Back to California Disability

Ethan Brown

SDI denied because using vacation time to make up pay — what do I do now?

I got a denial notice from EDD and I'm honestly panicking a little. I've been out since my back surgery and my employer has been having me use my accrued vacation time to top off my wages while I'm gone. I thought that was fine and normal, but now EDD sent me a Notice of Determination saying my SDI claim was denied because of the vacation pay. I didn't even know that could be a problem. The notice has an appeal form attached but I don't know if I should appeal or if I actually did something wrong. Has anyone dealt with this? Did using vacation pay actually disqualify me or is this something I can fight?

The vacation pay situation with SDI is genuinely confusing and EDD's own notices don't explain it well. What EDD looks at is whether your vacation pay was equal to or more than your weekly SDI benefit amount. If your employer was paying you full wages through vacation, EDD treats those weeks as not being a wage-loss week, which is why they can deny or reduce benefits for that period. The key question is whether the vacation pay was bringing you to full wages or just partial. If it was partial, you may well have a case to appeal.

0 coins

Thank you, so the vacation pay was covering about 60 percent of my normal pay, not the full amount. Does that change things for the appeal?

0 coins

It could matter a lot, actually. If you weren't being made fully whole, you likely had a wage loss EDD should recognize. Put that in your appeal letter and attach any pay stubs that show the actual amounts.

0 coins

Wait, I'm not sure I follow. So EDD compares your vacation pay to your weekly benefit, not to your full salary? I think I might be in a similar situation and I don't want to make the same mistake.

0 coins

EDD compares whether you had a wage loss, so yes, your regular wages versus what you actually received during disability matters. Your Notice of Computation shows your weekly benefit amount, and your pay stubs show what came in. That gap is what an appeal would point to.

0 coins

The claim's start date on mine was listed wrong in SDI Online and I needed it fixed before anything else could move. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to reach an agent directly, and the video on getting a live person at EDD's disability line is here: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my file and confirmed the start date was off by a week, so I asked them to note it and they said a corrected notice would go out by mail. That resolved the issue without me having to guess whether the fix had happened.

0 coins

Claimyr worked for my situation too, lol. My medical certification was sitting unmatched for almost two weeks and I finally reached someone. The agent told me the certification had come in but the receipt number on it didn't match what I'd filed with, so they flagged it to be manually linked. Got that cleared up same day.

0 coins

How did they handle the fix, did you do anything on your end or was it all on EDD's side?

0 coins

All on their side. I just confirmed the receipt number I had from when I first filed and they did the rest. Payment came through a few days after.

0 coins

Appeal it. You've got 30 days from the date on that notice. Don't wait around wondering.

0 coins

Okay yes, that's the push I needed. The date on the notice was last week so I still have time.

0 coins

Good. Get those pay stubs together and write down exactly what your employer paid and when. Keep it simple and factual.

0 coins

EDD's phone line for disability is a joke. Called at 8 on the dot four mornings in a row and either got a busy signal or the system cut me off before I could talk to anyone. For a decision this big you really want to talk to a live person and that is basically impossible through normal means.

0 coins

Tried that line for two weeks straight. Never once got through. It's maddening.

0 coins

Have you tried the Request Claim Update option in SDI Online? It's not as good as a phone call but at least you get a written response eventually.

0 coins

Yeah I did that too. Took 11 days to get a reply and by then I had already missed information I needed. Phone is still the only way to get real answers fast.

0 coins

The appeal form that came with your Notice of Determination is the DE 1000A. EDD's site says you mail it to the return address on the notice itself, not to any general EDD address. Write a detailed explanation, attach your pay stubs showing what you received while on disability, and be specific about the weeks in question.

0 coins

Good to know, I was about to look up a general EDD address. I'll use the return address on the actual notice.

0 coins

Exactly, and keep a copy of everything you send. Date the envelope if you can, since the 30-day window runs from the issue date on the notice.

0 coins

Does a letter work if you can't find the form?

0 coins

Yes, EDD says a detailed letter works in place of the DE 1000A if you've misplaced the form, as long as it's mailed to the address on the notice within that 30-day window.

0 coins

My coworker went through something similar and her employer was doing the same vacation top-off thing. She didn't know about the wage-loss rule either. She ended up appealing and had to show every pay stub from the weeks she was out. It was a process but she got it sorted.

0 coins

That's actually reassuring, thank you. Did she end up getting any of the denied weeks paid out after the appeal?

0 coins

She did get some of them, the weeks where the vacation pay was clearly less than her full wages. The weeks where the employer paid her the whole thing she didn't recover, which kind of makes sense in hindsight.

0 coins

Makes sense. If you had no wage loss there's nothing for SDI to replace.

0 coins

ugh this is why i always tell people read everything edd sends you. they bury the important stuff and then deny you and you have no idea why

0 coins

yeah and the denial notices are so vague. mine said 'not eligible' and nothing else useful.

0 coins

exactly like give me a reason at least

0 coins

The Notice of Computation on my claim had a base period I didn't understand and I wanted to know exactly which quarter they used to calculate my benefit. Tried the disability line for a week, nothing. Ended up using Claimyr to get an agent on the phone about it. She walked me through which quarter of the base period they'd pulled and what the weekly amount came out to based on that. Nice to finally have an actual number confirmed instead of just what SDI Online estimated.

0 coins

Honestly that just sounds like an ad to me. You're telling me you just dialed and got an agent that fast after weeks of nothing?

0 coins

Thought the same thing the first time I saw it mentioned, and I actually tried it before I believed it. Needed to track down the receipt number my provider's office had used because there was a mismatch. The agent read me the number on file so I could compare it to mine. Turned out they had transposed two digits. That was the whole hold-up.

0 coins

Hm. Alright, that's specific enough that I'll probably give it a shot for my own situation.

0 coins

Can I ask something that might be dumb. The waiting period, is that the same as the processing time? Because I keep reading that SDI has a seven day waiting period and I assumed that was just how long it takes to process, not actual unpaid days.

0 coins

Not dumb at all, it trips a lot of people up. Those are two separate things. The first seven days of your claim are a non-payable waiting period, meaning EDD doesn't pay those days no matter what, it's built into the program. Processing time on top of that is just how long EDD takes to review everything after they have your paperwork.

0 coins

Oh wow, so I lost seven days of benefits automatically and then had to wait for processing on top of that? That's rough.

0 coins

Yep, that's how it works. The eighth day is your first payable day. Most people don't find that out until they check their Notice of Computation and see the first week missing.

0 coins

For what it's worth, I had a denial last year for a completely different reason and the appeal process was actually more straightforward than I expected! Write out your timeline clearly, attach everything that shows your actual income during those weeks, and explain the gap between vacation pay and your regular wages. You've got this.

0 coins

Okay, timeline with documentation. I can do that. Did you hear back on your appeal pretty quickly or did it take a while?

0 coins

Mine took a few weeks to get an administrative law judge assigned, so sit tight. But once I submitted everything they needed it did move along!

0 coins

For the appeal, organize your pay stubs by week. Show the date, what your employer paid in vacation wages, and what your normal weekly wages would have been. The difference between those two figures is your wage loss for each week. That's what the appeal needs to demonstrate clearly.

0 coins

This is exactly the format I needed. Date, vacation pay received, normal wage, and the difference. I'll set that up in a spreadsheet.

0 coins

Spreadsheet is perfect. Print it and attach it to the DE 1000A. Keep the original. Send everything to the address on the notice, not EDD's general office.

0 coins

The organization really does matter. When I had my start date corrected, having the specific dates and amounts written out made the conversation with the agent much faster.

0 coins

Vacation pay that covers your full wages kills the SDI claim for those weeks. Partial coverage is a different story and worth fighting.

0 coins

So partial coverage is the key distinction. I keep coming back to this.

0 coins

Yep. No wage loss, no benefit. Partial wage loss, partial or full benefit depending on the gap. That's the whole argument.

0 coins

Worth double-checking whether your employer gave EDD any information about the vacation pay arrangement. Sometimes the employer fills out a form or responds to EDD's inquiry and what they report shapes the determination. If their report didn't reflect the partial nature of the payments, that's another thing to address in your appeal letter.

0 coins

Hadn't even thought about what my employer might have told them. I'll ask HR what they submitted.

0 coins

Good call. If HR can give you a letter clarifying the vacation pay was partial and not full replacement wages, attach that too. More documentation is better here.

0 coins

The employer's report to EDD can absolutely be part of what gets corrected on appeal. Seeing it in writing from HR would strengthen the case significantly.

0 coins

Which weeks were paid out was the question on mine and it was a mess to sort through. The agent I eventually reached through Claimyr went line by line with me and confirmed exactly which two-week periods had been paid and which were still pending. Helped me figure out that one stretch of three weeks hadn't processed yet rather than being denied.

0 coins

Did the agent give you any idea when the pending weeks might actually pay out, or just that they were pending?

0 coins

Just that they were pending, they wouldn't say when. But knowing they weren't denied was the important part, honestly. Made a difference in what I did next.

0 coins

been calling that line for going on three weeks trying to get the same kind of answer. mornings, afternoons, nothing.

0 coins

Can vacation and SDI both be claimed for the same period if the vacation pay is partial? Or does any vacation pay at all block the SDI?

0 coins

Any vacation pay that fully replaces your wages for a given week means SDI can't pay for that week. If it's partial, the wage-loss portion is what SDI steps in for. So partial vacation pay doesn't necessarily block SDI entirely, it depends on the numbers.

0 coins

Okay so the original poster being at 60 percent actually sounds like there's a real argument to make on appeal.

0 coins

Exactly. 60 percent of normal wages is a 40 percent wage loss. That's what the appeal should be built around.

0 coins

Alright, hearing this multiple times now is making me feel like I actually have a solid case. I'm going to get those pay stubs pulled together today.

0 coins

My employer did the same vacation top-off during a surgery recovery last fall and nobody warned me about the SDI interaction. Ended up needing an extension through my doctor once I was cleared to appeal the original denial, and by then I had to get the DE 2525XX filed quickly. Used Claimyr to get through to an agent about whether the extension had been received, since my doctor submitted it and I had no confirmation. The agent confirmed the DE 2525XX was in the system and told me which weeks it covered.

0 coins

My own open question is about my final payment notice, specifically whether EDD sent the DE 2500E before my last payment went out. Going to try Claimyr for that. What did you have ready when the agent answered?

0 coins

Have your claim ID number and the date your doctor submitted the form. That's what the agent asked me for right away. If you have a receipt from the SDI Online submission, have that too.

0 coins

Useful. I never know what to have ready when I finally get through somewhere.

0 coins

genuinely wild that edd denies people on disability for using benefits their employer offers. like you built up that vacation time

0 coins

EDD's position is that SDI replaces lost wages. If your vacation pay means you didn't lose wages, there's nothing to replace. Annoying but that's the logic.

0 coins

i get the logic i just think it should be disclosed better before people get denied

0 coins

Has anyone had EDD reverse a denial on appeal where the employer was paying partial vacation the whole time? Curious what the success rate looks like.

0 coins

Appeal outcomes aren't something anyone here can predict, since an administrative law judge looks at each case individually. The strength of the case comes down to how clearly the wage-loss documentation lays out the gap between what was received and normal wages.

0 coins

EDD doesn't publish outcome rates for specific denial reasons, so anyone quoting a number is guessing. What matters is the documentation.

0 coins

File the appeal today, not tomorrow. The 30 days goes fast when you're recovering from surgery and not tracking dates closely.

0 coins

Filing today. I've got the DE 1000A and I'm writing the explanation now with the pay stub breakdown.

0 coins

Good. Keep a copy of everything and note the date you mailed it.

0 coins

One thing to know about PFL if this comes up later: bonding leave after a disability claim is a separate filing. If you end up needing time for recovery and then bonding with a new baby or caring for a family member, those are two different claims. Mentioning it because some people assume SDI covers all of it and are surprised.

0 coins

True, though for a back surgery situation like the original post, PFL wouldn't be in the picture anyway. Good note for anyone reading who is out for pregnancy though.

0 coins

Not my situation but good to know for future reference. Right now I'm just focused on getting this denial reversed.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure