. The options are usually sick leave, employer leave policies, or savings while you wait. EDD decides the claim and if the appeal goes in your favor the payments cover the period you were out.

0 coins

So if the appeal works, the money would be retroactive to when the claim should have started? That helps a little at least.

0 coins

Correct. Benefits go back to the first payable day of the claim if the appeal reverses the denial, minus the unpaid waiting period for the first seven days.

0 coins

been dealing with edd since september, still pending. your situation with the blank quarter sounds fixable though, mine is messier

0 coins

just got a letter finally, different issue than yours but still not resolved. this process is exhausting.

0 coins

September to now is a long stretch. Hope the letter moves things forward for you.

0 coins

County employees sometimes have wages reported through a separate system than private employers use. If your CASDI deduction shows on every pay stub but the quarterly wage report to EDD has a gap, that's a documentation issue on the employer's side, not yours. Bring it to payroll with your pay stubs in hand and ask them to file a corrected report to EDD. That can support your appeal significantly.

0 coins

Payroll confirmed this morning that they may have submitted one quarter under a different account. They're pulling the records now.

0 coins

Ask them to give you a written statement of the corrected submission to include with your appeal.

0 coins

A corrected employer wage report plus your own pay stubs is a pretty solid appeal package. That's the kind of documentation that tends to resolve cleanly.

0 coins

Payment date on my own claim sat wrong in the system for two weeks before I noticed. Used Claimyr to get to someone at EDD's disability line and the agent confirmed the payment had actually been issued but was still showing old information in SDI Online. Told me to check the Money Network card instead of the portal.

0 coins

Reaching a live person at EDD sounds like it might be marketing for some kind of service.

0 coins

Thought the same thing the first time I saw it. Tried it myself when my medical certification wasn't showing as received after ten days. The agent looked at my claim and confirmed they had the certification, told me which date it came in, and said my claim was processing. That was a real EDD agent, not a recording. Came away with the actual answer.

0 coins

Okay, that's more convincing than I expected. Might give it a try to find out why my Notice of Computation hasn't shown up yet.

0 coins

My claim was showing pending in SDI Online for over a week before anything changed. Would have been useful to know what was actually happening on EDD's end rather than just guessing.

0 coins

Had a friend go through almost this exact thing, different job but same denial for insufficient wages. The appeal took about three weeks and EDD reversed it once the employer submitted corrected wage info. She ended up getting paid from the original claim start date.

0 coins

Three weeks feels manageable if that's roughly the timeline. Nice to have a data point.

0 coins

Three weeks is a best case. Could be longer depending on how backlogged appeals are running. Plan for more.

0 coins

Fair point, she was pretty lucky with timing. Worth preparing for a longer wait just in case.

0 coins

One thing I didn't realize before my own denial: the base period looks at a 12-month stretch but it starts about five months before your claim date, not right before it. So your most recent months of work aren't even in the picture. If your pay went up recently or you just finished a probationary period, your current wages don't help you at all for this claim.

0 coins

That's exactly what bit me. Got a pay increase four months ago but that's apparently too recent to count in my base period.

0 coins

The calculator on EDD's site lets you put in your own quarterly wages and see what the estimate comes out to. Worth running your numbers from the actual base period quarters to see what EDD should be showing.

0 coins

Is the calculator on edd.ca.gov? I've been looking for it for my own claim and couldn't find it easily.

0 coins

It's on EDD's site, search for the SDI benefit calculator and it comes up. It's under the disability insurance section.

0 coins

I keep reading that you need wages in a specific set of quarters but I told my coworker and she said as long as you paid in anything you're fine. I don't think she's right but I didn't want to argue with her.

0 coins

Your coworker has it backwards. EDD requires at least $300 in SDI-covered wages in the base period, and those wages have to actually appear in EDD's records. Paying in doesn't automatically mean the wages were reported correctly, which is exactly the situation in this thread.

0 coins

So someone could have CASDI deducted every check and still get denied if the employer reported it wrong?

0 coins

Exactly. The deduction is yours, the reporting is the employer's job. If they filed late or under a wrong account, EDD's record shows a gap even if you paid in every period.

0 coins

That's why you get your own records and don't take anything on faith. Pay stubs exist for exactly this reason.

0 coins

Appeals are genuinely worth filing when you have pay stubs showing the CASDI deduction. It's not like appealing something that's judgment-based. Missing wage data is factual and correctable.

0 coins

Filed the appeal yesterday via certified mail with six months of pay stubs. Payroll also confirmed in writing they're submitting a corrected wage report for the blank quarter.

0 coins

That's as solid an appeal as you can put together. Good move going certified.

0 coins

Let EDD do their job now. You've done your part.

0 coins

does anyone know if edd contacts the employer directly during an appeal or if the employer has to reach out themselves to fix the wage report

0 coins

EDD can contact employers to verify or correct wage reports as part of the appeal process. Having the employer proactively submit a correction tends to speed things along, but EDD does have authority to pursue the wage information on their end.

0 coins

ok so doing both like in this thread is probably the smart move

0 coins

Proactive correction from the employer plus your own documentation is the strongest position. EDD has less to investigate if the employer's already filed the corrected report.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure