Back to California Disability

Victoria Stark

SDI claim disqualified for missing IME appointment I never received notice about

So I've been out since my back surgery in September and my SDI claim was going fine, payments coming through, everything seemed okay. Then last week I get this letter saying my claim has been disqualified because I missed an independent medical examination appointment. I never got any notice about this appointment. Nothing came through SDI Online, nothing in the mail that I saw. I don't even know what an IME is or when I was supposed to show up. My last payment just stopped and I'm completely lost about what to do. Has anyone dealt with a disqualification like this? Do I appeal? Is there a specific form? I'm really scared because I still can't go back to my regular job and I need these benefits.

The letter that disqualified you is called a Notice of Determination, the DE 2517. It has an Appeal Form attached, the DE 1000A. You have 30 days from the date printed on that notice to file your appeal. Write a clear explanation that you never received notice of the appointment, include any dates you were home, and mail it to the return address on the notice. Don't wait on this one.

0 coins

The 30 days, does that run from when I got the letter or the date printed on it? Mine is dated four days before it arrived.

0 coins

The 30 days run from the date printed on the notice, not the day it arrived. If the postmark and date are significantly different, mention that in your appeal explanation.

0 coins

Appeals go to the return address on the notice itself. Don't mail it to some general EDD address or it'll get lost.

0 coins

DE 2525XX came back denied on my extension even though my doctor submitted it, so I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com). The agent pulled up my file and confirmed the form had been received but hadn't been matched to my claim yet. If your disqualification notice showed up out of nowhere, it might be worth getting someone on the phone to find out exactly what triggered it before you write your appeal. Here's the video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

Payment method on my claim was stuck on the old card even after I updated it, so I used Claimyr too and had an agent confirm the Money Network card was set correctly. Getting someone actually on the phone made the difference. For the original poster, knowing exactly which date EDD has on file for that IME notice would really sharpen your appeal letter.

0 coins

Tried the disability line myself every morning from October 14th through the 23rd. Couldn't get past the automated message. How long were you on before getting through?

0 coins

The agent picked up and I asked about the extension form status right away. The line itself had been a wall for me too, multiple mornings with the same result.

0 coins

Appreciated. Going to try it for my own pending payment question.

0 coins

An IME is an independent medical examination that EDD can require to verify that you're still unable to work. What I haven't seen clearly stated anywhere is whether EDD sends the appointment notice by mail only or also through SDI Online. Does anyone know?

0 coins

EDD mails things. SDI Online shows claim status but appointment notices like that come by mail. If you never got it, say so explicitly in your appeal.

0 coins

That's actually important for the appeal then, because if mail is the only channel and it never arrived, that's a reasonable basis to argue the disqualification wasn't your fault.

0 coins

Keeping a record of anything you did receive around that time, and anything you didn't, helps establish the gap. I'd list every piece of EDD mail you've gotten on this claim with its date.

0 coins

EDD disqualifies people over things like this and then makes it nearly impossible to reach anyone to even understand what happened. I've been trying that phone line since I got my own weird notice and it just cuts off every single time. The whole system is set up to wear you down.

0 coins

Frustrating but the appeal is the move. File it, state you had no notice, and let the administrative law judge see it.

0 coins

Yeah I know the appeal is the right step. It's just the wall you hit trying to get a straight answer first that gets old.

0 coins

Filing the appeal doesn't stop you from also trying to reach EDD by phone or through the Request Claim Update feature in SDI Online. Both at once is fine.

0 coins

Not sure if this is the right question but, does filing the appeal automatically pause the disqualification while they review it? Like will I still be disqualified during the appeal period or does it kind of stay in limbo?

0 coins

Filing an appeal doesn't automatically resume payments. The disqualification stands until the appeal is decided. Keep your records of all the weeks you're out so you can account for them if the appeal succeeds.

0 coins

So I might go weeks or more without payments while the appeal is pending. That's a really hard situation to be in.

0 coins

That's the reality of it. File the appeal as fast as possible and also contact your doctor's office to make sure your medical certification side is fully in order, so there are no other reasons for denial sitting there when the appeal is reviewed.

0 coins

The claim start date on mine was listed incorrectly in EDD's system, a full week off, and I ended up speaking with an agent through Claimyr to get it sorted out. The agent confirmed the date EDD had on file and told me a correction would need to come through a notice. Worth knowing that EDD's records of what they sent and when they sent it are what matters most in an appeal over a missed appointment.

0 coins

Hard to believe any EDD phone line is reachable right now. I've tried that number at 8 on the dot, tried midday, tried everything. What line actually got you through?

0 coins

The disability line, 1-800-480-3287. I'd had the same experience you're describing, several mornings with nothing. The agent I spoke to was straightforward and pulled up the dates on my file immediately.

0 coins

Knowing what date EDD actually has on file for a notice changes your whole appeal strategy! If EDD's records show they sent something to a wrong address or at the wrong time, that's exactly what an administrative law judge needs to see.

0 coins

Fine, I'll give it another shot. The start date issue is relevant to mine too actually.

0 coins

Thirty days goes fast. Mail the appeal today, not after you figure out the rest.

0 coins

Even before I fully understand what happened, just mail it?

0 coins

Yes. Write what you know. You got a disqualification notice for a missed IME appointment you had no notice of. That's enough for now. You can add detail later.

0 coins

You can always send a follow-up letter with more information as you gather it. The important thing is getting that DE 1000A postmarked before the 30 days are up.

0 coins

my coworker had something similar happen, got disqualified for missing something edd said they mailed. she appealed and explained she never got it and the judge sided with her. not saying it always works out but it does happen lol

0 coins

That's actually really helpful to hear. Did she have to do anything specific to prove she didn't get the notice?

0 coins

she basically just wrote out what she did and didn't receive and when, kept it simple. the postmark date on the disqualification letter versus the date EDD claimed to have sent the first notice was part of it.

0 coins

Postal records and your own account of what arrived are legitimate evidence. An administrative law judge can weigh all of that.

0 coins

late appeal is possible too if you miss the 30 days, you just have to explain why, anyway just making sure you know that option exists

0 coins

Correct. A late appeal can be filed but you need to give the administrative law judge a reason for the delay, and they decide whether it's acceptable. Filing on time is always better if you can.

0 coins

yeah file on time obviously, just didn't want someone to feel completely stuck if they found this thread after the deadline, anyway

0 coins

edd mail gets lost all the time mine got sent to an old address because they had wrong info in the system, worth checking what address edd has on file for you before you write your appeal

0 coins

How do I check what address EDD has on my account?

0 coins

log into myedd and look at your profile settings, if its wrong update it and mention in your appeal that the address on file may have been different when the notice was sent

0 coins

Verifying the address EDD had on file at the time of the alleged mailing is a smart thing to include in your appeal explanation. If it was outdated, that's directly relevant.

0 coins

Notice of Computation on my claim had a base period I didn't recognize, so I had an agent on the phone through Claimyr look it up. The agent read back which quarter they used and what it showed. For this situation, getting EDD to tell you on the record when and where they claim they mailed that IME notice gives you something concrete to put in your appeal.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly?

0 coins

You give it your number and it handles being on hold with EDD, so your phone rings when an agent picks up. That's about the whole of it.

0 coins

Okay, that's plain enough. I'd want to ask about a DE 2593 that I sent back but EDD has no record of. Might try that.

0 coins

been trying that disability line for three weeks straight, haven't gotten through once

0 coins

Can you request a copy of whatever notice EDD claims they sent you? Like is there a way to ask for their records of what they mailed and when?

0 coins

Requesting EDD's records of what was sent is reasonable. You can contact EDD through the Request Claim Update feature in SDI Online or use Ask EDD. Having what they claim they sent, and comparing it to what you received, strengthens your appeal.

0 coins

So basically ask EDD directly in writing through SDI Online to show what notices went out on the claim and when. Got it.

0 coins

Filing the appeal and explaining it clearly is the right move. No notice, no way to show up. An administrative law judge reviewing your case can understand that.

0 coins

Writing the explanation is the part I'm most nervous about. How specific do I need to be?

0 coins

Be as specific as you can about dates. When your last payment came, when the disqualification letter arrived, what other EDD mail you've received and when. A timeline helps.

0 coins

Specific dates and a calm, factual tone carry an appeal letter further than frustration does, even when the frustration is completely understandable.

0 coins

While the appeal is going, keep your doctor in the loop. If your disability is still ongoing, the medical certification side needs to stay current regardless of what the appeal does.

0 coins

Does my doctor need to do anything specific while I'm appealing, or is the existing certification enough?

0 coins

The existing certification covers the period it was submitted for. If more time passes and you need an extension, your doctor would submit the DE 2525XX. The appeal and the medical side run separately.

0 coins

Right. Don't let the appeal distract you from keeping the medical certification current if you're still out.

0 coins

49 days from the disability start date is the deadline for the medical certification to be submitted. Making sure nothing else has lapsed while dealing with the disqualification is worth a quick check.

0 coins

49 days from when exactly, the first day I couldn't work?

0 coins

Yes, 49 days from the date your disability began. EDD's rules say both the claimant's part and the doctor's medical certification need to be in within that window. If you're well past your start date and already had an active claim, that part is done. The 49-day window was for the initial filing.

0 coins

For anyone mid-claim dealing with an extension, that's a different form and a different timeline than the original 49-day window.

0 coins

the ime thing confused me too when i first read about it. so edd can literally require an in-person exam to verify your injury? thats wild

0 coins

EDD can require an independent medical examination as part of verifying a claim. It's not common but it happens. Missing the appointment without notice of it is exactly the kind of situation an appeal is designed to address.

0 coins

and if you never got the letter about it edd still considers you to have missed it? the whole burden shouldn't be on the claimant if the mail didn't arrive

0 coins

Address verification is probably the first thing worth doing. If EDD had a stale address the notice went to a dead end before it ever reached you.

0 coins

Checked my myEDD account and the address is current. So whatever EDD says they mailed should have come to the right place.

0 coins

Then the argument is straightforward. Right address, no mail received. Put that in the appeal.

0 coins

That actually makes the appeal cleaner. No address confusion to untangle, just a letter EDD says they sent that you never received.

0 coins

There's a calculator on EDD's site to estimate your weekly benefit amount if you're worried about what you're owed for the weeks you were still on claim before the disqualification. At least you'd know the number going into the appeal.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation already has the weekly amount on it. If the original poster has that letter, the number is right there.

0 coins

True! The Notice of Computation is the real source. The calculator is just for people who haven't gotten theirs yet or want to double-check.

0 coins

Before mailing the appeal, make a copy of everything. The DE 1000A, your written explanation, the disqualification notice, and anything else you're including. Keep the copies and get proof of mailing.

0 coins

Proof of mailing meaning certified mail?

0 coins

Certified mail with return receipt is ideal. At minimum, a certificate of mailing from the post office. You want to be able to show you filed within the 30-day window.

0 coins

Don't overthink it. Certified mail, keep the receipt, done.

0 coins

Has anyone actually had an appeal decision go their way on something like this, missed appointment they claim to have sent notice for? Just curious what the realistic outcome looks like.

0 coins

my situation from earlier in this thread, the coworker who appealed the missed notice, hers went her way. one case is one case but it does happen.

0 coins

An administrative law judge weighs the evidence on both sides. EDD has to show notice was properly sent. If they can't, or if there are inconsistencies, that works in the claimant's favor.

0 coins

Nobody can tell you odds. File, explain clearly, let the judge see the facts.

0 coins

also worth trying the Request Claim Update in SDI Online to ask EDD in writing about the IME notice, gives you a paper trail and sometimes you get a written response before the appeal is even heard anyway

0 coins

Can I do that while the appeal is pending, or does filing the appeal close off that channel?

0 coins

you can do both, the appeal and the written inquiry through SDI Online are separate, the inquiry might even get you useful information before the hearing anyway

0 coins

A written response from EDD about what they claim they sent, obtained through SDI Online, could be useful documentation to bring to the appeal hearing.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure